THE SIGN OF THE FOUR
Date: “July 7”, “nearly ten years” after “the third of December, 1878”, “About six years” after “the fourth of May, 1882”, also “September” (a contradiction)
Comments:
“July 7” is the date postmarked on the envelope of the letter sent to Mary Morstan on the day she consults Holmes. “[T]he third of December, 1878” is the date of Captain Morstan’s disappearance (and as it turns out, his death). “[T]he fourth of May, 1882” is the date an advertisement appeared in the Times asking for the address of Miss Mary Morstan.
Later in the story, Watson states that it was a “September” evening, a contradiction. I would prefer to go with “July 7”, since for this chronology I prefer precise dates over imprecise dates, but “The Noble Bachelor”, which is said to take place shortly before Watson’s marriage, takes place in autumn. So, I’m going with September as the more accurate date.
One might conclude from all this that the year this story takes place in is 1888. Reinforcing this is Watson musing that if Mary was 17 at the time of her father’s disappearance, she’d be 27 now. However, there are reasons to think it occurred a year earlier in 1887.
For one thing, “A Scandal in Bohemia”, which definitely takes place after this story, gives a precise date for “Scandal”: “the twentieth of March, 1888”. In contrast this story takes place “nearly ten years” after Captain Morstan’s disappearance and “about six years” after Mary started receiving a pearl each year, all making the year of this story an imprecise date. As I mentioned earlier, for this chronology I favor precise dates over imprecise dates anytime there’s an apparent contradiction.
Also reinforcing, perhaps unintentionally, the idea that the year of this story is 1887, is that Mary’s been receiving a pearl every year since 1882, and that she now has six pearls. If the year of this story were 1888, she’d have seven pearls by then. It’s possible that Doyle made the common mathematical mistake of not realizing that when one refers to something starting “six years ago”, one is actually referring to seven years: the current year plus the previous six years. Be that as it may, it’s one more bit of evidence to reinforce that the year of this story is 1887.
Solely within the context of this one novel, I’d be inclined to date the year of this story as 1888. Within the greater context of the Canon, I date it as 1887. For one thing, it gives Watson more time to squeeze in all the cases he took part in after his marriage to Mary and before his “sad bereavement”.
Current Canon Placement:
After “A Study in Scarlet”. Also, the most recent story to date.
Full Chronology after The Sign of the Four
I. 1882-1887, Holmes and Watson are sharing rooms at 221B Baker Street as bachelors.
1. A Study in Scarlet. March 4, 1882
2. The Sign of the Four. September, 1887