Surelock
Detectives-
Posts
381 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Surelock
-
No idea. Adler isn't even mentioned in The Greek Interpreter. The Greek Interpreter does feature the story of a lady and her brother. Some criminals want the lady's property but her brother refuses to sign off the papers and eventually the criminals kill her brothers. By the end of the story, the criminals escape into another country but there comes news of their deaths. The official reports say they died fighting each other but Holmes chooses to believe that it was actually the lady who killed them for revenge. Maybe Moffat is planning on replacing this lady with Irene Adler and doing some sort of backstory, family study etc of her. However I think it's more likely that Moffat just named the incorrect story or maybe the interviewer got something wrong. Okay, thanks. I really hope I don't ever see anything connecting her and anything remotely based on The Greek Interpreter. That would really be stretching things. I'm afraid my eyes would roll. Besides, didn't they already have a "Geek Interpreter" reference? ;) Yes you are correct. You know that BBC created John's blog to tie-in with the universe? According to it, The Greek Interpreter happened on 16 June 2011: http://www.johnwatsonblog.co.uk/blog/16june However that doesn't Moffatiss won't contradict their own canon by doing another The Greek Interpreter in the future. You see John's blog also featured The Six Thatchers on 19 December 2011: http://www.johnwatsonblog.co.uk/blog/19december It's funny that we got another The Six Thatchers story set in 2015. It's funny that BBC stopped updating this blog after Season 3. I guess they realised Mofatiss were going to contradict themselves again and again so there's no point. I mean this blog was already in contradiction with the events in the show as some of the dates are wrong e.g. according to the blog, Sherlock was missing for one year but according to the show he was missing for two. It looks like Moffatiss don't plan out the details correctly and end up contradicting themselves as a result.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
No idea. Adler isn't even mentioned in The Greek Interpreter. The Greek Interpreter does feature the story of a lady and her brother. Some criminals want the lady's property but her brother refuses to sign off the papers and eventually the criminals kill her brothers. By the end of the story, the criminals escape into another country but there comes news of their deaths. The official reports say they died fighting each other but Holmes chooses to believe that it was actually the lady who killed them for revenge. Maybe Moffat is planning on replacing this lady with Irene Adler and doing some sort of backstory, family study etc of her. However I think it's more likely that Moffat just named the incorrect story or maybe the interviewer got something wrong.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
That's what TAB was about; Moriarty had an accomplice. In T6T, Sherlock confirms Moriarty made the tape before he died. In TFP we learn his accomplice was Eurus. As to why Sherlock was saved from exile, I presume it's because Eurus wanted to play with him. Which means she's been in control at Sherrinford for quite some time. How on earth did Moriarty and Euros work together as accomplices? Moriarty wanted Sherlock dead but Euros didn't. If Euros was willing to interfere and stop Sherlock from being sent to a deadly mission in Europe at the end of Season 3 then why didn't she intervene to help Sherlock when Moriarty was trying to kill him at the end of Season 2? Why didn't Euros just mind control Moriarty to not kill Sherlock when he came to meet her? Above all this we never hear of how Euros reacted when Sherlock faked his death. Judging by how she allegedly wanted him to play with her then I find it strange that we didn't hear of her having a mental breakdown on hearing of Sherlock's alleged death. Maybe Euros just later mind controlled someone in MI6 to tell her the truth about Sherlock but there still should have been an initial outburst. I bet Moffatiss would explain all this by saying that Euros predicted that Sherlock would defeat Moriarty lol.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
I'm sorry, I can't agree that Adler worked better than Eurus. I imagined the original Adler to be so much more intelligent and less obvious, and I still cringe at how they wrote her in Scandal, and that's keeping in mind that she was canon! If they were trying to tackle his feelings on love, as I agree with you they likely were, I wish they would have given a more rounded view of her character. I largely agree with this criticism (except with Euros being better than Adler but that's just a difference in value judgement). Do note though that our opinions are in the minority. On IMDB 26,529 viewers have rated A Scandal in Belgravia to be 9.6/10 which makes it the second highest rated episode after The Reichenbach Fall . Also A Scandal in Belgravia was nominated for an Emmy for its writing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primetime_Emmy_Award_for_Outstanding_Writing_for_a_Limited_Series,_Movie,_or_Dramatic_Special#2010s It didn't win but it was the only Season 2 episode that was nominated. Not even The Reichenbach Fall got a nomination. There's something I've noticed when I look at Sherlock episodes that are nominated for an Emmy for their writing: they're all written exclusively by Steven Moffat. The episodes that Moffat wrote alongside Gatiss don't get nominated. It's only when Moffat writes an episode by himself does it get a nomination. I guess most critics think Gatiss is a weaker writer and brings down the quality of the writing. For Season 4, I expect The Lying Detective to get a nomination as well because it was written entirely by Moffat.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
I think Euros was just created to be used as a hook to explore Sherlock's backstory. One thing I've noticed about BBC's Sherlock is that Moffatiss always try to tie in different stages of Sherlock's developments to a current mystery, adventure etc. For example in A Scandal in Belgravia, they wanted to explore Sherlock's idea of love so they decided to write the episode to be about Irene Adler. In The Hounds of Baskerville, they wanted to explore Sherlock's fear so they decided to use the alleged ghostly hound from the books. Similarly Culverton Smith was used in The Lying Detective as a hook to explore Sherlock and John's relationship when its stretched to its near limit. The difference is that Euros didn't work well as Adler, Smith or the Hound. I think the main reason for this is because she was an original character rather than something Moffatiss adapted from the source material. I think Moffatiss may not be that good with originality. If you look at their works, you'll notice that a lot of it is just adaptions, continuations etc of other works. I think they're good at giving new life to an old idea but I don't think they're that good with bringing up a new idea from scratch.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Do any of you guys have twitter? There have been these really funny arguments between Trump and Vincent Fox Quesada, the former President of Mexico, going on twitter. Trump keeps saying that Mexico will pay for the wall. Then Quesada replies by saying things like: ^Who knew that this is what International Relations would look like in 2017 folks.
-
Just yes on the Jeremy Brett series...I adore that series. I can easily see that Sherlock being our Sherlock older and living in Victorian England lol. It's a faithful adaption and so fun. Also, Inge, on the Dostoyevsky adaptions, are there specific versions you're talking about? Modern ones? Just curious all I have ever seen is a Brothers Karamazov that was made in the 50's or something, if I am even remembering it right. Would love to see others...anything Dostoyevsky. Help? Hard. Very hard. Twin Peaks maybe, or LOST, but they both have very unsatisfying endings IMO. If you are logical, you might have problems with Dr. Who. To me it feels a bit like the early Star Trek, but with more self-irony. I'm probably too old to really get into it. That is a tough one. I think JP is right, the Dr. Who thing sort of depends on your position on logic; it's a lot less grounded (literally and figuratively) than is Sherlock. If that's not something that bothers you, then there is a lovely character development arc between the Tenth Doctor (David Tennant) and his companion Rose Tyler that has some echos of a Sherlock and John relationship in some ways. The relationship between the Twelfth Doctor (Peter Capaldi) and his companion Clara Oswald also has some of that depth. Also, I've said before that House was my gateway into the Sherlock Holmes fandom, and I can't see why going from Sherlock to House wouldn't work just as well as going from House to Sherlock. The bonus is, you'll see a few recognizable Holmesian names and plots turn up, plus the relationship between House and Wilson is, of course, the Holmes and Watson dynamic that we love. If you are alert, you will see early on that House has his own Irene Adler, and, later, Wilson has his heartbreak with the death of his version of Mary Morstan. Thanks for the recommendations. I'm already familiar with the Basil Rathbone and the Jeremy Brett adaptions. I haven't heard of Dostoyevsky but I'll be sure to check him out. One other thing I'd like to add is that when it comes to detective shows, I usually don't get invested in the detective unless he/she is a classical detective. By 'classical detective' I'm mostly referring to those detectives that were created around the time of the Golden of Detective Fiction. The most notable trait in classical detectives were their eccentric behaviours. There was always this intriguing aura around a classical detective because they didn't always behave the same way a regular detective would. Thus classical detective stories essential had two mysteries: 1. The mystery the detective was trying to solve. 2. What methods that the detective would undertake to solve such mysteries. ^I think to make the most memorable detective stories possible you need to get the top two qualities done very well. This is why I think Sherlock Holmes books are considered to be the best detective stories. They nail these two qualities really well. I'd say that the second most popular detective stories would be Agatha Christie's Hercule Poirot. They're really good but if they have a weakness then I'd say it's that they're basically all murder mysteries. Not all the Sherlock Holmes books were murder mysteries. Some of them were just mysteries about strange incidents such as 'The Dancing Men' and 'The Red-Headed League'. So in terms of variety, the Sherlock Holmes books were just better. There were other classical detectives like Miss Marple and Father Brown that were interesting characters but never really got to participate in very interesting mysteries. I also think one of the main reasons why modern fictional detectives aren't as well recognised as Sherlock Holmes and Hercule Poirot is because they're not eccentric. You see after the Golden Age of Detective Fiction ended, crime writers just stopped making their detectives eccentric. They started to make their detectives more normal and ordinary and this gave birth to the hard boiled/noir genre of detective fiction. I was never too interested in the hard boiled/noir detective because they just didn't have the aura of mystery around them that Sherlock Holmes or Hercule Poirot had. However as far as I can tell, basically all modern fictional detectives are hard boiled/noir. It's like crime writers forgot how to write the classical eccentric detective after the Golden Age ended. I can't think of a single modern detective that's eccentric. This is why I'm not a big fan of modern detective shows like CSI, Twin Peaks etc. The detectives just aren't interesting. Usually I just looks up the episodes which have the best mysteries and watch them.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Despite the fact I didn't like most of Season 4, I'm starting to have Sherlock withdrawal. What else can I watch? I want something which is similar to Sherlock in at least some sense. I've tried both Elementary and House M.D. but I don't think either of them are anywhere near as good. They both have the problem of having too many episodes that just drag plot points along rather than dealing with them concisely like they are in Sherlock. I think the concise structure of Sherlock is one of the reasons why character development moments in Sherlock work so well. With a short episode count, Moffatiss can keep the moment in a character arc up. That can make the moment much better e.g. Sherlock and John's hug in The Lying Detective. In other shows, usually the momentum gets lost when the story starts to drag on. I think the concise structure also prevents reveals that have the potential to be disappointing from being as disappointing as they can possibly be. An example of this would be the reveal of Euros as the girl on the plane. If The Final Problem's story had been dragged out in several episodes like most other series, then I think that reveal would have been more disappointing. Honestly I hate shows that drag on with hundreds and hundreds of episodes. I just don't see how you can make each and every episode in a hundred episode series stand out. I think you can only do that without a small episode count. This is why Sherlock is one of the only series which has episodes that I can rewatch. All the episodes stand out and have something special to offer even the episodes in Season 4. I've considered trying Doctor Who because it has the same creators as Sherlock but I'm not sure. Doctor Who looks a bit too wacky/cartoon-y for me. I consider myself to be a very logical person so I'd like a show which tries to follow a logic fairly well. It doesn't have to be 100% realistic but it needs to be consistent and believable within its own universe.
- 1,402 replies
-
Well, how about this for an idea? Maybe she just has the same ability as her older brothers ... to be observant. For all his self-proclaimed sociopathy, Sherlock would have been a pretty poor detective if he hadn't been able to deduce what people were feeling. He didn't have to understand or share those feelings, he just had to know how they motivated people. So, Eurus wouldn't have to know why John was glancing to one side; she merely had to notice that he was glancing to one side. Besides, there's no indication she thought he was hallucinating; she simply asked what he was looking at. My argument wasn't that Therapist-Euros noticed that John was looking behind her. It was more she understood how he was looking. Remember John said he was 'looking away'. However Therapist-Euros seemed to correctly state that John wasn't 'looking away'. Rather he was 'looking to'. So she realised that John was specifically looking at something behind her despite the fact there was just an ordinary wall behind her. It sounded like Euros could identify that John was hallucinating someone, especially when you consider her next line: 'I think I am reminding you of your friend'. It looked like that Euros may have suspected that John was hallucinating Sherlock which isn't far off from the truth. I wonder if, instead of a fat Sherlock, that could be Sherlock being boiled alive in a cauldron? :o Not sure if I understand this joke. How does being boiled alive make you fat?
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
So in order to make sense of Young Euros' character I decided to examine those pictures she drew in the flashback. We only get three shots of the pictures for a few seconds so I had to screenshot them all to examine them thoroughly. From what I can see, it looks like Young Euros seemed to really hate Sherlock and wanted to get rid of him. Here's my 'deduction': Image 1 One thing I've noticed about these pictures is that Euros has a habit of putting a cross over Sherlock. She doesn't do it for her parents, Mycroft or even herself. It's just Sherlock. It looks like she wants to get rid of him. Look at the bottom right picture. It's Sherlock's corpse on a grave. It says 'RIP Sherlock' on the grave. If you look at the first row of bottom pictures clockwise, you can see she drew pictures of Sherlock with a lot of red near his neck. They look like pictures of Sherlock having his neck slit open and his blood bursting out. It also looks like Sherlock's eyes are drawn with Xs and in cartoon language when a character's eyes are drawn as Xs it means they're dead. The top left picture looks like Sherlock is being hanged. The middle far right picture looks like Mycroft as it depicts a fat figure which is dressed in the same clothes as Mycroft is in the other pictures (green shirt with blue pants). However I'm wondering if this figure is actually just a fatter Sherlock. The reason for this is because the hair is drawn with squiggly lines. Look at the rest of Euros' pictures of Sherlock. Sherlock's hair is always drawn with squiggly lines. However Mycroft's hair isn't. So is the middle far right picture really a picture of Mycroft or is it actually a fat Sherlock? However that raises the question of why is Euros drawing Sherlock like Mycroft? Is she perhaps mocking Mycroft's affection for Sherlock? If we take a look at the top middle picture we see a picture of the Holmes family. However it's clear that Sherlock is in a different place from the rest of his family. Mr and Mrs Holmes, Mycroft and Euros are on a beach as they're standing on sand, there are waves in front of them, there's a sandcastle behind them, a beach ball next to them and a clear blue sky behind them. However Sherlock seems to be pictured in a different place as the background doesn't look like a clear blue sky from where he is standing. It looks more like he's in a darker cloudier area. It looks like his family left him behind. Euros drew crosses over him and has him struck by lightning. Some of the top middle picture gets cut off but we can see some of it in Image 2. Image 2 You'll notice that there's a bottom left picture which gets cut off. This picture is a cloud which is striking lightning. What is the lightning striking? Well we can see the other end of this picture in Image 1. The top middle picture in the Image 1 is the other end of this picture in Image 2. Thus the lightning is striking Sherlock. So the cloud striking lightning is the same picture in which Sherlock is left behind as the rest of his family go to the beach together. This rest of Image 2 is self-explanatory. There's a picture of Sherlock's gravestone. Next to it is a picture of Sherlock with his hair on fire. Sherlock also has a cross over him in this picture. Image 3 This is just another picture with a cross over Sherlock while he's standing in their house all alone. Assuming that the middle far right picture in Image 1 is just a fatter Sherlock then it looks like Euros has a habit of only drawing Sherlock alone. Whenever she draws Mycroft, her parents or herself, they're always together. However only Sherlock is featured alone in her pictures. Also a lot of bad things happen to Sherlock in those pictures as I've explained already. To me it looks like Euros is angry at Sherlock. That's what I'm getting out of her pictures. It looks like she wants Sherlock to be alone. She wants him to suffer alone. She wants him to die alone. It really looks like she wants to kick Sherlock out of her family. That's how I interpret her putting so many crosses over her pictures of Sherlock. She wants Sherlock removed from her family so she's using crosses to 'delete' him. Considering the fact that Euros decided to set the house ablaze after drawing these pictures, then I think it may be possible that she intended for the fire to kill Sherlock. Remember she did draw a picture of Sherlock with his hair on fire in Image 2. Also the last picture she drew before lighting the fire was in Image 3. The picture in Image 3 depicts Sherlock alone in the house and a cross drawn over him. It's also notable that Euros doesn't seem to have the same hatred that she has for Sherlock for any of her other family members. She doesn't draw any of them suffering. She doesn't put crosses over them. In fact she draws pictures of herself standing side by side with Mycroft and her parents. It looks like she really wants their company. If I have to take a guess, I'd say that Euros seems jealous of Sherlock. She seems to think that Mycroft and her parents only think about him and not her. I can actually buy that being true because Sherlock was a very emotional child when he was young, unlike Euros. I guess it would make sense for Mycroft and his parents to be more affectionate towards him than to her. Assuming this is true then I can buy the middle far right picture in Image 1 being Euros' way of protesting that Mycroft only shows affection for Sherlock and not her. I think all of this may explain some of Euros' loneliness. If she felt that everyone loved Sherlock and not her (despite the fact that she was the youngest) then I can see why she would grow to resent Sherlock. What I'm not sure is how any of this ties into Euros' other actions, especially considering how she behaved in the future. I mean if Young Euros resented Sherlock then why did she still want to play with him? She wants to kill him but she panics when he points a gun at himself in the fourth game in Sherrinford? Did she change her mind when she grew up? What caused her to change her mind?
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Here's the problem with the the different-actress-so-not-Young-Euros-personality argument: the girl on the plane had to be a different actress. Remember Moffatiss wanted the twist in the end to be that the girl on the plane that Sherlock was trying to save all along was Euros. However in order for that to be a twist the actress had to be different. If they used the same actress as the one that played Young Euros in the flashback then they wouldn't be able to make a twist out of the girl on the plane because everyone would see that the actress who played Young Euros is also the girl on the plane. So we're left in an ambiguous position to interpret the girl on the plane: - The girl on the plane was Euros manifesting her child-like self in some way OR - The girl on the plane was a different manifestation of Euros' psyche. Which is the right one? We don't know and that's why it's difficult to interpret Euros' character. Honestly it felt like Moffatiss thought of the twist first and the story about Euros second. That's why Euros being the girl on the plane raises more questions than answers. Also when Euros was impersonating John's therapist, she did show at least a few signs of a professional understanding of psychology. The most notable example is how she seemed to be able to tell that John was hallucinating Mary. Remember that John hallucinated Mary standing behind Euros-therapist. When John lied to Euros-therapist that he doesn't talk to anyone, hallucination-Mary starts crying. John then turns his eyes towards her. Euros-therapist notices this and asks John what he's looking at behind her. John saying he's just looking away. However then Euros-therapist says, 'There's a difference between looking away and looking to. I tend to notice these things.' I have trouble seeing how Euros could have done that by just acting. She seems to actually be good at reading John's emotional state. I think I said earlier that I read Euros burning the house down as a protest against her parents for taking her favourite hairband away. However the very fact that she's willing to burn the family house down shows that she's willing to put her parents lives in danger if she deems it appropriate. So it is strange that she didn't try to toy with her parents in any of her games. The only explanation I can think of is that Mycroft may have lied to Euros that their parents had already died because he didn't ever want her to ever seek them out or anything like that. I do think it's possible that Sherlock will now not rely on drugs as much as he used to. The biggest problem with Euros is that I have trouble buying her being lonely. From what I can make out of their personal history, I don't see why it should be difficult to get Sherlock to play with her. Sherlock was an emotional child so if she was lonely then it should make sense for him to sympathise and want to play with her. Additionally it seems that Euros and Sherlock were on good terms in at least some point of their childhood. Remember Euros said so herself that she taught Sherlock how to play the violin. Most of the time when siblings teach each other to do things it's when they're close to each other. So Euros and Sherlock should have been close in at least one point of their early life. However Euros still ended up being lonely so I'm guessing that she may have had some sort of falling out with Sherlock? But what kind of falling out? I don't know. There just doesn't seem to be enough information given in this episode.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
I thought they might have mentioned Eurus having a therapist because Eurus used that person as a template, ans was able to mimic and re-use some of her responses? Yes, the insanity aspect gives her (and the writers) a bit of a carte blanche. I don't know if it is just how good an actress she is, but there is something about teh performance that makes me want to find an inner mechanism for why she does what she does. You get the impression that Sherlock is sort of sacred to her. Why does she in no way approach harming her parents? Is it because she doesn't believe Sherlock would care as much, or because they matter too much to her? And then if some part of the family are sacrosanct to her, why is it that Mycroft is expendable? Or is it that she expects Sherlock to get rid of John? Are her attempts to go after John and Molly more of an attempt to get rid of the non-Holmes family that Sherlock has built, because she wants to in some strange way rebuild her own? I wouldn't say Euros was just 'mimicking' responses. Remember what John said when he was surprised that Sherlock predicted which therapist he had two weeks in advance. He told Sherlock that the session he had with her at the start of The Lying Detective was his first session with her. The real therapist never met John. So basically Euros was able to conduct a emotional evaluation of a new patient. How did she do that considering her own damaged mental state? I'm not sure why Euros didn't consider harming her parents. When she burnt their house as a kid, she demonstrated that she was capable of at least being indifferent to her parents' welfare. Also I noticed something about Sherlock's first call with Child Euros. It gets cut off immediately before Sherlock tells Child Euros his name. I initially thought that this would mean that Child Euros has some memories of her childhood or something like that. I speculated that Adult Euros cut off the transmission then because hearing Sherlock's name would cause Child Euros to realise that he's her brother and open up too much to him. However this idea comes into contradiction with what Child Euros says when Sherlock is in Musgrave Hall later. Child Euros asks who Redbeard is when Sherlock mentions him. So what? Child Euros can remember Sherlock's name but she can't remember Redbeard? That's the confusing thing about Child Euros. Who exactly is she? Is she supposed to be Euros when she's young or is she supposed to be an independent young persona or what?
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
I think I know what you mean ... she's half smiling, as if she's genuinely touched by what Sherlock was willing to put himself through to save Molly. It fits with her "you're nicer than I thought you'd be" remark as Faith. But I still haven't decided what to make of it, because I'm still not convinced Eurus is actually capable of being touched in that way. For me it was more like fascination with what she saw, all those countless complicated emotions. Almost like it was something she didn't expect from her game and it took a moment to process. It was odd to me but the show kept the reactions in so it must have had some kind of meaning, right? I really like this interpretation too. Of course that assumes she was capable of knowing what she saw, would she have been? Or did she think she would be? Do you think it mattered that the conversation took place on the phone, so it meant Molly could not see him but Eurus could? Well, that's exactly what I'm struggling with ... Is she capable of recognizing the emotions for what they are? That's why I like the idea of "fascination" ... she's seeing emotions she's not accustomed to seeing (I imagine what she mostly sees in that place is fear, loathing, etc.) and filing them away for analysis. On the other hand, she's capable of acting like a normal person, i.e., Faith and gang. So she knows how to fake emotions, even if she doesn't really know what they feel like --- ?? But she recognized that Sherlock was "nice." Urgh, it just keeps twisting back on itself. That's why I keep going with she's just plain crazy, we can't expect any consistent behavior from her. But that's not very satisfactory either, because then we don't know how to understand what's going on with her ... why was Sherlock able to reach through to her when he did? Why did she start the game in the first place? Random whim, or plan? Ak!! What makes it even more confusing is that Euros was able to effectively impersonate John's therapist. Therapy is all about reading emotions and it looks like Euros did that really well. We even see her read John's emotional state in 'The Lying Detective'. At the start of the episode, she says things like how John is behaving is normal and that he shouldn't hold himself up to an unreasonable standard. By the end of the episode, she can tell that John is better. If Euros is supposed to have trouble with emotions then how can she read John's emotions so well? I considered the possibility that Euros was good at reading others but not herself. However even that doesn't really make much sense to me. I mean the Adult Euros persona was clearly aware of her Child Euros personality as she used it to scare Sherlock into playing her games. Euros is one of those characters that doesn't really seem to behave logically and that's why it's difficult to understand her.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 4
-
-
I think Moffatiss making this season so much about love runs counter to how they were also trying to make this season dark. Before this season premiered, basically all the articles said it would be a darker season: http://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2016/12/sherlock-season-4-mark-gatiss-interview http://movieweb.com/sherlock-season-4-story-details-steven-moffat/ http://ew.com/tv/2016/12/28/sherlock-season-4-darker/ I think a lot of the inconsistent, ineffective characterisation/plot etc can be explained by Moffatiss trying to mix darkness and love together. It's difficult to get the such different themes to work alongside each other. This can most clearly be seen with Euros. Moffatiss wanted to create a terrifying villain out of her to tie in with the theme of this season being dark. However they also wanted us to sympathise with her on some level because they also wanted this season to be about love. This just resulted in a number of viewers being unable to connect with Euros and thus the episode getting a mixed reception.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Oh, absolutely. And when dealing with a work like this that was made primarily for fun and entertainment, even more so than when analyzing a Tom Hardy poem. Did the Sherlock Holmes stories ever mean anything except "Sherlock Holmes has adventures because Sir Arthur Conan Doyle needs money?" Maybe they did, maybe that meaning was intentional, maybe it's just what we choose to read into it. My personal theory is that the closest we can come to accurately reading authorial intent in a narrative is if we can find links to the author's personal history. This is why I believe Watson and Holmes' relationship is similar to the relationship that Sir Arthur Conan Doyle had with one his teachers, Joseph Bell. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was a medical student. His teacher, Joseph Bell, was able to draw conclusions from minute details. That's where the whole idea of a detective who can deduce from so little came from. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle revealed this in a letter he wrote. I think it's important to note that Watson is a doctor. Why is he a doctor? I'd say it's because Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was also a doctor. When he was being taught under Joseph Bell, he was a medical student who was amazed by what his teacher could do. He translated these experiences into his stories. That's how I really see Holmes and Watson's relationship being written in the books. The Sherlock Holmes books are just a curious student writing about the experiences he has with an exceptional teacher.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
True there were no explosives in the flat but Euros may have flied one of her drones into Molly's flat, similarly to what she did with Sherlock's flat in 221B Baker's Street.
- 1,402 replies
-
It seems to me we've seen plenty of his personal sense of justice, the big one being shooting CAM. But in TAB he sympathizes with the "murderous women", and insults the person whose life has been threatened, Sir Eustace. He doesn't report John's role in shooting the cabbie. He saves Irene. He tells John not to bother checking on the injured guard in CAM's office, because the man is a neo-Nazi. Heck, he protects Mary, the woman who almost killed him when he was just trying to help her. This is true but in all of these examples Sherlock is just helping his friends (except in The Abominable Bride but that's just a Mind Palace experiment). The Sherlock Holmes in the books was depicted to be more sympathetic in the sense that he was able to empathise with people he just met. Like in 'The Devil's Foot', he just met the culprit but after evaluating his character and determining that he wouldn't do wrong again, he decided to just let him go instead of giving him to the police. The Sherlock Holmes in the books was a good judge of character. I felt that Moffatiss didn't capture this enough because they just had Sherlock help his friends. That's why I believe there's still room to explore this concept in a potential fifth season.
- 1,402 replies
-
It seems possible John could have mentioned it in passing, though unlikely. I would really like to know the answer to this. I wish someone would ask the writers. Though, I suspect you might get a snippy reply similar to when people asked what happened next with Molly. It's almost like some sort of... conspiracy ;) Well John kind of did mention it in passing. When Sherlock arrived at his therapy session and asks for help, John says that he wants Sherlock examined first. Sherlock then says that John is a doctor and can conduct the examination himself. However John replies with: 'I want you examined by the one person who, unlike me, learnt to see past your bullsh*t long ago. I want you examined by Molly Hooper.' Since Euros heard that line then it may not have been difficult for her to deduce that there was potential romance between Sherlock and Molly. I mean who else can look past your bullsh*t better than your significant other? She may have also put on another one of her disguises and interviewed Molly about her feelings for Sherlock before revealing herself to John.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Agreed, but the backdrop was Sherlock being a jerk after returning from exile, having pretended to be dead for two years At this point, a similar plot would be considered character regression, not development. I love TEH, don't get me wrong, but I don't want to see Sherlock being that ignorant of someone's feelings again - at least not in such a serious context. He's grown too much for that. I think there is at least one way Moffatiss can still continue to develop Sherlock and John: explore Sherlock's personal sense of justice. In the books, Holmes didn't always hand the criminal over to the police. If the criminal was actually a decent person who only killed once out of rage, revenge etc and didn't look like they would commit any further crimes, then Holmes would let them go. Examples of short stories where he did so were 'The Devil's Foot' and 'The Boscombe Valley'. Holmes was a bit of a vigilante in the books. He wasn't always on the side of the law. He used his own sense of justice at times. Watson used to argue sometimes when he saw Holmes take justice into his own hands. I'm surprised we didn't see this trait in BBC Sherlock considering that they wanted to humanise Sherlock. Showing a personal sense of justice in him would be a good way of showing how he has developed empathy. However I can see Moffatiss explore this idea in a potential fifth season because it would flow on logically from where Season 4 left off. Season 4 ended with Sherlock trying to make up with Euros in his own way so it could make sense for him to develop his own sense of justice by the next season.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 4
-
-
Yes, especially some of the poor reviews online seem quite unfair, when you consider the quality of this episode compared to a lot of other shows on TV. The fact they have so many relationships, interactions and concepts that we all can see in so many different ways, must mean they are doing something right. And, this one in particular, had so many small but huge moments for the characters, that a little outlandishness from the plot can be forgiven You know it's not just fans that are giving this season poor reviews. It's professional critics as well. Season 4 of Sherlock got 59% on Rotten Tomatoes. For comparison's sake, Season 1 got 100%, Season 2 got 100% and Season 3 got 97%. Dropping from 97% to 59% is quite bad. Metacritic hasn't released its released its score yet however it has made 3 reviews it used public. 2/3 of the reviews are mixed (which is the 40 - 60 range). For comparison, none of the previous seasons ever got any mixed reviews. All the reviews were positive. Season 1 got 85, Season 2 got 91 and Season 3 got 88. It's expected for Season 4's score to be lower here as well. Season 4 isn't getting critical acclaim which feels very off to many Sherlock fans because Sherlock is a show that has been critically acclaimed since its first season. I can see why so many people are angry at Moffatiss for the new direction they took the series with in Season 4. This makes me wonder if the poor reviews would convince Moffatiss to not take the next season of Sherlock (assuming they make it) in a new direction like they did with Season 4.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Another reason why I think this episode feels different from other Sherlock episodes is because of how it's titled. Each Sherlock episode is usually given the same title as one of the Sherlock Holmes' stories (not necessarily the one it's basing itself of). However the title is altered slightly. Usually this is because Moffatiss change one word in the title. For example, 'The Six Thatchers' gets its name from the short story, 'The Six Napoleons'. Similarly, 'The Lying Detective' gets its name from the short story, 'The Dying Detective'. However Moffatiss decides to break this formula with this episode. This episode directly takes its title from the short story, 'The Final Problem'. However I think a more fitting title would have been 'The First Problem'. After all Euros says that her song puzzle was Sherlock's first case. I'm not sure why they emphasise it as 'The Final Problem'. Yes I know that Euros places it as her last game in the episode but originally it was the first game she played. That's why I personally believe it would make more sense for this episode to be labelled 'The First Problem'. 'The Final Problem' just build up my expectations a lot. It makes me expect a sense of finality in this episode. However I don't think it delivered enough on these fronts.
- 1,402 replies
-
That doesn't change the fact or nature of unrequited love. The fact that you see others who ARE in love the way you seek to be in love only makes that unrequited love all the more painful in contrast. Not only are you alone, but you see some others are not. Thus the jealousy part of her 'murderous jealousy'. Again, Eurus does not see in Mycroft a kindred soul - any more than Molly sees a kindred soul in Mycroft rather than Sherlock. Neither loves Mycroft. That doesn't mean Mycroft can't love or doesn't love in his own way. You seem to be very forgiving of this episode because of its thematic focus on love. I have to ask: Do you consider yourself to be a fan of love-conquers-all stories? Personally I strongly dislike stories like that. It's become such a cliche theme that it just feels lazy when writers resort to it.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 3
-
-
TBH Euros said that every time she closed her eyes she was on the plane again so she could switch to her little girl persona quite easily. She just has to close her eyes. It's a contrived explanation but this episode is full of them. I also find it weird that Adult Euros knows everything about Child Euros but Child Euros doesn't seem to know anything about Adult Euros. This is evident when Sherlock mentions Redbeard to Child Euros and Child Euros says 'Who's Redbeard?' I also don't find Euros to be as sympathetic as the writers seem to want her to be. Euros hid Victor, a little boy, away and refused to say where he was unless people could solve her puzzle. Victor was never found and that traumatised Sherlock. We don't get all the information of how Euros responded after committing this atrocity. However when Sherlock first meets her in this episode, Euros says that the last thing she told him was to go get her favourite hairband from mummy. Judging by the fact that her mum had her hairband, I'd say it's probable that her mum was punishing her (by taking her favourite hairband away) for not telling them about Victor. Euros said she made this request to Sherlock on the day that she was taken away. So it was the same day she burnt the house down. In the flashback of when she lights the matches, we hear background conversations of presumably her parents arguing. Her mum mentions how they can't make Euros tell them or do anything. Her mum presumably took away her favourite hairband to try and coerce Euros to cooperate but it Euros still refused. I'm guessing what happened on Euros' last day with the Holmes is: 1. Euros was being punished by her mum by having her favourite hairband taken away. Her mum said 'I'll only return it if you tell us where Victor is.' However Euros refused to say. 2. Sherlock couldn't wait. He begged Euros for information of where Victor was because he couldn't solve her puzzle. Then Euros responded by saying something like 'I'll give you another clue if you can get my favourite hairband back from mummy.' 3. Euros wasn't cooperating so her parents got into an argument on what to do with her. Mr. Holmes seemed insistent on punishing her (as he said 'She knows where he is') while Mrs. Holmes seemed to realise that coercion wasn't going to work on Euros (she said 'We can't make her do anything'). 4. Euros was upset because she overheard her parents' argument. It didn't sound like she was going to get her hairband back anytime soon because her parents were divided on how to deal with her. Also it's clear that Sherlock didn't get her hairband back. 5. Thus Euros decided to burn the house down in rage. After that Uncle Ruddi decides to take her away to an asylum. However Euros then decides to burn down that asylum as well so then she's moved to Sherrinford. ^This is why I don't like Euros. When she doesn't get what she wants, she just lashes out at anyone even if they have nothing to do with it. It also looks like she didn't care about Sherlock being traumatised for losing Victor. All she cared about was herself. If that isn't selfish then I don't know what is. Also I think it should be noted that Euros probably was more closer to her mother than father. Remember in that flashback of her lighting the matches, her father seems to be the one who's more insistent on punishing her. Additionally when Mycroft tells them about Euros being alive in the end, it's only Mrs. Holmes who gets out of her chair. I'd say that Euros had a more negative opinion of her father because he was more strict with her. This dislike for her father and closeness to her mother may have materialised in her Child Euros persona. Child Euros only talks about her mum and never her dad.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Well Mycroft vomits after the Governor shoots himself in the face. I'd say that's pretty close to cracking. I think the darts were always planned to be there because Euros was always planning on putting Sherlock and his companion to sleep and transport them to their old house. I doubt Euros was planning on taking Sherlock and his companion to their old house while they were awake. Transporting them would be easier if they were asleep and not struggling. So initially Euros believed that Sherlock was going to shoot Mycroft so she positioned a bunch of dart holes throughout the room. After Sherlock shot Mycroft, darts were supposed to come out and sedate Sherlock and John. She didn't know exactly where they were going to stand in the room so she had a number of darts ready to be fired from every angle. However Euros believed she would only need two by the time that the fourth game was complete. However when Sherlock pointed the gun at himself, Euros ended up firing the darts early and she ended up using one extra dart because Sherlock didn't shoot Mycroft.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 3
-
-
That was true with all of the other games as well but the other games also had additional hostages that Euros could execute immediately. However you bring up a good point. Why didn't Euros just tell Sherlock that if he shot himself then she would call the game off and let all the little girl and all the other hostages in the plane die? It's a good point. I think she just didn't consider the option that he might do such a thing and started to panic unable of thinking of exactly that. Also the plane technically wasn't real and maybe she considered that Sherlock might have figured that out at that point. His very action of suicide might suggest that to her since if he's dead he can't save the girl anyway if she was on a real crashing plane? I doubt Sherlock was actually giving up on the girl and the plane when he turned the gun on himself. I think it's more that he couldn't bear to kill his brother or friend so he decided to kill himself, leaving Mycroft and John to advance to the next game and save the girl and the plane. It makes sense when you think about it. If Sherlock shot himself, even Mycroft would want to save the girl and the plane because that would be Sherlock's final wish.
- 1,402 replies
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)