-
Posts
361 -
Joined
-
Days Won
1
Everything posted by BLS_Pro
-
More LOUSY writing: Mycroft knows the truth about Redbeard, but when we see him thinking to himself, we are shown a dog, not Sherlock's friend. That is a direct LIE told to the audience by the writers, not something IN story. It is a BAD writing cheat. Also, there is NO reason for Mycroft NOT to tell Sherlock Redbeard wasn't a dog but was a boy instead. MORE bad writing (So to extend the Harry Potter analogy someone else used here - Mycroft is Dumbledore, not telling Harry the things he should know - and is sending people off to Azkaban. Sigh.)
- 1,402 replies
-
- 3
-
-
I want to see the additional material that'll be in the Theatrical release. I'm hoping (against hope) that it fills in the missing gaps pertaining to Eurus' mental problems. Beyond that, I don't think any missing material could dig this episode out of its deficits.
- 1,402 replies
-
I thought everything about Moriarty was a waste. It didn't really explain anything - and there was no need to explain anything, certainly not as they did.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Well, they do show that there are essentially two personalities of sorts in Euros - the psychopath and the frightened, lonely little girl. But you are correct - they did a horrible job of connecting them and did nothing to explain how the psychopath essentially disappeared and left us with just the broken little girl. And Mycroft being 'squeamish' is completely out of character - given what he undoubtably has had to do for the government. Look at how quickly he was willing to kill the little girl in the plane for the 'greater good'. He didn't care about the blood on his hands there. So not only was the squeamishness out of character overall, it was contradicted IMMEDIATELY. More of the show's BAD writing. Also, there is NO way Sherlock does not notice the LACK of his own reflection in the glass - especially as he moved around. MORE bad writing. And, about that - WHY have the glass missing, when you have secret exits built into your 'secure' room. It was POINTLESS, except to show Sherlock as INEPT rather than even just partially smart let alone SUPPOSEDLY (at this point one SEVERELY needs to question this proposition) possessing of great intelligence.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 5
-
-
Yes, the film "Saw" (along with The Dark Knight) kept leaping to mind (as well as Silence of the Lambs of course). Bringing that to mind certainly didn't help the episode.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
I think half of that was again the WAY they told it. Even though I expected almost EVERY revelation, I was STILL looking forward to having them use good plotting and good character development as a means of the reveals. Instead we again (like 3.1 and 4.1) got it all delivered in the most pedestrian of ways. THAT is the biggest disappointment. I still think that what they revealed has made Bride a MUCH better episode. Bride is like The Sixth Sense in that regard. What we've seen in Final unlocks a completely different take on what Sherlock's subconscious was telling him - that he had a sister he had forgotten. It explains so much about that episode. They were laying the groundwork for 4.3 through the WHOLE of the Bride. It was essentially its true point. To me, this has made Bride even better than Sixth Sense, because Bride had to work completely APART from the sister 'reveal' (and then, much later, as a completely different episode WITH the reveal) where Sixth Sense only works WITH the reveal.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
THIS. The whole story felt like it was NOT about Sherlock at all, and he didn't actually do much in the way of solving things. Like 3.1, where he was lead around by the nose by Mag, here he was being led around by the nose by Eurus. And to what end exactly? She was certainly schizophrenic (the little child and the psycho), but also not. There doesn't seem to have been a point to the Saw/Dark Knight-like 'Morality Maze'. It didn't really cause any of the characters to reveal themselves in ways they hadn't already (except Mycroft, who was bizarrely contradictory in his behavior). And Sherlock didn't have to actually DO anything to cause himself to remember what he had blocked out. He was (again like 3.1) simply TOLD most of it. THAT is what makes this a disappointing episode of Sherlock.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Hello Papcroft and welcome to the forum! Don't be so sure that it's all over, the bbc posted only yesterday that "Creator Steven Moffat has suggested another series of the detective drama "was possible" and he and fellow creator Mark Gatiss were not planning for the latest episode to be the final ever instalment.", after all. Yes, the episode did NOT have a sense of unbreachable finality. In fact, it sets it up that it could continue indefinitely, so long as the stars align.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
I wasn't surprised. Given that BC said about this season "Love conquers all" and the fact that the Sussex Vampire was about "murderous jealousy" I suspected both the motive and the resolution. I also suspected it would be Sherlock who gave the love, which is why I loved your reversal of that saying it would be Mycroft - ie the (Red) Queen. ;) I did NOT like the Mycroft characterization in this episode - at least not in the 'Morality Maze'. His shrinking away and not wanting blood on his hands?!?! He has undoubtedly had to do FAR worse in his job. To be such a shrinking violet was COMPLETELY against type - especially when, in the very next scene, he is immediately willing to get the blood of an innocent little girl on his hands.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
So you'll only accept "Good bye" if they "say it like they're going to come back"? [Doctor Who reference of course ;) ] I think you're getting a head start. Which stage of grief is 'bargaining'? ;)
- 793 replies
-
- 3
-
-
I think that's a function of the difference in HOW they go about doing it. In series 3 much of it (at least in 3.1 and 3.2) was done via comedy, sometimes at Sherlock's expense (either in contradiction to his characterization or with him as the butt of the joke). In 4, its done through drama and compliments rather than contradicts his established characterization. It is plot-driven growth, not comedy-driven change.
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
I am wondering (worrying) now if they consider the special (TAB) 'Season' 4 and this is thus really Season 5. :(
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
I suspect TAB and 4.3 will essentially be companion pieces - almost a two parter (separated twins, one could almost say - heh). I'm beginning to think the whole of TAB works on two layers - as a stand-alone of sorts and as Sherlock's subconscious trying to awaken him to Eurus, what happened, and the effect it has had on his life: "We all have a past, Watson. Ghosts. They are the shadows which define our every sunny day"..."What made you like this?" "Oh, Watson. Nothing made me. I made me. (Sound of a dog comes from nowhere, causing Sherlock to frown in confusion) Redbeard?"
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Wow - they seem to have jammed TAB full of clues for this season and Eurus. Right down to Mind Palace Victorian Sherlock mentioning he was interested in understanding the Obliquity of the Ecliptic and the end credits spell out Ecliptic Obliquity. It is interesting to note the definition of Obliquity is: "deviation from moral rectitude or sound thinking" (which could have a double reference - to his own problematic thinking ie repressed memories - and to Eurus [presumable] deviation from moral behavior). And the skull on the wall is really a woman looking in a mirror. The episode is veritably overflowing (a water reference, get it? ha! - :roll eyes: ) with clues. I'm beginning to wonder if Eurus faked her own death.
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Also from TAB (could you guess I've rewatched it - heh): in Mycroft's notebook, pertaining to Redbeard (which is squared and used as a header, much like a code-name) is the date 6/1/74. Given that TLD may have just confirmed the general date of Sherlock's birth, could this be more evidence for the "It's never twins" (except that it is twins for Eurus and Sherlock)?
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Has it been mentioned/discussed here yet, the tombstone from Sherlock's mind palace in TAB which says "Beloved Sister Faithful Beyond Death" Could that be some subconscious thought about Eurus, especially since the corpse rises - saying "Do not forget me" - even though the (Victorian) case is solved (that always bothered me)? Also, if water/drowning/death is what happened in relation to Eurus, does that somehow explain the existence of the waterfall at the end of TAB (esp as "Do not forget me" comes as a jump cut to the waterfall) as well as the "deep waters" comments sprinkled throughout - and thus all the water references in T6T are just a continuation of that subconscious connection? I know Sherlock has to figure out his repressed memories, but I wonder if the writers are going to have something more for him to do? In other words, I wonder if there is something related to the Eurus case in her youth which she needs Sherlock to solve/resolve for her? Also, the song "Do not forget me" begins: "Golden years ago, in a mill beside the sea, There dwelt a little maiden" More of his subconscious speaking to him?
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Euros wants Sherlock to help her enact her vengeance on their big bad brother Mycroft. In the climax, Euros does a lot of bad stuff. She has Mycroft at gunpoint. Mycroft tells Euros that he loves her. Euros then accepts his apology and willingly gives herself up to the authorities. All along Euros just wanted Mycroft to tell her that he loved her the same way he loved Sherlock. The End OMG, Mycroft IS the (Red) Queen!!! ;) (Sorry, if you didn't watch Disney's second 'Alice' movie you'll likely not get part of that reference)
- 793 replies
-
So it would appear that Eurus used the Moriarty "Did you miss me" video save Sherlock from being sent to his death. Any speculation as to why she might do that - other than supposedly wanting to be the one directly responsible for his death. If they are NOT going that direction, any clue what alternatives there might be for her actually saving him? Edit: I'm presuming in the above question that it wasn't Mycroft who saved him because it would have 'broken his heart' otherwise. I still haven't decided which is actually the more plausible explanation. In fact, that's one of the reasons I'm asking the question - to spur the brain cells.
- 793 replies
-
It has nothing to do with Eurus evading Mrs H or Mrs H not being eagle-eyed. She doesn't exit her flat until well after Eurus has exited the flat. Even an eagle-eyed person simply would not have seen her. She was COINCIDENTALLY already gone. That is the bad writing. Except in the snippet they show, there is no interference. It's just somewhat dark. And so the audience would have trouble seeing if another person was with Sherlock, but a person tasked with that job and who was able to look at the screen for more than two second would have NO that trouble at all. It's just bad writing. Furthermore, that excuse doesn't work for when the helicopter finds them again and hovers over them with its spotlight directly on BOTH of them in the middle of an empty street. Its just bad writing. That doesn't make it good writing. Tricking the audience by tricking characters in the story is one thing. Tricking the audience despite no one being tricked (or evading the fact that no one could be tricked) in the story is just bad writing. It is the Wizard saying "Pay no attention to that man behind the curtain!" That is just bad.
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
From a survey performed in 2011, of cities worldwide Bejing has the most government CCTV surveillence cameras, coming in at over 470,000. London came in second with more than 420,000. Chicago came in a far 3rd with less than 17,000, with NYC coming in 5th with less than 5,000 (Houston TX was supposedly 4th, but the numbers had to be estimated due to Homeland Security for some reason). So yes, we do that here (I presume 'here' for you is America). But no we don't do that at levels even close to those approaching London. London is imfamous for its Big Brother levels of government watchfulness by camera. The first helicopter shot is when they have just finished their chips. The helicopter clearly sees Sherlock standing and Eurus sitting. Then they cut to the two of them walking. It is, as you said, intentionally dark and viewed for a fleeting moment by the audience. But if you were a security person tasked with following Sherlock, you would be able to to see that there is someone walking with him. Furthermore, in the scene where they are standing in the middle of the empty street while Sherlock makes deductions about Faith's note, the helicopter flies overhead and shines it bright spotlight on BOTH of them. It would be impossible for the government to conclude Sherlock is "alone" at this point. Yet the writers continue with that blatant falsehood for the purposes of trying to fool the viewers ONLY. That is the bad writing. It is unclear what both he and Eurus are drinking. They each have identical cans, thinner than the usual beer can, and reminiscent in color and shape of the somewhat larger, thin Red Bull cans. But the show is careful not to reveal any brand name (don't want to have to pay for it), so it could be anything from a cola, (though again not in a standardized can) to red bull type of drink, to a beer-type alcohol.
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
No. Look again at the small size of that room. There wasn't the space to shoot the actors moving around in there, let alone having them move "dynamically". If you notice, when they film Sherlock about to be 'shot', they couldn't even do the dolly/zoom in-camera there. They did it mostly as a special effect. That is a TINY space. AND they needed to 'divide' the room up into two scenes - the confrontation (where they are being held STILL at gunpoint) AND the death scene. So they couldn't use ALL the space for BOTH sequences. They were limited because more than one scene was being shot in there. The two scenes are as dynamic as (if not more than) the revelations scene on the plane between Sherlock, Mycroft, and Irene in SiB. And in SiB they had the 'luxury' of lighting through the plane's windows. T6T didn't even have that because they were surrounded by the aquariums. I don't think anyone is going to accuse SiB's director of being pedestrian, let alone bad. Also, do not think that the actors would not have moved around if they felt they should and if they had the space to do so. Especially in the second half of the scene, if they thought they lacked movement - and had the room to move - they would have demanded to do so, saying it was a requirement for their characters. Don't think they wouldn't. And don't believe that this director would have had the power to forbid it.
- 831 replies
-
- 1
-
-
She was there, as Eurus explicitly admits. As to someone "interfering with the video feed", I might buy that if the writers hadn't also had Mrs. Hudson ask 'What friend' - which exists for the sole purpose of giving the -audience- the impression Faith was a figment of Sherlock's imagination, when in fact it was just a COINCIDENCE (again) that Mrs H HAPPENED not to see Eurus because she'd already stepped outside. As to the video feeds, that's just another cheat by the writers. Recall both Sherlock AND Eurus are standing in the middle of an empty street when the helicopter flies overhead and sees them them. She might be able to avoid or interfere with the cameras, but she is NOT invisible. So even if the writers later try to use the excuse that she did mess with the feed so Mycroft and others who might recognize her wouldn't see her, that just won't fly.
- 793 replies
-
All I can think is that they ARE jumping out as important. He just hasn't been able to make the connection. Because we haven't reached that part of the story yet. :D Except this is the man who can't leave a random "loose thread" alone. He will focus on it to the detriment of everything else. And that is when it is about seemingly unimportant things - like something missing on a table. If it something as important to him as his MIND, then for him to not be shown doing ANYTHING about them - just SEEING them but never being shown to consider them again in ANY way - is BAD characterization. So, if you are correct and the flashes of memory ARE jumping out to HIM as important, then the LACK of him pursuing them (while pursuing every other imaginable, unimportant case) is a betrayal of character by the writer. And I would suggest that they are NOT jumping out at him as important because, if he was puzzling over something of such import but couldn't get anywhere with it then, as Mrs. Hudson pointed out, it would be stabbed on the mantle. ;) (Edit: that last is intended as a joke, because Sherlock does NOT do that with every problem he can't solve. Mrs Hudson was in on the Game and pointing John in the right direction - as Sherlock had been having her do all through the episode. She'd seen the video and knew what it said and where Sherlock had put it and what he was doing to himself for John because of it etc.) Which would mean the writers are sacrificing characterization to plot - one of the major problems with T6T. They're moving pieces around the board without regard to HOW they get there - simply because they need them to be in certain positions for the plot to work. :( Probably the same unknown reason the episode was written so differently, especially the stepping outside of the story with those Sherlock Narrations at the beginning and end. As you say, we may never know. :(
- 793 replies
-
Foreshadowing isn't what I am identifying here as bad writing. My problem is having UNIQUE and IMPROBABLE events replicated and tied together by nothing but coincidence - from repression of a tragedy as a child being transformed into an entirely other event, right down to the detail of another person being mentally transformed into a dog, to another individual who knows the truth purposefully keeping it from him. That is NOT 'foreshadowing'. It is bizarre 'coincidence' of the WORST sort. It's like one character having a relationship with another, moving on, then years later discovering they each had separately and coincidentally been shipwrecked, orphaned, and raised by apes from birth. That isn't foreshadowing. That's just REALLY BAD writing.
- 793 replies
-
Oh, I never took any of your comments as insults to anyone. As you say, you were complaining about the "look" and attributing it to the director. I was just trying to explain how, especially on television, the "look" is more attributable to the show runner (and writer, since they are essentially the same in this instance). That's all. No offense and no worries.
- 793 replies
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)