Once again I have to admit my age. Sigh. Years ago there was a made for tv (American) movie with a female Watson. The premise being : Dr. John Watson had , at his friend Sherlock's urging,found a way to place the detective in a cryogenic state of suspension. Dr. Watson then moved everything from England to America. He then left a will stating that the house and it's contents were to be given to whoever was his clesest descendant 100 years later. Enter the female Dr. Watson , who mysteriously inherits an out of the way cottage from a relative she didn't know. And then she finds something wild in the basement. She of course thaws out Sherlock, and together they go on to fight crime and solve mysteries.
So yes, a female Watson has been done before. And yes, us Torchwood fans know what happens when American tv gets a hold of a popular British show.
I am willing to give Elementary a chance. I am not expecting breathtaking tv, but it could be alright. Ya never know.