Jump to content

sfmpco

Detectives
  • Posts

    4,894
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    61

Everything posted by sfmpco

  1. That would take TAB down to what? Fifteen minutes or less?
  2. If anyone is interested, I've fleshed out what might have happened during Sherlock's week in solitary. It is in canon with the show. http://archiveofourown.org/works/11262213/chapters/25180593
  3. Just popping 'round to say hello. Also wondering... where do you think Moriarty was being held in prison at the end of THOB? The bowels of MI5?
  4. I didn't attend the event even though it was within my city (sort of if you count where I live as "greater Los Angeles"). However, I did know people attending, and I had one of them pick me up some of the pieces of wallpaper that Arwel sells, so I'm expecting those soon.
  5. Although Moffat has said before that he has a 5th season in mind, I really feel as if he and Gatiss have painted themselves into a corner. I am honestly not sure they had Eurus in mind in S1 and S2. But somewhere between S2 and S3 they came up with something that really didn't quite work (I keep thinking of the line from THE GRINCH WHO STOLE CHRISTMAS - "Then he got an idea. An awful idea. The Grinch got a wonderful, awful idea!"), and I hate saying that because I love the show so much. But I did not LOVE S4 the way l loved the others (I am not including TAB when I say S4). Although I knew that Moriarty was dead, I did like the idea that his influence was not - but not through Eurus. I think at this point they are so far left field of any pretense of canon that they simply have no place to go.
  6. Maybe this as been mentioned before, maybe not, but does anyone know the background music from the dropped tea cup sequence? It's some famous classical piece, and I want to say Mozart or Beethoven, but perhaps someone can be more specific? The car chase is of course Beethoven' 9th. Nevermind. It's the andante movement from Mozart's 21st piano concerto.
  7. Of the three episodes form S4, I think it was right to choose TLD for Emmy selection, regardless of whether or not Moffat wrote it. It was a much more cohesive and complex episode, and it also stands out for BC too. Did he get nominated?
  8. Sherlock would only cock-block, just as he has done repeatedly.
  9. But is it a matter of shipping? I don't think so. I think it is merely examining what is already there and saying that although they didn't come together as a couple on the screen, that clearly there is something very special but very much in the background between them, and it had been brewing and bubbling since ASIB and finally had some resolution in TFP. As both John and Sherlock said, "It is what it is."
  10. I should also add that it's very hard to say ILY to someone for the first time because of the fear of rejection, another reason why I think she had him say it first. She created her own soft landing by that. She may have always felt it, and he may have known for a long time that she felt that way, but saying the actual words was something entirely different. To him they were just words to be said... until he said them himself. Then he had a little light bulb moment. Those words were powerful.
  11. Well, lots of things. First of all, I think she and Sherlock have a very deep friendship, and that no matter what, he can count on her and trust her, even if he's being an ass, even if he's drugged out--he knows she will be there for him and NOT because she's pining hopelessly for him but because he put his trust in her when his life was on the line. That alone created an intimate bond between them that could never be broken. She was there for him, believing in him in his darkest hour and he clung to that like a lifeline. For two years she didn't spill the beans. If he had died on his mission, she probably never would have said anything. Why put John through Sherlock's death twice? The point is that she and Sherlock have an unstated intimacy between them (not sexual but deep friendship). He probably calls her often. Sometimes for a favor, sometimes to gossip. He expects her to pick up the phone when he calls, and I think it's a bit of a wake up call to him when she doesn't pick up every call. He's in a bit of a panic about her not picking up, but she's not in a panic. He also knows flat out since ASIB that she loves him, that all the adornment she wore and the color of her lipstick and the color of the wrapping paper was all for him. And having her work with him for a day in TEH was like a date - Sherlock version - that ended with him wishing her a happy life when he acknowledged her engagement. Two ships passing on the night, but she declared out of his earshot that he was just her type. Still she carried on with Tom for another 6 months but it was clear at John and Mary's wedding that she only had eyes for Sherlock and that Tom was doomed. The writers could have had her go on with Tom and live happily ever after, but they didn't. They freed her up. In TAB, much nonsense was made of Sherlock not knowing Dr. Hooper was actually a woman, people forgetting that Sherlock assigned her that role in his mind palace, and just as she had kept his secrets after TRF, he keeps that secret for her. He protects her. That's how he feels - protective of her since TRF. And at the end when the ladies are revealed in that cavern, she steps forward into the warm light by him but Janine only stays in the background, and Irene is nothing more than a picture in a locket. That warm light is very deliberate on the part of the filmmakers. This is how he thinks of her - warmly. This is his mind palace. That's why he would never do anything to humiliate her in TFP, and Eurus' interpretation of it was from the POV of a psychopath. Molly knows he knows how she feels. Whatever happened that made her day bad was like her saying, "Really, you want to do this now? Why are you asking me?" She had to believe, however, that there was something more to the question or he wouldn't be asking it at all. Of course I'm not saying she thought that there was any kind of nefarious plot behind it, because she was oblivious, but for him to ask that out of the blue was something that likely triggered that ultimate deep friendship between them where he was saying yet again, "trust me." She could tell he wasn't playing one of his "stupid games." He was too serious for that, but she took control and made him say ILY first, and if he didn't say it like he meant it, she would not have said it back. That he said it even the first time made her smile a bit, but it was only after the meaningful second time that she said it. And that's not humiliation. That's actually her level of trust with him.
  12. If she truly felt she was being humiliated, she would not have done it. She would have told him to bugger off and hung up on him. If he also hadn't said ILY like he meant it, she would have just hung up on him, because she does see through his bullshit and always has, as is documented as far back as TBB in her blog. I think the call was bad timing for whatever reason she was having a bad day, but I don't think humiliation was happening.
  13. Well they've already done all the big ones, so who knows... and they've always said, it's not a detective show. It's a show about a detective.
  14. I seriously doubt they will just wash S1-4 under the bridge as if it never happened. That would be a little too weird.
  15. Well, I think the "he hurt and humiliated Molly" is not true. He never humiliated her at all. From her perspective, it's just a private conversation between her and Sherlock, and I think he did everything he could to do it in a way that would not be hurtful. What would have been truly humiliating would have been for her to have been under direct Eurus' influence KNOWING that John and Mycroft were watching, but she didn't know. As I said, as far as she is concerned, it's a private conversation that has become intimate.
  16. But I don't believe that Sherlock's knee-jerk reaction to be abrasive is in play the way it was up to TRF, and I'm just talking in general. I think he really took a look at the damage his words and unsolicited deductions can do with the death of Mary. Then he got put through the emotional wringer in TFP not only with the ILY scene but also the whole memory recovery of Redbeard and what that was all really about. Mycroft said that Sherlock was an emotional child, and those emotions came to the surface when he lost control by smashing the coffin (for whatever reason may be assigned to the coffin-smashing, the point is that he totally lost control of his emotions and took them out on the coffin, something we haven't seen before). So while I don't believe we will see a teddy-bear Sherlock should more episodes ever happen, I do believe we will see a more human, vulnerable Sherlock, one who no longer hides himself behind his cold, deductive reasoning. Plus, if the show ever comes back, Rosie will be several years older, and they will have to deal with that. And will his and Molly's relationship been in limbo for all that time? That doesn't really work.
  17. Actually, Sherlock said "You do count. You've always counted and I've always trusted you." He later called her the one "who mattered the most." Now, I'm not here to argue Sherlolly because it's not worth the aggravation. However, I do believe she took the bull by the horns in the ILY scene by making him say it first. But then, she's always been the one to put him in line when he's out of line, and he falls back into place at her prompting and becomes sincere, just as he has done since ASIB,, which is why I believe his second ILY was sincere (though not in a gushy, hearts aflutter way). That's one of the reasons he uses her to focus in his mind palace after being shot. She keeps him in line in a way that John never could because John and Sherlock are generally goofing around. Does Sherlock heed John's admonishment to apologize to Mrs. Hudson at the beginning of THOB? No. Does he immediately back off after insulting Molly and apologize in ASIB? Yes. And he's sincere. In fact, aside from saying, "Don't make jokes, Molly. It's really not your area." in TRF, he doesn't really say disparaging things to her again. He doesn't even comment on Tom in TEH although he was quick to comment "gay" on Jim from IT in TGG. Molly, the one person who learned to see through his bullshit, according to John in TLD, is indeed not the last person Sherlock would ever think of. No, he has thought of her long before John did. If the series ever does go forward, they have to deal with the consequences of the ILY and have Sherlock and Molly in a different place. Not canon? Canon is out the window at the point with Eurus, so it doesn't matter.
  18. So I watched/listened to "The Final Problem" again tonight, and I was struck by a couple of thoughts regarding the whole coffin scene: 1) When Mycroft says "So who loves Sherlock?" that's in the present tense, and John responds soon after "Irene Adler." Mycroft did not respond at all to that, which leads me to believe that he always knew she was alive and that he had just bluffed to John at the end of ASIB about her truly being dead. Otherwise, he would have said something to the effect of "What do you mean, Irene Adler? She's dead." But he didn't. 2) The level of intimacy between Molly and Sherlock that precedes the "I love you" bit. He expects her to take his calls, as if she always takes his calls. He counts on her being there for him. Even as far back as ASIB, he clearly gossiped to her when they were together. So what I am saying is that there is a deep level of trust and intimacy between them. He actually does love her. I know I am barking up an unpopular tree by saying that, but the more you study it, the more you realize just how much he has grown to love her. Maybe not in a totally romantic way (something that is a bit foreign to him anyhow) - but in a deep, abiding way, and that is pretty heady stuff coming from him because it's truer than romantic love.
  19. The "amo" thing and the texting ... I really thought those were either going to turn out to be red herrings, or have some significance in the later episodes. But they were neither ... just pointless detail, imo. I do think "amo" was meant to be a red herring, but they muffed it if it was. That's the main thing I notice about T6T, sfmpco ... it doesn't fit, it feels like it's from a different TV show. And it drives me freakin' nutz. I think I could accept some of the silliness more if the dang thing didn't just LOOK so wrong .... ak!!!!!!!! I sort of felt like none of S4 fit, but there were some nice moments in each episode with TLD having the bulk of the good moments.
  20. Well, I think when they wrote TRF in 2011 that they didn't have the whole Eurus plot line worked out (if at all) since THE EAST WIND and REDBEARD didn't come up until S3, and the when S4 came around they were trying to force dots to connect backwards, but it's an awkward fit, and it doesn't all match perfectly. Perhaps they should have taken some tips from JK Rowling on how to plan out a plot line and stories for years to come.
  21. The 'amo" wasn't a red herring as it clearly went back to the code name LOVE of one of the people involved with the Tblisi incident, although that person, Lady Smallwood, was nearly framed for what her secretary actually did.
  22. We do? CAM somehow knew something about it (and just how did that happen??????), although he may have known nothing more than the name. But I can't remember anything Moriarty said to indicate he knew ... ? What did I miss? JIM: I’m your Christmas present. (He strolls forward again, Eurus also approaching the glass from her side. They stop again, Jim looking down at her appraisingly.) JIM (in a whisper): So what’s mine? (Eurus’ eyes turn towards the camera on the wall outside the cell. She focuses in on the red light showing that the camera is active. In the governor’s office, Mycroft watches as the footage is replaced by an image of a heavy flow of water pouring down the screens. In the cell, Eurus looks at Jim.) EURUS (softly): Redbeard.
  23. The Christmas present wasn't metaphorical. Again I refer to the transcript: GOVERNOR: You even brought her a visitor on Christmas Day. (John frowns.) MYCROFT (quieter): I took a calculated risk. GOVERNOR: You gave her a Christmas present. Remember her Christmas present?
  24. Well we know she gave him information on Redbeard although she didn't know that Sherlock had blocked and rewritten that part of his memory. So she may have only given Moriarty the fact that she murdered Sherlock's best friend, drowned him. Of course, Moriarty's early works included the drowning of Carl Powers, so they no doubt found a common theme...
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.