-
Posts
97 -
Joined
Everything posted by Janine M. Adler
-
have anyone seen the lastest episode of Elementary 'Hounded' based on The hounds of baskervilles? What do you think of it since it is the only episode based on canon? Which one you like better- bbc version or elementary version?
-
Episode 4.0: The Abominable Bride (alias The Special)
Janine M. Adler replied to Undead Medic's topic in Special and Series 4
Yes, conviction is necessary for getting pardons from the queen/president. A person must confess his crime before asking for a royal pardon. But isn't Sherlock is already convicted (though through a secret trial maybe) and was sentenced to be exiled? I don't know. I am just guessing. It'd be shame if Motfiss just ignore the topic at all in the next season and only focus on Moriarty things. BTW...I am watching all the Sherlock episodes in a row for the last two days. I love how cute BC looks in the unaired piilot. -
Episode 4.0: The Abominable Bride (alias The Special)
Janine M. Adler replied to Undead Medic's topic in Special and Series 4
I am still wondering how Sherlock will get away with the killing Magnassum? I mean maybe this killing most possibly kept hidden from public eyes, and Morierty is back and blah, blah...but heck there are laws, how can he be allowed to his home in Baker street than the prison after his return? Even Mycroft has limitations of his powers, doesn't he? It will be unrealistic if they simply not address the consequence of the murder. How can Sherlock be pardoned after sentenced to be an exile? -
Episode 4.0: The Abominable Bride (alias The Special)
Janine M. Adler replied to Undead Medic's topic in Special and Series 4
can anyone tell me what does these notes in Mycroft's notebook means? Is it related to season 4? And what does Vernet means? Does anyone have a theory? -
Episode 4.0: The Abominable Bride (alias The Special)
Janine M. Adler replied to Undead Medic's topic in Special and Series 4
I have seen someone questioning about Molly's profession. I think she is actually a doctor who graduated from a medical school who later persuaded her career in Forensics. I myself work in forensics and I am a medical school graduate. So when Lestrade adresses Molly as Doctor Hooper, I think it is her true designation. -
What would you like to see in series 4?
Janine M. Adler replied to T.o.b.y's topic in Special and Series 4
Ah, you should see this. Excellent. https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=gnPK2_RrWCo -
I know it is very silly thought, but there is another rumor in the fandom that Mary is the other one. I don't believe this theory, still it's an interesting idea, I think.
- 4,923 replies
-
I've read all of Doyle's works when I was 15 (Of course in my language), then I re-read them in English. I was very reluctant to see any kind of film adaptation of my favorite detective, but I changed my mind when I saw Sherlock for the first time. I really did enjoyed the canon references they used in ASIP. Specially the cabbie, and Rache...In the book there was indeed a tire print of a carriage, and the rider took the evidence from the victim (I guess it was a ring, I can't recall clearly because I read the story 10 years ago), and Rache was written on the wall. Lastrate interpreted as Rachel, but Holmes said it was Rache. I liked the tease they gave us. That's is one reason I like the show. I also like the book code reference they used in TBB *Although it's my least favorite episode), from The Valley of fear. I like to see more canon stories on the show in future. But I wonder what stories they will use next. Because most of the famous stories are already used.
- 636 replies
-
- Episode Discussion
- Series 1
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
What would you like to see in series 4?
Janine M. Adler replied to T.o.b.y's topic in Special and Series 4
i've a feeling that they'd do an asaptation for valley of fear. -
hahaha....like it., Carol There are plenty of stories out there. I think there will not be any lack of source material. They have already adapted two of my favorite stories "A scandal in Bohemia" and "Chales Agustus Milverton". I can't wait to see if they ever adapt "Valley of fear". It's the one which contains Morierty as reference. If they really bring him back, this one will be more reasonable. Besides the story contains an interesting explanation of a fake suicide. If they ever use it explain Morierty's return. (or Sherlock's. It was much better than jumping on an airbag. Also I've three more stories in my favorite lists, "The solitary cyclist", "Devil's foot" and "Gloria Scott." There is another story,( I can remember the name) where Mycroft appoint Sherlock to retrive important state documents, and some state person is involved. If they ever adapt that one, it may be grant Sherlock a perdon for CAM's murder (Who knows if he had those documents)
- 4,923 replies
-
My thoughts exactly, T.O.B.Y. But where did they used the plot in TRF? Forgive me, I can't remember. Still I like this villain from the books. Besides he is a doctor (!) too. May be the writers can make him anti-John, like they made Moriarty anti-Sherlock.
- 4,923 replies
-
- 1
-
-
anyway I feel like that Irene Adler will make an appearance in the next season. She was mentioned in 3rd season at least two times- once in Sherlock's mind palace, and in Moriarty's list on who will cry if Sherlock died. and she was the second in list next to John! i've an hunch that The Woman isn't completely gone from Sherlock's life. Remember what Moffat said about women in Sherlock. Besides I like to see a new villain besides Moriarty. Culverton Smith possibly. He is the next brilliant baddie in the books who almost fooled our favorite sleuth.
- 4,923 replies
-
What would you like to see in series 4?
Janine M. Adler replied to T.o.b.y's topic in Special and Series 4
i lke to see adaptations from Gloria Scott, Vally of fear, The solitary cyclist , Devil's foot . and the illustrious client, I'd love if they bring Irene Adler back if they ever make any complete adaptation for The Illustrious client. If Morierty can be back from dead, why not she. Besides her ending is still unclear. Plus I can't resist to see another brain duel between them. -
I've a few questions in my mind while re-watching HLV. What was the problem with putting Sherlock in an actual prison? I know Mycroft thinks that no prison can hold Sherlock or causes riot in daily basis. But prisoners even Sherlock can be kept in some prison cells where escapade can be impossible. Riots can be controlled, besides murdering a man can destroy Sherlock's reputation. His explation seems a bit inappropriate to me. So why Mycroft thinks like that? Is he wants to escape the pain to see his little brother in prison or hear his sentencing during his trial? To the jury he spoke seems a bit unofficial meeting to me rather than an actual trial. Though sending Sherlock to a near-death mission is really hard, but still it makes me to think about Mycroft's real plan. (Although he clears himself that he doesn't speaking for brotherly compassion. But he also admits that Sherlock's loss will break his heart. Pretty controversial, isn't it?) So is that Mycroft advocates this punishment because he secretly believes Sherlock will actually survive the M16 mission? Perhaps Sherlock did something very like, and survived during his hiatus. Besides whole faking death plan and hideout entirely involved Mycroft always. Though the mission means near-certain death, but it also seems like the kind of adventure Sherlock would be amenable to, and therefore, not entirely a punishment. Besides Mycroft rescued Sherlock once in undercover, was he planning to do the same this time? Or does Mycroft know/believe that the REAL punishment, in the sense of the thing that truly hurt and upset Sherlock, is the separation from John? It is pretty unbelievable to call back some exiled murderer to stop Morierty in the first place before using other forces (government secret service, or other things like that) which may involve some government issue. And the gif seems pretty ridiculous, even the voice doesn't belongs to Morierty. And the timing...it was pretty suspicious. Of Morierty is truly alive, why would he stop his arch enemy from going to the near fatal mission. So I'm wondering about the accuracy / honesty of NOT exiling Sherlock because he's the only one who could stop Moriarty: what about Mycroft himself? I've a suspicion that he doesn't want to lose his dear brother. And the video of Moriarty himself at the end of the credit is just a teaser from the writer (ok, I always want to ignore the part)
- 4,923 replies
-
- 1
-
-
I totally agree with you T.O.B.Y. HLV is my favorite episode too. I just can't get through how much emotions it contains. And I like the thing that how much true they remained to the canon stories. Oh, my God. But the scenery of the Mind Palace just blew me off. I like the idea of mind palace thing. You know mind palace isn't a fantasy thing. It is an age old technique used by ancient Greeks. I like how they used the idea here. Here is more scientific analysis about building mind palace - http://www.salon.com/2014/02/09/its_not_so_elementary_the_secrets_of_sherlocks_mind_palace/ BTW, I like the first ending when the plane took off with Sherlock, I almost cried at that point. But the second ending was okey too, especially when John referred Holmes as "East wind". I like to think Moriarty isn't really alive, someone is using his face to terrorize England, may be a new villain. I like to ignore the teaser at the end of the credit. And at last I want to share a nice youtube video here on season 3. It summarizes the whole season just poetically. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Txf3qiXPCv8&feature=youtu.be
- 4,923 replies
-
- 1
-
-
here is a beautiful analysis of Sherlock's psyche and his actions in http://wellingtongoose.tumblr.com/post/73246764901/his-last-vow-why-being-a-high-function-sociopath-is
-
thank you guys for welcoming me.
- 4,923 replies
-
Hey, I'm new to this forum. I've been reading the posts for a while. I've recently read an article about How Sherlock survived despite being flat lined. Being a doctor myself I found it logical and coordinating with the events shown in the episode about how he survived. I like to share this link with you. http://wellingtongoose.tumblr.com/post/75415111199/how-sherlock-survived-his-heart-stopping-a-medical
- 4,923 replies
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)