Surelock
Detectives-
Posts
381 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Surelock
-
Gatiss also wrote The Hound of Baskerville which I thought had a pretty good script. What did you guys think of it? Also have you guys heard of that theory on reddit of Redbeard not being real? It's based on what Sherlock tells Henry about the hound at the end of The Hound of Baskerville. Sherlock said that there was no hound and Henry just imagined it because when he was a child he had trouble rationalising the traumatic experience of watching his father die. Some people have speculated that Sherlock is subconsciously speaking from experience when he said that. Basically when Sherlock was a kid he saw Euros go insane and watched as she was taken away and locked up in a mental asylum or something like that. Sherlock had trouble understanding all this when he was a kid so his brain rationalised all of it as Redbeard. Basically Sherlock thought he had a dog named Redbeard instead of a sister named Euros and Redbeard being put down was actually Euros being taken away after going insane. This sounds like a plausible theory. What do you guys think of it?
- 793 replies
-
That particular part I'm actually not too fond of, since we weren't told how he could make such a deduction, and it just seems way out of proportion - even for Sherlock. How could he possibly know that John would bring his cane and leave it with Sherlock - and at that specific time? Makes no sense. But I'm trying hard to overlook this fact, because I really, really love this episode, and I really want to keep on loving it! Even if Sherlock was smart enough to predict all of John's actions and was able to plant a bug in his cane, there's still something that's difficult to explain: how did the bug turn on at the right moment to record Culvertion? The bug needs to be turned on in order to start recording audio. However IIRC Sherlock doesn't say anything about how he turned the bug on. He simply said that he planted a bug in the cane three weeks ago. Was the bug recording audio for three weeks straight? That's implausible.
- 793 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Honestly I think Sislock just shot near John rather than at him.
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
That reminds me ... going back to this... If that "curtain rises" text really was sent only to Mary, and the other one only to John ... Who else do we know who might possibly have the initials SH? ;) SH = Sherrinford Holmes? People are already speculating that the Sherrinford that Mycroft wanted to talk to in the end was the third Holmes brother.
- 831 replies
-
Gatiss wrote his response as a poem because he was referencing Sir Arthur Conan's Doyle's own 'To an undiscerning critic' poem (published in 1912) that was a response to a critic that complained about how Doyle had written Sherlock Holmes to criticise other fictional detectives.
- 831 replies
-
- 6
-
-
I think the reason that Ajay didn't shoot Sherlock is because he realised he could use Sherlock to track Mary. Remember Ajay found Mary in Morocco by just following Sherlock. After Sherlock revealed to Ajay that Mary was his friend, Ajay decided to not kill him. Good catch. I was so focused on where they met (church lair) I didn't focus on the order of the meeting. IF that wasn't a mistake on their part, it raises questions like: Why not meet together w John? Why not meet all together at 221b? Again, what is that lair place? Why did Sherlock seem so surprised Mary would run, given they expected it to the point of planning ahead to trace her? 1. and 2. In Season 3, Mary said John wouldn't love her if he found out about her past life so I guess Sherlock realised that he was going to have trouble getting information out of Mary if John was present. 3. I think this lair may be some sort of meetup place for Sherlock's homeless network. 4. No idea; maybe he was acting? Mycroft is more than likely Antartica. Remember Moriarty's nickname for Mycroft was 'The Iceman'.
- 831 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Good Point! It's interesting to note, I don't think we ever saw his Mind Palace in this episode. Which makes 'The Six Thatchers' the first episode to not feature Sherlock's Mind Palace if we start counting from 'The Sign of Three'. It's ironic that the episode without the Mind Palace has the most story inconsistencies. I'm also wondering if anything in this episode can clue us to what Moffatiss are planning to do with the final episode of this season, 'The Final Problem'. The original case dealt with the alleged death of Holmes in his struggle to bring down Moriarty. However that was already covered in the Season 2 finale, 'The Reichenbach Fall'. I doubt Moffatiss are going to go with another Sherlock dying story. ATM my theory is that 'The Final Problem' is the final problem (or case) that Sherlock and John solve together for at least the foreseeable future. My evidence is: 1. Mofatiss and the rest of the cast have said that this season may be the final season due to their busy schedule. Yes I know that a few years ago, Moffatiss and Cumberbatch said that they planned to do a fifth season as well but plans can change. 2. Moffatiss have also said that they plan to make this season darker. This episode has already given us a few clues on where they're going with a rift in Sherlock and John's friendship due to Mary's death. I think it's important to note what Moffat said about this matter in his interview with Entertainment Weekly: http://ew.com/tv/2017/01/01/sherlock-season-4-premiere/ ATM I'm interpreting all this to mean that Sherlock and John's rift will never truly heal. I think John is still going to be angry with Sherlock in the later episodes and by the final episode he'll decide to just do one more case with Sherlock. That case will be the titular 'Final Problem'. I think that's a dark way of tackling the concept of grief because sometimes grief doesn't heal. Sometimes instead of trying to get rid of your grief, you have to accept you can't get rid of your grief. You have to then adjust your life so you can live with your grief instead. At the end of 'The Final Problem', I speculate that John will leave Sherlock to raise Rosie on his own. I know John likes adventure but I think he'll realise his duties as a parent require him to sacrifice his lifestyle. As for Sherlock, I think he'll retire. I think he'll never truly get over the grief of losing Mary. I think Moffatiss may just write Sherlock to be a beekeeper in retirement at the end of the episode similarly to the books. I think this would be a fair way for Moffatiss to conclude Season 4. It doesn't rule out the possibility of Sherlock and John coming back together for another adventure some time in the future. However it still adds somewhat of a conclusion to the story. ATM I think Moffatiss aren't sure if they'll be able to do a fifth season, so they may plan on making the ending of Season 4, at least semi-conclusive.
- 831 replies
-
I suspect Mary will reappear in Sherlock's mind palace.
- 831 replies
-
If Nor had the gun trained on Mary the entire time he was talking and his talking caused her to change aim, I might agree. But Sherlock didn't need to diffuse the situation for Mary or need to cause Nor to shift focus from Mary to himself. Almost immediately, Nor let her gun droop, taking it OFF both of them. And she did this BEFORE he had spoken a word. IF he was worried about the weapon and Mary's safety, he could have done SO many OTHER things to turn down the already lessening tension. In fact, he could have simply let Nor WALK OUT - and let the police catch this obviously NOT 'master criminal' later (right IN the Aquarium, given they were there already and he knew it). IF this was an attempt to protect Mary, it was a STUPID act, not a smart one. And that just makes Sherlock an idiot (as opposed to self-absorbed and cocky, which is STILL bad writing in this context, but certainly fits what they keep saying is supposedly Sherlock's character. And fits what Sherlock says about Nor to Mrs H. IF his intent had been to deflect to him, and he misjudged MARY not NOR, then the comment would be 'Just say Mary'. In other words, the reference is to WHO surprised him - ie who did he get wrong? He is saying to Mrs H that he was surprised by Nor, NOT Mary.) Also traditionally Sherlock has kept his mouth shut when his opponents had a gun. In Season 1, when Moriarty had his snipers point their guns at him and John, Sherlock kept his mouth shut. In Season 2, when those US agents had their guns pointed at him, Irene and John, Sherlock kept his mouth shut. Sherlock has never tried to be arrogant when his opponent had a gun. However he decides to do so in Season 4 and that's so out of character and inconsistent of him. I think Moffat and Gatiss may have forgotten what they wrote in the earlier episodes due to the long gaps between each season.
- 831 replies
-
- 4
-
-
What the heck is ADC? I think he said 'ACD'. ACD = Arthur Conany Doyle (author of the Sherlock Holmes books)
- 831 replies
-
- 3
-
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)