Surelock
Detectives-
Posts
381 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Surelock
-
That was true with all of the other games as well but the other games also had additional hostages that Euros could execute immediately. However you bring up a good point. Why didn't Euros just tell Sherlock that if he shot himself then she would call the game off and let all the little girl and all the other hostages in the plane die?
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
So I found another example of smarter-than-Newton Euros being not so smart. In the fourth game, she panics when Sherlock points the gun on himself rather than Mycroft and John. The rules of this game were to shoot Mycroft or John yet Sherlock was able to defy the rules in this game although he wasn't able to do so earlier? Why? Well it's because the fourth game didn't have a hostage. Think about the first three games. Each of them had a hostage (Governor's wife, suspects, Molly) and Euros used that hostage to get Sherlock to follow the rules of that game. She herself said that if Sherlock tried some funny business then she would execute the hostages. However in the fourth game, Euros decided to not have any hostages and she was surprised when Sherlock decided not follow her rules. If she was just holding someone like Mrs. Hudson hostage, she could have convinced Sherlock to shoot Mycroft. In fact she could have just said to Sherlock that if he shot himself then she would kill both John and Mycroft. However she didn't do anything like that. Yet she was still surprised when Sherlock decided to point the gun at himself. I swear this episode tries to be all about the feels but in doing so it only ends up proving what Sherlock and Mycroft have been telling us in the earlier seasons about sentiment. Sentiment is a detriment to your intelligence and that's reflected in the writing of this episode. They try to make it all about the emotions and that's why the story doesn't feel cleverly written like the stories of the previous seasons were.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Another one I'm still processing. I wondered the same thing, until other people started suggesting that he was her favorite and she just wanted to play with him, not that she was out to get him. But she's so warped she doesn't know the difference? She's really acting out of love but doesn't know it? Urgh. But the idea intrigues me, and is starting to make more sense to me. More rewatching required..... My theory on that is that she always felt closer to Sherlock than Mycroft. With the age difference in between being much smaller, I guess there was a lot more immediate jealousy that he was ignoring her so obviously. From Mycroft describtions he clearly took an interest in his little sister, talking to her and trying to understand her, even though he was disturbed by her actions, whereas Sherlock basically just ignored her, since he had his own friend, a boy his own age. So I guess his sister would have been entirely not interesting to him, which since she doesn't seem to have developed emotionally in her relationship to Sherlock very much since that age, is a pretty good reason to have a much bigger grudge as well as longing for him than Mycroft. In addition Mycroft seems to have visited her quite a lot since he's been in a position of power and in an odd way cared for her by keeping her save from the world as well as her own actions. At least that's probably how he would see it. Yes, he is absoultely terrified of her but he also seems somewhat concerned about her well being. Therefore she would have got a fair bit of attention from him and although she might be angry for being locked up, it wouldn't nearly be as bad as her frustration of Sherlock ignoring her, worse forgetting her entirely for more or less her entire life. At least that's the most reasonable explanation as I can come up with. I think Euros was just more interested in Sherlock because he was the emotional one. Remember in all of her games she (as she said so herself) was trying to add emotional context. Euros likes seeing people emotional. The reason why she isn't interested in Mycroft is because Mycroft is a lot less emotional than Sherlock. He can keep a straight face and not give in to his sentiments much better than Sherlock can.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
So has anyone heard of all the theories of their being a secret 4th episode that's going to air on 22/1/17? I want it to be real but it's too good to be true.
- 1,402 replies
-
E please.
-
Well according to history, the far right tend to come into power during times of social and economic upheaval. This is usually because far right parties do a better job of projecting the big-daddy-who-protects-everyone image than any other party. As for Trump, it really looks like they're trying to get him impeached. I'm not sure if all those allegations about his ties with Russia are true but I don't think the CIA, FBI etc are necessarily looking for truth. They think he's insane and they want to impeach him.
-
I read through your idea and it seems very plausible. TBH, I don't see why it can't function alongside the backstory we were shown. Once Eurus was out of the picture, I think everything would have progressed pretty much as you outlined. I know Mycroft said that the way Sherlock turned out was all due to Eurus, but I don't take that very literally ... nothing's ever that simple. Plus it was Mycroft saying it ... Mycroft, who thinks he's always right. So of course he thinks any poor choices Sherlock made in his life were due to his trauma, and not to having an overbearing big brother .... Okay suppose Mycroft's 'The man you are today is your memory of Euros' quote isn't mean to be taken an absolute explanation for Sherlock's character. What about Mycroft's other quote? Remember in Sherlock's flat this episode, Mycroft said to Sherlock 'I never bullied you. I used trigger words to update myself on your condition. I was protecting you.' Do you believe this quote not meant to be taken literally? It appeared to me that what Mycroft was saying that all these years Sherlock was misinterpreting Mycroft's actions. Sherlock thought that Mycroft was bullying him because he wasn't as smart as his elder brother. However Mycroft's statement seems to suggest that was never Mycroft's intention. Mycroft just wanted to protect Sherlock so he put on the persona of a bully. He was actually just checking to see if Sherlock's memories resurfaced. At the same time he went on his anti-sentiment speeches so he could stop Sherlock from becoming sentimental and subsequently remembering his memories of Euros. This makes Mycroft less relateable to me. Mycroft and Sherlock are superhuman but one of the most human aspects of the two of them is their sibling rivalry. Everyone who has a sibling has competed with them in at least one point of their life. The sibling rivalry dynamic between Sherlock and Mycroft made the relationship between them feel like a relationship between two real brothers. However this episode seemed to suggest that the sibling rivalry from Mycroft's side was a farce. He never meant to hurt Sherlock. He was just protecting him from painful memories. So basically Mycroft was able to put on a false persona ever since he was 13 and tricked Sherlock into thinking that he was someone that he was not for years and years and years. That's not relateable. Who has siblings that are capable of doing that? Most people know when their siblings are acting different or hiding something even if they're not close to their sibling. I know Mycroft is superhuman so within the context of the show it may be possible for him to pull something like this off but I think if a character is too superhuman they just cease being a likeable character. There needs to be some humane element to them. Something that everyone can relate to. Sibling rivalry was a good way of doing that but this episode seemed to diminish its effect. That's the ironic thing about Euros. Euros was supposed to be about making Sherlock and Mycroft more human but, since she was linked to their history in such a contrived way, she ended up dehumanising Sherlock and Mycroft's relationship with one another. EDIT - Also I forgot to mention this earlier but in The Lying Detective, when John questions Mycroft about his other sibling, Mycroft attempts to lie but John catches him lying. If Mycroft is such a great actor then why couldn't he deceive John? I mean John isn't as smart as Sherlock but Mycroft had fooled Sherlock for years and years into believing that he was bullying him.
- 1,402 replies
-
Also I forgot to mention this last time but another reason why I find Sherlock's backstory to be so disappointing is because it's made to be complex and convoluted when a simpler and more believable backstory could have done the trick. Around Season 2/3, I developed my own head cannon for what Sherlock and Mycroft's backstory was and it relied on just studying Sherlock's interactions with Mycroft. It went something like this: 1. When Sherlock and Mycroft were kids, Mycroft was smarter than him and used to make fun of him for being slow. This makes sense. A lot of talented children act like this with their less talented siblings. 2. Mycroft and Sherlock presumably initially lived in some remote area with their parents because it took some time for them to meet other kids. Mycroft thought that Sherlock was dumb and he desired companionship with someone who was his intellectual equal. Mycroft thought he would meet this person when he would meet other children and become friends with them. 3. However when Mycroft actually met other children he found that they were a lot less intelligent then Sherlock. That's when Mycroft realised that both he and Sherlock were geniuses compared to everyone else. 4. This caused Mycroft to panic. He realised that closest person to an intellectual equal in the world to him was Sherlock. However he had teased Sherlock for years. Thus when Mycroft went to Sherlock and tried to make amends, Sherlock refused to accept his apology. 5. Mycroft and Sherlock then grew into adults and went their separate ways. Mycroft was still looking for companionship so he decided to join an intelligence agency like MI6 where the smartest people in the country worked. 6. However Sherlock developed a massive inferiority complex due to years of being bullied by Mycroft. Ever since he was a kid, Sherlock wanted to prove that Mycroft was wrong about him. He wanted to prove that he was smarter than Mycroft. This is why Sherlock decided to become a private detective. 7. Sherlock wants to surpass Mycroft and that's why he decides to never join MI6 that's headed by Mycroft. He's unwilling to accept Mycroft as a superior. 8. Sherlock's desire to solve difficult cases is his way of developing and/or reassuring himself that he's as smart as Mycroft. Similarly, Sherlock's arrogant and condescending attitude is just a means for him to take out all of his frustrations that he developed on being teased by Mycroft. In a way, Sherlock adapted Mycroft's bullying behaviour. Similarly to how Mycroft teased him for not being smart, Sherlock teases other people for not being smart. Sherlock does this to reassure himself that he is smart. His arrogant attitude is kind of like a defensive mechanism. 9. However Mycroft still doesn't find anyone in MI6 that's as smart as Sherlock so he still tries to make up with Sherlock for years and years. That's why we see Mycroft monitoring Sherlock, giving him cases etc. I believe Mycroft really wanted Sherlock to join him and accept him as a companion. We do see Mycroft making Sherlock a job offer on the phone at the end of The Empty Hearse. ^I wish the backstory we got was more akin to this. It's more realistic and I prefer backstories where everyone is their own independent actor and nothing revolves around one person entirely. However the backstory we get is the polar opposite. So basically Mycroft was never really bullying Sherlock. He was just pretending. He was just using trigger words to see if Sherlock's memories of Euros had resurfaced. Similarly Mycroft didn't join MI6 because he sought companionship. It was presumably so he could be in charge of taking care of Euros. Sherlock didn't become a private detective because he wanted to surpass Mycroft in his own way. He became a private detective because he never solved the puzzle that Euros gave him to save his friend. So Sherlock became a private detective to reconcile with the failure of solving his first case (which caused him to lose his best friend). He solves cases to deal with that depression. So basically Mycroft and Sherlock's backstory revolves around one character that we never knew about before and I don't really like that. I think a more natural and simple backstory could have been more relateable and better received by at least myself.
- 1,402 replies
-
I also believe the story doesn't fit as a series finale. This becomes clear with Mary's epilogue. Basically Mary sums up everything by saying this was the story of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. John Watson. Well the former is true, the latter isn't. This episode barely had anything to do with John. John was mostly just a plot device in this episode. His character didn't develop or have any big moments. This episode was more about Sherlock and Mycroft and that's why it was awkward how Moffatiss took Mycroft out of the final act. It honestly looked like they took out Mycroft because they wanted to somehow force the focus back to just Sherlock and John. I think Mary referenced both Sherlock and John because the books focus on their relationship. However their relationship is given a backseat in this episode as the story focuses more on Sherlock and Mycroft's personal history. That's why Mary's line in the end just feels unfitting.
- 1,402 replies
-
S
-
E please
-
It also ties into The Hound of Baskerville. Fans were already speculating that Sherlock was just imagining having a dog named Redbeard (I posted about that last week). At the end of The Hound of Baskerville, Sherlock explained to Henry how he imagined the hound because he was a child and couldn't deal with the traumatic experience of watching his father die. Sherlock subconsciously referenced himself during this explanation. Sherlock did pretty much the same thing as Henry when he was a kid. Sherlock couldn't deal with the traumatic experience of losing his best friend because his sister hid him away and refused to say where he was unless Sherlock could solve her puzzle. Similarly to how Henry reimagined his father's killer as a ghostly hound, Sherlock reimagined his best friend as his pet dog Redbeard that was 'put down'.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Best episodes (ranking)
Surelock replied to sherlockandjohn's topic in BBC Sherlock General Discussion.
My top five will be a combination of TRF, SIB, HLV, TGG, one more slot for either TAB, SIP or TLD, I'm not sure yet. TFP may be a contender as well. But HOB is in my lowest five, together with TBB, T6T, TSOT, TEH and one more, wait, I have mentioned all. Aiz! But I like Hounds more than TBB, T6T or TSOT. Why it's still low, I think it's because the case and supporting casts are less appealing to me, I think the plot of the case is a bit weak especially the way the villain deals with Henry, and I don't really buy that the innkeepers are driving Henry crazy just for monetary reason. I buy that people do that, but not the characters that we saw. I do like John and Sherlock's dynamic, and we see more in Sherlock personality, well if you realize actually at this point or even two points before this I have run out of things that I don't like about Hounds, :P it's just other episodes are better for me so I should stop talking. Yeah I meant Sarah; I just got the name mixed up with some character in another show. BTW I don't think the inn keepers were specifically trying to scare Henry. They brought the dog to scare anyone who went into the forest because they wanted to create the illusion of the hound to boost sales. Also I agree the supporting cast was weak in the episode but I thought the horror/thriller element of the episode made up for it. I'm a big horror/thriller fan. However if that doesn't work for you I can see why you won't like the episode as much. -
Even if Euros is healed of her psychosis and is allowed to leave Sherrinford, she should be thrown into a regular prison. She still killed innocent people and has to face justice. This is why I have trouble seeing Euros ever actually leaving Sherrinford. The most I can see is Mycroft allowing her to leave temporarily to help Sherlock on a case maybe in a Suicide Squad-esque style?
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Best episodes (ranking)
Surelock replied to sherlockandjohn's topic in BBC Sherlock General Discussion.
I think it's interesting to compare our picks with the picks from IMDB. IMDB probably has the largest voting base as there are thousands of people (even tens of thousands) rating a single episode. Sherlock's episode scores on ti are probably most reflective of the viewer base. Here are the episodes of Sherlock ranked based on their IMDB score: IMDB Ranking 1. The Reichenbach Fall (Season 2) - 9.7/10 2. The Lying Detective (Season 4) - 9.5/10 2. A Scandal in Belgravia (Season 2) - 9.5/10 4. His Last Vow (Season 3) - 9.4/10 5. The Empty Hearse (Season 3) - 9.1/10 5. The Great Game (Season 1) - 9.1/10 5. A Study in Pink (Season 1) - 9.1/10 8. The Sign of Three (Season 3) - 9.0/10 9. The Final Problem (Season 4) - 8.6/10 10. The Hound of Baskerville (Season 2) - 8.5/10 11. The Abominable Bride (Special) - 8.2/10 12. The Blind Banker (Season 2) - 8.1/10 13. The Six Thatchers (Season 4) - 7.8/10 Note: - Some episodes got the same score and that's why we have equal 2nds and no 3rd. - Season 4 episodes only came out a few days ago. While their score is pretty stable atm, they may still decrease. So here's my ranking again: My Ranking 1. The Lying Detective (Season 4) 2. The Reichenbach Fall (Season 2) 3. The Abominable Bride (Special) 4. The Hound of Baskerville (Season 2) 5. The Empty Hearse (Season 3) 6. The Great Game (Season 1) 7. A Study in Pink (Season 1) 8. The Sign of Three (Season 3) 9. A Scandal in Belgravia (Season 2) 10. The Final Problem (Season 4) 11. His Last Vow (Season 3) 12. The Blind Banker (Season 2) 13. The Six Thatchers (Season 4) Well it looks like most of the viewers like A Scandal in Belgravia and The Final Problem a lot more than I did. I liked The Abominable Bride and The Hound of Baskerville more than most people. It also looks like my preferences on the weakest episodes aligns with the majority which makes sense I guess. I'll be really surprised if someone doesn't have The Six Thatchers and The Blind Banker in their bottom two. -
Best episodes (ranking)
Surelock replied to sherlockandjohn's topic in BBC Sherlock General Discussion.
Eh..! Another one. Soooo...what is your reason SIB is so low? :P I wasn't a fan of Irene. To me she's just a typical femme fatale character. I never really got what was so great about her. Also the books make her out to be cleverer than Sherlock in some respects but I don't think this adaption captured that well enough. I know that she manages to sedate Sherlock and keep him guessing on what the password to her phone is but I don't think that was good enough. I thought Moffatiss could have incorporated her intellect into a bigger mystery with bigger stakes. Her phone does have stakes but the possibility of that isn't brought up until the last 5 minutes. Before then all we know is that her phone has some secrets that Mycroft would want. Also there are some minor details I wasn't a fan of: - I don't like how Moriarty was portrayed in this episode. This episode starts off from the cliffhanger of Season 1 and we find out that Moriarty isn't going to kill Sherlock and John because of a phone call from Irene. What was the phone call even about? I think this is the only episode where Moriarty doesn't amaze me. - I didn't like how we found out that John randomly broke up with Rachel some time before this episode. I liked the couple and if there was a breakup I'd prefer it to at least be on-screen. - There are some convoluted plot devices. How did Irene trick Sherlock into thinking that another lady's corpse was her? I mean Sherlock saw her naked. Irene can't observe information as well as Sherlock can (she admits this when Sherlock asks her to deduce information about the murder at the river). This episode did have its moments though. Minus the flaws I mentioned, Irene was still well acted. I also like how John told Sherlock a white lie at the end because he didn't want to hurt his feelings. However that wasn't enough to make this episode better than all the others. Anyway mind explaining to me why most people don't like The Hound of Baskerville as much as me? The only big flaws I see in it is that the minor characters aren't interesting and Mycroft is barely featured in it. I do think the horror/thrilelr element of it was done pretty well. I think Gatiss is really good at horror/thriller. -
That interview was pretty condescending but it got me thinking of another way to interpret this episode. I've been wondering if Euros may just be Moffatiss' attempt to project themselves into one of their own characters? You see Moffatiss think they're so much smarter than all of us. That's why they write these challenging plots that only smart people can understand. All the people who criticise their writing must be dumb. Moffatiss are like Euros on the plane. They're above everyone on an intellectual level and they don't know how to land because everyone else is so stupid compared to them. Similarly to how Euros played games on Sherlock, Moffatiss are using Sherlock's plot to play games on us. They want us to become as smart as Sherlock so we can 'solve' their mysterious writing and come rescue them from the plane. Then we'll be on their level and everyone will be smart. You see all us mean critics just misunderstand Moffatiss. They just want to be loved and understood like Euros.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
So when the Governor was explaining Euros in Sherrinford to John, Mycroft says that Euros has been able to mind control people ever since she was 5 years old. If that's the case then why didn't she just mind control Sherlock into playing with her when they were kids? i swear you have to invent so much information to make this episode sound coherent. But this also begs the question if Euros ever used her mind control powers prior to this episode. I mean was she using them when she had disguised herself as the lady on the bus? Maybe John wasn't really cheating on Mary but was brainwashed by Euros? Similarly did Euros use her mind control on Sherlock when she spent the night with him?
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Reminds me of Sherlock Holmes' famous quote: 'Once you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be the truth.' I think Moffatiss may have taken this quote a bit too far with Season 4, especially with this episode: - Euros is smarter than Isaac Newton so she has mind control powers. - Euros has a great IT department that can set up TVs wherever she wants them to. Heck her IT department can even get footage of Molly. - Euros even has a better remodeling unit that can create all these trap rooms for her. - Sherlock can break into Mycroft's house and rig everything to play prank on him. - Mary can somehow send DVDs well after her death. - Molly has her emotions toyed with but she's smiling at the end so it's all okay. Etc
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
There's also a (fanmade) timeline for Sherlock. http://bakerstreet.wikia.com/wiki/Sherlock_timeline That's what I linked at the end of my earlier post (Post #326) when I said that there were timeline errors. But thanks for sharing it anyway.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
TBH = To Be Honest Yeah ACD didn't do the best job at making his timeline clear. This is a proposed chronologically consistent timeline done by a fan: http://www.nekosmuse.com/withlovesh/?p=328 But I'm sure some fans can find holes in it.
- 1,402 replies
-
I doubt it was when Mycroft had Moriarty in custody. In the flashback, Mycroft clearly tells Morairty that he's under suspicion but they don't have any evidence against him yet. So the flashback should have taken place before we saw Morairty being slapped by Mycroft in The Hound of Baskerville.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Wasn't Sherlock the one who defined the meeting place? Re: TRF - why would she do this? Killing Sherlock would rob her of the hope for a playmate. Wait: what it Jim was her way to play with Sherlock? There are allusions to playing all over the episode. Now, wasn't it 5 years ago when they met? Would make it 2011-1012. Could work. TBH Moffatiss have done a bad job of maintaining the timeline. When Magnussen scans Sherlock in His Last Vow, it clearly says that Sherlock has been reported deceased from 2011 - 2013. That was the period when Sherlock faked his death and was out of the country. This means that the Christmas that Moriarty met Euros couldn't have been in 2011 or 2012 because Morairty should have been dead by then as there is no indication that the events of The Reichenbach Fall took place during Christmas. However if we try to calculate the year in which The Final Problem's Moriarty flashback takes place in, it strangely works out to be 2011 which looks like a contradiction. Here's my reasoning: 1. When Sherlock returns to London in 2013 in the Empty Hearse, it's near the end of the year as John gets thrown into a bonfire that's being lit for Guy Fawkes Day. Guy Fawkes Day is in November. 2. At the end of The Empty Hearse, Mary tells Sherlock that her and John's wedding is set for May so it's probably May of 2014. So the Sign of Three happens in 2014. 3. His Last Vow's climax is set on Christmas so it's probably Christmas of 2014. 4. It's obvious that the events of The Six Thatchers take place in 2015 since they take place over a significant period of time. 5. However in The Lying Detective it's Sherlock's birthday in the end and Sherlock's birthday is January 6. This means that when John and Sherlock hug in The Lying Detective it should be 6 January 2016. 6. So The Final Problem should take place in 2016. However if we apply the '5 years ago' statement we get 2011 Christmas as the Christmas that Moriarty visited Euros. however that doesn't make sense because The Reichenbach Fall clearly took place before 2011 Christmas so chronologically, Moriarty should have been dead by then. This looks like a contradiction. The only explanation I can think of is maybe the characters are just rounding down? The Lying Detective may have ended in early 2016. We can't be sure because there's no indication given of the amount of time that passes between Sherlock and John getting back together and Euros revealing herself to be John's therapist. We also know that a significant amount of time passed between those two events as John tells Euros about how Sherlock has recovered and is now clean shaven. Anyway if The Lying Detective ended in early 2016 then The Final Problem should be set in early 2016 as it begins right from where The Lying Detective left off. Maybe when the characters say '5 years ago' they're counting from 2015. That would make the Christmas that Moriarty visited Euros the 2010 Christmas. That's consistent with the timeline. But I don't know. There are a number of timeline errors from the show, John's Blog etc. You can read more about them here: http://bakerstreet.wikia.com/wiki/Sherlock_Timeline
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Probably before and it's referring to what Moriarty was planning to do in The Reichenbach Fall. Moriarty was planning on destroying Sherlock's reputation and forcing him to commit suicide by threatening the three people who were closest to his heart (Mrs. Hudson, Lestrade and John).
- 1,402 replies
-
"Without doubt, she WILL kill again if she has the opportunity." Yup. You nailed it. 'Sherlock talked Eurus out of being evil'. Sherlock to Euros after helping her land: 'Help me save my friend.' So yes Sherlock did talk to her out of doing evil if it was just temporarily.
- 1,402 replies
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)