Jump to content

Surelock

Detectives
  • Posts

    381
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Surelock

  1. Because she wasn't a normal kid. She's above normal kids? Being a genius doesn't mean you can make sense of yuourself. Her mother surely said go ask Sherlock to play with you. Of course she went and said to Sherlock she wanted to play with him. But he was a boy, wanted boyish games. She probably also scared away all other kids in the neighborhood, they were too stupid, and she might have made them "laugh". Sherlock was the only one who could keep up with her, but he prefered a normal friend, who wasn't smarter than himself, over a manipulative genius without empathy, which was much safer and probably more fun. Please don't put together intelligence and empathy/emotional intelligence/assertiveness. They are different things, they come from different places. She could make sense of herself. She clearly said she wanted to play with Sherlock. She knew what she wanted. However she resorted convoluted means rather than the obvious methods. All that stuff of Sherlock wanting to play with someone not as smart would just make Sherlock a hypocrite because he's also a genius and is smarter than everyone. I'm starting to think Sherlock's parents were just terrible. They couldn't even tell when their daughter was lonely. Who is to say she didn't? In fact, she probably did - like any normal kid. And, like any normal kid, it wouldn't have solved her problem. You can't force other kids to WANT to be your BEST FRIEND. Your parents can't help your lack of having a best friend. You can't MAKE someone have a deep connection with you. You can't FORCE someone to love and want to be with you. And any pretense at it just amplifies the loneliness. So 'Sherlock - go play with your sister' wouldn't help. (This is one of the reasons why the "I Love You" scene with Molly is so painful for both of them) Why would Sherlock not want to play with his sister if she was lonely? Why wouldn't he want to show her that she was loved? Wasn't Sherlock supposed to be the emotional child?
  2. It looks like nobody has asked the obvious questions so I may as well: If Euros was feeling lonely and wanted to play then why didn't she just go and say it to Sherlock like any normal kid would? Why did she go to great lengths to put Victor in a well and make this complex puzzle for Sherlock to solve? If Sherlock wasn't listening to her then why didn't Euros just go to her mother and tell her she was lonely? I swear for a genius, she does a lot of things that defy common sense.
  3. Behind the Scenes of this episode 'The Final Problem': https://vimeo.com/199600904 Watch it quickly before it gets taken down. Okay I watched it and they don't tell us anything special about Euros. They just said she wants to be loved and she also wants revenge. They don't mention anything about a split personality.
  4. I don't think anyone has posted this interview with Mark Gatiss yet: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-4122352/Sherlock-creator-Mark-Gatiss-slams-fans-confusing-tells-read-children-s-book.html This article has some interesting points: It's funny that Gatiss said they don't give in to fan pressure. I'd say that Season 4 gave in a fair bit to fan pressure. Also it looks like Gatiss and Moffat can simply use the 'oh we're challenging our audience' excuse when anything in their show doesn't make sense.
  5. Did anyone here watch or read Naruto? It's a popular anime/manga series. Naruto has this power of talking his villains out of being evil. He doesn't say anything insightful or amazing. He just says cliche things about love and understanding for a few minutes. Then the bad guys who have been bad guys for their entire life decide to become good. When I saw Sherlock talk Euros out of being evil I immediately thought of how Naruto talked Nagato out of being a mass murderer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N9UdW76UmvA Since this episode is so derivative I wonder if Moffat and Gatiss got inspiration from Naruto.
  6. 1. The Lying Detective (Season 4) 2. The Reichenbach Fall (Season 2) 3. The Abominable Bride (Special) 4. The Hound of Baskerville (Season 2) 5. The Empty Hearse (Season 3) 6. The Great Game (Season 1) 7. A Study in Pink (Season 1) 8. The Sign of Three (Season 3) 9. A Scandal in Belgravia (Season 2) 10. The Final Problem (Season 4) 11. His Last Vow (Season 3) 12. The Blind Banker (Season 2) 13. The Six Thatchers (Season 4) This isn't just based on reasons but also personal preferences.
  7. I already explained why I disagreed with your premise. You didn't contradict my argument, but simply expanded upon your own. It doesn't change or invalidate my argument. Of course, my larger point is that it doesn't matter WHICH of us is right because we both agree there is no connection between the games - it 'doesn't make sense' how or why Eurus was going from where she started to where she finished. The writers didn't provide the necessary connective tissue. They wrote her badly. Saying she is lonely doesn't have anything to do with morality. As I pointed out, and you've NOT contradicted, a completely immoral (or amoral) person can be lonely - or angry - or happy - or jealous - or feel any other emotion. That is NOT a contradiction. As you say, even YOU don't understand WHY she is bringing up loneliness. You say explicitly she might be "trying to use morality to make Sherlock guilty OR SOMETHING." You do NOT know. It is NOT clear - not at all. THAT is the problem. You know what a rationalization is - right? And you know it doesn't change one's feelings - right? That one's feelings and one's ideas are at odds with one another is NOT an indication that her characterization "doesn't make sense". In fact, it is a fact of life for almost ALL people. People DO hold contradictions. They experience feelings which contradict their ideas all the time (revealing, whether they identify it or not, that they hold conflicting ideas - ideas being the result of what one thinks). People experience these contradictions ALL the time. Eurus has such a DEEP contradiction it seems to have literally split her consciousness into two. She is desperate to resolve the contradiction - the conflict - the divide SHE cannot surmount or unite. She's tried to resolve it - all her life - and hasn't been able to resolve it. NOT by herself. THAT is what it means to say she can't land. She can't land by herself. She can't unite herself. She can't resolve the contradiction in her BY herself. She needs help. She needs the one person she knows who is somewhat like herself and who seems to HAVE resolved it. She needs Sherlock. That is why she is DRAWN to Sherlock, not matter WHICH personality we are talking about - and is why she PANICS when she thinks she's going to lose him. HE is her salvation - and she has known that since the beginning - as her poem says explicitly. The rationalized grown up is the wall she has created (like Sherlock) to repress that lonely little child inside of her. But she can NOT escape that loneliness - no matter HOW hard she tries, no matter what she does, no matter what she thinks. It remains - because she has no one to love or be loved by. No. And again, believing morality is useless - and being lonely - are NOT mutually exclusive conditions. One is an idea. One is an emotion. They can - and DO - exist together in reality. Or are you claiming heartless murderers , totalitarian dictators, those who believe in philosophies which reject the concepts good and bad, etc etc are physically INCAPABLE of feeling the emotion 'loneliness'. If so, that is simply false - and I would suggest some good criminal psychology books. I gave you an in-depth explanation for how each of the first 4 games were designed to confirm Euros' hypothesis of morality being useless. If you disagree then please inform me how you interpreted the purpose of each of the first 4 games. I honestly don't see how you can interpret the first 4 games in any other way. You say they're about 'landing'. Elaborate with respect to each game. To be clear I don't believe that all the games are disconnected. I believe the first 4 games are connected. They're each designed to accomplish the same purpose but in rising degrees of intensity. Sherlock is put in a more morally difficult situation with each subsequent game. In the 1st game he has to deal with a guy who betrayed them. In the 2nd it's with people he doesn't know and may be innocent. In the 3rd, it's with Molly, someone who he's close to. In the 4th, it's with Mycroft and John, the two people he's closest to. It's just the 5th and final game which I believe is different and honestly does basically nothing to show that morality is useless. Also why do you think Euros was talking about how lonely she was to Sherlock in his old house? It looked like she was trying to guilt trip him. She was trying to say you left me alone and that made me so sad. If you want to dispute this point then tell me how else you can interpret this scene because I don't see any other way. Euros was playing on Sherlock's guilt and to have guilt you must have morality. This is why I'm saying Euros was contradicting herself in the 5th game. In the first 4 games she was saying that morality is useless. In the 5th game she tries to use morality to help herself so she is effectively contradicting herself. It's ridiculous that Sherlock wins in the 5th game by going to play with lonely Euros because playing with a lonely person is the morally right thing to do. While the purpose of the first 4 games was to show that morality was useless, the 5th game can only be won by recognising the value of morality and that's why it contradicts all the earlier games. I'm not saying an immoral person can't be lonely. I'm saying that Euros is an immoral person who wants to prove that morality is useless. Her first 4 games were designed to prove that point. However in her last game she tries to use morality to make Sherlock guilty. Somebody who says morality is useless and then goes on to use it is contradicting them self. Euros' character isn't in the same category as Sherlock's character. Sherlock doesn't change in 1 minute like Euros does. It takes a long time for him to open up. Euros on the other hand has a whole plan for what she wants to do with the games. However in her last game she starts contradicting herself out of nowhere. What on earth caused her to change?
  8. I don't see her trying to "prove" anything to him. She's studying him and his friends - trying to isolate the difference between her and them. She's trying to determine WHY she can't "land" (and what would be the purpose in landing?) Further, is is a "Morality Maze". But her purpose is to explore how emotion impacts morality. Because that wasn't the point of any of the mazes. But you are correct that there is a disconnect between the games. The fifth game is the final problem - and was planned as such from the beginning. So why ANY of the other mazes? How are they connected. WHY did the different personalities, who seem to have different focus and potentially conflicting goals, end up cooperating to get to the end game? There's no dispute between us about these points. The only thing I've said is this problem is a result of the writers not explaining her character as they needed to explain it. Put simply, character contradiction is not change nor an arc. That's a shift in her focus, not a contradiction. WHY did she shift her focus? Again, bad writing doesn't tell us. Being a ruthless dictator who tortures everyone - and being lonely person who wants a friend - are not mutually exclusive -personalities-. A brutal murderer can want to be loved. He doesn't have to have a multiple personality disorder to be both a murderer AND lonely. I don't see how any of Euros' first 4 games had anything to do with 'landing'. Each of them was designed to prove her hypothesis of morality being meaningless. Euros was NOT conducting the kind of experiments where a scientist goes in with no idea of the result. Rather she was conducting the kind of experiment where a scientist has an idea of the result but wants to run the experiment so they have irrefutable proof that their hypothesis is correct. For Euros, it's clear she already had an answer and just wanted to prove it with each of the first 4 games. In the 1st game, after John refused to kill the director, the director shot himself. Then Euros shot the director's wife and said that John's moral code didn't grant him any advantage because now two people were dead instead of one. In the 2nd game, Euros first killed the innocent suspects. John then yelled at her why she killed the innocent. Euros then killed the guilty and said it made no difference. Killing the guilty or innocent isn't any different and that was supposed to show morality was meaningless. In the 3rd game, after Sherlock made Molly confess to him, Euros revealed that she actually hadn't planted any bombs in Molly's house. Sherlock made Molly confess because he was following his moral code of being the hero. However he ended up toying with her emotions so Sherlock's moral code ultimately made him do a bad thing. That one again proves that morality is useless. That's why Sherlock was angry and destroyed the coffin. In the 4th game, Euros asked Sherlock to shoot either Mycroft or John. Once again his morality was useless. He had to give up one of his loved ones and his morality did nothing but make the decision more difficult. The point of this once again was to prove that morality was useless. That's what Euros was doing. She was trying to confirm her hypothesis of morality being useless in the first 4 games. However in the 5th game, Euros starts talking about how she was lonely and she tries to blame Sherlock for it. That completely contradicts how she was behaving earlier. She believed morality was useless but now she's trying to use morality to make Sherlock guilty or something. What happened to morality being useless? Playing with a lonely person is the morally right thing to do so why were the first 4 games about morality being useless? This is why it doesn't make sense for Euros to be a lonely person who was angry at Sherlock for not playing with her. Her whole philosophy was that morality was useless so in her mind being lonely or not lonely should be meaningless. It doesn't matter if Sherlock treated her well or treated her bad. She doesn't believe in good and bad (she said so herself in those tapes that John and Mycroft were watching of her). It should make no difference to her. I suspect Euros' contradictory character is a result of Moffat and Gatiss (who both wrote this episode) having different ideas of what they wanted to do with her character. One of them wanted to make her a psychopath that believes that morality is useless and wants to prove it. The other one wants Euros to be a misunderstood person who's lonely and wants a friend. However i don't think Moffat and Gatiss realised that these two aspects don't fit together into a personality without coming into conflict with one another.
  9. I have to share this really funny post from reddit user _Oisin: https://www.reddit.com/r/Sherlock/comments/5ocen8/spoilers_mycrofts_house_of_haunted_horrors/
  10. It almost came across like a split personality thing, because it wasn't set up in order not to reveal that he girl on the plane is her. But by not revealing anything about that beforehand it became just a break in character to me. I get why it was necessary from a suspense point of view both to the viewer and for the characters to keep playing Euros little game, but part of me would have wished for a different ending too, as I just couldn't connect the two personalities at all. And that's where I really struggled with the story. Because all other logical flaws aside, I loved it, but it just seemed like a bit of an easy way out and didn't feel particularly satisfying. The thing is even if it's a split personality, I would argue that the Adult Euros personality ends up contradicting itself in the final act because it behaves completely differently from before. The biggest problem is that Adult Euros went to great lengths to prove that her philosophy of there being no good and bad was true to Sherlock. That's what her first 4 games are about. She tries to prove that morality is meaningless. However the 5th game doesn't follow the same logic. in the 5th game, Sherlock just has to find Adult Euros and play with her. That's what the whole 5th game is about. The 5th game doesn't do anything to prove that there is no good and bad or that morality is meaningless. Even Adult Euros acts different when she's on the TV in Sherlock's old house. In Sherrinford she kept talking about how there's no difference between killing the innocent or guilty. However in Sherlock's old house, she starts talking about how she was lonely on the TV. How does that make any sense? If the ultimate goal of these games is to get Sherlock to come and play with her then why was Adult Euros trying to prove that there was no good and bad in the first 4 games? Why was she talking about being lonely in the 5th game? I thought she believed there was no good and bad? What was the purpose of the first 4 games? That's the problem with Adult Euros' personality. It's like she has 2 separate adult personalities: one being the psychopath that wants to prove there's no good and bad and the other being a lonely person that wants a friend.
  11. I agree that he has likely NEVER been the 'bag' man, as it were - he's never been the one to literally pull the trigger. But it isn't that he's shown as being a coward - that he doesn't have the courage of his convictions. He explicitly states he doesn't want to be MORALLY responsible for this person's death: "I can't. This is murder" and more specifically "I will not kill. I will not have blood on my hands". This isn't about having the "stomach" to kill, but not having the morality to kill. Yet we KNOW he does have the morality to kill - and to kill innocents. He DOES have blood on his hands - and he KNOWS it. If this is all about him just being a COWARD about his morals, then that is an even WORSE destruction of his characterization than I was positing. I don't think this was about morality. That was just an excuse that Mycroft used. I think the actual reason had to do with Mycroft's sentiment. I think Mycroft was unable to kill that director guy because he knew him and once had a very good relationship with him. I mean Mycroft trusted him with Euros, the greatest secret of his life. Even when Mycroft is lambasting the director in his office he says stuff like 'I put my full confidence in you'. Mycroft was initially even unwilling to believe Euros had escaped Sherrinford probably because he trusted the director that much. This director may have once been the closest person Mycroft ever had to a friend. Now it's true that the director betrayed him but Mycroft only knew about that for a few hours at most. For most of his life, the director was someone that Mycroft trusted completely. I would argue that Mycroft had an emotional attachment to the director but he just didn't want to admit it. Mycroft is like that. I mean we all know he loves Sherlock but he won't admit it. Mycroft always tries to hide his loving nature. In this episode, Mycroft also tried to tempt Sherlock into shooting him so he could save Sherlock from the agony of shooting John. Basically I think Mycroft is capable of being a cold hearted person who's willing to kill people for the greater good. However this is only if he doesn't have an emotional attachment to the person in question. Mycroft didn't have an attachment to the girl in the plane so he was okay with her dying. However he had an emotional attachment to the director so he couldn't bring himself to kill him. I think Mycroft vomiting at the sight of his former close colleague dying does a good job of showing his humanity. It shows that Mycroft has trouble watching people who he's close to lose their life. That help explains why he's so protective of Sherlock, John and other people he cares about.
  12. Well, as I've stated in an earlier post, the biggest problem in the character arc for me is how they portrayed Euros for the first hour contradicts how she's portrayed in the last half hour. Euros' philosophy is that there is no good and evil. She says that in her tapes. She says good and evil are just stories people tell themselves to justify their survival tactic. She says she doesn't believe in good and evil because she's too clever. She's portrayed to be one of those characters who's so intelligent that good and evil become meaningless to her. She sees herself as a person and everyone else as ants. I can buy why someone so smart would have a perspective like that. Throughout the first 4 games, Euros tries to prove to Sherlock and the others that her philosophy on there being no good and evil is true. She points out how there's no difference between killing the innocent or guilty. She points out the worthlessness of morality. The ideal way for Sherlock to deal with a character like that is to outsmart her. I mean Euros is right in a way that people use morality to compensate for their lack of intellect. Euros believes she's so smart so that's why she throws morality out of the window. Euros believes that she's just stomping on ants when she's killing people but what if she wasn't as clever as she thought she was? What if other people could work together to outsmart her and show her she wasn't as far above them as they thought she was? That's how I was hoping the episode would end. I thought maybe Sherlock and Mycroft would have to use their brains together to outsmart Euros. This would stop her from believing she was as smart as everyone else. Thus she would develop a sense of good and bad like everyone else because she now realises she has flaws and is human as well. However that doesn't happen. Sherlock just plays Euros' game and beats her with brotherly love. This is why I think Euros being the girl on the aeroplane makes no sense from a characterisation purpose. The girl on the aeroplane clearly believes in good and bad but Euros said multiple times in the episode that she didn't. It's like Euros became a different character in the last half an hour. EDIT: Sorry I misread your post as 'specific questions' instead of 'specific threads'.
  13. I think they destroyed the characterization of Mycroft in this episode. He was just contradictory all over the place. Doesn't want innocent blood on his hands in one scene and casually wants to kill innocent girl on the plane in the next. John making all the clever deductions rather than Mycroft in the Gov's office. They made someone we KNOW is demonstrably smart into "the village idiot". I think it's more that Mycroft just doesn't have first hand experience with these things. He just sits back in his office and gives orders. He doesn't actually participate in the action. That's why he's uncomfortable about participating. I think it makes sense for him to do things like vomit after that director commits suicide. Even in the books, Mycroft basically just sat back in Diogenes Club and had Sherlock do all the practical work. I like how this episode showed Mycroft's vulnerable side but I hate how it wrote him out of the final act. IMO Mycroft should have been in the final act as well as he was largely responsible for what Euros was doing.
  14. Am I the only one that thinks that Moffatiss threw all of Euros' characterisation out of the window by making her the girl on the aeroplane? Think of how Euros was portrayed before Sherlock returned to his old home in the 5th game: Euros was somone with no moral code. That's what her first 4 games were all about. That's why she wanted John or Mycroft to shoot the director. That's why she killed all the 3 hanging suspects. That's why she asked Sherlock to choose between Mycroft and John. Euros was trying to prove that morality was nothing. There was no such thing as good and bad. That these are all fairy tales we told ourselves to justify our survival. Euros even said this in the tapes that John and Mycroft were watching. Additionally in one of the tapes, when one of the guys asked her about why she doesn't have a moral code, Euros said it was because she was too clever. That's what Euros was. She was so smart that she considered everyone else to be ants and that's why she had no problem stomping over them. However the girl on the plane has the opposite personality to Euros. She clearly does have a view of good and bad. How else can she be scared of a plane crashing and nobody helping her? She clearly is afraid of dying. How am I suppose to buy that Euros and the girl on the plane are the same person? Their personalities are completely opposite. The only thing that makes sense is if Euros has two different personalities but that's not stated anywhere in the episode so I doubt there's enough evidence for that view to be plausible. Honestly Euros' personality changes completely after the 4th game. When Sherlock is in his home in the 5th game, Euros starts talking to him about how she had no friend and how she was alone. She makes it sound like something bad but that goes against how she was behaving earlier. What happened to there being no good and bad in her eyes? It looks like to me that this episode was rewritten in the last minute. It looks like initially the girl on the aeroplane was a different person but Moffatiss decided to rewrite her as Euros because they thought it would be clever or something. I honestly think it would have been better if Euros was just a deranged psychopath for the entire episode.
  15. The biggest problem with this season is that it looks like Moffatiss didn't know what they wanted to do with it. Each earlier season at least had a clear logical progression: Season 1 - Basically a set up season for Sherlock. Season 2 - Explore Sherlock's flaws. Each episode focuses on one of them: love, fear and demise. Season 3 - Show how Sherlock is now more human after acknowledging his flaws. Season 4 - I don't know. Let's try to do the Sherlock is human thing all over again despite the fact that's what we just did in the last season? It felt like they just killed Mary off just because that's what happened in the books. Then they used Mary's death to create a rift between Sherlock and John despite them already exploring that such a conflict in the beginning of Season 3. Then they decided to focus on some unknown family member of Sherlock because they need to do something big in the final episode? If there is a 5th season, I'd like to see Moffatiss hire another writer. It really look like they've started running out of ideas.
  16. Mycroft said that Eurus has an intellect that rivals Newton's. Moffatiss logic: Intellect that rivals Newton's = Mind control lol
  17. Because of fan service. really what kind of service is it to see her suffer??? I hope if there is a 5th season, that there will be a BIG sorry from sherlock... Some shippers will cling to anything. I'm sure that there are some Molly-Sherlock shippers that are now very happy and are claiming that their ship has been confirmed.
  18. John was shot with a tranquiliser. I don't know about Molly. Yes they took away from Moriarty. Also I was livestreaming and the stream got cut off. Did they explain how Moriarty returned? How did he fake his death? Or was he a twin, double etc?
  19. Am I the only one that hates the ending? It's just another person who's angry because they're not loved story. It can't get more cliche than that. I almost predicted this ending a few days ago: http://www.sherlockforum.com/forum/topic/3548-episode-42-the-lying-detective/?p=114092 Euros wants Sherlock to help her enact her vengeance on her big bad brother Mycroft. In the climax, Euros does a lot of bad stuff. She has Mycroft at gunpoint. Mycroft tells Euros that he loves her. Euros then accepts his apology and willingly gives herself up to the authorities. Euros became insane and a criminal master mind because all along she just wanted Mycroft to tell her that he loved her the same way he loved Sherlock. The End The only difference is that it's Mycroft rather than Sherlock who told Euros that he loves her.
  20. Because of fan service.
  21. Lestrade also says Sherlock is a 'good man' after one of his officers says he's a 'great man'. In the first episode Lestrade told John 'Sherlock is a great man and one day he may even be a good one'. So it looks like all Sherlock had to do in order to become a good man was to express concern for Mycroft's welfare.
  22. This episode was underwhelming. The fan predictions weren't far off and once again the mysteries weren't that intriguing. How Euros could control people with her voice is so convulsed. The whole episode felt more like a tribute to the fans kind of episode. The kind of episode that happens when all the main storylines are wrapped up and the writers just want to confirm shippings etc to make it a warm sendoff to their fans.
  23. Euros wants Sherlock to help her enact her vengeance on her big bad brother Mycroft. In the climax, Euros does a lot of bad stuff. She has Mycroft at gunpoint. Mycroft tells Euros that he loves her. Euros then accepts his apology and willingly gives herself up to the authorities. Euros became insane and a criminal master mind because all along she just wanted Mycroft to tell her that he loved her the same way he loved Sherlock. The End
  24. Just a heads up: the final episode has been leaked via a Russian website. Be careful of where you visit on the internet because people are trying to post up spoilers. There are still about 24 hours until the episode officially airs. This will be 'The Final Problem' that we have to face until watching the season finale.
  25. Certainly not me. I only call her Mary's ghost because I do not find her believable as an inner voice of John's. She's too much exactly like herself and it also comes across as if he's got access to her superior intelligence and insight even though she is no longer actually there, so she seems more like a ghost to me than a part of John's consciousness. Her presence, the way it is done, anyway, is my main complaint about this episode. I had just made my peace with her through The Six Thatchers (no, not because she sacrificed herself, that scene was horrible and tacky if you ask me, lowest point of the show. Sorry for being so drastic, but it really bothered me). Then when she was back in The Lying Detective and so clearly back as herself, not as additional depth to John's character, I felt very, very annoyed. If they cannot stand dead characters, they should just not kill them off in the first place. So there. She takes away so much from the boys. And she gets credit for so many things that were there long before she showed up. Sherlock always knew how to get John to come out of his shell, toss his physical and psychological canes and become himself again. That's how their friendship began in the first place. He wouldn't have needed Mary to instruct him how to "save" his best friend. And John has always wanted to live up to the "good man" ideal that Sherlock labeled him with. At least that's what previous episodes implied (to me, at any rate). Now suddenly it's all about Mary and if she weren't around past her expiration date to help them out the two stupid boys still wouldn't be talking to each other, Sherlock would be completely out of control on drugs and John might have killed himself. Yeah, right. TBH Sherlock wanted to leave John alone because he thought John didn't want to see him (Molly said this herself to him). Sherlock needed permission from Mary to help John. Also I think it's obvious that Mary is meant to be John's guilt of not being able to live up to the good man ideal. We see her throughout the episode until John accepts he wants to be the man that Mary thought he was. Then she disappears. That makes it look like that Mary was just a figure of John's guilt. Maybe using her for comedy wasn't the best idea.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.