-
Posts
361 -
Joined
-
Days Won
1
Everything posted by BLS_Pro
-
Indeed. And the supposed reason for that meaninglessness is that things have no meaning unto themselves. As Sartre would put it, they are "nothing". A thing just "is what it is". "she can't find any [meaning]". And that is The Final Problem - how to find meaning in the meaningless.
- 1,402 replies
-
More Existentialism references: When describing Eurus to Sherlock and John, Mycroft 'remembers' himself skipping pebbles while Eurus watches Sherlock and "Redbeard" engaged in 'frivolous play'. In his adult form, Mycroft picks up a pebble. We cut back to 221b and he is holding the pebble his palm, saying: "She knew things she should never have known...as if she were somehow aware of truths beyond the normal scope". After being 'disturbed' by the memory, the pebble is no longer in Mycroft's hand. We hear it having been dropped in the water. This is an allusion to the Existentialist Sartre's "Nausea". It mirrors when the book's protagonist Roquentin first became aware of the "existential condition" of man. He had picked up a pebble, wanting to play "ducks and drakes" "to throw a pebble into the sea like [the children at play]". But he "stopped, dropped the pebble and walked away". This was his first experience of "the Nausea: this blinding revelation" that there is no meaning to anything in existence. Existence is absurd, a horror show. At that moment, Roquentin first became aware of "truths beyond the normal scope": the truth that existence is absurd and meaningless - leaving him in isolation, feeling great "terror" and "angst". That is his normal condition. And that is Eurus in total - given to us in a mere 25 seconds. That is great writing. As to the dismissive notion that Eurus is 'merely' suffering from a "mental condition" - that she was "born" supposedly 'defective' in some way, rather than the explicitly stated fact that she is so intelligent as to be "aware of truths beyond the normal scope" - Sartre's point is: "Roquentin's problem is not simply depression or mental illness, although his experience has pushed him to that point. Sartre presents Roquentin's difficulties as arising from man's inherent existential condition. His seemingly special circumstances (returning from travel, reclusiveness), which goes beyond the mere indication of his very real depression, are supposed to induce in him (and in the reader) a state that makes one more receptive to noticing an existential situation that everyone has, but may not be sensitive enough to let become noticeable. Roquentin undergoes a strange metaphysical experience that estranges him from the world. His problems are not merely a result of personal insanity, without larger significance. Rather...they are victims of larger ideological, social, and existential forces that have brought them to the brink of insanity. Sartre's point in Nausea is to comment on our universal reaction to these common external problems." In other words, Eurus isn't suffering from a psychological illness or defect that somehow prevents her from grasping reality. She is suffering from a philosophic awareness of reality - of everyone's natural condition - to which much of the rest of the world is blind. Her vision of herself as a helpless little girl, eternally trapped in a plane - alone and terrified - is her metaphoric grasp and expression of that 'natural condition'.
- 1,402 replies
-
Eurus tells Watson: "Did Sherlock ever tell you about the note? I added some deductions for Sherlock. He was quite good. But he didn't get the big one." In other words, Eurus is telling us she manufactured ("added") the clues for his deductions. They weren't naturally occurring. The note wasn't in the sunlight for a few years. It just appeared to have been. It didn't have to be posted. It didn't have to be in a book. It didn't have to be in a kitchen. She simply created the clues which would lead Sherlock to such conclusions - just as she created the "Miss Me?" clue on the note - and created the "Anyone" clue, etc.
- 793 replies
-
- 4
-
-
I just went back and watched Doctor Who: Heaven Sent again. One: it shows what the director of T6T can do with a good script. Two: Eurus (the child on the plane) is the Doctor - she's trapped, tortured, and constantly terrified (in "my hell" as the Doctor says) - but without his hope of escaping by herself.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Perhaps it is the hide of the HOUND. ;)
- 793 replies
-
- 2
-
-
The show didn't provide any explicit indication they had all conspired to keep Sherlock's memories repressed. But, for all the reasons you indicate and more, that would seem to be the only logical conclusion.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Indeed. I posted for his attempt at relative thoroughness, not because I believed everything he stated was correct.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
A brisk video analysis of The Final Problem - delving into some ideas mentioned here, exploring a few not yet discussed, and identifying many of the callbacks to prior episodes, cultural references, and Doyle canon connections. Of course, while not exhaustive, it definitely tries to be attentive:
- 1,402 replies
-
- 5
-
-
To show why Sherlock needed to be humanized in the first place - ie justification for their entire story arc. Eurus is Sherlock absent selfless love of others. She is essentially what Sherlock was at the beginning of the entire series (though magnified, of course, to make the distinction more apparent - ie psychopath to Sherlock's sociopath). That is the rationale behind choosing Smith as the lead up villain as well - to establish Ego (selfishness) as the "signature in human destruction" which is "hidden in plain sight" - the element in Sherlock which had to be 'arrested' to make him "good". Fundamentally, Mofftiss creates Sherlock's main villains to be his demons - reflections of his own Ego. He is essentially battling himself. Like those villains, Sherlock's own Ego must be stopped. That is the lesson he finally learns in S4
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
I agree with your conclusions about Doyle not having an 'arc' in mind for his Sherlock. I don't recall ever having read anything from Doyle pertaining to such an arc, let alone intending it from the beginning. But, while Season 3 is when Moffitiss decided specifically on the Redbeard/sister arc "outcome", they were essentially telling us from the beginning that their story was of Sherlock's humanization, right? IOW, their goal of developing Sherlock into a "good man" - they had that 'particular character arc in mind for their Holmes' all along. That particular outcome wasn't decided in S3 (though the particular means to how they would achieve that arc was decided in S3).
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
More mirroring: Smith: "Once you've opened your heart, you can't close it again. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! I'm kidding! Hahahahahaha. Of course you can." Closing his heart is precisely what Sherlock had done after the trauma of his best friend's murder. And closing his heart is what Watson has just done after the trauma of Mary's murder.
- 1,402 replies
-
And more mirroring: Sherlock's love is murdered (Best Friend) John's love is murdered (Wife) Sherlock withdraws from everyone, isolates himself emotionally, - is alone without love. John withdraws from everyone, isolates himself emotionally - is alone without love Both of them are in hell because of a devastating loss. Both of them need to be saved from that hell. In both cases, the love of the other is what saves them. Both cases mirror the final case. What they have done to save each other is what Sherlock does to save Eurus from her hell - from being alone without love. He loves her.
- 1,402 replies
-
More mirroring in the last season: CORRUPTED MEMORY "The virus in the data" - TAB ​T6T The Thatcher statues are a ​callback to HOTB - a case where a man experienced such an emotional trauma, related to the murder of a loved one, that he repressed its memory, which became so "corrupted" that the man involved became a dog in the victim's mind. This secret trauma caused him to isolate himself. This person's entire life revolved on and changed with one name - "HOUND" (Additionally, the callback itself is being triggered by one word - "MAGGIE", as in Thatcher) TLD Faith's case is one where a woman is subjected to a drug that represses the memory and "corrupts" it. She is traumatized by fragments of a memory she cannot recall but believes to be related to the murder of someone. This secret trauma caused her to isolate herself. This person's entire life revolved on and changed with one name - "Anyone". TFP Sherlock's case is one where he experienced such an emotional trauma, related to the murder of his best friend, that he repressed the memory, which became so "corrupted" that the friend became a dog in Sherlock's mind. This secret trauma caused him to isolate himself . Sherlock's entire life revolved on and changed with one name - "Redbeard"
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
The premonition in T6T wasn't a premonition at all. It was Sherlock's subconscious connecting "water" (drowning/death) with Thatcher - which is a connection to Hounds, which is the case identical to his own repressed and corrupted memories.
- 793 replies
-
Interestingly, they are mirrors in a different way as well (which is why this is brilliant writing - 'deep waters' here). Culverton and Norbury are mirrors of Sherlock (as well as Eurus). All of them are "monsters" - Sherlock is just "our monster". All of them treat people as "things". Recall that Moffat has said all along that Sherlock is not a good person. The whole of the series is about him learning to be a good person. Ajay is the "monster" created out of trauma - just like Sherlock. Norbury was jealous of others. She was not Amo (Love) - she was not acting selflessly, but selfishly. Sherlock doesn't love people (in general). He loves the game. He loves beating other people. He loves -beating- the competition. "Vivian Norbury - who outsmarted them all. All except Sherlock Holmes." He plays the game for himself. It is all about his Ego. And Ego is the killer. It is the "signature in human destruction". That is the lesson Sherlock learns at the end of T6T. We see in TLD (and TFP) he now plays the game for love of others, not for love of himself. His Ego - he himself - is no longer the end. As we see in TLD, he is willing to die to save Watson. The game is about Watson, not about Sherlock. Watson is the end - the purpose - the meaning of the game. Others are now why he plays the game. And, if that wasn't clear in TLD, Watson makes it explicit in TFP: "No. We are not competing. There is a plane in the air about to crash. What we're doing is actually trying to do is save a little girl. Today we have to be soldiers, Mycroft. Soldiers. And that means to hell with what happens to us." which Sherlock later affirms. "Soldiers." He stops playing the game. He stops trying to "beat" Eurus. That is when he decides to sacrifice himself. (A mirror of Moriarty here - the difference is that Moriarty kills himself to one up Sherlock - to beat Sherlock in their competition. He will kill himself out of Ego. Sherlock, here, will kill himself to save his friends, not to 'win the game'. He will kill himself, not for himself, but for his friends. He will kill himself out of selfless love.) That is Sherlock having learned NOT to be a monster any more. That is Sherlock having learned to be a human being.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Then I am curious how you interpret the message translated from her song: I am lost. Help me brother. Save my life before my doom. I am lost without your love. Save my soul, seek my room. As to "psychotic", would you describe Mary's old comrade as "psychotic" after having been left alone to be tortured senselessly and without end for six years? Or do you, in pity, call him a tortured soul? Do you blame him for being angry? (One can certainly blame him for misdirecting his anger, but that of course is not the same thing). I believe that is why the writers created this particular backstory about Mary - so that the audience would sympathize with him, and thus sympathize with the little girl in the same situation (and is why she is depicted as a little girl) - who has been alone and tortured (by existence itself) without end since childhood. It is another of the mirrors they created for the audience to reflect upon.
- 1,402 replies
-
Yes, there was more to it. Think about what case she brought him. Faith is a mirror of Sherlock. She is a person whose memory has been intentionally repressed and "corrupted". She remembers snippets of something - a traumatic secret about death hiding in plain sight, of which there are signs all around. It is a secret which caused her to isolate herself from others. Faith's "whole life turned on one word" - which is why Sherlock takes the case. He takes it because, as he says, 'one word, she instantly recognized, tore her world apart' - and he doesn't know how that is possible - yet'. Of course that is Sherlock - and the one word is "Redbeard". That is her purpose in bringing that case to him - to hold up that mirror to him.
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Loneliness is her problem. As is possessiveness. The love that saves is not selfish love. Ego is "the signature in human destruction". Selfish love is love of others as commodities for yourself. It is the making of others into "things" for your pleasure. Jealousy - possessiveness - is selfish love. John and Molly - especially Molly - are examples of selfless love. Selfless love is what Sherlock finally gives John in TLD. Sherlock 'plays the game', not for love of the game, but for love of John. That is the lesson he learns. He acts, not to satisfy his needs, but the needs of another. It is that lesson which allows him to save Eurus. And he learned that lesson dealing with another jealous murderer - where his lack of love, his lack of empathy, for that woman - and his love of himself, his Ego - led to death. That is how Sherlock has grown from the beginning of the season. He doesn't make the mistake he did with Norbury. Sherlock doesn't just love - he loves selflessly.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Given that Watson is a Doctor, Sherlock couldn't be seen by John as faking his condition. It had to be real or the plan wouldn't work. Molly was there as a second opinion not the only opinion. And as Sherlock says on his hospital bed he is indeed in terrible shape. The timing of the case and his drug use bothered me as well at first, but it makes sense that he would have to establish his use long before a case came to him. If it didn't start before the case then it would look suspicious. That and it would take longer than two-three weeks to get into a functional but life threatening state. So presumably he began his drug use while he was searching for just the right case. And Faith brought him that case - tailor made for HER purposes - a case which mirrored her and Sherlock exactly. So the drug use wasn't for entertainment purposes, nor is it him plotting against Smith specifically. It is him setting the game-space as it were. Getting things in place while he looked for a big bad bully. IOW he was making himself vulnerable so that Watson would truly believe he was in trouble - which he was.
- 793 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Yes. We are all capable of error, just as we are all capable of accuracy. But, just as I cannot logically point to every instance throughout history when human beings were right as reason to have belief in my argument, nor can anyone else logically point to every instance throughout history when human beings were wrong as reason to have doubt of my argument. In other words, just as my capacity for being right doesn't make my argument right, so too my capacity for being wrong doesn't make my argument wrong. Pointing to either capacity says nothing whatsoever about the validity or invalidity of the argument being presented.
- 1,402 replies
-
Right. You'll simply declare you don't need evidence to doubt - the same way others declare they don't need evidence to believe. In other words, you 'stand by your assertion' based solely on faith. Fine. You have every right to do that. I will not impede nor deny you that right. As you say, this is a fan forum not a symposium. Debating the merits of faith vs reason would either bore - or inflame - everyone else. More importantly, a forum - regardless of its subject matter - is not a place one can teach others the merits/problems of faith or reason. That requires a different format entirely. As to continued examples of yourself or others 'getting something wrong', that is - again- not evidence of error, any more than examples of yourself or others 'getting something right' is evidence of accuracy. Capacity for accuracy is not evidence of accuracy, any more than capacity for error is evidence of error. Sorry. We simply have to agree to disagree here - due to opposing epistemologies.
- 1,402 replies
-
Does no one else think Eurus recognizes Molly as a mirror to her own relation to Sherlock? That Eurus recognizes they are both in exactly the same situation - they both suffer from unrequited love for Sherlock?
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Another BTW - John's comments to Sherlock about The Woman apply to both Irene and Eurus: "you BLOODY moron. She's out there, she likes you and she's alive. Do you have the first idea how LUCKY you are? Yes, she's a lunatic, she's a criminal, she's insanely dangerous..." But loving others "will complete you as a human being". It doesn't matter who you love. It doesn't matter "who you are" or who they are. All that matters is that you love. It is what saves you.
- 1,402 replies
-
I agree that Watson was reduced more to the role of Damsel in Distress in this episode. But then everyone's role, including Sherlock, was reduced. As I noted previously, Sherlock's actions are not what move the story here. He is told the backstory. He doesn't deduce it. He doesn't discover it. He is spoon-fed everything - led around by the nose. This story is not his. It is Eurus' story. Sherlock just happens to be a major character in it. Overall, he is not the one doing things. Overall, he is just the one things are done to. It is only in the end where he exercises much agency.
- 1,402 replies
-
I believe you are closer on the latter. Look at John. He wasn't emulating Eurus subconsiously when he distanced himself emotionally from others, especially Sherlock. When humans get hurt, they have a tendancy to retreat. To isolate themselves emotionally to prevent further trauma. It's the same as jerking your hand away from a stove when you get burned. You try to avoid that which hurt you in the first place. Don't love. Don't feel. Be detached from your emotions. That will keep you safe. Of course it does the opposite. It leaves you alone - and miserable. That is Eurus' state - and John's state after Mary's death. You need the love of others to save you. And, as John provided that love to him and saved Sherlock, so Sherlock provided that love to John, and saved him. And, as Eurus needed that same love, so Sherlock finally provided it to her, and thus saved her as well.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)