Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I enjoyed the book a lot, devoured it in a week-end. It was written in 1974 by Nicholas Meyer and the film is from 1976. I already talked about the book in another thread (book recommendations), it's a really ingenious explanation of what happened just before the hiatus and throws a light on Holmes's character. I enjoyed the movie rather less. Biggest problem for me was the actor portraying Holmes, with his sandy hair and not really prepossessing appearance, he really didn't fit my idea of Holmes. Though BC is my favorite, I can be convinced by Jeremy Brett or by the Russian version guy, but this one was really difficult for me. Watson wasn't particularly interesting for me either, I did enjoy Freud's character, actually he's the only one who really stood out for me. Vanessa Redgrave was OK, the baron too ugly (sorry but I couldn't believe in him being the lover of such a supposedly sucessful beauty of the time), Regine was of anecdotal interest (I saw her a few weeks ago in a tearoom in Paris, very old now of course).

 

What bothers me also are the differences with the book. Nicholas Meyer wrote the script and I suppose he had to make the story more sensational for the screen. I guess for me the turkish pasha and white slavery plot were a bit too much. If I hadn't read the book first I suppose I wouldn't have thought anything of it, but whenever I see an adaptation of a book I enjoyed, which simplifies the story or makes it more crude, I cringe. An example that comes to mind is The remains of the day, a great movie is you see it as a stand-alone, but so much less subtle than the book.

 

Finally, I do like a sense of humor and some funny moments in Holmes movies, and found almost none here.

 

Still an interesting movie to see for any Holmesian student.

Posted

I haven't read the book, but I believe I have my father's old hardback copy (presumably Somewhere in the Attic). I'll have to see if I can find it. As I understand it, the basic premise (not the actual plot) is that Watson invented "The Final Problem" and "The Empty House" in order to cover up what really happened during those years -- but then he finally decided to document the true events.

 

As you mentioned, Nicholas Meyer wrote both the novel and the screenplay, and that's another Sherlock Holmes / Star Trek connection -- Meyer wrote and/or directed what I consider to be the three best original-cast movies (Wrath of Khan, Voyage Home, and Undiscovered Country).

Posted

I read the book and watched the movie eons ago. I think when my refund comes in I am going to have to see if I can get another copy. By the help of this Forum, Facebook, and Youtube I am being introduced by all sorts of Sherlock Holmes movies and books I have nevere heard of. Cudos to you all and thank you.

  • 5 months later...
Posted

I've only ever seen the movie version, just recently actually.

 

Based on your review, I'm rather inclined to read the book now. I feel as though we didn't get enough background information in the movie, although I really, truly, did enjoy it.

 

I agree though, that the movie lacked subtlety. I did really enjoy Freud's character though. I enjoyed Watson's as well, although I can understand why this version might not be to everyone's liking. I was a bit ambivalent on this portrayal of Holmes.

 

The meeting of Freud and Holmes, in and of itself, IMO, is a fantastic idea.

Posted

I know Freud is considered the "father of psychiatry", I was never impressed with him. He was to hung up on sex. Seeing it as the bases for most of man's mental disorders.  And sending a drug addict to another drug addict for a cure? Eeehhh....how is that supposed to work? Or in breaking the patient of the habit the doctor becomes cured as well? Somehow.....neehh.

 

And in my experience of dealing with four different psychiatrists, I can honestly say that the only real cure was getting me out of the situation all together and getting to work on something I really loved to do. And that was worked by a college campus Bible study leader not by a so called professional at all.

 

And Sherlock said it time and time again in the canon. "Give me work to do!"

Posted

I know Freud is considered the "father of psychiatry", I was never impressed with him. He was to hung up on sex. Seeing it as the bases for most of man's mental disorders.  And sending a drug addict to another drug addict for a cure? Eeehhh....how is that supposed to work? Or in breaking the patient of the habit the doctor becomes cured as well? Somehow.....neehh.

 

And in my experience of dealing with four different psychiatrists, I can honestly say that the only real cure was getting me out of the situation all together and getting to work on something I really loved to do. And that was worked by a college campus Bible study leader not by a so called professional at all.

 

And Sherlock said it time and time again in the canon. "Give me work to do!"

 

Freud's theories of psychosexual development have generally fallen out of use. However, his focus on the unconscious remains to be a well-respected part of psychology. Many professors of psychology and psychiatric professionals tend to not put much stock into Freud's theories at all, criticizing, among other things, the fact that much of his research was done on upper-class Victorian women.

  • Like 1
  • 1 year later...
Posted

I didn't know there was a book, and although I'm aware of the movie, I've never seen it.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 111 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.