Jump to content

jameskirk

Members
  • Posts

    1
  • Joined

About jameskirk

jameskirk's Achievements

Trainee Detective Constable

Trainee Detective Constable (1/8)

2

Reputation

  1. Evening all. This issue has also been causing me some dissatisfaction. I have however been re-reading 'The Empty House' and in it Holmes offers some explanations which i believe may also resolve the issues in the BBC series. So Holmes explains to Watson that he needed him to be convinced of his death in order to write about it in a convincing way that the world could be sure he was dead. In 'The Empty Hearse', John mentions that Sherlock's parents were not present at his funeral, and I can't help but think what a difficult task it would be for John to convincingly act as if Sherlock were dead and attend his funeral etc. etc. if he were actually in on 'it'. I therefore think it is vital for John, Sherlock's partner who is also somewhat in the public's consciousness, to be convinced of Sherlock's death in order for the world to be convinced of it. The world presuming Sherlock dead has two benefits that I can think of. Firstly, it seems important in restoring Sherlock's crushed reputation. The tragedy surely would make the public more receptive to the idea of his innocence. With Sherlock presumed dead, he can't defend himself from Moriarty's lies and so isn't left open to counter-accusations of constructing his defence. When it is suggested that he was in fact the victim of an evil plot by moriarty, the world is receptive to it because there is nobody as innocent as a victim other than a dead victim. Look, for example, at the guilt experienced by one of Sherlock's accusers Anderson in the wake of his death. The emotive nature of death seems to play an important role here. I am drawn to consider also the importance that Sherlock places on his reputation throughout the series. Secondly, there is a possibility that Sherlock wishes himself to be considered dead in order to aide him in his quest to deconstruct moriartys international network. In 'The Empty House' Holmes explains to Watson that following Moriarty's fall, there are other enemies/ partners of moriartys that he had to tackle next. He says it is important he is considered dead so that none of them suspect he is 'after them' so to speak and therefore have their defences down to an extent. I wonder if this can be interpreted in the BBC series as being equivalent to Moriartys network. I am considering here the over-arching plan of Sherlock's revealed in 'the empty hearse' that all along, dating back to moriartys interrogation and in partnership with mycroft, was to close this network down. Much like in the original writings, might it be of significance to this project of sherlocks for him to be presumed dead so as not to raise alarm or suspicion amongst these enemies? The project is after all, as it turns out, Sherlocks primary objective. SO in conclusion for anyone who has stuck with me through this long maiden post (apologies), I am drawn to the conclusion that this may provide the rationale for Sherlock's death stunt in spite of the fact his friends are not in danger from the snipers. and that Sherlock's explanation to Anderson may be genuine. There is a scene in 'the empty hearse' that further draws me to think this, as when sherlock sits down with john and mary and john asks sherlock to explain 'why' rather than 'how', sherlock instinctively says it was to stop moriarty (as if this were obvious). not for example, to protect johns life. it was all related to helping him bring down moriarty and his extensions. anyway those are my thoughts for what they're worth!
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.