-
Posts
361 -
Joined
-
Days Won
1
Everything posted by BLS_Pro
-
So you agree that is the story. You just don't like it. Why do you dislike the idea of a man being devastated by being lied to by, not one but both, the most important people in the world to him? Or is it that you simply dislike the idea of anyone but Sherlock having any importance to him? She saw what the loss of Sherlock did to him. That she may have underestimated John's resilience doesn't change her motivation. It doesn't make her a coward, as you claim. No. But here it is done honestly and directly. And John knows Sherlock. He would never conclude Sherlock can't survive - especially when he survived his own death. He is alive - and thus can come back. How. John recognizes the fact that Sherlock supposedly sacrificed himself for the sake of John. He cannot do anything to resolve that issue. Are you, again, claiming the writers should never put Sherlock in the position of having to demonstrate his love by means of sacrifice??? THAT would be bad writing. You misunderstand my complaint about HEARSE. It's not that their friendship suffered. It is that neither of their actions made any sense for the characters. The writers didn't create bad situations. They badly wrote the characters. They wrote them falsely. The same cannot be said here. Sherlock heroically saves John. And he does so by sacrificing his own life. If anything, the writing is bad because it is (as Moffat often does) simply a repeat (with less drama) of FALL.
- 4,923 replies
-
Already answered that one: because it would break him. I must say, you presume something not in evidence. You presume she thought she would ever have to reveal her prior life - which was dead to her (as dead as his military life). She thought she was successfully clear of that life - and would never have to deal with it again. Telling John her past would do nothing but hurt him. Or are you suggesting that she should never have allowed John to fall in love with a person everyone (including John) agrees is precisely her type - and which he knew, at some level, was dangerous?
- 4,923 replies
-
- 1
-
-
BTW - to all those who've said CAM didn't threaten Mary's life - he explicitly did.
- 4,923 replies
-
You dislike Sherlock loving John enough to let him go? But if he didn't do that, then he would fit the definition you identify as cowardice. He would be placing his desires above those of John's well being.
- 4,923 replies
-
I'm glad you agree that the writers are indicating she is concerned about John. That concern is the explicit rebuttal to your points: 1) no. to reveal the lie would, as Mary stated, have broken John and she explicitly said she would never allow him to be broken. She'd seen what Sherlock's death had done to him. She wasn't about to see him completely destroyed by her revelation. She loves John too much to see that happen to him. 2) no. as stated, she risked (and later threatened once more) sherlock's life - again BECAUSE she would never allow John to be broken by revealing the lie. She loves him too much to see that happen to him. So no, she was not being "cowardly" - unless you consider valuing John's life above all else (including Sherlock) to be cowardice. But, if you do, then Sherlock - by that same standard is "cowardly". I disagree on both counts. But, of the two, Sherlock engages in more so-called cowardice (in HEARSE) by his fraudulently coerced forgiveness. He wants what he wants, regardless of how he gets it - even if that includes torturing John.
- 4,923 replies
-
- 1
-
-
You missed something. As Mary herself states, she didn't lie to protect herself. She lied to protect John: "....John can't ever know that I lied to him. It would break him." So like Sherlock, she indeed lied to John. And while she indeed, like Sherlock, wants to keep their relationship intact, her concern is for him. In effect, she is far more honest than Sherlock in this respect (at least as depicted in HEARSE).
- 4,923 replies
-
I've only finished watching VOW. I'm going to reserve most of my comments until after a second viewing and reflection. I will say though that this depiction of Sherlock (and the depiction of Sherlock in THREE) completely support all the conclusions I made about the deficiencies and plain bad writing in HEARSE. The Sherlock depicted in HEARSE contradicts everything about him which came before - and after - that episode. Especially given all that has since transpired, there simply is NO excuse for HEARSE. None! It was just bad storytelling. Now - I do have two off the cuff reactions to note before going back for a second viewing. I think it is incredibly interesting how many people here are strenuously objecting to John ultimately forgiving Mary after a few months consideration, yet make every excuse under the sun to accept John forgiving Sherlock after 4 days. Of the two, I find the former forgiveness much more justified than the latter. There is no forgiveness for the latter because there was NO repentance on Sherlock's part. As to Moriarty's "return", it certainly seems quite coincidental, timed as it was to the moment Sherlock is packed off to die. Given the fact that we don't see a living Moriarty, one wonders if Sherlock himself didn't create this 'stay' of execution. While I doubt that Moffat & Co can resist bringing back Moriarty, given his tremendous popularity (and the fact that it would explain why we haven't seen the 'true' method of Sherlock's survival of The Fall), I would actually hope Sherlock planned this 'escape' before he planned on killing CAM.
- 4,923 replies
-
"How can you not remember which room? You remember everything!" "I have to delete *something*!" I am afraid to ask what Sherlock had to delete in order to remember how to make the Swan and Syndney Opera House!
- 1,338 replies
-
- 2
-
-
- Episode Discussion
- Poll
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Both episodes of Series 3 have relied heavily on sheer coincidence for storytelling - which is extremely bad.
- 1,338 replies
-
- 1
-
-
- Episode Discussion
- Poll
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
One note about Mary besides those already mentioned: pay attention to her reaction to the news of "three". It isn't pleasure but worry. It's obvious that her deception (whatever it might be) suddenly has ramifications far beyond any she anticipated.
- 1,338 replies
-
- Episode Discussion
- Poll
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
I agree completely. The train sequence simply made no sense whatsoever - for Sherlock or for John. Just as Sherlock's actions were unjustifiable, John's acceptance of them was even more unjustified. If someone betrays you, you don't forgive him because he betrays you again. Putting it in terms of justice, repeating a crime gets you a harsher punishment, not a pardon! None of it made either character sense or story sense. This is why I say the video recording of that sad excuse of a "solution" was inserted in the middle of that scene - so that Sherlock's betrayal wouldn't slap the viewer in the face so obviously. In fact, much of the humor in the episode was used, not for story purposes, but to obfuscate story problems (not all of the humor, mind you - ex. the humor in the initial reunion sequence actually does serve a story purpose, and is not, as some claim, a result of Sherlock being obtuse. He smartly did it on purpose, as he indicates to Mary afterwards). Indeed. Even considering amazon and netfix together, the streaming options are not nearly as rich as they could be.
- 1,338 replies
-
- Episode Discussion
- Poll
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Except the general excuse that people made for HEARSE was that Sherlock was simply being oblivious about human nature in general, and John in particular. Time away didn't make him ignorant. If anything, it can easily be argued that it made Sherlock more aware of the value of friendship and of John in particular (his conversation w/ Mycroft for example). Thus, far from the separation making it difficult to admit his feelings, one can easily argue it served to make it, well, easier. The other excuse used was that neither of them is capable (not uncomfortable w/ but simply not emotionally mature enough) to express their emotions to each other, even in private. Both of these excuses are contradicted by the episodes before and after HEARSE. That's (along with numerous other reasons) is why I say it was bad writing. At this point, my only hope is hope Moffat can rescue this third series with VOW. Since pretty much everyone else was universal in their acceptance/excusing of it, I would really enjoy hearing why you thought Sherlock's behavior in HEARSE caused you to go WTF - ie didn't fit his character and/or the storyline. That's why I do Amazon Prime. I get it each year and never once regret it. If you make more than a few purchases a year, it ends up more than paying for itself (not to mention the free movie streaming and free kindle book rentals you can get with it), I highly recommend it.
- 1,338 replies
-
- Episode Discussion
- Poll
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Without saying anything specific about episode 3.2, so as to avoid spoilers for those who've not watched it yet, I will say the characterization of Sherlock and John in THREE supports everything I claimed here, and contradicts all the excuses given for Sherlock and/or John here. If you want to know more, I posted my explicit thoughts in the THREE thread.
- 1,262 replies
-
- Episode Discussion
- Series 3
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Just finished watching. And I must say the episode was very uneven (and like 3.1 relied on coincidence far too much for good storytelling). But this episode does serve to confirm everything I said about HEARSE. The man who gave that speech is not what everyone excused Sherlock as being in HEARSE. He was not an idiot about human nature, about John, and about being able to either identify or admit his feelings to John. (Nor was John, as demonstrated in his response to the speech and when asking Sherlock to be his best man.) They were both able to freely admit their love for one another - in public no less! So all the claims that HEARSE was a result of their inability to do such things is a complete contradiction of what they did - without problem - in this episode. Sherlock's speech fit his character as it had been written in the first two Series completely. HEARSE, on the other hand, was a complete contradiction of all that had been established before HEARSE - and is further reinforced here in THREE. Whoever it was that the writers manufactured in HEARSE, it was not the Sherlock Holmes (nor the John Watson) of "Sherlock". It was bad writing.
- 1,338 replies
-
- Episode Discussion
- Poll
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
This is simply not true. You confuse "suspense" with "tragedy". You can have one without the other. Can one heighten the other? Certainly. But it is not a requirement for either. Suspense occurs when there is danger and you do not know the outcome of an event. Will she die or will she be saved? Not knowing the answer is suspense.
- 1,262 replies
-
- Episode Discussion
- Series 3
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
I believe you've misunderstood my argument, because that is the exact opposite of what I was saying. Yes. Which is why one doesn't make the question of his survival (or their reunion) the plot. It should always be something else - which is not to say that the stakes can't be high. Consider the BANKER episode. There would have been no suspense if Watson or Sherlock had been tied in front of the spear. But because Waton's new girl friend was tied to it, we couldn't be sure what would happen. They could not die. She could. Putting her in jeopardy created suspense. It was good writing in that respect. Indeed it is "standard". It is cliched. It is hackneyed. It is a bromide. In other words, it is bad writing. One expects better than that from Sherlock - because, up to now, one has gotten better. In some cases, one has gotten immensely better.
- 1,262 replies
-
- Episode Discussion
- Series 3
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
I agree completely. It was never going to change. Just as John was never going to die in the bonfire and neither of them was going to die in the train bomb. That is why it is bad writing to make either the return to normalcy or survival of an explosion the primary plot question. It is a foregone conclusion. (That's why everyone focused on HOW Sherlock survived - and why Moffat revealed Sherlock alive at the end of FALL - because everyone knew that Sherlock would survive). Unless you do plan on changing things, there is no drama or suspense in such plots. Which is why they had to resort to comedy instead - because they dismissed the one plot that everyone couldn't predict and chose to focus on plots which the audience knows the outcome of beforehand. The comedy here is an attempt to distract from the fact that you know the conclusion - and that no drama was built in getting there. We see one very short shot of John unable to sleep. Then he's decided to cut off his mustache. We see a few shots of John bored at work. Then he's decided to return to 221b. We see less than 24 hours of John and the 'conflict' is essentially resolved. WOW. That is amazing drama! What conflict! /sarcasm And that is the major plot?!? That is plain bad writing. Indeed. When one compares the two, Gatiss' story has more drama. But merely comparing one to the other doesn't make either of them good writing. It merely makes one better than the other. Of course, just as there are degrees of good, there are also degrees of bad. The original story for SCANDAL was pretty lame as well. But what Moffat did with it was brilliant. THAT was good writing. PS: I misspoke. It took a whole four days, not three, to return to normal.
- 1,262 replies
-
- Episode Discussion
- Series 3
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
As an aside, while waiting for the second episode of this series, I'll note that before the airing of HEARSE Gatiss and Moffit kept claiming that Sherlock comes back and expects to simply pick things up where he left off as if nothing happened. And they kept stating that was an unreasonable expectation on Sherlock's part. Everyone has moved on and as Gatiss put it "really nothing will ever quite be the same again." Yet in the course of a mere THREE DAYS, the writers end with things basically right back where they were. Sherlock and John are back together solving crime as if Sherlock had never been gone - as if Sherlock had never supposedly betrayed John. Seems the writers' contradict their own claims about Sherlock and his so-called unrealistic expectations. Turns out they accepted those expectations as completely realistic. Almost immediately, Sherlock is back to where he was when he left - with everyone (John, Molly, Lastrade, Mrs. Hudson, the Public, the Police - everyone). Which is why I continue to say - even by the writers' own standards - this story was bad writing.
- 1,262 replies
-
- Episode Discussion
- Series 3
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Will I sound like a bad friend if I said that if it was me, I'd cancel my plans to stay in and watch Sherlock? It's certainly something Sherlock would do.
- 1,338 replies
-
- 2
-
-
- Episode Discussion
- Poll
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Sherlock Series 3 DVDs can be preordered from Amazon
BLS_Pro replied to Alex the Dabbler's topic in The News Stand
Indeed. That was exactly my plan. Great minds, eh? I was simply hoping someone might have more knowledge than I in regard to the contents. If there was evidence that the commentaries will be on the discs, then I would have placed my preorder immediatly. -
So they weren't idiots about this sort of thing before when they had the same sort of problem. But suddenly, for no apparent reason, they've lost all the smarts they had then in this regard, and are idiots about it now??? That just doesn't wash. It is bad characterization - especially for John (though almost equally for Sherlock)
- 1,262 replies
-
- Episode Discussion
- Series 3
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
There has never been the suggestion that Sherlock is not trying to manipulate John. Quite the opposite in fact. That is the purpose of the lies. But what would lead Sherlock to believe that it would work? As the example of HOUNDS shows, he isn't stupid when it comes to understanding human nature in general and John in particular. Just as in that episode, Sherlock wants forgiveness. But in that episode he didn't attempt to get it by lying to or otherwise abusing John. If he had laughed at John, he would never have gotten an forgiveness. He would have lost John. So why did Sherlock do the opposite of what he has proven to himself works - if forgiveness was his goal? Why does he do the very thing which caused him the problem in the first place? On what basis would he conclude that a repeat of the offense for which he sought forgiveness would somehow elicit forgiveness of the either offense? Usually if you repeat a crime, you receive harsher punishment, not forgiveness! Sherlock understands justice. And that is not justice. And that leads to the question of why did it work? It shouldn't have worked - as the example from HOUNDS demonstrates. The belief that it would work is out of character for Sherlock. And the forgiveness of Sherlock's original betrayal by means of another betrayal by Sherlock is out of character for John. It is only by believing both men are complete idiots that one claims either action is in character. And neither one of them is an idiot.
- 1,262 replies
-
- 1
-
-
- Episode Discussion
- Series 3
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
No. He indeed accepted it. After the apology, he pauses, thinks, then says: "Right". Then he walked away. And, as Sherlock started after him, calling John brilliant etc, he told Sherlock to stop overdoing the apology. And later, when Sherlock makes him coffee, John thinks it is even more apology, and tells Sherlock he doesn't have to keep apologizing. So not only did John openly acknowledge and accept the apology - he openly reiterates that he has accepted Sherlock's apology. As Sherlock stated, there is "always an off switch". So Sherlock entered a situation he believed he would be able to control, ramped up the tension by pretending not to know how to stop the bomb, does a cursory search and finds what he knows has to be there, then goes all emotional and completes the setup of John. Pretty much all of it was acting. Certainly everything immediately after the discovery of the bomb is an act on Sherlock's part, since he declares he has "no idea" what to do - ie lies completely. Thus everything from that point on is a complete act. Everything related to the non-apology is a complete lie on Sherlock's part. He does to John exactly what he did to him at the end of FALL. He completely lies to him.
- 1,262 replies
-
- Episode Discussion
- Series 3
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Just as John didn't have to punch Sherlock in the face and say "I hate that you think I'm not your friend" neither does Sherlock have to get down on his knees and say "Please John, I'm sorry. You are my bestest and only friend." What he does do is be intimate with John. Opens up to John and reveals something he would not reveal to anyone else. That he was afraid - because he doubted himself. When simply not being 'icy' fails to work - isn't enough of an apology for John - Sherlock recognizes that John is still upset at "what happened last night". He hasn't actually admitted that John is truly his friend. Sherlock recognizes that he must do so to repair the damage he has caused. So Sherlock tells him - tells John that he is Sherlock's only friend. This is not some lie he has rehearsed. It is not some trick just to get John back to work. It is not something that has no meaning to him. It is the truth. And it is a truth that Sherlock admits, not in some perfunctory, emotionless way. Sherlock admits it directly and in a heartfelt way. Put simply an apology doesn't have to be "on the nose". That would be bad writing as well. But it does have to be meant. It has to be true. In HOUNDS it is true and it is meant. In HEARSE Sherlock demonstrates it isn't true. He demonstrates he isn't sorry because he does the EXACT same thing again. Sherlock proves he doesn't mean it. He proves his apology is completely empty. If Sherlock had done this in HOUNDS, it would not have been something to laugh at - for Sherlock or the audience. It would have been the end of their friendship. And it would have been Sherlock who ended it.
- 1,262 replies
-
- Episode Discussion
- Series 3
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Sherlock Series 3 DVDs can be preordered from Amazon
BLS_Pro replied to Alex the Dabbler's topic in The News Stand
Hi Carol. Indeed we haven't met. This is my first foray into the world of the Sherlock Forum. I'm in the States and most people here haven't seen Series 3 yet, so this is the only place I've found I can talk about "The Empty Hearse" without spoiling it for everyone. I'll let you deduce from the facts I've thus far provided which viewing source I'm likely to have used. Thank you for the kindness of your advice. It is both welcome and appreciated.
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)