Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Dear VanBuren Supernova: Shooting the cabbie is not actively violent, in your opinion, despite the high moral principle and nerves of steel accompanying the action? Knocking chairs down all over the flat once Dr Watson discovers the truth about Mary is not violent behaviour? Remember, you set the parameters by inviting us to relate to Sherlock ( the series). What are the indicators ( in the series) that he is better than the average GP, who is, admittedly on a higher percentile scale than the average population, but still not exceptionally so? Indeed, Dr Watson is supposed to represent the general public's view of an exceptional personality, ergo average human.

Alright. I can’t speak for you or your world, obviously.

I also don’t think I would fit there, it’s too black or white for me, but it sounds like a tender world.

 

In mine though, John is not addicted to violence.

 

I even think he is quite opposite of that.

 

Being violent is actively involved is causing harm, intentionally, it could be physical or emotional harms, triggered by anger, furiousness and/or enjoyment. While you are looking at the definition, both scenes arguably fit, and arguably not. I am on the later side. A person might be driven to and described as violent but not necessary mean and right away categorized as violence, let alone addicted to violence.

 

When shooting the cabbie, John did it to save Sherlock. It’s a calm action that he deems necessary until the last moment. He has strong reason to do so and believes by not doing so, someone would be killed. Someone who is addicted to violence doesn’t seek good reason, some don’t even need reasons, they just enjoy chance to cause and witnessing harms.

 

Knocking chair all over the flat because of Mary. I would say that is the opposite of violence addiction. To me, he displays ability for self-control, even in the way he is speaking. Furious, yes, angry, yes, who doesn’t in his shoes? Shock, disbelieve, at the same time angry at himself about how he overlooks all that, but what he does is the smallest amount of harm. He doesn’t harm anybody but hurting his own leg, he doesn’t even destroy the chair, he doesn’t say something close to verbal abuse. I destroy more stuffs in lesser situations, although in this case, I might only just sit down and refuse to talk, or go away, disappear.

 

In other scenarios, imo, John exercises much more self-control. For example, in SIB, while he is angry, he listens to Sherlock and gets Mrs. Hudson down and treats her injuries without rush. He doesn’t give that CIA agent a couple of blows or hurries up treating Mrs. Hudson to confront him. I would. (that would get me categorized as violent in your eyes. I don’t argue if that’s your POV, I assure you I haven’t intentionally hurt someone, or a fly. (mosquitoes, spiders, yes, if they are unlucky enough that I share a home with them, but I believe I had and am capable to lose control badly when reacting to someone who wants to harm me or my family or friends).

 

John doesn’t attack people without little excuses, being provoked, or when not in self-defense. He exercises a very good amount of compassion that someone addicted to violence wouldn’t have. He likes excitement, adrenalin, yes, steady life is boring to him. It’s common, that is the reasons for extreme sports existence, for us who prefer to live in peaceful world yet desire adrenalin kicks once in a while.

 

Someone addicted to violence would create chances or jumps to any chance to be involved, it’s dangerous and extreme trait I would even argue that even Moriarty might not have that.

 

Now. John. Why he is above average in my eyes.

 

As mentioned, book smart, numbers, mean little to me. I appreciate Emotional Intelligence and street smart much more, those are more valuable in my world, and I think, in Sherlock’s world. Most of the characters have great amount of street smart that enable them to survive and thrive there.

 

John, why I think he is smart.

 

Indicators in BBC series, yes, there are plenty. Again, in my world.

 

Here are some on top of my head.

 

UAP: He knows something is wrong when Sherlock is kidnapped by the cabbie.

 

SIP: He knows something is not right and decides to follow the (chip, detector, allocator?)

 

TBB: He follows different clue and ends up like Sherlock does in Chinatown.

 

TGG: He makes relation of the phone messenge with the whereabouts of Golem.

 

SIB: He knows what is coming by looking at Molly’s expression during Christmas party.

 

TRF: He gets Mycroft using Mycroft’s way. Appearing in his office and surprises Mycroft is not easy to pull.

 

TSoT: He uses the right method and assertiveness to get the official to let him examine the victim in the changing room.

 

HLV: He figures it out when sitting on his chair and sees the perfume bottle.

 

Non specific: He is good at his field, although Bill Wiggin doubts that sprain is supposed to be squishy XD. He is able to follow Sherlock’s explanations even though he may not get it the first time (no one says he is as smart as Sherlock), he is good in reading situation and react fast in fights, and he survives in Sherlock’s world.

 

That is my view, he is far more intelligent than many people out there and I definitely think highly of him.

  • Like 3
Posted

 

To compromise my guilt of long posts streak..

 

Like John, I fight with machine. All the time. They hate me.

 

Always unfair fights.

They also just sit there, but they always win, everytime.

  • Like 2
Posted

Dear VanBurenSupernova, you have much more empathy than you let on :D ! My world has always been sort of black and white, greys and gradations thereof not my thing, really! You work with machines, I have to work with people; much more complicated machinery that requires careful handling: we wouldn't want bruised egos in students and colleagues, now would we? Internal seething permitted at the unconscionably long time some of them take to see the end result, so daydreaming sets in.

Dr Watson pulls rank in HoB and SoT, not a particular feat of intelligence. He is capable of thinking on his own, I never said he cannot do up his shoelaces, like Basil Rathbone's Dr Watson (Nigel Bruce), but he does have trust issues and anger management issues, and he is, I repeat, like all doctors, slightly more intelligent than the average person, so he can perform simple deductions on his own. As for going to the Diogenes, Mycroft had invited him first, to show him all the snipers congregating around the flat, so when Sherlock went to Molly, Dr Watson went to Mycroft to get some answers, perhaps because he was, for the moment, also a fugitive, like Sherlock?

  • Like 1
Posted

.... John is not addicted to violence.

 

I even think he is quite opposite of that........

That's one of the best descriptions of "our" John Watson I've ever read. I've basically dismissed the "addicted to danger" description as just some more of Mr. Moffat's love of dramatic language. I think a more accurate phrase would be that he likes to problem solve, but that doesn't sound very sexy! :D And I agree that John is intelligent, sometimes even more so than Sherlock; John wouldn't have climbed into a cab with a serial killer. It's just a different kind of intelligence, put to a different use. Sherlock's motive is to entertain himself; John's is to help people.

 

Dear VanBurenSupernova, you have much more empathy than you let on :D !

Agreed! :applause:

 

... but he does have trust issues and anger management issues ....

Now that you mention it, I don't actually see any evidence for John having trust issues; considering the circumstances under which he met Mycroft, I would have been pretty suspicious too! But he doesn't seem all that distrustful with anyone else; emotionally repressed sometimes, but then, he is British. And male. :D

 

At any rate, I'm willing to accept that he does have trust issues; it doesn't seem particularly relevant to the story either way. But I don't believe he has anger management issues. Having anger management issues doesn't mean that you get angry, it means that when you do, you lash out inappropriately, and to a frightening degree. We see John get angry a lot, but not without provocation; and he doesn't overreact, in spite of what Sherlock might think about it. (Sherlock is hardly the norm to which we should be comparing human behavior! :smile: ) Even when John assaults Sherlock, he does it with restraint ... or Sherlock would have been beaten to death by the end of the evening. (Assuming he continued to not defend himself.) I can't begin to imagine John treating Mary or Molly the same way, though.

  • Like 2
Posted

Quite frankly, the Dr Watson of the series is a person I could never relate to on so many levels that I would have to go on a rant! He is definitely NOT Sherlock's or anyone else's best friend, he has been portrayed in such a way that he becomes quite unlikeable at times, I would never compare anyone on the forum that I'm on polite terms with to this portrayal of Dr Watson.

Which is, perhaps, the reason that I never ended up with his character in any of Shadow Dweller's and other quizzes out there.

Trust issues: "She wasn't supposed to be like that, why is she like that?" Great comment, dear doctor, why is she like that, indeed, except that abnormal attraction to violence and uncritical thinking lead to such life choices; along with threatening a plainly barely standing Sherlock that if he didn't shut up he would not need morphine! Great best friend, no doubt, too. Kicking furniture around is a great way to control anger, as well!

  • Like 1
Posted

Inge, you're saying that Dr. Watson as portrayed by Martin Freeman isn't anyone's best friend?!   This is what I get for skimming this thread. 

 

b01be8f47d_96549733_o2.gif

Posted

I have to think about John for a bit and come back with something attempting to resemble a vaguely intelligible answer.  For now, I'll be on my fainting couch with my smelling salts.  

  • Like 3
Posted

Dear Sitty, why not find the scene from HLV when they come back to the flat and post that, too? I take it that we have all done our re-watch, of course. And it's funny that you picked Sherlock's reaction to the rather angry "drama queen " assertion to prove my point. Even in SoT, the dear doctor lets his frustrated anger run away with him! Good point, thanks!

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, I definitely agree with Watson in that I think Sherlock is a drama queen.  So is Mycroft.  The Holmes boys definitely have a flair for the dramatic!  

 

I would agree with the assertion that John can be hot-tempered, but I don't think his being hot-tempered precludes him from being a good friend.  John has gone above and beyond as a friend for Sherlock countless times.  And clearly Sherlock considers John a good friend.  I don't think John's the most interesting character in this show by far, but I think it's hard to be interesting and stand out when you're comparing him to Sherlock, Mycroft, Irene, Moriarty.  Brainy is the new sexy.

 

But back to John's temper and violent behavior, some examples you gave:

 

His anger in the flat in HLV:  I think John's anger here is perfectly justified.  He's just discovered that the supposed love of his life is some sort of former/current(?) assassin and leads/led a life completely different from what John thought AND she nearly killed his best friend.  Mary is not who he thought she was.  I don't take his anger directed at Sherlock in this scene as anything other than him trying to get Sherlock to shut his trap.  John is furious with Mary.  Sherlock is prone to smart-ass remarks that are a bit not good and the last thing John is wanting in this very traumatic moment is Sherlock is running his mouth.  I think Sherlock makes some very accurate statements when he points out that there are underlying reasons why Watson was drawn to her, but from an emotional standpoint that's not what John needed to hear in that moment.  When people are angry and upset they're often not rational, and if you are, well kudos to you because I know I'm certainly not.   I haven't watched HLV recently so I can't remember the chair bit specifically to remember how dramatic or violent it was.  Also, about threatening Sherlock while he's in terrible shape... I think two things are going on there:  1.)  John is in such a blind rage about the Mary thing I think he's oblivious to how unwell Sherlock is, and 2.)  His threatening to make sure he doesn't need the morphine is not really a threat.  To me that's just a snarky way of saying "shut up."

 

TSOT (from my gif):  I don't find John to be all that angry in that scene, to be honest.  Sherlock is saying he can't solve it, tells John to get his wife under control (oh Sherlock...not good), and then plays all confused and dumb like "Moi?!".  This is a do or die moment to save Sholto and John is trying to get him to solve the puzzle so Sholto will open the door and they can save him.  John raises his voice a bit.  A lot of people raise their voice with Sherlock.  He can be a bit infuriating and a bit of a git at times.  

 

Frankly, hot-tempered aside, I think John shows a lot of patience with Sherlock that other people haven't.  Also, John, like every other character, is there to aid in the telling of the story.  To me John helps exemplify how Sherlock can be frustrating and childish.  Make the character of Watson a bit hot under the collar and you can get a bit of humor out of it (I personally find Sherlock and John bickering entertaining) and at the same time use it as an illustration of where Sherlock lacks in being a good man.  

 

  • Like 3
Posted

I also wanted to add that I give a lot of leeway to fictional shows and books as far as character behavior.  Things in fiction can be more over the top than I would accept as normal and OK in everyday life.    There are very few things that really bother me in this show as far character behavior goes and that make me truly uncomfortable.  One is the character of CAM, and I think he's meant to do that, and the other is in ASIP when Sherlock is essentially torturing the dying cabbie for information. 

  • Like 1
Posted

Two more little things why I relate to Sherlock:

 

Despite being a loner, I tend to think better when I speak. Maybe I should get me a Billy the Scull (wouldn't be too good in an anxiety phase) or a Wilson (from Castaway) or just start to talk to my dolls. Okay, sometimes I also think better when I write, so I will rather stick with you. :wub:

 

I really like the idea of wearing the same clothes all the time. Or having a lot of the same pieces, like Sherlock his coats.

Sadly before I realize that a piece suits me and I like it - it's long gone from the market. Beside this, if I started to wear the same all the time, I would officially become the freak of the team.

  • Like 1
Posted

Dear sitty, that included some lovely insights, with which I happen to agree only partly. This Dr Watson is a caricature, therefore not relatable in any positive way! His anger does run away with him, so do his past and his insecurity, traits that make him a loose cannon sometimes. Granted, he has had to put up with a lot from his flat ate, but the original choice was his: he could not have accepted either the flat share or Sherlock's original invitation in SiP. Having done so, his anger management leaves much to be desired, and his uncontrollable temper makes him a bit hypocritical when he tries to rein in Sherlock at a crime scene.

Posted

I wouldn't disagree that he's a caricature.  I can't really compare him to the "real" Watson of ACD as I still haven't read beyond A Study in Scarlet, but I would definitely say that there are exaggerated aspects to his personality.  As a whole, I feel like many of the characters in this show seem very unrealistic to me in that sense.  I really can't imagine meeting many of these characters on the street.  If I didn't know Mrs. Hudson's past, maybe her?  Maybe Lestrade.  Maybe Molly.  Everyone else, not so much.  Obviously, that doesn't detract from my enjoyment of it.

Posted

Quite frankly, the Dr Watson of the series is a person I could never relate to on so many levels that I would have to go on a rant! He is definitely NOT Sherlock's or anyone else's best friend, he has been portrayed in such a way that he becomes quite unlikeable at times, I would never compare anyone on the forum that I'm on polite terms with to this portrayal of Dr Watson.... Kicking furniture around is a great way to control anger, as well!

I can understand having an aversion to John's anger; it can be very uncomfortable to be around someone who's angry. I have to admit, though, that most of the time I don't see his anger as actual anger; frustration, annoyance, bemusement ... expressed vehemently because nothing else seems to get through to Sherlock (and even that doesn't work half the time!) Even in TEH I don't think he's angry so much as he's hurt and bewildered by Sherlock's colossal betrayal. I find his reactions to be very honest and true, even if they aren't always rational. Far more honest than Sherlock stoically denying he has feelings....

 

b01be8f47d_96549733_o2.gif

I love Sherlock's reaction here, I wish they hadn't cut away from it quite so fast ... he's so insulted, and so innocent about it! :D And no, I don't think John is angry here, he's anxious and urgent ... his friend's about to die and his other friend isn't helping the way he should be able to...

 

His anger in the flat in HLV:  I think John's anger here is perfectly justified.  He's just discovered that the supposed love of his life is some sort of former/current(?) assassin and leads/led a life completely different from what John thought AND she nearly killed his best friend.  Mary is not who he thought she was.  I don't take his anger directed at Sherlock in this scene as anything other than him trying to get Sherlock to shut his trap.  John is furious with Mary.  Sherlock is prone to smart-ass remarks that are a bit not good and the last thing John is wanting in this very traumatic moment is Sherlock is running his mouth.  I think Sherlock makes some very accurate statements when he points out that there are underlying reasons why Watson was drawn to her, but from an emotional standpoint that's not what John needed to hear in that moment.  When people are angry and upset they're often not rational, and if you are, well kudos to you because I know I'm certainly not.   I haven't watched HLV recently so I can't remember the chair bit specifically to remember how dramatic or violent it was.  Also, about threatening Sherlock while he's in terrible shape... I think two things are going on there:  1.)  John is in such a blind rage about the Mary thing I think he's oblivious to how unwell Sherlock is, and 2.)  His threatening to make sure he doesn't need the morphine is not really a threat.  To me that's just a snarky way of saying "shut up."

This has always been my take as well; Dr. Watson is basically having the worst (2nd worst?) day of his life, and Sherlock, as usual, refuses to tend to his needs. I think John shows remarkable restraint, to be honest. And there is always the element of humor to consider; even in a scene like this, Moffat manages to mine the dialog for a bitter laugh. Nice touch, imo. In spite of his love for overstating the drama at times, Moffat can also be remarkably subtle with language.

 

Two more little things why I relate to Sherlock:

 

Despite being a loner, I tend to think better when I speak. Maybe I should get me a Billy the Scull (wouldn't be too good in an anxiety phase) or a Wilson (from Castaway) or just start to talk to my dolls. Okay, sometimes I also think better when I write, so I will rather stick with you. :wub:

OMG, I do the same thing. When I have a really difficult problem to solve I instinctively run it past someone else. Why I find that helpful I don't know, but I do. If no one's around I'll even talk to myself! (Not that I'm crazy or anything... ) Gosh, I hope other people don't find that annoying! Hm, maybe I should get a skull ....)

 

Dear sitty, that included some lovely insights, with which I happen to agree only partly. This Dr Watson is a caricature, therefore not relatable in any positive way! His anger does run away with him, so do his past and his insecurity, traits that make him a loose cannon sometimes. Granted, he has had to put up with a lot from his flat ate, but the original choice was his: he could not have accepted either the flat share or Sherlock's original invitation in SiP. Having done so, his anger management leaves much to be desired, and his uncontrollable temper makes him a bit hypocritical when he tries to rein in Sherlock at a crime scene.

It would seem it comes down to how you interpret John's reactions; Sitty and I see him more as annoyed, and at his wit's end trying to communicate with Sherlock; you and Inge see it as anger. The difference as pretty subtle, I'll grant you that, and the truth may be somewhere in between, for all I know. But if I were to take away one image of John, and one only, to represent who he is, it would be the image of his smile when he tells Sherlock -- Sherlock Bloody Holmes, of all people! -- that he's his best friend. If I knew nothing else about John Watson, that one expression would be enough.

  • Like 3
Posted

Van Buren Supernova, where are you at all of my childhood? I can use your companionship and we can go into our special brand of shenanigans together! :DDD

 

Oh look, you read Arcadia. Please do it to me too even if it only consist of 'SD is an attention-seeking prat' XD

 

Reason why I disappeared for few days: someone who I practically grew up with is dying and I went back and forth to hospital. Not bragging but reality, in the midst of confusion and emotional turmoil here I am the sole island of calm. Feel nothing beside backache from standing and walking for hours non stop but still watching doctors and nurses talking, trying to persuade the patient's husband to enter her into ICU using 'she's suffering here' argument, interjecting their 'persuasive attempts' with well-placed questions and bullying them to attend to this patient's needs NOW. I don't know why I didn't feel sad or scared but someone have to keep clear head on this situation. A bit like Sherlock's 'nothing I can do anymore for the people caught in the explosion so I focus to the other case' thing (maybe).

  • Like 5
Posted

Oh dear, ShadowDweller! You have all my sympathy! My first-hand knowledge comes from having hat to sit at too many bedsides , my aunt being the most heartbreaking, with her non-Hodging lymphoma, but there have been so many others, and right now I'm and out of hospital for a 3 and a half year old boy with terminal pancolitis: he either gets operated on ASAP or he won't get to blow his fourth birthday candle in November! We can lose ourselves in here, have fun, argue, bicker, but real life is so much harder to handle! All my hopes to you, to keep up your strength!

@Dear Arcadia, that thing about being Sherlock's best friend is Dr Watson's perception of the situation. Best friends don't try to throttle one the moment they clap eyes on one after having for so long prayed for one to work one more miracle and not be dead, nor do they punch them in the face, contrary to SIB, nor head butt them! In HoB Sherlock himself tells Dr Watson that he doesn't have friends, only one, and perhaps the dear genius has deluded himself into believing this, because he doesn't want to be Mycroft: "Oh, yes, friends! I wonder what they were thinking about" in TEH.

  • Like 1
Posted

Shadow - I would rather have you at my side than someone crying over me, or even holding my hand. Thousand times better.

I, for my part, would try to run away if only possible.

 

 

 

Arcadia: When I have a really difficult problem to solve I instinctively run it past someone else. Why I find that helpful I don't know, but I do

This has something to do with the way the brain is working. Talking/writing is like re-entering the thoughts from outside, so it gets processed in another part of it. Something like this.

  • Like 1
Posted

Reason why I disappeared for few days: someone who I practically grew up with is dying and I went back and forth to hospital. Not bragging but reality, in the midst of confusion and emotional turmoil here I am the sole island of calm. Feel nothing beside backache from standing and walking for hours non stop but still watching doctors and nurses talking, trying to persuade the patient's husband to enter her into ICU using 'she's suffering here' argument, interjecting their 'persuasive attempts' with well-placed questions and bullying them to attend to this patient's needs NOW. I don't know why I didn't feel sad or scared but someone have to keep clear head on this situation. A bit like Sherlock's 'nothing I can do anymore for the people caught in the explosion so I focus to the other case' thing (maybe).

Oh dear, ShadowDweller! You have all my sympathy! My first-hand knowledge comes from having hat to sit at too many bedsides , my aunt being the most heartbreaking, with her non-Hodging lymphoma, but there have been so many others, and right now I'm and out of hospital for a 3 and a half year old boy with terminal pancolitis: he either gets operated on ASAP or he won't get to blow his fourth birthday candle in November! We can lose ourselves in here, have fun, argue, bicker, but real life is so much harder to handle! All my hopes to you, to keep up your strength!

Oh, you both have my empathy. Have visited a few too many hospital rooms myself. Condolences.

 

@Dear Arcadia, that thing about being Sherlock's best friend is Dr Watson's perception of the situation. Best friends don't try to throttle one the moment they clap eyes on one after having for so long prayed for one to work one more miracle and not be dead, nor do they punch them in the face, contrary to SIB, nor head butt them! In HoB Sherlock himself tells Dr Watson that he doesn't have friends, only one, and perhaps the dear genius has deluded himself into believing this, because he doesn't want to be Mycroft: "Oh, yes, friends! I wonder what they were thinking about" in TEH.

Oh, I disagree, I think it's the people you feel safest with that you are most likely to express your feelings to, especially if those feelings are negative. I've seen that relationship at work so many times; it's very human. And a violent physical reaction is a very believable response to betrayal. Betrayal (which is what Sherlock did to John, at least from John's p.o.v.) is one of the worst things one can do to a friend.

 

And again, we must consider that Sherlock, the show, is at it's core meant to be humorous, and humor typically depends on exaggeration. In real life I imagine John would have shouted, maybe shoved Sherlock a little; but that hardly would have elicited a laugh from the audience. And the laugh was important there, otherwise the show risked becoming maudlin. Can't have that! -- as Carol and I have maintained many times, this is a show about boys, by boys, for boys. (Why so many girls like it too is a complete mystery to every man connected with it, it seems.) And boys are not going to settle for maudlin, they want to see some action and humor, preferably crude! :D

 

 

Arcadia: When I have a really difficult problem to solve I instinctively run it past someone else. Why I find that helpful I don't know, but I do

This has something to do with the way the brain is working. Talking/writing is like re-entering the thoughts from outside, so it gets processed in another part of it. Something like this.

 

Sort of like how writing stuff down helps you remember it better? The funny thing is, I don't think I realized I had this trait until I saw Sherlock! :lol:

  • Like 2
Posted

My world has always been sort of black and white, greys and gradations thereof not my thing, really! You work with machines, I have to work with people; much more complicated machinery that requires careful handling: we wouldn't want bruised egos in students and colleagues, now would we?

I have computer, but I work with human, not machinery at all. I don't know why you straight-away  confidently conclude that from a passing joke, but I guess that is where we are different. (I don't mind being a expert machinist though, would build myself an ironman suit to fly, Wohoooooo! Imagine the area coverage of my bolt hole!)

 

Same with you, I work with human, of course I don't want anybody's bruised ego (selfish reasons, I'm too lazy to deal with that)

now, the difference with you,

to me, exactly because I work with human, I can't look at them in black or white.

What is applicable to one might differ with another. Everyone has their own baggage, strength and weaknesses.

One might be clot in something but excellent in another. One might be motivated with reward another might be motivated by challenge. And they self-upgrade/downgrade their operating systems as they wish, go on screen saver mode when you want them to generate something and vice versa.

Nothing is black and white to me.

Dealing with human is exhausting, unlike machine, there is no control panel/template/exact formula for that.

Same thing with animals. I have chance to work with them to certain extent, but animals are cuter and less annoying than human. XD

 

 

Dear VanBurenSupernova, you have much more empathy than you let on :D !

Agreed! :applause:

 

 

But....... I just snapped at my colleague today and told him, "If you want to quit, quit! Go ahead already. Whatever! But you have to do your job while you are still here." And that is after no comment from me the first five times he said he is quitting on different occasions. What does he want, bait for attention, want more compassionate words? We are working in an intense project and he is one of key person. But lately, every project discussion he would say variation of him quitting. As usual, kinder people offers nice words, it's a shame etc etc, but no, I can't.

I'm lucky that I'm at the same range, but my other colleagues depend on him doing his job right instead of bit*ching about quitting but never does.

I won't be here next month you know, prepare to deal with my replacement (in five variations) then look at everyone and wait for reactions. Wtf...well..today he finally got it from me. Not what he expects I guess, and I feel no remorse. None.

 

So you guys take it back now? I guess so....! XD

 

Frankly, hot-tempered aside, I think John shows a lot of patience with Sherlock that other people haven't.  Also, John, like every other character, is there to aid in the telling of the story.  To me John helps exemplify how Sherlock can be frustrating and childish.  Make the character of Watson a bit hot under the collar and you can get a bit of humor out of it (I personally find Sherlock and John bickering entertaining) and at the same time use it as an illustration of where Sherlock lacks in being a good man.

  

It would seem it comes down to how you interpret John's reactions; Sitty and I see him more as annoyed, and at his wit's end trying to communicate with Sherlock; you and Inge see it as anger. The difference as pretty subtle, I'll grant you that, and the truth may be somewhere in between, for all I know. But if I were to take away one image of John, and one only, to represent who he is, it would be the image of his smile when he tells Sherlock -- Sherlock Bloody Holmes, of all people! -- that he's his best friend. If I knew nothing else about John Watson, that one expression would be enough.

Count me in..!

  • Like 2
Posted

I never wanted to work with people. I seem to have a kind of instinct dealing with mechanics, for people I need manuals. And even if I have read plenty of them, it still doesn't help - not when I'm involved as a part of a situation.

This is a aspect that I like to project onto Sherlock. He can analyze people's behavior, but he himself seems to be his interpersonal blind spot.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Granted, she's not the reason I started watching and fell in love with the show.  Cinematographically the show is gorgeous, and I'm a sucker for that (Hannibal?).  And Sherlock (the character) is every bit as exotic and beautiful as the cinematography.    

tumblr_nl2w0ldmOD1tq9fopo2_250.gif

I have to admit, I identify with THIS ... the cinematography just sent me on first sight, and so did Sherlock a short time later. So in that sense ... yep, I'm a Molly too. And that is the perfect gif to explain Sherlock's allure; heaven help me, I just luvvvvv watching that man move.... :drool:

The brain, The Voice, the music, cinematography, the eyes, the hand, the smile... EEEKKK.....what is this sticky puddle of liquid on my keyboard??

 

I really like the idea of wearing the same clothes all the time. Or having a lot of the same pieces, like Sherlock his coats.

Sadly before I realize that a piece suits me and I like it - it's long gone from the market. Beside this, if I started to wear the same all the time, I would officially become the freak of the team.

My ex-boss wears the same blue color formal top every day.

Funny enough, my current boss also wear the same type, same color, everyday.

(Ex & current job = 1500 miles apart).

I always have this vision that they are like Batman, or Donald Duck, that they have cupboard filled with identical clothes.

 

Despite being a loner, I tend to think better when I speak. Maybe I should get me a Billy the Scull ....

 

OMG, I do the same thing. When I have a really difficult problem to solve I instinctively run it past someone else. Why I find that helpful I don't know, but I do. If no one's around I'll even talk to myself! (Not that I'm crazy or anything... ) Gosh, I hope other people don't find that annoying! Hm, maybe I should get a skull ....)

There are synthetic skulls out there.. just saying.. just in case you two have different idea.. :P

 

I think I tend to only write keywords when I think. However, sometimes when I read it back, I forget what was original idea behind that very vague keywords. I think I need better system, my brain is a mess.

 

 

Van Buren Supernova, where are you at all of my childhood? I can use your companionship and we can go into our special brand of shenanigans together! :DDD

Sounds good.. looking back, there are not enough shenanigans in my childhood.

Not too worry, my quest is looking for fountain of youth..coming soon, coming soon..

 

Oh look, you read Arcadia. Please do it to me too even if it only consist of 'SD is an attention-seeking prat' XD

Oh I won't settle just with that! :lol:

It's walking on thin ice, but if I said anything wrong, you would not be able to whack me.

And again, disclaimer, I'm not always responsible for anything said under my username. XD

 

So...

Picking from passing east wind,

 

I think you are probably the sort of person who says anything that comes to your mind, not hiding behind a filter. When something connects in the brain, you'd say it the way you feel at that moment. I think it's the matter of being honest because you don't dwell on that, maybe sometimes you find yourself surprised when someone does while you already move on.

 

You might have capability to talk someone to their tears but also genuinely give them a clean slate to start over the day after, and wonder why they seems confused and cautious.

You might also be an expressive person, sometimes you could get excited about little things while other time you can be very serious and reserved, and I imagine it might be difficult for you to do nothing or just one single thing, busy little bee type? I think you are also committed to make something work when you are on it.

 

One thing I'm more certain, you are confident and sure about yourself, never feel you have to apologize or question yourself for who you are. Nobody does...! Well, as long as they are not serial killer or something.

 

Although I'm not sure who would you be, those above sound like Sherlock's traits? Except the last one, I think Sherlock is not very sure about himself.

 

Do I get at least one word right?

 

Reason why I disappeared for few days: someone who I practically grew up with is dying and I went back and forth to hospital. Not bragging but reality, in the midst of confusion and emotional turmoil here I am the sole island of calm. Feel nothing beside backache from standing and walking for hours non stop but still watching doctors and nurses talking, trying to persuade the patient's husband to enter her into ICU using 'she's suffering here' argument, interjecting their 'persuasive attempts' with well-placed questions and bullying them to attend to this patient's needs NOW. I don't know why I didn't feel sad or scared but someone have to keep clear head on this situation.

Sometimes when others are in despair, you look around and find out that maybe you are the strongest one there, it could make you take that position and being a rock and functional one for them. Hope all is well.

  • Like 1
Posted

Van Buren: But....... I just snapped at my colleague today and told him, "If you want to quit, quit! Go ahead already. Whatever! But you have to do your job while you are still here."

 

Well, maybe he is trying to say, that something in his opinion is wrong with the work process/interpersonal interaction/whatever and just has no guts to tell it or is just unable to articulate? Did he tell why he wanted to quit?

 

Another thing with showing compassion: I'm always afraid if I do it once, the person could look up to me for more help. Or even - God forbid - might adore me for what I am not, and it is more than I can handle. It happened. I know I'm odd...

  • Like 1
Posted

But....... I just snapped at my colleague today and told him, "If you want to quit, quit! Go ahead already. Whatever! But you have to do your job while you are still here." And that is after no comment from me the first five times he said he is quitting on different occasions. What does he want, bait for attention, want more compassionate words? We are working in an intense project and he is one of key person. But lately, every project discussion he would say variation of him quitting. As usual, kinder people offers nice words, it's a shame etc etc, but no, I can't.

 

I'm lucky that I'm at the same range, but my other colleagues depend on him doing his job right instead of bit*ching about quitting but never does.

I won't be here next month you know, prepare to deal with my replacement (in five variations) then look at everyone and wait for reactions. Wtf...well..today he finally got it from me. Not what he expects I guess, and I feel no remorse. None.

 

So you guys take it back now? I guess so....! XD

Sorry, nope! Sounds to me like you said exactly what the guy needed to hear; sympathy from others wasn't improving his outlook, was it? So what he needed was a reality check; that is, it's about the job, it's not about him, and he just needs to get on with it. The other people are probably wishing they said it first, now. :smile:

 

Another thing with showing compassion: I'm always afraid if I do it once, the person could look up to me for more help. Or even - God forbid - might adore me for what I am not, and it is more than I can handle. It happened. I know I'm odd...

Well, if you're odd, so am I. There are certain people I have to avoid, because if you show them any care or sympathy at all, they try to cling to you for life. They often have genuine troubles; but I can't take on their burdens for them, which seems to be what they want. Some people can, and I admire them for it; but I'm not one of them.

  • Like 2
Posted

@Inge: Definitely! ^^v

 

@J.P. Thank you... blush-skype-smiley.gif

 

@VBS, J.P. & Arcadia: where I may join the 'say no to simpathy-junkies' and 'we don't cater to leeches' clubs?

 

@Van Buren: That looks like what an astrologer would say about the Aries folks :D And yes you did get two things right, "busy little bee" and "you are confident and sure about yourself, never feel you have to apologize or question yourself for who you are. Nobody does...! Well, as long as they are not serial killer or something."

 

Not the strongest but it is because my intense disgust to emotional-based sales pitch and abhorrence of disorder, or at least that's what I think

  • Like 3
Posted

@VBS, J.P. & Arcadia: where I may join the 'say no to simpathy-junkies' and 'we don't cater to leeches' clubs?

 

 

 

I think you just did! Congratulations, we just voted you president and chief bottle washer.

 

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 35 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.