Jump to content

Chronologist

Detectives
  • Posts

    81
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    2

Everything posted by Chronologist

  1. The Greek Interpreter Date: “summer”, sometime after at least one of Watson’s Holmes stories had been published. Comments: Mycroft addresses Watson by saying, “I hear of Sherlock everywhere since you became his chronicler.” This implies that at least some of Watson’s stories have been published by this time. The only Holmes stories that had been published prior to Holmes’ supposed death in May, 1891 were “A Study in Scarlet” and “The Sign of the Four”. “Scarlet” was published in November, 1887, while “Sign” was published in February, 1890. Since, in the “The Final Problem” Watson states that he only has record of three cases with Holmes in 1890, and I’ve already decided those three cases were “The Copper Beeches”, “The Cardboard Box”, and “The Red-Headed League”; and since Mycroft’s statement is at least vague enough that it’s possible only one of Watson’s Holmes stories had been published at this point, I’m inclined to believe that this story takes place in the summer after the publication of “Scarlet”, the Summer of 1888. Going by publication order, the most recently published story taking place in the same season and year is “The Crooked Man”, so I’m placing this story soon after that. No mention is made of Watson’s marriage, but the main events of this story take place over the course of a single night, making it more plausible than the other stories that seem to take place after Watson’s marriage that don’t mention it. Current Canon Placement: After “The Crooked Man” and before “The Five Orange Pips”.
  2. The Resident Patient Date: “October”, “towards the end of the first year during which Holmes” and Watson “shared chambers in Baker Street” Comments: Dating this story is fairly straightforward. “[T]owards the end of the first year” Holmes and Watson were sharing rooms in Baker Street indicates this story took place the same year (and after) “A Study in Scarlet”, which I’ve concluded occurred in 1882. Current Canon Placement: After “A Study in Scarlet” and before “The Speckled Band”.
  3. The Crooked Man Date: “summer” “a few months after” Watson’s marriage Comments: “[A] few months after” implies within less than a year after Watson’s marriage, so I date this story in 1888. Going by publication order, the most recently published story set in the summer of 1888 is “The Stock-Broker’s Clerk”, set in June. I place this story soon after “Clerk”. Current Canon Placement: After “The Stock-Broker’s Clerk” and before “The Five Orange Pips”.
  4. The Reigate Squire Date: “a week after” more than “Three days” after “the fourteenth of April”, “’87” Comments: “[T]the fourteenth of April” is the date Watson receives a telegram that Holmes is in Lyons, having taken ill from working on his latest case. Watson’s able to visit him within 24 hours after that, “Three days later” they’re back in Baker street, “a week after” that they arrive at Colonel Hayter’s home at the start of this case. This ultimately gives us the fairly precise date of April 25, 1887. Current Canon Placement: After “The Musgrave Ritual” and before “The Noble Bachelor”.
  5. The Musgrave Ritual Date: (the time Holmes relates this story to Watson) “winter”, sometime after Holmes told Watson the story of “The ‘Gloria Scott’”, no mention of Watson’s marriage. Comments: There’s not much to indicate when the flashback that is the main story took place, other than before “A Study in Scarlet”. Again, as in “The ‘Gloria Scott’”, I’m solely interested in the time Holmes told Watson this story. Holmes refers to having already told Watson the story of “’Scott’”. Both these “flashback cases” are told to Watson during winter. It’s safe to assume they were both told in the same winter. And, since my chronology otherwise doesn’t have any case set in the year 1886, even though Holmes and Watson apparently spent that whole year together, I’ll place “’Scott’” being told in winter at the end of 1885, while I’ll place this case being told in the same winter at the start of 1886. Current Canon Placement: After “The ‘Gloria Scott’” and before “The Noble Bachelor”.
  6. The “Gloria Scott” Date: (the time Holmes relates this story to Watson) “winter”, no mention of Watson’s marriage. Comments: The bulk of this story is a flashback within a flashback set in the year 1855. The original flashback is supposedly set thirty years later as Holmes’ first case before he met Watson, “thirty years” being mentioned more than once, which is absurd since that would be around 1885, when Holmes and Watson were already sharing rooms together as bachelors for some time. Twenty-five years would be more likely. But for this chronology, I’m solely interested in when Holmes told this story to Watson. Since there’s no mention of Watson’s marriage, I’m inclined to believe this story was told to Watson during the first time period. Going by publication order, the most recently published story from this time period is “The Yellow Face”, which I’ve set in the year 1885. I’ve chosen to believe that Holmes told Watson this story sometime after that, perhaps in the winter of that year. Which means that I’ve set the time when Holmes told this story to Watson in the year 1885, the same year the original flashback supposedly took place in! Current Canon Placement: After “The Yellow Face” and before “The Noble Bachelor”.
  7. The Stock-Broker’s Clerk Date: “June”, “SHORTLY after” Watson’s marriage to Mary Morstan. Comments: Watson provides us with the month right at the start, with the inference that it’s within the first year of his marriage in 1888. An earlier published story, “The Boscombe Valley Mystery”, was also set in a June after Watson’s marriage without specifying a year. Due to the publication order, I placed “Boscombe” in the first year of Watson’s marriage in 1888. “Boscombe” also provides a day of the month of “June 3d”, something this story does not. Due to the early date in “Boscombe”, I’m placing this story after “Boscombe”. Current Canon Placement: After “The Boscombe Valley Mystery” and before “The Five Orange Pips”.
  8. The Yellow Face Date: “early spring”, no mention of Watson’s marriage. Comments: Since Watson appears to be sharing rooms with Holmes with no mention of his wife, this story presumably takes place during the first time period when they’re both bachelors. With no year mentioned, and no past published stories mentioned, I go by the publication order. The most recent published story set in this time period is “Silver Blaze”, which had no indications of its date. The most recent published story from this time period before that was “The Beryl Coronet”, set in February, where snow on the ground is mentioned and is even a factor in the case. In “Silver Blaze”, no snow is mentioned, so it had all probably melted by then. “The Yellow Face” does have a slight indicator of the date, that it’s “early spring”, and Watson even goes so far as to describe how, “the first faint shoots of green were breaking out upon the elms, and the sticky spear-heads of the chestnuts were just beginning to burst into their fivefold leaves.” This suggests that the story is set very early in the spring, which leads me to believe that this story takes place in 1885, the year after “The Beryl Coronet” and “Silver Blaze”. Current Canon Placement: After “Silver Blaze” and before “The Noble Bachelor”.
  9. The Cardboard Box Date: “August”, sometime after “The Sign of the Four”. Comments: Holmes mentions “A Study in Scarlet” and “The Sign of the Four” as past cases, the latter being the case where Watson first met and fell in love with his wife Mary Morstan. As I’m of the opinion that Watson married her soon afterwards, before any other case, I would place this story in the second time period, during Watson’s first marriage. With no year given, I go by the publication order. The most recent published story in this time period is “The Copper Beeches” which is set in early spring, in which I’ve determined to have been in 1890. Therefore, I place this story after “Beeches”, in August, 1890. According to “The Final Problem”, Watson worked with Holmes on only three cases in 1890. By my chronology, those three cases were “The Copper Beeches”, “The Cardboard Box”, and “The Red-Headed League” in that order. This is one of three puzzling cases in the chronology (the other two are “The Copper Beeches” and “The Hound of the Baskervilles”) that appear to take place after Watson’s marriage, but with no mention of that marriage and with Watson sharing rooms with Holmes for an extensive period of time (although in this case, it’s only three days). Here there’s a partial explanation, in that Watson states that he wanted to go on holiday, but a “depleted bank account” caused him to postpone it. Possibly only Mary could go on the full holiday, and Watson chose to send her off early, while he spent the first part of it more cheaply with Holmes before he could afford to go join her. Current Canon Placement: After “The Copper Beeches” and before “The Red-Headed League”.
  10. THE MEMOIRS OF SHERLOCK HOLMES Silver Blaze Date: None given. No mention of Watson’s marriage. Comments: For the first time, a story provides no indication of the date whatsoever. No year, month, season, not even (as in “A Case of Identity”) a day of the month without mentioning the month. Nor is there any mention of past published cases. The only indication of when this story takes place is that Watson appears to be sharing rooms with Holmes full time with no mention of his marriage, indicating this is during the first time period when both Holmes and Watson were bachelors. When I have so little to go on, I rely on the publication order of the stories set in the apparent time period. The most recently published story from the first time period is “The Beryl Coronet”, which is set in February without mentioning a year. I’m assuming “Blaze” takes place in the same year, which I’ve set as 1884. In “Coronet”, snow is mentioned and is a factor in the case. In “Blaze”, no snow is mentioned, so presumably all of it has melted by this time, or enough of it to not be a factor in the case. Current Canon Placement: After “The Beryl Coronet” and before “The Noble Bachelor”.
  11. The Copper Beeches Date: “early spring” sometime after “A Scandal in Bohemia”, “A Case of Identity”, “The Man with the Twisted Lip”, “The Noble Bachelor”, and “The Blue Carbuncle” Comments: This story references no fewer than five past published stories as taking place before this. The one with the most recent precise date is “The Man with the Twisted Lip” which occurred on June 19, 1889. “The Blue Carbuncle” also references “Twisted” as a past case and occurs on the second morning after Christmas. Assuming “Carbuncle” takes place the same year as “Twisted”, that would place “Carbuncle” on December 27, 1889. The only date given for this story is “early spring”. Since this story takes place after “Carbuncle”, the earliest possible date would be in early spring of 1890, making this one of the only three cases Watson worked on with Holmes that year as mentioned in “The Final Problem”. This is one of three cases (the others are “The Cardboard Box” and “The Hound of the Baskervilles”) that has a rather curious chronology, as it appears to take place after Watson’s marriage to Mary Morstan, but where Watson appears to be living with Holmes for an extensive period of time (a fortnight in this case) with no mention of his marriage. What was going on with Watson’s marriage and medical practice that he could have that much free time to spend with Holmes is anyone’s guess. Current Canon Placement: After “The Blue Carbuncle” and before “The Red-Headed League”. Full Chronology after The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes I. 1882-1887, Holmes and Watson are sharing rooms at 221B Baker Street as bachelors. 1. A Study in Scarlet. March 4, 1882 2. The Speckled Band. Early April, 1883 3. The Beryl Coronet. February, 1884 4. The Noble Bachelor. Autumn, 1887 5. The Sign of the Four. September, 1887 II. 1888-1891. Watson’s marriage to Mary Morstan 6. A Scandal in Bohemia. March 20, 1888 7. A Case of Identity. April 14, 1888 8. The Boscombe Valley Mystery. June 3, 1888 9. The Five Orange Pips. Late September, 1888 10. The Man with the Twisted Lip. June 19, 1889 11. The Engineer’s Thumb. Summer, 1889 12. The Blue Carbuncle. December 27, 1889 13. The Copper Beeches. Early Spring, 1890 14. The Red-Headed League. October 9, 1890
  12. The Beryl Coronet Date: “February”, no mention of Watson’s marriage. Comments: “February” is the only date given. Also, Watson appears to be living full time at 221B Baker Street, with no mention of his marriage. This would suggest this story takes place during the first time period when Watson was still a bachelor. In determining the chronology in cases like these, I go by the publication order and which of the four time periods this story would appear to take place in. Disregarding “The Noble Bachelor” as an outlier (since it’s clearly the penultimate story from this time period, soon followed by “The Sign of the Four” as the final story in this time period), the most recent published story from this time period is “The Speckled Band”, which is set in April, 1883. Therefore, I’m placing this story in the February after that in 1884. Current Canon Placement: After “The Speckled Band” and before “The Noble Bachelor”.
  13. The Noble Bachelor Date: “autumnal” season, “within a week” after “Oct. 4th”, “a few weeks before” Watson’s marriage to Mary Morstan, (the day and month listed is an impossible date), a “four-year-old drama”, “forty-one years” after “1846”. Comments: More than once in this case the season is referred to as “autumnal “. “Oct. 4th” is the date on the hotel bill Holmes finds on the back of the note Lestrade found, and he comments that it was dated “within a week” of the wedding and disappearance. Watson states at the start that this is a “four-year-old drama”. Since this story was first published in April, 1892, that suggests this story takes place in either 1888 or late 1887. The latter is more likely since “1846” is listed as the year of Lord Robert’s birth in the reference book Holmes looks him up in, and Holmes comments that would make him “forty-one-years of age” even though the reference book doesn’t mention the day or month of that birth. Watson also states that this story takes place “a few weeks before” his own marriage. This makes the story either the very last story before, or the very first story after “The Sign of the Four” where Watson first met and fell in love with Mary Morstan. Since Watson doesn’t seem to have anything to preoccupy his time except this case, this suggest that it’s the last case before “Sign”, especially since neither Watson nor Miss Morstan appear to have any living family members, so they wouldn’t have to invite very many people to their wedding and could’ve gotten married fairly quickly. But that would make the day and month provided in this story, “Oct. 4th” an impossible date. “Sign” has two contradictory dates mentioned, but either date would’ve been before October 4th. While the date and month provided are impossible, and it’s equally impossible to determine the correct day and month, within the context of the full chronology, it doesn’t matter. All that really matters is that this story is the penultimate case within the first time period of this chronology, when Watson was still a bachelor. Current Canon Placement: After “The Speckled Band” and before “The Sign of the Four”.
  14. More like the opposite. He'd move the date to a different year where the date would fall on the weekday. Like in the example you made up, dating the story to Tuesday, November 27, 1891. Baring Gould tried to provide a precise day, month, and year for all but two of the stories. I don't try to do that with my chronology. I do try to pinpoint which year each of the stories took place in (crucial for a chronology) and read each story very carefully for any mention of the date, but if Doyle/Watson don't give a fully precise date, I don't even try to come up with one unless I feel it can be reasonably deduced just from reading the story. And while I'm on the subject of Baring Gould's list, I think I'll talk here about Watson's "first" marriage Baring Gould seemed to believe he'd had before he met Mary Morstan in "The Sign of the Four". This seems to be based on all the discrepancies found in "The Five Orange Pips", which Watson dates to 1887, where Holmes makes an unmistakable reference to Irene Adler even though her case was originally dated to 1888, and where Watson refers to his wife as visiting "her mother", even though according to "Sign", Mary Morstan's mother was already dead by the time of her father's disappearance and death in 1878. Baring Gould then places several stories that mention Watson's wife and marriage, but without specifying that she's Mary Morstan from "Sign" as taking place during this "first" marriage. An alternative theory (which I didn't come up with, but was already aware of) is that when Watson says in "Pips" that his wife was visiting "her mother", that what he really meant was that Mrs. Mary Morstan Watson was visiting her former employer, Mrs. Cecil Forrester, whom she'd lived with for 5-6 years as a governess, and whose treatment of Mary in "Sign" Watson even describes as "motherly". Perhaps Watson subconsciously thought of Mrs. Forrester as Mary's "mother" when he wasn't giving it too much thought. I like this theory because it's so much simpler to believe Watson got a date wrong in one story, "Pips", than that he got so many other dates in so many other stories wrong.
  15. Interesting list. I deliberately avoided looking at other's chronologies while I was compiling my own, because I wanted to draw my own conclusions. Some stray observations I have is that Baring Gould seems to have discarded the days of the months and year provided by Watson anytime they didn't line up with the historical days of the week. He also seems to have ascribed to the theory that Watson married more often than the two marriages mentioned. He seems to think Watson was married at least three times (I know there's one theory that Watson married 5 times, which I find silly). I've already finished my list, and it doesn't fully agree with his, but I'd be interested in comparing my completed list once I've finished posting it all a month and a half from now with this and other chronologies.
  16. The Engineer’s Thumb Date: “the summer of ’89” Comments: Watson provides the date right at the start, which is just the season and the year, not the day or month. This also happens to be the same season and year that “The Man with the Twisted Lip” takes place. Since “Twisted” was published earlier, I’m assuming this story takes place after “Twisted”. Current Canon Placement: After “The Man with the Twisted Lip” and before “The Blue Carbuncle”.
  17. The Speckled Band Date: “early in April in the year ’83” Comments: Watson provides the date right at the start, it’s the only date provided, and all that’s really needed. Current Canon Placement: After “A Study in Scarlet” and before “The Sign of the Four”.
  18. The Blue Carbuncle Date: “the second morning after Christmas”, sometime after “A Scandal in Bohemia”, “A Case of Identity”, and “The Man with the Twisted Lip”. Comments: Holmes and Watson refer to three specific cases, the one with the latest date being “The Man with the Twisted Lip”, which took place on June 19, 1889. Presumably, this case takes place in the same year, which would make the precise date to be December 27, 1889. Current Canon Placement: After “The Man with the Twisted Lip” and before “The Red-Headed League”.
  19. The Man with the Twisted Lip Date: “June 19th”, “’89” Comments: Watson says at the start that this story takes place in “June, ‘89”, and later tells Isa Whitney that the day is “June 19th”, so we are given a full, precise day, month, and year. (In the story, June 19th, 1889 is on a Friday, when in reality it was on a Wednesday. This is why I didn’t use the day of the week provided by “The Boscombe Valley Mystery” to determine what year it fell on. Holmes and Watson exist in a fictional universe created by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle where the day of a month and year fall on whatever day of the week Doyle says it fell on.) Current Canon Placement: After “The Five Orange Pips” and before “The Red-Headed League”.
  20. Yes, he does. Right at the start of the second paragraph, Watson mentions his "marriage". When Holmes first greets him, he says, "Married life suits you." There can be no doubt that "Scandal" takes place after his marriage, and is probably the very first case he worked on with Holmes after his marriage to Mary Morstan. In general, where there are contradictions, I prefer precise dates over imprecise dates, and "the twentieth of March, 1888" is a more precise date than "the latter days of September" in "The year '87".
  21. The Five Orange Pips Date: “the latter days of September” in “The year ’87” (an impossible date) Comments The funny thing is this date almost works, if one accepts that “The Sign of the Four” took place in 1887. Watson’s wife and “Sign” itself are both referred to, “the latter days of September” would fit no matter which of the two self-contradictory dates in “Sign” you rely on, etc. What makes this an impossible date is that Holmes makes an unnamed, yet unmistakable reference to Irene Adler. In this story Holmes states he has “been beaten four times–three times by men, and once by a woman.” If any woman other than Irene Adler had beaten Holmes prior to his encounter with her in “A Scandal in Bohemia” that began on March 20, 1888, then Irene Adler wouldn’t be “the woman”. When the story provides a precise, but impossible date by year, I move it to the nearest possible year. So, I date this story in “the latter days of September” in the year 1888. Current Canon Placement: After “The Boscombe Valley Mystery” and before “The Red Headed League”.
  22. The preferred reading order is the original publication order, regardless of the chronology. Doyle published 9 Sherlock Holmes books, 4 novels and 5 anthologies of short stories. Their publication order is this: 1. A Study in Scarlet 2. The Sign of the Four 3. The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes 4. Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes 5. The Hound of the Baskervilles 6. The Return of Sherlock Holmes 7. The Valley of Fear 8. His Last Bow 9. The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes "Hound" was written and published after Memoirs and before Return. It's clearly set sometime before Holmes' apparent death at the end of Memoirs. Most Complete Editions of the novels and short stories will include Memoirs, immediately followed by Return, followed by Hound. This makes some sense, since Memoirs ends with Holmes' apparent death while Return starts off by revealing how he actually survived. You can read these three books in whatever order you like. There's one bit of annoying censorship trivia you should probably be aware of. All the Holmes short stories were originally published individually in the Strand magazine before being published together in anthology book form. "The Cardboard Box" was the second story in the Memoirs cycle published in the Strand, after "Silver Blaze" and before "The Yellow Face", but it was kept out of most early book editions of Memoirs, due to its exceptionally gruesome content. But "Cardboard" starts off with a neat opening scene where Holmes deduces Watson's silent train of thought and makes a comment that 's a direct reply to what Watson's thinking, as if he's reading Watson's mind. The editors who were too squeamish for "Cardboard" still liked this opening scene enough they decided to put it at the start of "The Resident Patient", which somewhat butchers the opening of "Patient", which now started off as a "hot August evening" (the opening scene from "Cardboard") and then just a few paragraphs later has Watson complain about how bitterly cold this autumn is! The original, unaltered version of "Patient" doesn't have this contradiction. The publishers that left "Carboard" out of Memoirs wouldn't publish it until they placed it as part of His Last Bow. Unfortunately, the earliest editions of Complete Sherlock Holmes stories would keep "Cardboard" out of Memoirs, stick it in Bow, and keep the butchered opening of "Patient" so that both "Cardboard" and "Patient" had the same identical opening scene. Check the Volume II you just got. Is "Cardboard" in His Last Bow? If so, there's a good chance that Volume I will have the butchered version of "Patent" with the same identical opening scene. If that's the case, then for these two stories only, "Cardboard" and "Patient", you should read them in this online version of Memoirs: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/834/834-h/834-h.htm It contains "Cardboard" as a part of Memoirs, as it should be, and includes the original, unaltered, unbutchered version of "Patient".
  23. When I started making my list, I gave myself three rules: 1. The simplest explanation is the most likely 2. Where there are contradictions, go for the solution with the least amount of contradictions 3. When in doubt, stick as close to the publication order as you can It's the second rule that's the most relevant here. "The Red-Headed League" itself, provides a great example of contradictions. There are three separate mentions of the date: "autumn of last year [1890]", "two months" after "April 27, 1890", and "October 9, 1890". The one thing all three mentions agree on is the year, 1890, which I feel makes the year indisputable. But the second mention directly contradicts the other two mentions. The first and third mentions don't contradict each other at all, so disregard the second mention, and you have no contradictions. The problem here is that both "The Blue Carbuncle" and "The Copper Beeches" mention "Identity" as a past case, and "Beeches" mentions "Carbuncle" as a past case as well. "Carbuncle" is set two days after Christmas and "Beeches" is set in early spring, so it's impossible for "Carbuncle" and "Beeches" to be set in the same year. If "Identity" is set shortly before "League", and "Carbuncle" is set after "Identity", then "Beeches" has to be set in Spring, 1891, the same season and year that "The Final Problem" begins, which would contradict Watson's statement in "Problem" that he hadn't seen much of Holmes recently prior to the start of "Problem". Disregard the mention in "League" of "Identity" taking place "the other day" and nothing else contradicts. The King of Bohemia's gift in "Identity" helps to reinforce (if not necessarily prove) that "Identity" takes place closer to "Scandal" than to "League". Judging by Holmes' service, I'm sure it would've been hugely important to the King at the time, but less important as time went on. This would leave the King highly grateful at the time, but unlikely to feel indebted to Holmes for the rest of his life. His gift feels like something he'd give in the enthusiasm of the moment, at how happy the King is with the outcome. Less likely he'd keep sending gifts to Holmes years (or even a year) after the event.
  24. The Boscombe Valley Mystery Date: “June 3d”, sometime after Watson’s marriage. Comments: “June 3d” is the date of McCarthy’s murder. No year is named or even hinted at in this story. Nor is there any direct reference to any past case, beyond that this takes place after Watson’s first marriage (the story does mention “A Study in Scarlet”, Watson’s first case with Holmes, back when they were both bachelors, so not at all helpful for this chronology). In cases like this, I go by the publication order of these stories and which of the four time periods the story appears to take place in. The most recent story published prior to this that’s set in the same time period is “A Case of Identity” which takes place soon after “A Scandal in Bohemia”. In the absence of any further evidence, I place this story soon after “Identity”. Current Canon Placement: After “A Case of Identity” and before “The Red-Headed League”.
  25. A Case of Identity Date: “the fourteenth”, sometime after “A Scandal in Bohemia”. Comments: Mary Sutherland’s advertisement says Hosmer Angel’s disappearance occurred on “the fourteenth” without specifying a month or year. Mary Sutherland is actually referred to in the previous story, “The Red-Headed League”, which Holmes claims happened “the other day”, implying that this case takes place just before “The Red-Headed League.” The problem with that is that while “A Case of Identity” doesn’t specify the year it takes place, “The Red-Headed League” does, the very precise date of October 9, 1890. This would make “A Case of Identity” a fairly late case for this time period. What makes this a problem is that there are two other stories from the same period that reference poor Miss Sutherland as an earlier case, “The Blue Carbuncle” and “The Copper Beeches”. Neither specifies a year, but they do specify a set period within a year. “Carbuncle” is set two days after Christmas. If this story takes place shortly before “League”, then this story and “Carbuncle” would both have to take place in 1890 as well. “Beeches” is set in early spring and refers to both this case and “Carbuncle”, meaning “Beeches” would have to take place in the year after “Carbuncle” in 1891 at the earliest. But Holmes seemingly died in 1891, as recorded by Watson in “The Final Problem”. In that story, Watson states that he worked with Holmes on only three cases in 1890. At first glance, that might look like those three cases were “A Case of Identity”, “The Red-Headed League”, and “The Blue Carbuncle” in that order. But Watson implies in “Problem” that he hadn’t seen Holmes since the (unnamed in “Problem”) third case in 1890. He even mentions only reading about Holmes in the papers in “early spring”, the exact same period he’s with Holmes for an apparently extended period of time in “Beeches”. While it’s still possible “Beeches” could’ve taken place in 1891, it’s highly unlikely. This is further reinforced in “The Five Orange Pips” where Watson refers to Sherlock Holmes cases “between the years ’82 and ’90”, which conforms with Watson’s statement in “Problem” that he wasn’t originally going to include Holmes’ “death” among his published stories, and that his last case with Holmes prior to “Problem” was in 1890. Finally, in this story, Holmes shows Watson a gold snuffbox he got as a gift from the King of Bohemia “some weeks” earlier for his work on the “Scandal” that bears the King’s country’s name. This implies that this story takes place soon after “Scandal” rather than just before “League”. This combined with the references in “Carbuncle” and “Beeches” strengthens the idea that this case is more likely to take place in 1888, rather than in 1890. Current Canon Placement: After “A Scandal in Bohemia” and before “The Red-Headed League”.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.