-
Posts
361 -
Joined
-
Days Won
1
Everything posted by BLS_Pro
-
"SHERLOCK: The East Wind takes us all in the end. JOHN: What’s that? SHERLOCK: It’s a story my brother told me when we were kids. The East Wind – this terrifying force that lays waste to all in its path." Hmm - could it be Sherlock doesn't KNOW about his sister? Or has repressed his memories about her? (I wouldn't like the idea of the latter. That would seem to be more bad writing, but is hinted at via the flashbacks we keep seeing him supposedly have. And I REALLY hope that Redbeard isn't some subconscious representation of his Sister. THAT would be REALLY BAD WRITING. Uhg!) Obviously Sherlock equates the East Wind with death as well. "Mind-Palace Mycroft tells Sherlock, "The East Wind is coming, Sherlock. It's coming to get you." ie Sherlock is telling himself he needs to think fast because he's about to die. It's also in this context (approaching death) that we see Redbeard and Sherlock says "They're putting me down too now" indicating that Redbeard was put to death for some unspecified reason. So more death connections. Given the flashback by the water with Redbeard and two kids, in this episode and the last (and all the NARRATIVE IMAGERY of water and sharks/combined with the Appointment in Samarra death references in the last only), it would suggest his subconscious is supposedly trying to tell him death approaches in the form of his sister. And that it has been telling him this since 3.3 It is obvious that his Sister didn't know (much) about Sherlock. In the form of the fake "Faith" she says "You're not what I expected" meaning she hasn't associated directly with him, unlike (apparently) Mycroft. She calls Sherlock "Nicer" and says he thinks "Sweetly" in comparison to Mycroft (whom likely has code named her Sherinford and believes she is "secure" somewhere.) And obviously Mycroft does know about his Sister as well, stating she went "rogue" and indicating he did something about it (ie something to her) or at least didn't stop something from being done to her. All of this begs the question, why is she going after Sherlock? IS she going after Sherlock? Is all of this actually about Mycroft and HIS secrets? And why does she (apparently) shoot at Watson? (I say apparently, because we know he is alive still, so why the shooting? Is someone outside, listening to the conversation (ie Mycroft security keeping an eye on John)? Is that why she didn't say 'you' but said 'he' and 'him'?
- 793 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Okay. I agree this was a MUCH MUCH better episode than the first. The last I gave a 1. This I gave a 9. Thoughts as they are occurring to me. BEST LINE (maybe in the entire series): "In saving my life, she conferred a value on it. It is a currency I do not know how to spend." Just beautiful. THAT is why Moffat's writing is FAR superior to the Gatiss episodes. -- John should have recognized the therapist as the bus woman immediately. I didn't buy that for a second. And I don't buy that Sherlock didn't recognize his own sister (in the form of the therapist) even in his somewhat drug addled state (perhaps his sister is where the 'premonitions' in the first episode came from though? Her hand in things - or her appearance somewhere we weren't shown or didn't notice). -- WAS the actress playing his sister also playing the fake 'Faith' or was that another actress? If it was the sister actress, it was a far better form of the disguise - because I suspected it might be her at first, but watching her, it just didn't look like her to me. If it wasn't the same actress, that's a cheat I don't like. -- Speaking of a cheat, I don't like the fact that through ALL the walking he was doing with fake 'Faith', the government could NOT tell if he was with someone (and thus prevented Mycroft from seeing the sister and having her game ruined.) That just is not possible given all the walking they did and all the different forms of surveillance used. Again, that is bad writing. -- Still don't like the COINCIDENCE that the ONE woman John 'cheated' with was the Sister. That is bad writing. I still don't like the OUT of CHARACTER fact OF his 'cheating'. That's bad writing. -- Not sure how I feel about Sherlock having to be TOLD to save John, and how. I'm tending not to like it but haven't digested it fully yet, so am withholding final judgment. -- I like that Sherlock's drug using is, as always, part of his plan. And I like how it fits with the 'sickness' induced by the villain ala the Dying Detective. I also like that it better explains why he would not inform Watson that the whole thing is a ruse. -- The use of Mrs. Hudson was PERFECT comedy writing. It used and expanded upon already known elements of the character, rather than contradicting them. I love how she gets the gun from Holmes in his drugged state. I love how the Bond expectation of Sherlock emerging from the Aston Martin is subverted. (Not sure about her 'deductions' since she already knew what was bothering Sherlock - ie knew what Mary had instructed him to do. Seems like she's just playing along the whole time. Have to think about this one too). -- The "two weeks" running gag was a good one. The fact that John figures it out on his own via HIS 'Mind Palace' version of Mary was perfect. (And lets us know how the sister figured it out too). -- Why did the Sister want Sherlock to take the Smith case? -- Did the sister TORTURE Redbeard? Is that why he had to be put down? Was she a serial killer - or at least was everyone afraid she was going to become one? Because one of the signs of that mentality in childhood is torturing animals. Is THAT why she wanted Sherlock to take Smith's case? -- Don't like that Watson doesn't call Mycroft when he thinks Sherlock is about to be harmed. -- Don't like that the police officer just wandered away when told the man he is guarding might be being attacked and then he can't get in the door. He should have done exactly what John did. -- I basically like this episode because it is Sherlock being SMART, not STUPID. -- I HATE the phrase "It is what it is". Always have. It represents a form of helplessness and acceptance of determinism/fate. I have to chew on its meaning in the context in which it was used - and how it might be a much more mundane way of saying the same thing as Samarra -- I like that John gives Mary back her self-motivation, by saying Sherlock didn't kill Mary. She acted of her own accord. Still don't like the bad writing in regard to HOW they killed her though. -- I think we were able to trust the characters and especially Sherlock more here because, ironically, we suspected we were being played by Sherlock - and suspected we knew WHY we were being played by him - his love of John (and Mary). So because we knew the truth (that a deception WAS likely afoot) and had it confirmed in the end, what worked AGAINST emotional involvement in the last episode actually worked FOR emotional involvement in this one. -- Since the sister wrote Miss Me? on the paper, she is obviously somehow connected to Moriarty. But the question is: was she a cohort of M? was she a consort of M? was she a manipulator OF M? In other words, was he working on her behalf or is she working on his behalf? The fact that M is likely the "mutual friend" who put her in touch with Calverton and gave her Faith's original note suggests she is simply using Moriarty's posthumous visage as a way of 'tweaking' Sherlock (and Mycroft). -- Could the fact that his sister is behind things be why Sherlock fixated on and made the whole TAB situation about the women in his life - and about a plot by women? The East Wind call back was nice - and was definitely on his mind as he got into the plane. -- What is the note opposite Mycroft's "Call Sherrinford"? Who/what is Sherrinford? The institute in which his sister is supposed to be kept? -- What was the note Watson gave to Molly to give to Sherlock at the end of 4.1? Seems an unnecessary mystery, if all that was being conveyed was what Molly told him. I'm sure I'll have more thoughts, but this is my stream of consciousness thinking at the moment.
- 793 replies
-
- 2
-
-
The problem with the video is that you can't trust what the actors or writers say. And that is actually a problem which has bled into the show itself. You can't trust anything you see or hear from anyone to be the truth. And so there is a lessening in the emotional investment in the people and the actions they take. Withholding one's emotional investment in the death of a major character in the climax of the show is BAD. That is the OPPOSITE of what one is trying to achieve. :(
- 831 replies
-
- 1
-
-
That reminds me ... going back to this... If that "curtain rises" text really was sent only to Mary, and the other one only to John ... Who else do we know who might possibly have the initials SH? ;) SH = Sherrinford Holmes? In this context, I don't believe so. I believe both are from Sherlock. The timing is FAR too coincidental, Sherlock was not surprised that Mary showed up (nor was he surprised she was by herself), and the prose is similar to that which he used in TAB: "The stage is set. The curtain rises."
- 831 replies
-
- 1
-
-
I just realized something else about these texts. I haven't rewatched the whole thing again to make certain, but I don't believe any other texts in the episode are shown to end themselves in SH. I know there are many to John which do not have such an ending. If I am correct, it does make this inclusion on EACH intriguing. IOW, it suggests it is a clue for the audience. If true, I would surmise it is indeed supposed to indicate they are each supposed to be individualized messages sent to just Mary and John respectively.
- 831 replies
-
Too complicated/far fetched. It would require an amount of information about Mycroft and his government that we KNOW Moriarty doesn't possess (I say this because Moriarty required Sherlock's help to discover what Mycroft was doing in regard to the string of numbers and letters held by The Woman. He didn't have a clue about it).
- 831 replies
-
Another Question (what number is this now?): What was the point of the whole "Miss Me? bit" It got everyone's attention. But it was, in the Sherlock timeframe, YEARS after Moriarty died (and supposedly his entire network destroyed). That seems like an awfully long time to get revenge/last Game etc. And it was an isolated incident (ie was not part of a rash of incidents or the indicator that the Game Is On, since MONTHS pass after the "Miss Me" incident with nothing else happening). The ONLY purpose it served was to get Sherlock a pardon. That makes it just ANOTHER in a long line of STUPID COINCIDENCES. In other words, another example of the HORRIBLE writing I've been talking about. - OR - It could have been Mycroft. He could have concocted it as a way to save his little brother. In the very first episode of Sherlock, we see that Sherlock is capable of hacking any and all phones he wishes. Given his much greater resources, it seems likely Mycroft could do the same with any and all tvs. And, if one watches the beginning of this episode, when Sherlock twice responds to questions about what Moriarty is up to, they cut to Mycroft silently appraising Sherlock each time. Were these just random, meaningless cutaways? Or was Mycroft watching to see if Sherlock has figured it out - or with worry as to where the false idea of a Game with Moriarty might lead him?
- 831 replies
-
- 3
-
-
I agree. A lot of it was violating Characterization to satisfy Plot (ie another example of the bad writing I keep complaining about). I also believe there is likely some as-yet-unexplained reason Sherlock wanted someone out in the world to know that he was 'back' (which would imply a LOT to thoughtful Sherlock audience members).
- 831 replies
-
Except that Sherlock did touch Mary's body and was holding the wound (presumably to try to stop the blood) BEFORE John even enters the scene. In other words, while I wouldn't put it past Moffat et al to reverse the "fake death" (because it would just be more of the stupid writing we're getting lately), it would be too much to claim Sherlock couldn't tell the difference between a squib/blood bag prop strapped to Mary's chest and a hole in Mary's chest. The same is true about John as well. If this was a fake death by Sherlock and Mary alone, then he would have immediately figured it out as well. The ONLY way it is a fake death is if EVERYONE were in on it. And that's just 'too much stupid in the room'.
- 831 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Except John didn't arrive until well after Mary was on the ground. He didn't know she took a bullet for anyone. He just knows she's been shot. Nothing more.
- 831 replies
-
I was looking for blatant examples of lying, as opposed to examples where we aren't sure one way or the other. By the sounds of it, prior to this episode, we haven't seen any. The one I'm referring to is right at the beginning of the episode: "Are you TWEETING?!" "No." "Well, that's what it looks like" "No, of course I'm not tweeting. Why would I be tweeting?" I also don't think we've seen Sherlock supposedly embarrassed or reticent at being 'discovered' doing something others would frown upon. He has shown disdain and indifference and defiance in regard to his brother (and authority figures in general). But he has never been shy or worried about what they think. Quite the opposite. This would appear to be another example of trashing character (Sherlock's) for a cheap laugh.
- 831 replies
-
Another Question: Have we ever seen Sherlock outright lie to Mycroft? Especially in regard to inconsequential things? [Asking seriously. If it did happen, I don't recall it. As such, it seems to be another out of character thing (presented solely for comedy) in 4.1]
- 831 replies
-
I actually meant that John might be texting someone else at night. If true, that would be REALLY bad writing, since it isn't Mary and it isn't Sherlock he is texting (Mary we know for obvious reasons, Sherlock because John's question: "Night owl?" indicates he doesn't know the person well. He would know that about Sherlock). As such, if it is NOT the flirt girl he is txting, then it is someone we haven't met at all in the episode, and the writers are purposefully deceiving the audience (and ONLY the audience, not anyone in the episode) making them think it is the flirt girl whom he DID text earlier and then later. Deceiving the audience and NOT the characters (as opposed to deceiving the characters and thereby the audience) is HORRIBLE writing. Addendum: It will be EXTREMELY bad writing/directing if it isn't the girl that he was txting, because the flashback to the in-the-bed texting is bookended by John, on the plane back to London thinking about the girl. The flashback sequence is ALL the instances of him texting- and some we KNOW are the girl. So if it is NOT him texting the girl in that ONE instance among all the others when he DID, then that is both COINCIDENCE and DECEPTION of the AUDIENCE alone. That is such BAD writing that, if it turns out to be true, I'm dropping the series completely.
- 831 replies
-
I questioned this as well, back on Jan 2nd: http://www.sherlockforum.com/forum/topic/3542-episode-41-the-six-thatchers/?view=findpost&p=112902 And the fact that Mary seemingly manipulated the argument so that it seemed John sent her alone first would indicate this was indeed a setup (even though I'll be upset if her death was indeed just another plot repeat of faking death and not telling John). Though, thinking about it, one could easily argue the reverse and claim John manipulated Mary into going first (as part of the flirt girl texting plan or the like). IF that is the case, then John's angry accusation "You made a VOW!" would have more meaning - ie 'You had me do the other and I trusted you to take care of her here. You failed in that ONE job!' Of course, Arcadia could be right as well. It bothered me at the time that the note to Mary didn't include WHERE to go. I presumed that meant John and Mary shared their texts with one another - because it doesn't make sense for Sherlock to end each set of thoughts or each text balloon SH. He has sent multiple texts in the past, each ending SH. But they were always presented as an idea he added after the original ie 'Come if convenient. SH' followed by the afterthought: 'If inconvenient, still come. SH'. MAYBE they were intended to be a single message to both. If true, then it is again bad writing/directing. But the presentation of it still makes me think it was two different messages, each sent to one person only. Just another reason I don't like this episode.
- 831 replies
-
- 1
-
-
I don't want this to be what they write (because the supposed 'dalliance' is SO out of character and UN-motivate), but I wouldn't be surprised if Moffat ends up having Watson's anger "You made a Vow" to be more anger at himself for 'breaking' his marriage Vow - and Watson's subsequent distancing of himself from Holmes to be Watson trying to keep Sherlock from deducing his 'infidelity'. I truly hope that the apparent 'affair' is actually part of an elaborate plot by Sherlock and Watson. But, given how they've treated Sherlock since S3 (when they had Sherlock making "deductions" even HE was not AWARE of!!! - ie Mary is a Liar. That is NOT how deduction works!), I don't think Moffat and Co hold Sherlock and his keen rationality in as high esteem as the rest of us. More and more, IF they use it at all (rather than rely REPEATEDLY on stupid COINCIDENCES), they treat Sherlock's reasoning as akin to magic or as a punch line. As such, I fear an elaborate plot by Sherlock is not in the cards here.
- 831 replies
-
- 2
-
-
This article in the Independent identifies many of the problems with the series: http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/tv/features/sherlock-season-4-episode-one-benedict-cumberbatch-martin-freeman-tv-series-mary-watson-amanda-a7509261.html
- 831 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Blue is the new METAPHORIC NARRATIVE IMAGERY being used to reference death. Extremely Slight Spoiler for 4.3
- 831 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Good catch. I was so focused on where they met (church lair) I didn't focus on the order of the meeting. IF that wasn't a mistake on their part, it raises questions like: Why not meet together w John? Why not meet all together at 221b? Again, what is that lair place? Why did Sherlock seem so surprised Mary would run, given they expected it to the point of planning ahead to trace her?
- 831 replies
-
Yup. It's Visual Narration, much like the Verbal Narration Sherlock engages in. Both are lazy forms of writing - Telling, not Showing (through deed and dialogue). And I agree, I immediately thought of Mag when I saw it. Then I thought 'Sherlock is Jumping the Shark'. Unfortunately the latter seems more the case. :(
- 831 replies
-
Could you be more specific about the Thatcher moment? I don't see it. Not really, because I'm just operating on memory right now. But when he first sees the statue there's some camera trickery, I think. I might be confusing it with something else. I just remember thinking "mind palace." You are correct there is some camera trickery. But that's all it is. It is the blue water ripple effect being projected onto him, isolating him in darkness, along with the trite zoom/dolly effect. Presumably (though they don't use it consistently this way) it relates neither to the Mind Palace, nor Deductions, but is a new effect which, like those things, is used to represent a new form of 'thinking' on Sherlock's part: Intuition (which is what he explicitly said he had at that moment). The fact that it is used inconsistently - sometimes as representation of the Moriarty/Sacara/Death intuition - and sometimes as just camera trickery to be 'impressive' (like the end when the bullet is traveling to him), means that one can't be certain what it means. It is just blatant VISUAL NARRATION for the Audience (hitting them over the head with it in fact), much like his beginning and ending Narration - both forms of Narration being examples of bad writing to me.
- 831 replies
-
That was Sherlock, not John. Could you be more specific about the Thatcher moment? I don't see it.
- 831 replies
-
Good Point! It's interesting to note, I don't think we ever saw his Mind Palace in this episode.
- 831 replies
-
Another problem I am noting with the new episode - which is a problem due to previous episodes as well as this episode and all its plot holes and character inconsistencies - is that emotional impact of events and characters (like Mary's death), are lessened considerably. Why? Because now one doesn't know if they are true or not. Did Mary actually die, or is it a ploy? Was Watson emotionally or physically unfaithful with the hippy chick, or is it an elaborate plan coordinated with Sherlock? All the trickery and dishonesty by everyone means one can't trust what one sees, so one holds off one's conclusions and thus one's feelings. Maybe Mary is dead. Maybe she isn't. That uncertainly means I'm not as invested in the death scene as if I thought she was indeed dying. The deceptions are emotionally distancing - and that's not a good thing when you are writing (or watching) a drama.
- 831 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Another question: When Mary knocks out Sherlock, what is the children's song being sung as he and Sherrinford and Redbeard play on the beach?
- 831 replies
-
I can absolutely believe that. Plot-wise it certainly seemed out of place.
- 831 replies
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)