-
Posts
361 -
Joined
-
Days Won
1
Everything posted by BLS_Pro
-
I'm a bit bothered by that too, though Eurus did say she intentionally made some clues for him to follow. So it sounds like she purposefully manufactured many of the elements he deduced about the note. Just as she purposefully manufactured the one thing he missed on the note.
- 793 replies
-
I was hoping this would not be the case. I don't like the idea and having such a bizarre, uncommon thing be EXACTLY what happened to Sherlock (down to representing a person with a dog mentally). It would be an example of the NUMEROUS coincidences (BAD writing) the show sometimes relies upon. I say 'was hoping' because I now believe that is EXACTLY what it will be. I kept wondering WHY the thatcher statue would cause 'premonitions' for Sherlock. And it goes back to THoB episode. MAGGIE (thatcher) was the clue which helped unlock the case of the repressed/tramatic representation substitute memories. It is his subconscious linking maggie with approaching death - the East Wind - Eurus. I think, combined with the 'vampire' reference in Eurus' txt w John, we've got a pretty good idea now of the whole backstory here. :(
- 793 replies
-
I wasn't suggesting anything about 'literal representations'. The point had been made that it was surprising he didn't recognize his own sister. I simply provided an example of how this could be possible, from the perspective of the direction I think the writers are driving. And my comment about 'implausible' was made in that specific context - how, if it IS repressed memories of Eurus, then why the flashes of memory surfacing aren't like atom bombs going off in Sherlocks head, making him follow those MASSIVE loose threads, is problematic. Of course, if the writers don't go with the idea of Eurus as a 'repressed memory', then the whole issue of my specific concern about the implausibility of Sherlock not noting and following those completely disconnected memories evaporates.
- 793 replies
-
Their work neither begins nor ends with the "screening and editing". As you see in all the BTS, they are there throughout. And they are there from conception through pre-production as well. It is NOT the case they were unaware of what was going on UNTIL screening and editing. The problem here is the assumption they are not in charge of EVERYTHING - including the director and his/her choices in every episode.
- 793 replies
-
I keep getting the impression they will be going for 'repressed memories'. So Sherlock may have known about Eurus as a young boy, but as an adult has no memory of her at all - except maybe the flashes we keep getting of kids playing near the water - which should be clues to him. That we don't see him thinking about them at all as clues to something is the only thing which 'seems implausible' to me. For the man who regards his mind so crucially, anything in his mind which he can't account for should jump out at him as important, especially if it keeps repeating.
- 793 replies
-
First, the pool fight is an example of the bad writing I'm talking about. That went on for a uselessly long time. It was almost all filler. It is one of the two points where I actually fast forwarded to get to the actual only 'meat' (ie the breaking of the bust by Sherlock). As such, I had to go back to see what you meant, because even at a faster speed I didn't recall a problem following the action. In fact, even sped up, it seemed much of the action was actually too slow). In the entire fight in the pool, I see two very quick shots which correspond to your description. They are not "so far away" but are rather are shown to be about 5 feet from the water's edge (and another 5-7 feet from the fight). In this context they would qualify as med or med wide shots. Both of them occur AFTER one already knows where the fighters are relative to one another. And they are purposefully obscured by water on the lens to artificially induce a sense of 'immediacy' to the fight - that one is 'in' the action and struggling to keep up. In addition, I see two very quick shots from the alternate end of the pool, used to establish that they are in the vicinity of the whirlpool. Perhaps these are what you referenced as "so far away" (20-25 feet)? They are the ONLY shots not directly 'in' the fight. Again, these fleeting shots are not used to establish individual -character- position, because the OVERLOAD of med close and close shots give far too much very slow detail in that regard. They are used solely to establish the fight as close to the whirlpool, and to establish where the whirlpool is to the window that they will exit through in a few moments after leaving the whirlpool. It is a geography establishment shot. Further, it should be noted these shots are also another issue with the watery location chosen by the producers. There is no place ANY director could have placed their cameras BUT where they were placed in order to get the wider shots (ie any shot that wasn't a couple feet away from the actors). They could ONLY shoot from three general angles on the wider shots. And the editing of them - ie the inclusion or exclusion of them - is, again, ultimately not the director's say. The producers/show runners have final say. They are the ones who were there on the day, approved them, liked them, decided it was a good idea to use them in this form of edit, etc.. What we see on screen is NOT the 'director's cut' of any of the episodes (though of course they do have a say in the cutting). The editor has a massive say in how this is done - putting things together for both the director and the show runner on a daily basis. And the show runner has FINAL cut. Pointing to TBB's example is not a fair comparison, because this scene in T6T does all that you point to in the TBB scene. The T6T scene simply had a TON more (wasted) time and (meaningless) action the writer forced the director to cover as well and so had to do a LOT more than the TBB description you provided. Trust me when I say any change as radical as this is not only sanctioned but requested/insisted upon by the producers. This goes back to the continuity issue and the show runner I previously mentioned. And I personally know shows where even the show runners get 'yelled' at by the networks for too bright, too dark, etc. There is a whole CHAIN of command above the director which is responsible for the consistency (and deviation from consistency) between episodes. That is NOT the discretion of the director. That is the choice of others - and, as such, is WHY a particular director is chosen: BECAUSE the producers WANT the look. Given today's digital technology, we can't even say this desaturation wasn't done after the fact - ie not by the director/DP at all - but done by the producers in post production against how it was conceived of by the director. WHY they want it? I cannot say. But to blame the director for giving them the look THEY wanted is placing the blame in the wrong spot. Perhaps you can point to an instance of such travelling in another episode. They didn't make as much of an impression upon me as they obviously did for you, so I'm not recalling where they are in order to review them again and compare them here. I will not disagree that it looks different from the rest. I will just point out that the director does NOT have the final say in it looking the same or different. If the show runner doesn't like the look, the show runner will not allow it. So this is a look the show runners chose - not only by choosing the director, but by ACTIVELY sanctioning (if not explicity specifying) to ALL departments, what would and would not be done. The differences did NOT slip by ANY one. The photographic records alone that the different departments make and maintain simply make it impossible. It is a CHOICE - and the show runner is the one who ultimately makes it. We do not know this one way or the other, not having seen the script. But the writer can indeed indicate the fracturing in his descriptions for a scene if not for a shot. And he can certainly include it in his character description. Do not believe the director comes up with the idea on his own, any more than the T6T director came up with the 'intuition' blue water reflected on Sherlock's face idea on her own. That IS the script. Possibly. But I'd love to have seen Paul McGuigan or Nick Hurran have a go at that episode. I can almost guarantee that it would have looked different. Basically, they had two and a half-walls to work with. Regardless of director, the look would not have been too different. Look - my point here is not to claim T6T's director was brilliant. As I stated in my first post after the episode aired, the writing AND directing of T6T were 'pedestrian' at best. I'm simply saying that this is not ultimately due to the directors choices, but to the writer/producer's (Gatiss' specifically here) choices. He (and Moffat/Vertue) hire a director who will give them the vision THEY are looking for in an episode. THEY, not the director, are responsible for ALL the choices ultimately made here. And I don't mean this in a 'The Buck Stops Here' manner - ie 'I'll take responsibility for the problems and mistakes of others'. They are directly making and/or directly overseeing EVERY single decision being made before, during, and after production (that's why you see them constantly on set in all the BTS vids). They can and do override the director and the DP et al if they are not getting what THEY want. So the end result is THEIRS more than ANYONE else's - including the director. I work in the industry. I see this every single day.
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
I was very surprised it wasn't a set for that very reason. It is both more difficult and less efficient to film in a jumbo jet than to use a set of a jumbo jet. It constrains the director rather than freeing her. Again, that is the problem with the Aquarium set. As Arcadia pointed out, that severely restricted what could be done with the scene and thus made it more pedestrian.
- 831 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Arcadia - at work right now so on IPhone and can't deliver my full response at the moment. But concerning your point 5, that is the script and show runner. The script dictated the aquarium. There were only a couple angles they could use there. As such the director was constrained by the location due to the script. That's why the angles were pedestrian and the editing etc were all constrained- and why montage had to be used in introducing and leaving the scene.
- 793 replies
-
Actually, when it comes to the look of a television show, the director can ONLY do what the show runner allows. Television is not like a motion picture. The director, while having much creative control, is not 'architect' of an episode the same way a movie director is the architect' of a movie (usually - Marvel and franchises in general are an obvious exception, but that is for precisely the same reason). It is exactly because a show requires a sense of continuity that someone other than the director is essentially in charge. That person is generally the show runner. They have the first and final say on how anything will be shot (it always helps when the show runner is the creator of the show). And I guarantee you that the SCRIPT is why the show looked different in its many ways. It is the script which says cut to shark, fade to blue water which will be our motif and have a voice over etc etc. I believe our director was chosen for this particular script because the way it was written is closer to her style. Thus if you have an issue of continuity between scripts/episodes, the director is not to be blamed. The show runner and writer are to be blamed. In this case, Gatiss. As to me, my problem with T6T was with the plotting, the characterization, and the themes. You'd have to be more specific about what "visuals" you are referencing which felt "cheap" to you. Can you provide an example? (What might be interesting is, when you think of an example, consider how you think TLD's director could have supposedly made it 'better' - but without changing any dialogue, action, or scripted direction. I suspect you might discover what you dislike isn't something TLD's director could have improved given the explicit script limitations.)
- 793 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Given that there is a common denominator between the two episodes that is not the director, I'm more than willing to place a lot of the blame elsewhere. I'd reverse that statement
- 793 replies
-
I had no problem with Wiggins because his presence is used to show that Sherlock is being VERY controlled in his drug use. It was one of the indicators to me that his behavior was part of an overall plan rather than just a descent into drug madness.
- 793 replies
-
- 4
-
-
The way Sislock says 'he' and 'him' I suspect she is talking about a govt spook hidden in the yard watching/protecting all of Sherlock's friends - esp John. Since it's possible she's about to kidnap John she would have to get that person out of the way first. So she shoots him - not John.
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
And it was explained how Sherlock could know something like that in advance. That's the thing - one doesn't need his every deduction explained when one has a similar deduction explained. Once you know the 'trick' you know it can be done.
- 793 replies
-
- 4
-
-
Sigh. Home late from work so can't respond to so many of the wonderful, interesting thoughts here. One of my biggest qualms with the episode was the introduction of Smith. He is being presented as an entrepreneur and philanthropist whom NO ONE supposedly suspects is a monster. He is supposed to be a much loved star. So when he gathers together that group of people at the beginning, they are not criminals nor of a criminal bent. They are simply well-to-do people in society. WHO in their right mind, then, would agree to participate in this scenario where you are injected with something you do not know and are told you will not remember what you are told??? This was THE most unbelievable part of the story. It's another instance of the plot requiring something, characterization be damned.
- 793 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Have to wonder if The Woman is actually the one texting with Sherlock or if it is Sislock pretending to be The Woman
- 793 replies
-
Right. He always planned to make a seeming drug induced attack because Faiths being there wouldn't change the situation - Faith would not remember (and couldn't prove anything even if she did) - and Smith would never confess under those circumstance. Her arrival would have been a (planned) failure by Sherlock due to his drug addled condition. And it is that failure which would have caused him to lash out exactly as he did. The only monkey wrench in the plan was it being a different girl. But that change and his confusion because of it didn't change the outcome he had planned from the start.
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Sherlock expected John would beat him. He not only expected it, he REQUIRED it to get him into Smith's clutches in the hospital. It was how he planned to get Smith to try to kill him, to confess, to get John to rescue him how he planned to record the confession and wrap everything up. Remember he planted the bug in his cane three weeks earlier. It was ALL part of Sherlock s plan, established more than a fortnight before any of the events shown in the hospital.
- 793 replies
-
- 2
-
-
I think I'm going to have to wait to get home to address anything beyond this comment Moriarty theory: Jim was indeed an actor hired by E. I think this can't be true. How do you get the actor to kill himself at the end. It would be bad writing if it were just an actor
- 793 replies
-
The coincidence I'm talking about is the fact they seek to set Watson up as not "loyal" and the one and ONLY person this is show to occur with just happens to be Sislock. It is that singularity which makes it coincidence and bad writing.
- 793 replies
-
Question - did you feel the same in 3.1 when John beat Sherlock not once not twice but three separate times - with Sherlock not even trying to defend himself from Watson's assaults?
- 793 replies
-
It definitely seemed odd and out of place. I think of Mycroft as even less of a sexual entity than Sherlock. But the implication is that he supposedly knows about sex and believes Sherlock doesn't - raising the issue about Mycroft and his dealing with the lowly "humans" when it comes to sexuality Yes. Yup. Just shows how much his character has grown from the first episode. He did this because he loves John rather than it being what is expected by 'humans' Still catching up on all the comments here
- 793 replies
-
Diving in with some responses now: I think that was intentional hyperbole on the part of Sherlock (mirroring his comments about Mag) to get John involved in a 'big' case Sherlock couldn't handle by himself There is a difference between 'fine' and 'not unexpected'. When people are in pain they sometimes lash out at those closest to them. This is not unusual. In this case, the lashing out is actually at the subject which supposedly cased that pain. It isn't rational. It isn't fine. But it IS as the show declares 'human'. Sherlock, understanding human psychology, understands that Watson need to be able to identify for himself WHY he is angry specifically at Sherlock, and so allows himself to be blamed so that the anger can be released and he can get to the truth. He loves Watson (and Mary) this much. He loves him so much that he will let himself be used as the emotional and literal punching bag, knowing ahead of time that Watson does NOT mean it and it is NOT reflective of anything but an enormous wound which MUST be healed and can only start to be healed in this way. (I say he loves Mary here because she told him he would have to go to hell and back to save John. That is the least he can do to spend the currency she gave him and he recognizes as his form of love for both. I disagree. I believe he expected exactly such a beating. . It was blind rage. As such he was simply unaware of exactly what he was doing and how long it lasted. As you point out he isn't even aware how hard he hit. No it's not. It is an aberration not the norm. And "EVERYONE" knows it. They know John is sorry and they know he will NOT do it again. sherlock is NOT making amends for anything. He is nursing a sick friend through the worst experience of his life. As I indicted above he know what his friend needs to do to get past the rage and to the truth. That is what he does. This is made clear in his "currency" response. He doesn't believe he was guilty of anything - and he has gotten Watson to that point as well now. No. No. And no, he explicitly states multiple times he doesn't believe it is anything but another of Sherlock tricks. He apologizes, stating he was wrong - Sherlock isn't responsible for Mary's death and was stupid to think so (giving back to Mary that which he took from her in the last episode - her agency) Then it should be okay because he did apologize
- 793 replies
-
I'm going to have to say it qualifies as a spoiler, because it fits so well: WOW. Another connection (from 4.1) to that same story: "Holmes mentions to Watson the case of the Giant Rat of Sumatra, identifying it as "a story for which the world is not yet prepared". It would appear the writers have morphed that into the alternate version of Appointment in Sammara which Sherlock supposedly wrote as a child with the name Sumatra in it.
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
More about the Water motif relating to Death. I wonder if it somehow is related to Mycroft as well, given the meaning of his name: "Mycroft is an English last name too. It comes from the Old English roots mýðe, literally meaning 'mouth of the stream', or mype, meaning 'the function of water', and croft, meaning 'an enclosed, small field'. It basically means farming with water."
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
At the end of the fake Faith meeting, the children's singsong in the flashback sounds like it's saying "My little master...will find me". Does anyone know a children's song or rhyme like this?
- 793 replies
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)