Jump to content

BLS_Pro

Detectives
  • Posts

    361
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    1

Everything posted by BLS_Pro

  1. No. Just as accepting an idea is true (or possibly true) absent evidence is irrational, so too is accepting an idea is false (or possibly false) absent evidence. You show me the evidence which contradicts my premise (about the integration present throughout the episode [and since Bride]). You show me evidence that thematic integration simply does not exist - that it is only a phantom of the imagination - then I'll certainly consider that evidence. But you just tell me to think I may be wrong for NO reason whatsoever? Not happening. The capacity for error is not evidence of error. Sorry. As to the statement about plot holes and mis-characterization, I've already said they exist and that I don't like them. But, even there, the thematic integration explains them.
  2. It is like in TLD. In both, he must get John past being angry. He has to expend his rage. It must be released rather than repressed. Once he has released it, he can move past it - as we see happens in both. That is John's nature.
  3. Another BTW - Mycroft's 'nightmare' is a mirror of the situation Eurus finds herself in: a nightmare world which makes no sense. And, like Eurus, Mycroft calls to Sherlock: "Sherlock, help me" ie save me from this madness. And, like Eurus, Mycroft is mad at Sherlock because he is the one who ultimately put him through that nightmare. The only difference between Eurus and Mycroft - the amount of time they lived the nightmare.
  4. It think it is those viewers who don't want to invest time in thinking about the show afterward whom Moffat et al are telling to go read Children's books.
  5. BTW - I love the "Once More Unto The Breach" speech Sherlock gives. Whenever he says "The Game is On" I imagine that is how he is feeling when he declares it, even if he doesn't show it.
  6. When a story has an antagonist who can "reprogram" people's minds in five minutes just by talking to them, this is the least of my questions and concerns. ;)
  7. Not a contradiction. He has brotherly love for both of his siblings. That is why he doesn't allow them to simply be executed. He does "the best he can" given his purposeful distance from "sentiment". It is his lack of understanding - his lack of general empathy - which is his problem. In other words, its not that he doesn't have relationships with others. It's that one would not call them "warm" relationships. Warmth is NOT the first thing that springs to mind when talking about Mycroft.
  8. I don't believe he meant it at all. He was acting. And he lets this facade down only at the end when replying to Mary's question: "You don't know anything about human nature do you?l" "Mmmm, nature? No." he replies flippantly. "Human? he says more slowly, pausing to give Mary a serious look. "No" he states in a deeper, self-confidant tone. And then he smiles. This is Sherlock essentially winking at Mary. And Mary smiles back at him. She gets it. This was NOT blindness but knowing action. Recognizing that his WHY she immediately says she will help Sherlock. "I'll talk him round."
  9. I reference her as Love contextually - not her pre-S4 characterization. She was not identified as Love until 4.1. It is her actions in that episode to which I refer - specifically she saves Sherlock, but more importantly to the story/theme Love was saving the hostages. (And could even save Mycroft perhaps, as someone to Love) But it is the twisted Love which destroys people's lives. It is murderous jealousy which wreaks havoc. (As Eurus' murderous jealousy does) So what we get here is tragedy. More importantly, though, what we get here is the alternate ending of 4.3 if Sherlock was simply the repressed deducing machine - absent the willingness to love. He doesn't feel empathy for Norbury. He simply dissects her. It is his lack of empathy which leads to more deathly consequences. He learns that lesson HARD. But the learning of that lesson saves EVERYONE in the end (4.3)
  10. And of course 4.1 features a character code-named LOVE. What does Love do? She saves people. ;) Further, what happens when it is NOT Love? When something is used in Love's stead? People are not saved. There is but suffering, destruction, and death.
  11. Another BTW - more ways in which Mary and Eurus' stories mirror each other: (and T6T mirrors TFP) Mary's colleague was 'abandoned' by Mary - and because of that he was left to be tortured relentlessly for SIX years for absolutely NO reason. He was trapped and alone. It was insane, senseless, endless. So he is mad as hell at Mary for leaving him alone in that hell - just as Eurus is mad as hell at Sherlock for leaving her alone in her hell. And in both cases, neither Mary nor Sherlock knew those they had abandoned all those years ago were even alive. Didn't know of their existence. They were nothing anymore. "We were family" "Families fall out" And now something in Mary's past has come back to haunt her, as she says. A "very tangible ghost" Sherlock comments. Sherlock says his loved ones will not die "Not on my watch" While on the run - ie alone - Mary's "anxiety" while flying. "I think I'm dying. I don't feel so good." It's all random action when she is alone. No rhyme or reason it it. It's all a "roll of the dice", nothing more when she is separated from others. Mary ultimately doesn't hate the man who is trying to kill her - who has killed others. She doesn't want to kill him and is pained when he gets hurt. Sherlock doesn't hate Eurus - who has killed others. He doesn't want to kill her and is pained when he discovers her hurt. Mary and Sherlock both understand that the two are literally tortured souls. They don't forgive them for their wrongs. But they do empathize with their pitiful plights - and want to set things right. The antagonist in both stories acts out of "jealousy" - and who have a "void" in their life because they are alone. The person who loses a love (John losing Mary; Sherlock losing Victor) raises walls against others because of it. Mary tells Sherlock she must go to hell to save John. That is exactly what he also has to do to save Eurus. And he has to save them both from the same fate: being alone. Being without love.
  12. Another BTW - to show how Eurus and Sherlock are kindred souls, as apart from Mycroft: Mycroft is not "given to outbursts of brotherly compassion". In both cases, when dealing with unwieldy siblings, he doesn't save them. Mycroft sends Eurus to hell and Sherlock to his death. That is why it was Eurus who had to save Sherlock with the "Miss Me?" ploy (as opposed to Mycroft). Mycroft's lack of sentimentality when it comes to human relations constrains his thinking - limits his choices. Eurus recognized this about Mycroft even as a child (as apparently did their parents). Eurus is much like Mary. She threatens Sherlock's life, but her intention is not to kill him. "Mixed messages" indeed. ;)
  13. Another BTW - as I previously noted, the choice of "Break Free" is perfect choice for Moriarty's 'theme' music. And it is telling that he stops the song where he does: "I want to breaaaak freeeee. ... I've fallen in-" He stops it there because the next word is "love". And love is NOT his solution to The Final Problem".
  14. I don't think Sherlock was ignorant at all of John's feelings in TEH. I think he was completely calculating - as much as he was in TLD. I think TEH and TLD are echoes of each other in this regard. In both, Sherlock knows John is hurting (supposedly at Sherlock's hand). In both Sherlock has to get John past the wall he erects which is his anger and rage, and to the point of acceptance - so that they may renew and reaffirm their friendship. Thus, in both Sherlock provokes John in order to get him to release that rage (physically - so as to break down that wall) in order that John may then get past it. Put simply, where Sherlock builds walls of repression to protect himself, John builds walls of anger to protect himself.
  15. I think one of the excuses Moffat et al would use to "explain" S4 and all its problems - especially the fact that Final doesn't see him doing much 'detecting' - is something he's said in the past: Sherlock is"not a detective show; it's a show about a detective."
  16. I don't think the ratings would ultimately be a hindrance. I think the comparative dip in ratings wouldn't be enough to prevent a return (but it might be enough, given the criticisms the BBC execs would have seen as widespread, to have those execs exercise a bit more control over the content). I believe the real question is whether the creators and the stars have a desire to come back. From the way I understand the story, it seems like the writers did reach the climax of what they were ultimately trying to achieve. They even explicitly say it is at least the end of a "chapter" in the life and writing of Sherlock Holmes. Whether they want to pursue another chapter and have to come up with as compelling a theme for it, remains to be seen. And I think that whatever they come up with as the new theme would be what ultimately draws the actors back - or has them shrug their shoulders and walk away to other projects.
  17. Yes, especially some of the poor reviews online seem quite unfair, when you consider the quality of this episode compared to a lot of other shows on TV. The fact they have so many relationships, interactions and concepts that we all can see in so many different ways, must mean they are doing something right. And, this one in particular, had so many small but huge moments for the characters, that a little outlandishness from the plot can be forgiven I'll say that I can understand the poor reviews. Before I grasped what they were trying to do, this episode seemed like a real departure from and contradiction to, everything which had come before - including the point of Sherlock not even solving anything about the case really. It seemed a mess and a betrayal of "the quality" of this show, making it seem worse than many of the 'ordinary' shows on TV. Indeed, even after understanding WHY they did everything they did, much of my plot and character complaints remain. What they were able to achieve was great. But they did it at the cost of many of the things which made people love the show in the first place. I don't think it's "unfair" for people to complain about that fact. If they had been able to integrate the plot, character, AND theme as they did in TLD, people would be (deservedly) raving.
  18. Another BTW - John viciously attacking Sherlock (in the morgue) is a mirror to Eurus' viciously attacking Sherlock (since childhood). Both are instances of a person who loves Sherlock 'hating' him for the same reason: supposedly taking away that which they love (in John's case: Mary; in Eurus' case: Sherlock). And both of them thus need their souls to be 'saved' from this loss by Sherlock.
  19. Another BTW - I like the echo in the S4 episodes - of "someone" "anyone" and "no one". Cute.
  20. Questions of psychology and motivation are complex - especially since humans can and do knowingly and/or unknowningly accept contradictions. It isn't in areas where the writers are purposefully being ambiguous or requiring you to do some deep thinking that I was saying is likely insanity inducing for them (which is why I didn't attack jadpdr's other examples). It is things which should require no explanation and certainly no miracles to explain - so long as even a LITTLE bit of thought is given to them. Examples like this one are why the writers suggest people 'go read a children's book'. While there may be MANY, MANY things which are a challenge the writers set for their audience to work understand, the above is not something adults should need explained to them.
  21. It's statement's like this which must be what drive the writers insane: 'You showed me the rope being lowered into the well. But you didn't show me someone climbing down the rope! You didn't show me someone unlocking John with the keys to the chains which Eurus gave Sherlock! You didn't show me them then climbing back out of the well!! Without showing me that, I MUST conclude that John "miraculously" just climbed up on his own with no problem - that the chains somehow MAGICALLY were no longer binding him - despite the irrationality of such a blatant contradiction. It can't be my conclusion! It can't be you think I'm smart enough to figure this basic stuff out on my own! I'm NOT! I have to be show EVERYTHING. So if you don't show it to me, then it MUST be a PLOT HOLE! Stupid writers!!!!' Double Sigh.
  22. Never said that. I said SOME might be accidental, and we can't be 100% which of them. That's all. Good. So you CAN know the theme as I've stated it, because of the overwhelming number of the examples in accord with that theme (how it serves to explain the words and actions seen on screen throughout the episode), even if you aren't sure as to perhaps one particular or another. You CAN know that such integration is NOT a coincidence - is not an accident. You are NOT dismissing the theme as UNknowable UNLESS you ask the writers. Good to know.
  23. Another BTW - Molly, in this episode, is the mirror of Eurus. Both are a "unmarried woman, distant from her close relatives...acquainted with the process of death, but unsentimental about the necessity of disposal" "unmarried; practical about death; alone." "I Love You" is "true" about how both Molly and Eurus feel about Sherlock. Both love Sherlock but are not loved by him.
  24. If it was JUST the Hungry Donkey example, you would have to ask. It isn't. That's the point. I am not claiming that every single detail on screen is unified to the theme. I haven't claimed that a pillow on one side of the couch instead of another is thematic, etc. I have identified all the overwhelming number of things which are unified with the theme - all the facts which support the conclusion and which explain every plot and character action. You are free to claim that some examples might be coincidental. But to suggest (and dismiss) them ALL as just an accident is, as I stated, BIZARRE. Ironically, it is the view that one can never be certain of anything - that because there is the capacity for error, there can never be certainty about anything - which is the philosophic foundation of existentialism and its dread. And, like Moffat, your solution to that problem is to look to Others. No matter what evidence, no matter how much of it exists, you "can not KNOW" anything unless you are informed BY others. You can't deduce. You have to be told - which is exactly what happened to Sherlock in this episode. They're simply illustrating YOUR philosophy. ;) (It's interesting to note that this is the exact opposite of the philosophy of the film "The Man Without a Face" - a film whose theme I believe Doyle's Holmes would agree)
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.