Jump to content

BLS_Pro

Detectives
  • Posts

    361
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    1

Everything posted by BLS_Pro

  1. There are SO many out of character inconsistencies throughout this episode that they hurt the story and the characters immensely. That is why I am wondering what 'tricks' are being hidden from us to supposedly explain them. Either way though, be it trickery or ineptitude, this episode has ASTONISHINGLY bad writing. I've always disliked Gatiss' episodes as the weakest/worst of each season. But the depths to which this has sunk are truly awful.
  2. If Nor had the gun trained on Mary the entire time he was talking and his talking caused her to change aim, I might agree. But Sherlock didn't need to diffuse the situation for Mary or need to cause Nor to shift focus from Mary to himself. Almost immediately, Nor let her gun droop, taking it OFF both of them. And she did this BEFORE he had spoken a word. IF he was worried about the weapon and Mary's safety, he could have done SO many OTHER things to turn down the already lessening tension. In fact, he could have simply let Nor WALK OUT - and let the police catch this obviously NOT 'master criminal' later (right IN the Aquarium, given they were there already and he knew it). IF this was an attempt to protect Mary, it was a STUPID act, not a smart one. And that just makes Sherlock an idiot (as opposed to self-absorbed and cocky, which is STILL bad writing in this context, but certainly fits what they keep saying is supposedly Sherlock's character. And fits what Sherlock says about Nor to Mrs H. IF his intent had been to deflect to him, and he misjudged MARY not NOR, then the comment would be 'Just say Mary'. In other words, the reference is to WHO surprised him - ie who did he get wrong? He is saying to Mrs H that he was surprised by Nor, NOT Mary.) From the Behind The Scenes video (around 15:30), Moffat confirms this while speaking of the scene: "There's a real moment of Sherlock facing his own worst enemy - and obviously Sherlock's own worst enemy is himself - is that he can't stop himself from making a series of damaging, hurtful deductions..." Moments later Gatiss states: "We've been here before with him, saying the wrong thing at the wrong time. But now it has literally fatal consequences." He goes on to say that its related to a Sherlock story set in Norbury where he "gets everything wrong". And so, Gatiss states, in this story he "literally made Norbury flesh". In other words, Moffat and Gatiss explicitly state their intent is that Sherlock is simply being his 'self-absorbed and cocky self' and that his uncontrolled and unintentional behavior leads to the tragedy. His attack on Nor was NOT a calculated act to save Mary, but an act Sherlock was 'helpless' to stop (despite Mary warning him twice) and heedless as to the effect it would have on Nor (and subsequently on himself or Mary). He wasn't trying to goad Nor into shooting HIM rather than Mary. He simply misread Nor completely. He "got her wrong".
  3. I agree. Her words, while presented in a deadly serious tone, do not seem to have the heat of an attack or a rebuke. Instead they are delivered more as an instruction to Sherlock.
  4. Another question: The 'hippy chick' - is her rose necklace supposed to have some significance, especially in the context of the baby's name?
  5. If Nor had the gun trained on Mary the entire time he was talking and his talking caused her to change aim, I might agree. But Sherlock didn't need to diffuse the situation for Mary or need to cause Nor to shift focus from Mary to himself. Almost immediately, Nor let her gun droop, taking it OFF both of them. And she did this BEFORE he had spoken a word. IF he was worried about the weapon and Mary's safety, he could have done SO many OTHER things to turn down the already lessening tension. In fact, he could have simply let Nor WALK OUT - and let the police catch this obviously NOT 'master criminal' later (right IN the Aquarium, given they were there already and he knew it). IF this was an attempt to protect Mary, it was a STUPID act, not a smart one. And that just makes Sherlock an idiot (as opposed to self-absorbed and cocky, which is STILL bad writing in this context, but certainly fits what they keep saying is supposedly Sherlock's character. And fits what Sherlock says about Nor to Mrs H. IF his intent had been to deflect to him, and he misjudged MARY not NOR, then the comment would be 'Just say Mary'. In other words, the reference is to WHO surprised him - ie who did he get wrong? He is saying to Mrs H that he was surprised by Nor, NOT Mary.)
  6. Another question: Why was the text to Mary different than the one Sherlock sent at the same time to John? The one to her was all about acting references. His, just a summons.
  7. I watched it again, but I don't see evidence in tone, action, or body language by either of them that this is the case. :( What I do see is EVERYONE's uncharacteristic thoughtlessness when going off to face woman whom they should NOT have been surprised had a gun.
  8. One of the MANY things which bothered me about this episode is the DIS-service it does to Mary's character. She is a 'super-agent', as the example above is supposed to indicate. Yet she always carried evidence on her which must never fall into the enemies hands because it would betray all four of them disasterously? She isn't smart enough to even check for a tracker in the USB (and thus her ineptitude is turned into a one liner joke I saw coming a mile away and thus turned that long travel sequence into one of TWO parts of the story I just fast-forwarded through because it was boring and the end predictable)? And when told "It's not over" by sherlock, she doesn't come prepared to defend herself somehow (despite having come prepared to knock Sherlock out earlier)? And SHE has to be told by SHERLOCK to not step close to Nor because she was about to pull out a gun??? REALLY?!?!?!? SO very VERY wrong (like SOOOOOO many other things in the ep) if its NOT all just a trick (and if it is a trick, its a badly written and executed trick).
  9. BTW - another question: If I recall correctly, this is the first time we've had Sherlock (apparently) speaking to the Audience and Narrating. Just more bad writing? Or is he actually talking to someone? If the latter, who and in what (apparently ongoing) context?
  10. I noticed it but had to go back to actually read it. Seems like foreshadowing, as was done with the sign in TEH. "He's Back" (He's related to Moriarty's 'return'). "Murder" (It will involve murder - and business apparently, perhaps murder AS business) "Coming" (Obvious)
  11. I was quite annoyed by the pedestrian writing AND direction of this episode. It isn't even close to the quality of prior seasons. In fact, it felt like a typical procedural. I am withholding ultimate judgment though because I suspect there are many things we are purposefully being 'tricked' about in this episode. With that in mind, I have (at least) one question: When Sherlock texts Mary to meet him at the Church after discovering the USB, where/what is that room exactly? I don't recall that we've ever seen it before. It seems like he has created a separate, secret lair for himself. Why? Secret from whom? Why does he summon her there rather than to 221B? etc
  12. Ooh, neat how they created that message by having the top poster start to peel off a bit, revealing one word on an older layer underneath. I should know this (I mean, how often do we see John with a car?), but what scene is that from? It's when John is pulling out the tire iron as he is about to storm into the drug den.
  13. Right. Well, Blu Ray pre-order officially cancelled.
  14. INFORMATION IS POWER BTW - I'm certain this has probably been noted elsewhere by someone, but this is the first opportunity I've had to post a picture of something I noticed when first viewing the episode. Nothing like a "subtle" theme, eh? Subliminal indeed.
  15. If that is indeed true, then I am sincerely disappointed. This series has been a letdown for me, and I wanted to hear them explain their thinking. Apparently they won't be bothered anymore. MORE disappointment from this series then.
  16. Yes. Consider Mary's dialogue in HEARSE when John is about to shave his mustache. If one looks at just the words as written, they could have been very confrontational and indicative of a spat or fight. Instead the actress delivered them in a loving and teasing manner. So the actor can definitely transform a scene. And that's when it gets fun.
  17. I am puzzled by your references to "the script," RadCap. Are the scripts for the Series 3 episodes available somewhere? Or are you referring to the dialog? Or am I missing something? Unfortunately I have not seen any actual scripts in public. Like toby I only wish they existed. I use the term script to cover action, settings, props, and dialogue etc which we see on screen - as opposed to suppositions made about any and all such things.
  18. Indeed. Since the episode never identifies what facts led Sherlock to his conclusion, I simply pointed out what the script revealed he had deduced, not by what method he had made his deduction. I agree, though the fact that Sherlock believes (for some unstated reason) that a physical vault exists, he has this unnamed reason for thinking CAM needed a physical vault in order to retain the all the information That, combined with CAMs decidedly non-intellectual - ie very physical - way of expressing his "ownership" of others, is likely supposed to excuse Sherlock from making the Mind Vault deduction too early. I think this is just another example of poor writing for Sherlock this series, akin to neither Sherlock or Mycroft even thinking about a terrorist connection to Guy Fawkes until after CAM hands them that clue on a silver platter in HEARSE.
  19. I thought they wee 'Google Glass' from the moment he originally put them on while talking at his summoning. It's a new technology and I thought it would be an interesting thing for them to play with. They aren't 'magic' glasses, they are a real product. While Sherlock does mention a '4G' connection, which would mean net access, he also mentions a USB device and things like that. Something where the information might be stored directly to the glasses themselves. I do know they are not magic. Didn't think Sherlock had turned in Harry Potter! My point is, one of the first things Sherlock tells John is that CAM stores nothing on computers. At this point, he thinks all the blackmail material is stored in the vaults under Appledore. So how does he think CAM can access this physical information by his "google glasses"? Wouldn't it have to be held on a computer in some form or other? For instance, if your info was stored in a box file, you couldn't look at it from a distance through an electronic device, could you? Surely it would have to be in digital form. We are obviously meant to think they are special glasses, hence the deliberate polishing, but why would Sherlock think that, if he believes all the info is in physical form? He uses a memory system himself all the time, so it seems logical that he would guess that CAM was doing the same. It would not necessarily mean the material did not physically exist in the vaults, it would just mean CAM could recall it accurately at will. At least it would work, which is more than the glasses would unless CAM had suddenly decided to computerise his information. Sherlock says CAM is smart "[it's] the Alexandria Library of secrets and scandals. And none of it is on a computer. He's smart. Computers can be hacked. It's all on hard copy, in vaults, underneath that house." These are obviously all deductions based on information Sherlock has somehow acquired. And I say these are deductions because we know for a fact that there are no hard copies of most of the stuff and there are no vaults underneath the house. So presumably the conclusion that none of it is on a computer is based on similar deductions - deductions Sherlock also comes to conclude were wrong because he has seen CAM "reading" files and, with this additional fact, surmises CAM has not been as "smart" as Sherlock first deduced. Of course when Sherlock tests his deduction - claiming CAM has been "careless" - Sherlock learns that he has, as CAM puts it, "underestimated" CAM. In other words, Sherlock learns part of his original deduction was right. He learns CAM did not put any of it on a computer, but kept it in his mind instead.
  20. I understand the Series 3 discs are supposed to be released tomorrow (20 Jan). It would be greatly appreciated if anyone who purchases them would provide a detailed list of the Extras which are included. Most specifically, it would be incredibly helpful to learn if any commentaries were included on the discs, as they have been in the past. As it stands, the sketchy details currently available have not listed any. Please let us know one way or the other!
  21. So not walking away after all, but instead making an argument (among other things). Okay. By saying "could" you are claiming that the script may be indicating CAM is reading something other than a physical or digital or mental file. What other option are you claiming exists for the script to be having CAM read? Remember, while it is just a TV show, it isn't a science fiction TV show (like Moffat's other big hit), so lets keep things in the realm of the facts of reality, shall we? In other words, no wibbly wobbly timey whimey stuff allowed. Sorry...
  22. Thank you for acknowledging what I've been claiming has been in the script all along - ie Sherlock's recognition that CAM was not reading physical or digital, but in fact mental files. In other words, that Sherlock recognized, as you put it, CAM "could access his vaults mentally". Of course that fact alone was not how the script revealed Sherlock's deduction about any physical vaults and his consequent plans, including the killing of CAM. As I explicitly stated, if you wanted the rest of what you demanded - quotes from the script which show all that I've been claiming - I would be happy to provide them. However, you've indicated you prefer to agree to disagree instead. So I'll simply leave as read the proof that all the rest of my claims were as validly supported in the script as this one - and walk away as you request.
  23. Funny that I've pointed to the facts in the script four times now and yet you keep blithely declaring they do not exist. Sherlock's explicitly stated motivation in the script is to see the vault. So, contrary to your claim, it is far more than merely "personal opinion". Nor is it, contrary to your claim, just "personal opinion" that Sherlock recognizes in the cafe that CAM has Appledore in his mind - ie that CAM himself is the "portable Appledore". That explicit revelation is the entire point of that scripted scene. And, contrary to your claim, it is not "personal opinion" but fact that the script reveals Sherlock has the entire plan put together right after discovering the vault is mental rather than digital - right down to the day it will occur - months later on Christmas - and down to the explicit motivation for it: Sherlock's "deal with the devil" is, contrary to your claim, explicitly stated right in the script, to be the betrayal of his brother - not for Mary's files - but to see the vault. Everything I've stated about Sherlock's motivation has, contrary to your claims, been in the script. In fact, the script virtually beats the viewer over the head with it - especially with Sherlock's discovery that Appledore is in CAM's mind. I'm not sure why you keep trying to claim all of this doesn't exist in the script, but if it is more "fun" for you that these scripted facts not exist, then far be it for me to stand in the way of your "enjoyment". If you truly don't want to talk about them further, then I won't discuss them with you any longer either. Seems fair enough. Please *quote* lines/stage directions - *not* 'he looked like this which meant he was thinking this'. If you can't do that, we're going to have to agree to differ and accept that none of us know except the writers - and if you are one of the writers undercover, i'm sorry but you didn't do a good enough job of conveying what you wanted to get across! I'm sorry my summary of the words and actions of the script are not convincing. However, I am more than happy to quote the actual words and actions from the script as they occur on-screen, if that is what you truly require (though, for the record, I never said anything like 'he looked like this which meant he was thinking this'. Quite the opposite, in fact. I have stated 'He did or saw this, which is why he looked like that'. If you truly believe otherwise, then I would request you do the same that you request of me: provide my actual words - ie please "quote" me.) Now, here is when Sherlock discovers CAM's vault is in his mind: Sherlock: "Oh, I think you're a lot more careless than you let on." CAM "Am I?" Sherlock: "It's the dead-eye stare that gives it away. Except it's not dead-eyed, is it? Sherlock takes off CAM's glasses. "You're reading. Portable Appledore. How does it work? Built-in flash drive? 4G wireless?" Sherlock puts the glasses on. He realizes they are normal glasses. Sherlock: "Just ordinary spectacles." CAM: "Yes. They are." We see CAM's view again - and see the readout we've seen all along, except now without the glasses. It is thus similar to what we see when Sherlock identifies things in his mind. CAM: "You underestimate me Mr. Holmes." So, as I've stated numerous times now, in the script Sherlock identifies the fact that CAM is reading. What is CAM reading though? The script makes clear he has no papers physically in his hands. So he's not reading physical files. The script does have CAM wearing glasses though. Thus the script has Sherlock conclude that CAM is reading something digitally in the glasses (something akin to an HUD). The script has Sherlock attempt to confirm his deduction about what CAM is reading by taking the glasses to view the vault himself. But was CAM reading from the glasses? No. So - the script tells us Sherlock knows CAM is reading. But the script now tells us Sherlock knows CAM was not reading physical files nor digital files. So what was CAM reading then? In the script, CAM tells Sherlock his deduction - that CAM supposedly requires an external source to be able to read his files - underestimates CAM. In other words, the script has CAM state to Sherlock that the belief that CAM requires files to be either physical or digital is an underestimation of what CAM is capable. So the script tells us Sherlock knows CAM is reading. And the script tells us Sherlock knows CAM is not reading anything physical or digital. So if the script eliminates for Sherlock the files being physical or digital, what does the script then leave him? The mental, of course. The script leaves for Sherlock only the fact that CAM is reading mental files - files in his mind - the files which the script had Sherlock call the "portable Appledore". In other words, the script leaves for Sherlock the fact that CAM holds Appledore in his his mind. Pretty simple actually. And all in the script. One simply need pay attention to it. Now, I can provide the verbatim quotes from the script for all the rest of the points I made as well, if you really need them. Just let me know. However, since this is the most important point of them all - Sherlock's recognition that the "portable Appledore" is not the glasses but is in fact CAM's mind - it should suffice to prove what I've been stating. For if the script itself is not enough to convince you, then nothing will.
  24. "See my previous reply." Saw it. Refuted it. You've nothing to add to dispute that refutation? Okay.
  25. Funny that I've pointed to the facts in the script four times now and yet you keep blithely declaring they do not exist. Sherlock's explicitly stated motivation in the script is to see the vault. So, contrary to your claim, it is far more than merely "personal opinion". Nor is it, contrary to your claim, just "personal opinion" that Sherlock recognizes in the cafe that CAM has Appledore in his mind - ie that CAM himself is the "portable Appledore". That explicit revelation is the entire point of that scripted scene. And, contrary to your claim, it is not "personal opinion" but fact that the script reveals Sherlock has the entire plan put together right after discovering the vault is mental rather than digital - right down to the day it will occur - months later on Christmas - and down to the explicit motivation for it: Sherlock's "deal with the devil" is, contrary to your claim, explicitly stated right in the script, to be the betrayal of his brother - not for Mary's files - but to see the vault. Everything I've stated about Sherlock's motivation has, contrary to your claims, been in the script. In fact, the script virtually beats the viewer over the head with it - especially with Sherlock's discovery that Appledore is in CAM's mind. I'm not sure why you keep trying to claim all of this doesn't exist in the script, but if it is more "fun" for you that these scripted facts not exist, then far be it for me to stand in the way of your "enjoyment". If you truly don't want to talk about them further, then I won't discuss them with you any longer either. Seems fair enough.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.