Jump to content

BLS_Pro

Detectives
  • Posts

    361
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    1

Everything posted by BLS_Pro

  1. Interesting that you believe the reaction should be "Aha! I thought so!" as opposed to "Damn! Now I have to go through with it and lose John (and likely my life) in order to save him!" Benedict was quite a wonderful actor if one realizes what the reaction would actually be in those circumstances. Already stated why. So that CAM's henchmen would not act against Sherlock or John - ie the reason for specifically wanting the police there is to protect the two of them. Quite an act of genius actually. As to a "better place" for the killing (not murder) - the death of CAM was a secondary, not the primary, purpose in going to CAM's place - a purpose wholly dependent upon the outcome of the fundamental purpose in going there. Sherlock's primary purpose was to confirm or deny his deduction that the vault was in CAM's head. The vault, as the script explicitly states, is what Sherlock is out to see there - the vault is what he keeps demanding. Again, recall his "deal with the devil". Sherlock offers Mycroft up in exchange, not for Mary's files, but to see the vault. Remember, stick to the script. It is the "authority".
  2. This may be right, but it was the look on Sherlock's face as Magnussen is demonstrating his own mental powers that leads me to believe that Sherlock hadn't decided until then that perhaps violence was going to be called for after all. Also, Sherlock asking Magnussen one last and final time on the terrace if there was no paper trail, before he shot him kind of cemented that for me. I am certain Sherlock hoped that violence wouldn't be necessary - that he was wrong and that a vault did exist. But the look on Sherlock's face is not one of surprise or defeat. It is one of unavoidable negative consequences. And of course Sherlock confirmed that there was no paper trail. But the question was simply a confirmation of what he had already concluded (just as seeing the vault was confirmation of what he already concluded). Just as Sherlock was not surprised that no paper trail existed, neither was he surprised that no vault existed. He had deduced these facts earlier - and simply wanted confirmation that his deduction was not flawed in any way. He wanted to know there were no alternatives he hadn't considered. Sherlock wanted to know he was right - as he always wants to know (a trait he demonstrates goes all the way back to PINK).
  3. No. His purpose in visiting CAM's residence was to see if the vault existed or not. To do so required his elaborate ruse, and that ruse required the presence of John. That is why Sherlock then needed the impartial witnesses - to show John was not a party to the killing. Indeed he did. Which is why when he discovered the google glasses were but glasses and thus everything was inside CAM's memory, he realized where the vault actually was - his mind. He had evidence for that conclusion literally in his hands. No. His attitude makes perfect sense. It just wasn't one of utter defeat. Nor was it of surprise. It was of recognition of what he would now have to do - and what it would mean. This is when the little boy recognized his 'final solution' was unavoidable - as was what it would cost him.
  4. I agree with everything you say except as to the "when" of it. In the cafe, when CAM demonstrates he has no portable google glasses vault, but instead has everything committed to memory, Sherlock realizes that the only way to destroy the files is to destroy the memory which holds them. That is why Sherlock stares so long at the glasses, slumping in his chair. That is when he recognizes exactly what he will have to do. Basically Sherlock's whole plan is finalized as he sits there - right down to the specific day he will execute it: Christmas - ie months later.
  5. Actually I've provided the evidence twice now. For the third time, the proof is the fact Sherlock asked to see the vault upon learning of CAM's mental abilities. If , as you claim, Sherlock's purpose is simply to get the files from CAM to free Mary, then there is no need to actually see the vault at all. It is only if Sherlock suspects there is no vault that seeing it becomes important to him. Notice that his brother is the price Sherlock offers to CAM to see the vault. Mary isn't even MENTIONED. Seeing the vault is what Sherlock is "negotiating". This is not true. Killing CAM was not Sherlock's purpose in going to CAM's residence. Getting proof that the vault didn't exist was the purpose in going there. He simply used the opportunity it created to wrap everything up. And Sherlock had to bring John along for his ruse to work - just as he had to get Mycroft there as well. For it is only in the presence of Mycroft's security service that Sherlock could be certain any of CAM's bodyguards would not interfere - ie kill John. Sherlock is a lot smarter than you give him credit.
  6. Actually Mary's motivations are explicitly stated. More importantly, none of the actions taken contradict her claims. This is not true of the notion of a "plot" between Mycroft and Sherlock. Not only is there absolutely no explicit statements for such a plot, but in fact there are statements - and more importantly, actions - which contradict such a belief.
  7. BTW - this is false. Mycroft did not say "What have you done now?". His reaction to the shot is: "Oh Sherlock. What have you done?" The word "now" is never uttered.
  8. Ummm...there was no "plot" between Mycroft and Sherlock. Mycroft was not in on anything - which is why Sherlock drugged him along with the rest. There was the fact that the laptop had GPS in it for normal security purposes - which Mycroft would naturally track when he discovered it missing. In fact Sherlock was using Mycroft himself to be a witness that John was not involved in the killing of CAM. That is why he took Mycroft's actual case, rather than simply using a dummy version (as he did to Irene in SCANDAL). Sherlock wanted Mycroft to be there.
  9. She didn't. Shooting Sherlock bought her time she simply didn't have in the office. Even that statement could be walked back by Sherlock if necessary. That is far different than John catching her in the act. At that point, CAM's damage is done to him. Not true. Sherlock asking to see CAM's vault rather than being given Mary's files is the reason. It is his love of John, not her, that leads him to kill (not murder) CAM. No. That was the bait he used to get to see the vault - ie to confirm no vault actually existed and thus no freedom could be obtained for Mary or John by a simple handing over of files. Sherlock's purpose is to obtain their freedom from subjugation by CAM. The moment he suspects there are no physical files to hand over - and thus no way to obtain their freedom from enslavement to CAM, is the moment he realizes he may likely have to kill CAM to gain their freedom. That moment is far, far before CAM is flicking John's face.
  10. It bought her the time she simply did not have in CAM's office. And doing more than 'winging' Sherlock was required by the situation. But Sherlock IS threatening someone else: John. Mary believes the truth will break John. So indeed she must keep CAM and now Sherlock silent - to prevent them from destroying John. And she must do it right then and right there. So the threat is immediate and it is to John. As to the notion that Mary simply wants to "silence" Sherlock then, as Sherlock himself points out, the kill shots would have done the job without question. But, also as Sherlock points out, Mary let "sentiment" get in the way - ie she values John (and Sherlock). And so, in that split second, she did the only thing she could to save John. Thus not only is Mary's action defensible - Sherlock himself indeed defends it. No. Once Sherlock learned of CAM's mental powers in the cafe, Sherlock recognized the 'final solution' likely would have to be the killing of CAM. That's why he demanded to see the vault - as opposed to simply demanding CAM's files on Mary. Sherlock needed to confirm his suspicion - as well as give him the time and opportunity to plan on killing CAM. In this case, the "deal with the devil" was literal - it was not a deal with CAM. It was a deal Sherlock made with the devil himself - trading his own life for John's life. And it was a deal he made far before "this point".
  11. Of course, because Sherlock and John were on the scene she couldn't. Nor could Mary simply "wing" Sherlock. She needed him to be unable to speak. Simply hitting him in the shoulder would have been as useless as not shooting at all. And she had to shoot. Otherwise Sherlock still would have been able to speak and as such would have been the weapon by which CAM broke John. She had to shoot him. So the only question open is does she take the "kill shot" or take a shot which incapacitates him. She did not take the kill shot. Thus she indeed left him alive to fight for his survival - which he did. As to the second instance, she explicitly stated she would do anything to protect John. This is what is admired about Sherlock - and is proof of his love. Interesting that is what is not admired about Mary - and is rejected as proof of her love. She is as cool under pressure as Sherlock. She knew she had no time to discuss anything with Sherlock - to "beg" him. John could come around the corner any second. She had to act. You seem to be of the mind that Mary intended to kill Sherlock here. So then why did she not take the head shot? She was certainly capable. No. She acted in the only way she could in a horrendous situation which required immediate action. Sherlock stood there with deliberate intent. He was simply waiting for Mycroft to arrive so there were witnesses to the fact that Sherlock was acting completely alone and that John was not complicit in the killing of CAM. He had made the decision far earlier. In fact, the need to kill CAM occurred to Sherlock when he discovered CAM's mental powers - in the cafe months earlier. Unlike Mary's dilemma, Sherlock's was not one which was unexpected - and so, unlike Mary, Sherlock's choice and action was not made on the spot in a split second (ie without time for planning and reflection, as Mary's choice had to be made).
  12. Now for something completely different. AGRA Does anyone know if these initials correspond to any person in the Sherlock canon?
  13. I'm glad you appear to believe both Mary and Sherlock's attempts to kill CAM were just/right. Of course because Sherlock and John arrived, Mary couldn't kill CAM. That would have led to the damage to John she was trying to prevent BY killing him. And it's also why she had to incapacitate (as opposed to just wound) Sherlock. If Sherlock had been able to talk, he would have been the instrument by which CAM would have supposedly broken John. Understanding and sharing that motivation (valuing John's life so highly) - is why Sherlock forgave her that action against him. He certainly would not have forgiven just anyone who shot him. They would have to have a damn good reason for doing so. And Mary certainly had one.
  14. Also interesting is the idea that Mary is being uniquely "selfish" when she declares CAM's actions would break John - meaning she would lose him. Indeed, when you threaten to destroy a man like that, you would indeed lose him - just as you would lose him if you put a bullet in his brain. It is to prevent losing John that both Mary and Sherlock act. Both are acting "selfishly" because neither wants to lose John. Both value John's life and do not want to see it lost.
  15. It's been claimed that Mary should be condemned as a murderer (or attempted murderer) because she went to kill CAM. The (HIGHLY debatable) claim has been made that she did not fear for her life and so her action was unjust and unjustified. It was plain morally wrong. Strangely, however, the same condemnation - of Sherlock and his actual (rather than simply attempted) 'murder' of CAM - has been nearly completely absent. In fact, many have cheered at Sherlock killing CAM. Yet Sherlock acted no differently than Mary was about to act. Interestingly, some have excused/applauded Sherlock because he is a socipath/psychopath/fill-in-clinical-term-here. And the complaint against Mary has been made there simply shouldn't be more of that type in the series (certainly not loved by John). What I haven't really seen is a view that Sherlock's action was an act of justice - ie was morally "right". The show goes out of its way to demonstrate that CAM engages in what he explicitly describes as "ownership" of people. There is a term for such "ownership": subjugation - or more plainly, slavery. One can easily make the argument that force used in defense against it is an act of justice, not a violation of justice. In fact one can point out that is the very reason blackmail is against the law. IT is the initiation of force against individuals. And it is recognized that the government properly acts to defend against this initiation of force. As such, both Mary and Sherlock were simply defending themselves against CAM's attempt to subjugate them. I suspect many reacted quite negatively to the visceral depiction of CAM's injustice (ie the display of his ownership of John and Sherlock) - and cheered at Sherlock's subsequent killing (not murder) of CAM because, at some level, they 'get' the justice of Sherlock's action.
  16. In fact, that is the reason Sherlock took so long to kill CAM. Sherlock wanted there to be witnesses to the fact that he, and he alone, killed CAM. That's why he let CAM display his supposed ownership of John. Sherlock was delaying so as to get Mycroft etc as witnesses to John's innocence.
  17. No. Mary is not a murderer. She, like John, is a killer. As was made explicit in the "flicking" scene, CAM had threatened to have men kill her. As such, her action was self-defense, not murder.
  18. Dalwhat, you're proceeding from a false premise. I never compared the show to the "original". I compared this episode to previous episodes. And that is certainly a valid thing to do.
  19. John is a military man. He too has killed people in the past. So both he and she are killers.
  20. What's not understandable about Sherlock's response here? It is exactly the same response as both FALL and HEARSE. He sacrifices himself (FALL) - then uses humor to deflect/express his true feelings(HEARSE). If one wants to complain about the writing, one should really be complaining about the cliched stories. We only have 9 now and already we are repeating them.
  21. HEARSE was a change from everything before and after. If you are going to demand the writers do something different, it should be in the one episode which the characterization contradicts all other characterization.
  22. Well, it's a good thing the writers haven't done that then. But if you are going to claim this to be the case, then you have to claim it right from HEARSE (which you haven't been doing - quite the opposite in fact). In the end, John loves Sherlock more than anyone else in the world - and Sherlock loves John more than anyone else in the world. If you are going to claim otherwise, you have to provide the evidence. So far, you have not. The only real difference between FALL and VOW is that - after Sherlock's sacrifice - John still has Mary in the end (whereas in FALL he had no one). That is not the same as saying he chose Mary over Sherlock - or that he loves her more than he loves Sherlock.
  23. Yet you excused their lack of appropriate responses like this in HEARSE. You said they simply weren't emotionally developed enough to do so. It was claimed that Sherlock had to manufacture a deathly threat because it was agreed John 'didn't do this stuff' well. Now you demand they do it well? The thread running between both complaints here is that everyone wants the characters in a particular place - regardless of how they get there. That isn't good writing or characterization.
  24. Again I am struck by the claims that she shouldn't lie, but it's perfectly fine for Sherlock to lie. If you are going to say that a relationship must be based on truth rather than lies - and that John must not enter into relationships with people who grievously lie to him, then you must condemn his relationship with Sherlock (from HEARSE onward) as much as with Mary. But the point I'm saying you missed is not whether Mary lied or not - or whether she should have lied or not. The question was her supposed motivation - and even others admit that it was for love of John that she threatened Sherlock. Not cowardice.
  25. No. As Sherlock states, she did not try to kill him the first time. And the second time, she merely made the threat - hoping that both their love of John would serve to prevent such an act. But she had seen him recover from the loss of Sherlock. So she knew it could be done again. It wouldn't involve a lie by Sherlock. And he had already gotten on with his life. What she believed is that a second lie revealed would break him. And so she kept trying to keep the lies at bay so as to save him.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.