-
Posts
361 -
Joined
-
Days Won
1
Everything posted by BLS_Pro
-
I am glad you now agree that Moffat does say this about Sherlock. That sociopath is the "standard" to which Sherlock "aspires". That it is his philosophy to intentionally limit his empathy - for ego-driven reasons (so he can supposedly be "better" at being "clever"). Again, what Moffat says makes my case. That was neither my point, nor my terminology. I have stated many times that Sherlock's behavior is not deterministic. He chooses his behavior. He is not 'sick', mentally or otherwise. Nor does he get "cured" of any supposed sickness in TFP. Sherlock is a "monster" because of his moral choices - the choice of ego (himself) as his standard, rather than empathy (others) as his standard. Again, as Moffat states, Sherlock is a "bad man". And the show is his journey to becoming a "good man". That is the opposite of being "cured" of a mental illness. That is a man learning and practicing moral truths. It is a moral journey, not a medical 'cure'. Putting aside your addition of the term "just" again, no it is not reductive. It is the central theme and conflict of the entire series: Ego vs Empathy. To reference your example, that Sherlock doesn't want to feel pain and so rejects empathy as his standard: that is Sherlock acting profoundly selfishly. It is him choosing ego (himself), not empathy (others), as his standard. Empathy is being selfless. As John says, and Sherlock agrees, it is being a 'soldier' and saying 'it's not about us'. It's not about our pain and whether we want it or not. It's about the other person and what they need. That is choosing empathy (others), rather than ego (self), as one's standard.
- 793 replies
-
No - which is why I suggested perusing medical/psych sites. Picking one such site, written for the layman: http://www.webmd.com/mental-health/features/sociopath-psychopath-difference (Edited link because originally posted link started on second page) But you can find similar on more technical sites if you wish. Suffice it to say, the blog you reference is incorrect when it states "psychopaths and sociopaths are the exact same thing. There is no difference. Whatsoever." As such, the author's harangue against the idea 'Sherlock is a psychopath' is but an attack on a straw man. He is not a psychopath, nor does he aspire to that standard. I'm sorry but that is a false statement. Moffat's explicitly states: "He’s not a sociopath, nor is he high-functioning. He’d really like to be a sociopath. But he’s so f***ing not. The wonderful drama of Sherlock Holmes is that he’s aspiring to this extraordinary standard. " So, as I said: "Moffat explicitly states that sociopath is the standard Sherlock upholds and aspires to." I was very careful and very precise in my words - because I actually did read a full version of Moffat's oft stated quote. And, again, that quote confirms "both the writers and Sherlock agree he is intentionally limiting his empathy for ego-driven reasons. That makes my case."
- 793 replies
-
I tend not to get my psychological definitions from blogs, but rather from psychological sites and texts. I stand by my statements about the distinction between psychopath and sociopath because they are drawn from such sites and from psych textbooks. As to Moffat's statement, it doesn't change a word of what I wrote, because - in the quote you reference - Moffat explicitly states that sociopath is the standard Sherlock upholds and aspires to. All you've done by providing the quote is confirm both the writers and Sherlock agree he is intentionally limiting his empathy for ego-driven reasons. That makes my case.
- 793 replies
-
This appears to be the fundamental disagreement at the root of our discussion. And I can only say the writers themselves state Sherlock is a sociopath. He is a "bad man". And his journey is that of becoming good, which they claim he has done by TFP. In other words, by the end of TFP, Sherlock is no longer a sociopath. Please check out the distinction between psychopath and sociopath. As I tried to identify, a psychopath is the individual who is devoid of empathy etc. not a sociopath. As already stated, Sherlock (as he himself - and the writers - state) is not a psychopath. Sherlock is not "devoid of sympathy" etc. He is a sociopath, and thus has empathy (as well as other emotions). That empathy is just, as already noted, quite limited.
- 793 replies
-
Being told something and actually understanding it are two different things. I didn't say "just consumes". Sherlock is not a psychopath ie devoid of empathy/love. Sherlock is a sociopath ie has severely limited empathy/love. His ego rules him - drives him. But it is not the "only" thing in him. The conflict of the series is the concretization of the conflict within Sherlock - the battle between his Ego and his Empathy. The villains - the monsters - are physical manifestations of his demons - his Ego. Sherlock is a "monster", as John Watson himself says - because Sherlock is a sociopath ie because Ego rules him. He's simply "our monster". Sherlock had not stopped being a sociopath. His behavior at the end of T6T was not an aberration. It was not a "mistake". It was Sherlock doing what Sherlock does - feeding his ego - trying to prove himself the 'cleverest' person in the room. It was the devastating consequence of his ego-driven action - the death and destruction that feeding his ego caused - which finally made Sherlock understand what he had been doing - and thus finally act to correct it: to replace empathy for ego as that which drives him.
- 793 replies
-
John neither knows that nor has reason to suspect it. John does know that Sherlock is emotionally repressed. True, he doesn't know the cause Actually John thinks he does know the cause - given that Sherlock himself continually expounds on why he is a sociopath (and himself thinks he 'made himself'). It is a new idea that Sherlock should not be treating people as things for his consumption. Even his friendships up to this point have been about his ego (I would agree with you about CAM, except the writers essentially reset Sherlock back to his old form immediately afterwards with his complete disregard for those loved ones in favor of cases - ie ego over love. It is only in the end of TFP that Sherlock is shown to actually be partaking in and enjoying those relationships, rather than being forced to be a part of them begrudgingly). It is only in TLD - in what he does for John - that Sherlock demonstrates his actions are no longer about his ego and that Sherlock knows it - that he has learned that lesson. He is not like Eurus anymore, wanting love for her own ends. TFP didn't give the 'Sherlock Tin Man' his heart. T6T showed Sherlock that, while he might indeed have a heart, it wasn't in the right place. It showed Sherlock he was still a "monster". TLD shows Sherlock putting his heart right. And, so at the end of TLD, John is telling Sherlock: now that your heart is in the right place, you should stop repressing your emotions. John is telling him that such repression is but a remnant of the old Sherlock. He's telling him a new Sherlock has been born - and he wishes that new Sherlock a "Happy Birthday". TFP is simply where that remnant is finally swept away, because the trauma which created it is finally identified.
- 793 replies
-
Love in general, but romantic seems to have been John's context. John neither knows that nor has reason to suspect it. I don't believe we've ever seen him take drugs for any other reason. However, the reason he supposedly takes drugs is because he gets bored. He doesn't have anything to entertain his ego. When he doesn't have people to consume (ie a case), he consumes drugs. They are the same to him - things. John's point is to stop treating them as things - as 'distractions'. Stop being Smith. Stop being Moriarty. Love them. That is what John is telling him to do. That is what John is saying would 'save' Sherlock. That is what would rehabilitate him - and, in fact, ultimately does. So the good Doctor's prescription is sound. That's because its meant to be more like Sherlock and Eurus. The reason for Mary's death is so Sherlock could realize he is a petty. ego driven "monster" just like Norbury. The reason for Mary's death is so Sherlock could see and feel the death and destruction caused by his ego. The reason for Mary's death is so Sherlock could abandon his ego - pursue cases not for his ego (not to be the cleverest person in the room), but out of empathy (to help others) - as he does in John's case. The reason for Mary's death is so Sherlock can prove, once and for all, he loves John - that he will sacrifice himself if necessary to do so - that he will become a 'soldier', like John. The reason for Mary's death is so Sherlock could do for John what John had done for Sherlock - save him. Mary had to die for this season to proceed to its final destination: Sherlock becoming a "good man".
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Given that Sherlock's problems - including his boredom and need to get 'high' to alleviate it - are due to his lack of empathy (ie due to his isolating himself from human interactions -due to him making himself a sociopath), John's advice was that of 'rehab' - of 'restoring him to good health'.
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
I have qualms about using the term reprogramming in this regard. By this usage, almost any act or interaction with a person is an act of "reprogramming" them.
- 1,402 replies
-
You had me up til "likely he probably knew about Sherlock as far back as...Carl Powers" - and "JM was a psychopath from birth". As you say, however, there is no need to claim Moriarty was "programmed" by Eurus. He was a psychopath before meeting her. Their interests simply intersected.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Sherlock himself links them. It was never stated 'your experiences' are "invalid". The only thing stated was the philosophy of the writers. Please do not conflate the two. Oh, and you are quite free to disagree with their philosophy (I certainly do). In other words, you are free to be 'offended' if you so choose - ie you are free to choose your philosophy, just as the writers are free to choose theirs. No one here claimed otherwise (well, at least not me).
- 793 replies
-
The whole point of S4 was that it isn't a question of wiring (determinism), but of choice (free will). Sherlock wasn't born without the desire to love (as his having a best friend as a child proves). He chooses not to love - because he had his heart tragically broken as a child. He chooses ego over empathy - bad over good. And his whole journey, according to the writers, is to choose to be good - choose empathy, choose love, instead. He is not fated to go to Sumatra (not fated to feed his Ego). He can choose to go to Sumarra instead (choose to love others). His rejection of romantic interests is just an example of his rejection of love in general. That isn't merely an "implication" by the writers. That was the point of the entire episode. "Save John Watson". From what? From the "hell" of "being alone" (like Eurus - like Sherlock before John). That is the writers' philosophy. Would it have been "better" to leave John in his hell - just leave him "alone"? Should Sherlock not have "saved" him - not done anything he did in that episode for John? Are either of them "whole" without the other - without the love of the other? That isn't the "implication". The implication is that one should not simply and arbitrarily reject relationships, especially romantic ones, out of hand. One should not treat them with disdain or contempt. One should not avoid them. That is what the writers are saying. Intentionally isolating one's self, as John did - as Sherlock had done all his life - just to avoid the pain of relationships, is cutting one's nose off to spite one's face. It is putting one's self in "hell". Moftiss' whole point is that relationships are what make people 'human' - as opposed to treating people as things to feed one's ego. The point is - people exist. You can't avoid them. The only question is: how are you going to treat them? Merely as things for your consumption - or as fellow travelers to be treated with compassion? Are you going to be a Smith, a Moriarty? Or are you going to be a Watson, a Sherlock (not as he was, but as he learns to be in the end)? John's statement served two purposes. One: to say there is no reason not to love her - just as John loved an assassin. The whole point is: "Who you are doesn't matter". And that means 'Who they are doesn't matter' as well (as it didn't matter to John about Mary). The fact is Sherlock is loved and there is no reason to reject that love. Two: to make the connection to Eurus and thus declare there is no reason not to love her either. The description is specifically limited so as to describe both women and thus set up the idea that, just as one should love Irene, so too one should love Eurus. There is no reason to treat either of them as Sherlock treats Molly. There is no reason for love to be spurned - to be completely unrequited.
- 793 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Sigh - so just the first two scripts. :(
- 1,402 replies
-
Along these lines, I seem to recall reading on the forum here that some of the scripts were included in a "Collector's Edition" of one or more of the Series. Anyone know anything about that?
- 1,402 replies
-
Yes, it will depend on which draft - which colored pages - are or are not included. Whichever version, however, I would still be very interested in reading them.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
And yet they allow individual scripts to be sold etc after airing.
- 1,402 replies
-
Usually that's because they don't want spoilers getting out before the show airs. Printing names on scripts and making it difficult to copy scripts are simply techniques to make such leaks difficult - and to make leakers more easily to track, thus making people less inclined to leak.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
If he doesn't want to publish them because he doesn't think there would be demand, then he could certainly release them for free as pdf files. Most shows already publish them internally that way. No reason not to simply release it - as apparently they did for the Blind Banker episode (especially since, this season, they don't have any other writers from whom they would have to seek permission etc)
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
It is a shame that they don't release the actual shooting scripts for the series. I would be keen on reading the descriptions etc from this season.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Yes. "Yellowbeard" is that movie. As to checking it out, it has been a long time since I saw it, but I don't recall it being particularly good - despite having a ton of famous comedians in it (including many from Monty Python, which is the reason I originally watched it). Of course Moftiss are known for employing terms etc with multiple meanings/depth (ex: Moriarty's line "This is where I get off"). So it wouldn't surprise me that Yellowbeard was chosen for that reference the same way Redbeard was chosen: because it worked both as the name for an Irish Setter, given its hair color - as well as for the Best Friend, who was red headed. Always "deep waters" with Moftiss
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
More Existentialism References: No one has yet commented on the fact that the writers have Sherlock playing a fictional pirate: "Yellowbeard". Why did they choose a fictional - rather than actual - pirate (like Redbeard, Blackbeard, etc) for Sherlock to play? I think the answer lies in who, or more specifically, what "Yellowbeard" was: an absurdist comedy. As such, it serves as a mirror to Eurus' existential horror. Both Eurus and Sherlock inhabit the same "absurd" reality. But, because Sherlock has a best friend - has love - instead of being terrifying, the existentialist's nightmare world is transformed into a harmless, humorous farce. In other words, the name is an allusion to how love "saves". Love transforms all of existence.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
More Existentialism References Mary's end video is an allusion to Roquentin's epiphany at the end of Nausea. She says: "I know who you really are: a junkie who solves crimes to get high and the doctor who never came home from the war. Will you listen to me? Who you really are? It doesn't matter. It's all about the Legend. The Stories. The Adventures." This is Roquentin. He knows who he is - what he is - and it is nothing to speak of. But what he is doesn't matter. What now matters to him - what gives him meaning - is being like the composer and the singer: "Could I try...Naturally, it wouldn't be a question of a tune...but couldn't I in another medium? ... It would have to be a book: I don't know how to do anything else. But not a history book: history talks about what has existed - an existent can never justify the existence of another existent. ...Another kind of book... [one where] you would have to guess, behind the printed words, behind the pages, something which didn't exist, which was above existence. The sort of story, for example, which could never happen, an adventure. ... A book. A novel. And there would be people who would read this novel and who would say: "It was Antoine Roquentin who wrote it...and they would think about my life as I think about the life of [that singer]: as about something precious and almost legendary." This is what Moftiss is saying about Doyle (and indirectly - or perhaps directly - about themselves). "There is a last refuge for the desperate, the unloved, the persecuted. There is a final court of appeal for everyone. When life gets too strange, too impossible, too frightening, there is always one last hope. When all else fails, there are two men sitting, arguing, in a scruffy flat - like they've always been there and they always will." This is gift Roquentin sought to create. It is the gift Doyle (and Moftiss) gives to everyone who suffers from the angst of living an absurd world: the legendary love and adventures of these two "best and wisest men" - in the hope that gift of love will "save" them all.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Her problem is the same as Roquentin's problem. It is the same as everyone's problem. It is the existential problem: the terror of being alone in a meaningless world. And, in the end, she is saved from this endless nightmare. Her problem is solved. That Eurus remains, like The Woman, 'a lunatic, a criminal, and insanely dangerous' is not her "problem" here (though the solution to the Final Problem is the path to solving the rest - since all solutions derive from the Final Solution). Actually, it is Mycroft who believes that Eurus is beyond redemption - that her soul cannot be saved - that she cannot be "cured". But it is also Mycroft who believes Eurus cannot be reached by any means. Of course Sherlock demonstrates Mycroft is wrong. Sherlock does reach her. He "solves" that problem. He saves her. And Mycroft would believe Eurus is unreachable and unredeemable (as he always did), wouldn't he? For Sherlock is the one who became "a good man", not Mycroft. Mycroft hasn't learned that lesson - at least, not yet. (Since he now has his brother as an example and guide, like Eurus, he can learn it if he so chooses - as Sherlock learned it.)
- 1,402 replies
-
More Existentialism references Again, to Sartre's "Nausea". In the end of The Final Problem, Eurus has become completely isolated - "She won't talk. She won't communicate with anyone in any way. She has passed beyond our view. There are no words that can reach her now." But Sherlock goes to her repeatedly, playing his violin. It is through his music that she is finally brought back from the abyss. It is through his music that love is expressed for her by another. And it is the two of them playing music together which makes her finally happy - saves her from the terror of existence. This is an allusion to the ending of "Nausea". Roquentin considers existence to be "beyond words". Words are "lies". And he thinks the same about music. It too doesn't "reach" existence. Existence "is beyond - always beyond something, beyond a voice, beyond a violin note. Through layers and layers of existence, it unveils itself, slim and firm, and when you try to seize it you meet nothing but existents, you run up against existents devoid of meaning." Music is as meaningless to Roquentin as the rest of existence. But then he actually listens to it. "Behind these sounds which decompose from day to day, peels away and slips towards death, the melody stays the same, young and firm, like a pitiless witness." He thinks of the person who created the music, that he suffered just as Roquentin suffers. "There was nothing very pretty or very glorious" about his life or suffering, "but when I hear the song and I think that it was that fellow ho made it, I find his suffering and his sweat...moving. He was lucky." Roquentin recognizes "this is the first time for years that a man has struck me as moving. I should like to know something about that fellow. I should be interested to find out what sort of troubles he had... not at all out of humanism,,,but because he made that [song]." "I don't suppose it would make the slightest difference to the fellow if he were told that in the seventh largest town in France, in the vicinity of the station, somebody is thinking about him. But I would be happy if I were in his place; I envy him." Roquentin then listens to the woman singing the song "Some of these days You'll miss me honey" and thinks "That makes two people who are saved: the [composer] and the [singer]. Saved." Roquentin is struck by the recognition that they have 'justified their existence' - that by giving this of themselves to others, they have been "saved". It is the idea of "empathy" - of placing one's self in another's shoes - which suddenly grants him meaning. "This idea suddenly bowls me over, because I didn't even hope for that anymore....I feel something timidly brushing against me...something I didn't know anymore: a sort of joy." And he imagines he can do this himself - do something like performing music, and give it to others and they would think of him as he had thought of the composer and the singer. And then he too would be saved. This is what happens between Sherlock and Eurus. As music saved Roquentin from the existential terror of existence, so too it saved Eurus.
- 1,402 replies
-
More Existentialism references: Existentialism proceeds from the premise there is no "Creator" of existence to imbue things with any meaning. There is no God who has a "plan". The absence of such a plan is what renders everything absurd - arbitrary - pointless. This absence of such a Creator - and the consequential absurdity and horror of existence - is alluded to by the Governor when Watson, about to shoot him, asks "Do you want to pray or anything?" to which the Gov replies: "With Eurus Holmes in the world, who the hell would I pray to?" Even the Gov recognizes the supposed truth of Existentialism. But his love of his wife is what gives him meaning - in his life and in his death. It is why Watson calls him "a good man".
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)