Jump to content

BLS_Pro

Detectives
  • Posts

    361
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    1

Everything posted by BLS_Pro

  1. I understood what you meant. I was just using a different interval of time (between episodes rather than between seasons) to demonstrate the ultimate issue wasn't time. This is true of the complaint above as well. Because they had at least two years time between seasons, I expected 4.3 to be good and every moment will count. And I expected it, not just because they had time, but because they had succeeded in doing that in 4.2, the episode they had scripted at the same time. And I expected it because they had succeeded in doing it in Bride, a stand alone episode. And they had succeeded in doing it in other episodes in other seasons. The issue isn't the time. The successful episodes demonstrate that fact. The issue is whether they bother to write well or not, regardless of the time. They can always make changes and incorporate them as story points. The sort of changes you reference aren't an issue. I agree. And I can pinpoint it to the writing (and the directing of T6T). That COULD have been a strong episode, but they didn't actually create much DRAMA through most of it. That's the same problem with Final. There are a couple moments in both - but the episodes don't earn them through the action, plotting, and character development through them. Both episodes rely on BAD storytelling techniques which have been SHUNNED by the previous episodes. There is SO much, one could actually write a book on the bad writing used in the two episodes. Having a good one in-between doesn't change this fact. :( Yes.
  2. Yes, it is an ENORMOUS improvement for her. She isn't jealous any more. She isn't angry any more. She isn't confused any more. She isn't alone any more. She now has what she always wanted: Eurus is LITERALLY playing with her brother Sherlock.
  3. BTW - have they posted the Behind the Scenes video yet? By now someone here has usually provided a link to it. Also, will they be posting the Mary 'extras' being mentioned? Or will that have to be acquired on DVD?
  4. The analogy isn't a good one. Most of us don't watch the slaughtering of animals either. Unlike Mycroft, we are completely separated from the entire process - which is why it would be difficult for us to shoot a pig (though I suspect most of us could do it, and - more importantly - without moral qualm). But, given his job, there is NO way Mycroft has escaped seeing all sorts of grotesque killings (via surveillance, both up close) as well as the bloody results afterwards in reports. He has never been squeamish in his job - he wouldn't have gotten as far as he did if he had. He is knee deep and up to his arms in the process. So Mycroft is not like "all of us".
  5. I agree that he has likely NEVER been the 'bag' man, as it were - he's never been the one to literally pull the trigger. But it isn't that he's shown as being a coward - that he doesn't have the courage of his convictions. He explicitly states he doesn't want to be MORALLY responsible for this person's death: "I can't. This is murder" and more specifically "I will not kill. I will not have blood on my hands". This isn't about having the "stomach" to kill, but not having the morality to kill. Yet we KNOW he does have the morality to kill - and to kill innocents. He DOES have blood on his hands - and he KNOWS it. If this is all about him just being a COWARD about his morals, then that is an even WORSE destruction of his characterization than I was positing.
  6. I think you've got something there. We had too much time to imagine what the "perfect" season would be like, and of course we didn't get it. I have to disagree. For instance, the wait time between 4.2 and 4.3 was a week, not two years. And I surmised much of Final's story points. And I didn't even try to imagine what the "perfect" episode would be like. I just knew that examples LIKE 4.2 - and Bride - meant it COULD be good, even (especially) KNOWING the story points. The disappointment in 4.3 came, not as a result of any time between episodes, but as a result of its BAD writing. If I had been able to binge watch 4.2 and 4.3 or had to wait months or years between them, I would still be disappointed in the exact same way and for the exact same reasons.
  7. So - what IS "The Final Problem" in the episode?
  8. Yup. I loved and admired this show for its SMART writing. But as it progressed, it turned more and more into BAD writing, with exceptional exceptions. I blame Gatiss for this trend (his were always the weakest episodes and Moffat's the strongest, when it comes to good storytelling techniques). And the writing ended on their biggest flop - where they just kept TELLING rather than SHOWING. Exposition rather than drama (and artificial tension clock-ticking, rather than plot and character driven drama and conflict). The main character being led by the antagonist, rather than being driven by his own actions. Where Watson removed Mary's agency at the end of 4.1 (and gave it back to her in 4.2), the writers removed Sherlock's agency, and gave it to Eurus (with a large helping from Mycroft). Bad plotting, bad story points (no consequence from being exploded out a window, unable to see missing glass or hear the sounds of the room which had NO wall!!!, etc etc ad nauseum). It isn't WHAT they tried to say which was the problem. It was the REALLY horrible way they went about saying it.
  9. I would agree that your POV is quite unusual - as I would agree that your POV was not the makers POV or their intent. The latter was my only point - not that someone couldn't somehow come to a different conclusion.
  10. Agreed. There was SOOOO much potential in this episode. The problem wasn't the material. The problem was the story TELLING. It was just HORRIBLE. I'll repeat what I posted in another comment, since I edited/added this part after the fact and many may not have seen it. I think all the 'explaining' rather than painful discovery and the BREAKING of those walls BY Sherlock as HE does something to recover his memories and thus feel the pain he repressed is the WORST writing we have gotten through ALL the seasons of Sherlock. This should have been an episode of IMMENSE catharsis through SHERLOCK'S own actions. It WASN'T. He was LED around by the NOSE. He didn't do ANYTHING. Everything was done for/to him or was just casually 'oh I remember now'. The IMMENSE dramatic potential was PISSED away - like Mag pissing in their fireplace)!!! If they had shown Sherlock WORKING to break down his memory walls (maybe literally destroying some in his mind palace?) - ie doing what Sherlock does: SOLVING things - rather than him being spoon fed EVERYTHING like a child - as Mag did in 3.1 - this could have been a GREAT episode. And then we would have had a wonderful two-parter between Bride and Final. As it stands, Final made Bride a MUCH better episode than it had been (since one can now see - Sixth-Sense like - that it's really about his subconscious pointing him to his 'missing' sister). But Final is a REALLY bad episode as far as actual storytelling goes.
  11. But isn't the idea that love is what 'saved' Sherlock (and John)? Isn't John's love of Sherlock, and Sherlock's love of John, the beating heart of the "Sherlockverse" these writers have created and pushed from the start?
  12. "Huge sacrifice"? What is Sherlock giving up? And why is what Sherlock giving up supposedly a greater value to him than the 'lesser' value of loving his sister and trying to help her? (If it were the other way around, where he is gaining a greater value for that which he trades - ie he would be profiting).
  13. Eurus had access to an endless amount of information about Sherlock because Moriarty had an enormous amount of information about Sherlock FROM Mycroft. And she was John's therapist. And she certainly had the time and resources to investigate all his emotional connections. Mycroft was just the tip of the informational iceburg to which she had access. Hell, she probably had access to ALL of the government files (including Mycrofts) on Sherlock et al because she had access to the computers (and thus the outside world) at Sherrinford.
  14. Agree completely. He served NO point here - neither to his OWN story, nor to Final. They could have left him out entirely and it would have changed nothing before the story nor anything IN the story.
  15. Exactly on both counts. Jealousy is the term used in Sussex vampire (from which the Sherlock/Eurus relation is drawn) and it is used in Bride (which is all about Eurus). And the little girl was jealous of Sherlock for having a best friend. She wanted one too - and wanted Sherlock to be that friend. Whether SHE would recognize it as jealousy doesn't change the nature of the desire or the nature of her actions. In other words, whether or not a person can accurately identify their own motivations doesn't mean they don't have them or that they are something else. I don't think boredom is her motivation. And, as someone else pointed out, she does have a conscience - at least the little girl form of her does, just as she has a wide range of emotions as the little girl. That is the problem. HOW those two disparate 'personalities' are related. She wants to play - she wants companionship. She wants love from someone. That is how John 'saved' Sherlock. And that is how Eurus needs to be 'saved'. She needs Sherlock to 'come to her room'. She has the longing, the desire - not to mention the anger when those desires are not fulfilled. This is the thread tying both 'personalities' together. But HOW the disparate personalities manifest from this desire and how they are supposed to work together to the one, PLANNED, goal by Eurus to have the little girl 'saved', is what needs to be explained. HOW the Games were supposed to lead from one to the other to the room needs to be explained - or at least how she expected them to reach that end - needs to be explained. In short, EURUS needs to be explained - explained FAR more and FAR better than she was.
  16. Oh I definitely think it is a problem. Given previous characterization in relation to Molly, it can't be that he doesn't process the info or hasn't got a grasp on her loving him - for the reasons I already identified. Yet that is indeed the way they first begin the scene. I think they destroyed the characterization of Mycroft in this episode. He was just contradictory all over the place. Doesn't want innocent blood on his hands in one scene and casually wants to kill innocent girl on the plane in the next. John making all the clever deductions rather than Mycroft in the Gov's office. They made someone we KNOW is demonstrably smart into "the village idiot".
  17. Yup. This was another of the COUNTLESS, MASSIVE plot holes carelessly strewn throughout this episode. All in the service of tricking the AUDIENCE -alone- at the cost of the plot and characterization and believability.
  18. I missed that detail. That's cute.
  19. Presumably for the same reason she played his therapist: to get information on him (and his relation to Sherlock). Ultimately, it is Eurus trying to learn why Sherlock would play with HIM but not her. I do believe that was essentially her motivation - the "murderous jealousy". She was alone and sought love from Sherlock. But she never got it. And that's supposed to explain "why" she became what she became - the lack of love from someone she apparently loved. I think you're headed in the right direction - but I think there's more to it than you identify. I think the writers definitely view Eurus as an alternative version of Sherlock. What is the difference between them though? Love. Sherlock had a best friend then - and has a best friend now. It is the lack of such a love which is the difference. Watson "saved" Sherlock BY being his best friend. Eurus wasn't saved BECAUSE she had no such friend - certainly not the one she wanted: Sherlock. And I think the point is that Eurus is not lost beyond retrieval. Sherlock is NOW returning that love. He did and has saved her (rather than abandoning her, as Mycroft was again ready to do given her complete shutting down at the end). The child version of herself WAS looking for it. She wanted help. She was desperate for a connection. She KNEW it was possible because she'd seen - twice now - that Sherlock had it.
  20. I don't think she influenced Moriarty into killing himself. I think Eurus saw the likely outcome. Moriarty may or may not have agreed with her conclusion. But to get the information he wanted on Sherlock, we know Jim was willing to go through a lot (he accepted his incarceration/torture with Mycroft to get information about Sherlock from him). So Jim was willing to humor Eurus (give her the videos she wanted - and, if she turned out to be right, to enjoy the idea of getting revenge on Sherlock by having his sister force him to kill his brother) to get more info about Sherlock. It didn't cost him anything. The real question is why "Redbeard" would be something Jim would find useful. How exactly did it help him with what he did? It doesn't seem to have anything to do with what Jim did in all his dealings with Sherlock. I think her discovery of the Napoleon of Crime, whom she could influence because of their shared interest, is the thing she needed to gain control of her situation and Sherrinford. She needed his considerable powers in the outside world - combined with her own powers inside - to achieve her ends of 'escape'. More to come....
  21. "Murderous jealousy" was her issue. From the beginning, she wanted Sherlock to play with HER. He didn't. So she eliminated the competition (Redbeard). But that didn't get her the result she wanted. She was still alone. Sherlock still didn't play with her. So she became murderously angry at Sherlock for not playing with her under any conditions. Her rage turned to him for denying her - for not coming to her room. The Saw "Morality Maze" was just her trying to get Sherlock to play games with her now - the only games she is interested in and the type of games Sherlock is interested in ("The Game is on"). That was her motivation. To get her little brother to play with her - to save her from isolated and alone (metaphorically and literally). The problem is that the writers didn't do a good job of explaining HOW the different forms of her personality interacted/worked. Her foundational motivation is clear (as is the linkage between her childhood motivation and her current motivation). But SHE isn't explained. And she NEEDED to be explained.
  22. I actually think he does. He didn't at first, as we see his usual inept understanding about it at the beginning of the call. And THIS is more of the bad writing and contradiction of previous characterization. One of the wonderful scenes in Scandal is when Sherlock realizes Molly loves him - and THEN realizes how his words hurt her because of it. He MAKES the connection way back then - ie YEARS and YEARS ago - is SORRY for it, and provides an emotionally heartfelt apology for the pain he KNEW he caused. For Sherlock to supposedly NOT recognize it now is not only an inexplicable character REGRESSION for NO REASON, it DESTROYS that previous scene completely. Yes. Like the scene in Scandal, he knows what he has done to her. But here he has NO ability to stop doing it - to RECTIFY the damage, as he did in Scandal. THAT is the source of his frustration. That and his repression of "emotional context" (of which Eurus is just the most extreme example). It is the breaking of the walls of repression which are why he feels this is 'vivisection' (and why I think all the 'explaining' rather than painful discovery and the BREAKING of those walls BY Sherlock as HE does something to recover his memories and thus feel the pain he repressed is the WORST writing we have gotten through ALL the seasons of Sherlock. This should have been an episode of IMMENSE catharsis through SHERLOCK'S own actions. It WASN'T. He was LED around by the NOSE. He didn't do ANYTHING. Everything was done for/to him or was just casually 'oh I remember now'. The IMMENSE dramatic potential was PISSED away - like Mag pissing in their fireplace)!!! I have no problem with Sherlock saying "I love you" to her. And I am certain it is true - just as it is true he loves John. There are all sorts of love and all sorts of depths to it. I love you, for him in this context, doesn't have to be limited to romantic love. Everyone seems to be under the false impression that Molly is "the last person [sherlock] thinks of". Even John falsely believes this, saying it explicitly. But time and again, we see it proven false. In this case, Sherlock immediately proves is false with the ringing of a door bell.
  23. I'm a bit skeptical that the "additional footage" is anything more than a "behind the scenes" type production. Somewhere, I saw something like that, and it said Amanda was narrating. But I can't find any specific information now. Unfortunately you are correct: "Special Fathom Features: Join Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman for the Season Four Finale of Sherlock, featuring a 15-minute bonus featurette exclusive to cinemas! In “The Adventures of Mary Watson,” actress Amanda Abbington takes us behind the scenes on her time on Sherlock to discuss her incredible journey as Mary Watson and the thrills and spills of filming some of her most memorable scenes." And THAT means we won't get any connective tissue to explain Eurus and her different personalities and how they relate to one another. That is one of the BIGGEST plot holes of the episode. And that is saying something. The moon doesn't have as many swiss cheese holes as does the storytelling in this episode. :(
  24. To what? Dead Man Walking? ;) Agreed, though some (including perhaps the creators of the show) might argue that the drama of their show was ABOUT "the greatest personal difficulties of their lives" and with those over, then the show is over too.
  25. There are still connections to Mary in these stories which aren't explained. The underlying theme to them seems to be that Mary somehow knew Eurus. That's why the Thatcher statue would connect him to both Mary and Eurus (TOO coincidental otherwise) - and Mary telling Sherlock to go to Hell, and Mycroft stating Eurus is IN Hell (another ENORMOUS coincidence). Either VERY bad writing or as yet unfollowed storylines.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.