Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

OK, so I'm not in bed yet.

 

Could be that the "thud" came before Sherlock himself landed, especially if the "body" was thrown out of a window.  Ten seconds is enough time for lots of shenanigans.

 

Okay, let's accept that.  They are going to hit the ground at the same time, though.  So, looking at the picture and thinking about the scene, where's Sherlock?  bodyhitsb.jpg

 

Possibly we can put him where he belongs: right next to the building.  They could have caught him in an old-fashioned fireman's safety net - fast enough to get there, held low to the ground.  They could have stuck this body inside the building.

 

Firemen's net page: http://my.firefighternation.com/forum/topics/fire-department-safety-nets-did-they-go-away-and-why

 

So - someone tosses the body out of the truck as Sherlock hits.  John can't see them catch him because they came off those buses and have been hiding inside the building for a while with the equipment, so he is behind that.  (I wonder how many of those Sherlock coats they bought at the beginning? ;) )  They knock John down, and ring the phone for - what?  If Sherlock is already in place?  To give him the injection and put out the blood, maybe?

 

(Oh yeah, you might notice I changed to my regular forum name from my other name which is my poker name - I was thinking "games" at the time.)

 

Posted

We only see a small shot of the "body" hitting the ground.  That could easily be Sherlock laying down quickly, or the guys flopping down the body.  That shot of the body hitting the ground doesn't necessarily happen in the time sequence it looks to be- here we have a bit of clever editing.  IF they were really going to have a body hit the ground, why not show more than a quick snippet and then nothing else until John makes his way around the corner.  There's also no way that a body falling face down and perpendicular to the building could hit in such a way that it would lie in even a slightly parallel position.

 

There's also no way to see the shot of Sherlock falling AND John watching him- they are too far apart.  I think it would be disingenous to say that John isn't seeing Sherlock fall because we don't see them in the same shot.  We see the camera pan up from John TO Sherlock earlier in the scene, therefore validating that we are indeed seeing Sherlock talking to John from the ledge of the roof.

 

Well, we could have that shot if they'd wanted to give it to us, we can see the roof and top two floors.  We could have watched from John's POV as Sherlock fell off, and descended at least a floor or two and then cut in to close shots of him. :

 

0928.JPG

 

 

 That shot of the body hitting the ground doesn't necessarily happen in the time sequence it looks to be- here we have a bit of clever editing.

 

 

 I guess I don't understand what you mean.  Do you think they toss this body down while the fall is going on and then show it to us at the end?  

 

 

There's also no way that a body falling face down and perpendicular to the building could hit in such a way that it would lie in even a slightly parallel position.

 

 

 

 

I agree entirely.  Yet, it does.  So, we have a choice and mine is a Mofftiss Error.  Because John and Moriarty's spotters watch the body fall, also.  Isn't John going to think back in a day or  so and go...   wait.... what?   Why would this be carefully planned to fool John and then screw up the position of the body?   I'm just saying I have personally discarded it as having any meaning.  Kind of like how you discarded the different locations as having any.  

 We see the camera pan up from John TO Sherlock earlier in the scene, therefore validating that we are indeed seeing Sherlock talking to John from the ledge of the roof.

 

 

Right, as I mentioned in my blog post.  I have a bunch of shots of that pan, overlapping to where they end.  It's a seamless continuous pan.  Sherlock is on a roof, and he can see John and talk to him.  But that pan doesn't get us to the location of the figure John sees silhouetted on the ledge.  Not in the real world. 

 

We never in that entire conversation ever see Sherlock looking down at John with both of them in the shot again.   John speaks looking up at the figure.  The one that never moves. Sherlock speaks looking down at John, but we don't ever see John again in those shots.  John is talking to dead guy, Sherlock is talking to John.

 

(BTW - this got kind of confusing - if there was an issue you posted and I didn't respond to, please repost so I'll see it if you want me to.)

Posted

TIME TO AND FROM BART'S TO 221B BAKER STREET:

 

It is BBC Canon that it takes 10 minutes to get from Bart's morgue to the flat, John says so in SIB when Mycroft calls from the morgue to say Sherlock is on his way.  John tells Mrs. Hudson that he's on his way, "ten minutes."

 

According to my timestamp, Sherlock enters the roof at 20:02 from the end, John gets back in a taxi for the trip back to Bart's at 16:02 and arrives at 9:57.  I'm not sure what that might mean, but it's all the data I have.

Posted

 

We only see a small shot of the "body" hitting the ground.  That could easily be Sherlock laying down quickly, or the guys flopping down the body.  That shot of the body hitting the ground doesn't necessarily happen in the time sequence it looks to be- here we have a bit of clever editing.  IF they were really going to have a body hit the ground, why not show more than a quick snippet and then nothing else until John makes his way around the corner.  There's also no way that a body falling face down and perpendicular to the building could hit in such a way that it would lie in even a slightly parallel position.

 

There's also no way to see the shot of Sherlock falling AND John watching him- they are too far apart.  I think it would be disingenous to say that John isn't seeing Sherlock fall because we don't see them in the same shot.  We see the camera pan up from John TO Sherlock earlier in the scene, therefore validating that we are indeed seeing Sherlock talking to John from the ledge of the roof.

 

Well, we could have that shot if they'd wanted to give it to us, we can see the roof and top two floors.  We could have watched from John's POV as Sherlock fell off, and descended at least a floor or two and then cut in to close shots of him. :

 

 

 That shot of the body hitting the ground doesn't necessarily happen in the time sequence it looks to be- here we have a bit of clever editing.

 

 

 I guess I don't understand what you mean.  Do you think they toss this body down while the fall is going on and then show it to us at the end?  

 

 

There's also no way that a body falling face down and perpendicular to the building could hit in such a way that it would lie in even a slightly parallel position.

 

 

 

 

I agree entirely.  Yet, it does.  So, we have a choice and mine is a Mofftiss Error.  Because John and Moriarty's spotters watch the body fall, also.  Isn't John going to think back in a day or  so and go...   wait.... what?   Why would this be carefully planned to fool John and then screw up the position of the body?   I'm just saying I have personally discarded it as having any meaning.  Kind of like how you discarded the different locations as having any.  

 We see the camera pan up from John TO Sherlock earlier in the scene, therefore validating that we are indeed seeing Sherlock talking to John from the ledge of the roof.

 

 

Right, as I mentioned in my blog post.  I have a bunch of shots of that pan, overlapping to where they end.  It's a seamless continuous pan.  Sherlock is on a roof, and he can see John and talk to him.  But that pan doesn't get us to the location of the figure John sees silhouetted on the ledge.  Not in the real world. 

 

We never in that entire conversation ever see Sherlock looking down at John with both of them in the shot again.   John speaks looking up at the figure.  The one that never moves. Sherlock speaks looking down at John, but we don't ever see John again in those shots.  John is talking to dead guy, Sherlock is talking to John.

 

(BTW - this got kind of confusing - if there was an issue you posted and I didn't respond to, please repost so I'll see it if you want me to.)

 

 

1. The only way Benedict Cumberbatch can "fall" from the roof is with a crane.  From John's POV, that would leave a very large crane in the picture.  Hence the shots that we see of him falling.

 

2. I don't think the "body" has to hit the pavement at that moment at all.  I think it is taken slightly out of sequence just to make it look that way.  It's a trick that is often used in movies to throw people off.

 

3. The way Sherlock falls is the textbook way for slowing down your descent (hence we know that he is really falling).  Moving his arms and legs was just to assure his audience that he was, indeed, the real Sherlock Holmes and not a fake.  He is lying the way he does so that Watson is assure to only grab the one wrist that is laying out nearest him.  I also wouldn't past Moffat and Gatiss to stage it this way so that Sherlock fans would see the clue and know something is fishy.  But it's not a mistake.

 

4. If Sherlock starts out talking to John from the rooftop, and John has his eyes laser locked on him ("keep your eyes fixed on me!" remember?), then there would be no opportunity for Sherlock to switch out with a corpse or dummy.  Sherlock is performing a magic trick- he needs the audience's full attention on him so that they don't notice what is going on underneath (moving the pad into position, putting the body out on the sidewalk, spilling the blood, getting people into position).  Sherlock does move his arm out to keep John from coming in after him.  However- he IS standing on a ledge very high up...there's only so much movement one can make without accidentally falling off.  

Posted

But one thing we're overlooking is the filmmaker's prerogative of simply ignoring anything they can't explain. (Like why didn't the Tong kidnap Van Coon and Lukis, and torture them till one of them told where the hairpin was -- instead of killing them both immediately, so nobody would have ever found it if Sherlock hadn't figured things out?)

 

SEER-EE-US-LEE!!!  Right?

 

I really hate that episode.  Well, not hate - but - I just can't make myself watch it.

 

I've been hanging onto this, It is a bit of a spoiler - non-specific -  but it is Canon, it comes from Gatiss:

 

 

 

Sherlock's great trick is said to be based on the Arthur Conan Doyle story The Adventure Of The Empty House.

 

Writer Mark Gatis said: "It'll be a version of it, because that's the one in which [sherlock] returns.

 

"How much or how little [we change], I don't know yet.

 

"As before, we cherry pick and we choose bits and pieces of other [stories] that we like. They're always less literal adaptations."

 

 

 

It's from this article also mentioning the hypnotist.  

 

Anyway, I originally thought about "The Empty House,"  (it's in the post) because I feel like we have to have seen plot devices in the show or it has to be in Classic Canon. The wax Holmes in the window  to fool the assassin just seemed to fit with all we can really see of Sherlock from John's POV - a backlit outline with the right clothes and hair.  Also, in that story, there are undercover officers waiting to assist - which I think supports the Mycroft's people portion of the program.

 

So when they announced the name of S3E1, well, it seemed so likely and then Gatiss said what he did.   In "The Final Problem," you'll recall, Sherlock escapes by climbing up a sheer cliff wall and hiding on a ledge.

 

In our case, maybe Sherlock escapes by jumping to a ledge and climbing down a building. 

Posted

I know you don't have much of an opinion of these writers-

 

I'll stop you here.  I am a writer.  I have such enormous admiration for what they have done.  I'd fall at Gatiss' feet salaaming my unworthieness if I met him.   But - they are being so wrapped up in their process, they are letting things slide.  That's just a fact. I want them to expect more of themselves and us.  I want Gatiss to stop explaining jokes and realize that dumb folks don't watch Sherlock.  Unless they are Cumberbatched, I guess. 

 

but have you seen many other tv shows?

 

No, I'm 63 years old and have only watched Sherlock and The Ditzie Debutantes of Dubuque.  I'm hoping Launsette goes back to her husband.

 

This show is one of the best written and best researched tv shows or movies out there.

 

 

You know, this is off-topic and we are going to disagree.  Maybe you should have read what I wrote in About the Blogger:

 

Liking mysteries and procedurals and trusting the BBC not to include the extreme close-ups of carefully crafted to look authentic gore endemic to such shows in America, I gave SHERLOCK a try. 

 

It was stunning. My confession is that I had loved television.  There have been amazing moments connected with not just news footage or documentaries, but great drama and wonderful entertainment.  It all turned to dross, finally, almost all of it.  SHERLOCK, as foolish as it sounds, was like something lost being found.   I wondered if my reaction might have something to do with being twenty inches from the screen:  The streaming images so clear, uninterrupted by either commercials or the necessity to fast forward.  And the currently available, masterfully handled technology certainly is critical to the show's quality.

 

And, of course, there was the music, the relationship, the graphics and photography. The concept.  I think, barring the two lesser episodes, (S1E2, S2E2) what captured me really was seeing Sherlock evolve through the most perfect melding of character and circumstance driving the arc I've ever seen on television.

 

You cannot credit one person or one part of the production when something that stuns appears as theater through any medium.  Writers, directors, actors - the synergy makes this art form unique and when it works, seamless. Still, I cannot help singling out concept as writing.  Writing isn't certain words in a certain order. It's creation of a reality inside your head, the emergence of concept through words. I am more than impressed by the creation, the words and images of the vision of SHERLOCK, than any other portion of the whole.

 

 We have to be careful on forums, on which I have been posting for twenty years, to not make assumptions about one another.  I have no idea if you are a sixteen year old boy or a woman older than myself.  We disagree on how well-researched the show is.  You can start a thread to discuss it if you like. 

 

They will occasionally mess something up- but I guarantee you, they did not mess this up.  The roof change was necessary because the wider roof did not have a clear area where they could shoot the scene- that's why they moved to the smaller roof.  It's not a ruse to throw people off- it's just a necessary evil of filming.  Everything they did in the fall scene was carefully edited and shot so that the clues would be there, but without giving it away.

 

 

Regardless of whether it was changed for practical reasons,  it doesn't mean that's Sherlock John is looking at.  I'm willing to bet it is not.  And unless you have a link to whatever Mofftiss said about this, we really can't use it as evidence of anything, for or against.

 

Posted

 

bborchar: 3. The way Sherlock falls is the textbook way for slowing down your descent (hence we know that he is really falling).  Moving his arms and legs was just to assure his audience that he was, indeed, the real Sherlock Holmes and not a fake.  He is lying the way he does so that Watson is assure to only grab the one wrist that is laying out nearest him.  I also wouldn't past Moffat and Gatiss to stage it this way so that Sherlock fans would see the clue and know something is fishy.  But it's not a mistake.

 

 

 

There is no way, textbook or otherwise, to slow your descent as a free-falling object in 50 feet.   You can do it at height with a parachute or other device.  I agree that they showed him moving his limbs in a purposeful way to demonstrate he is alive during the fall. As I said before, Sherlock also jumps - that doesn't mean the other body didn't fall, also.  It's an editing trick.

 

 

4. If Sherlock starts out talking to John from the rooftop, and John has his eyes laser locked on him ("keep your eyes fixed on me!" remember?), then there would be no opportunity for Sherlock to switch out with a corpse or dummy.

 

I see I have not explained this very well, I'm sorry.  Here's the sequence.

 

Sherlock watches the taxi drive up.

 

John gets out of the car, he does not see Sherlock.

 

John turns his back and walks away, following instructions from Sherlock on his mobile.  While he is not looking, the substitute is placed and Sherlock takes up his position where he sees John but John cannot see him.

 

John is told to stop and look up at the roof ( "Look up; I'm on the roof.") where he sees the outline of "Sherlock"  holding what appears to be a mobile phone to his ear.

 

Moffat gives us the panning shot to Sherlock, but not to what John sees - we just assume that - I believe you referred to editing tricks to fool viewers, this is one of them.

 

John never looks away from "Sherlock" again.  John never at any time sees the real Sherlock, until he's on the sidewalk.

 

 

 Sherlock does move his arm out to keep John from coming in after him.  However- he IS standing on a ledge very high up...there's only so much movement one can make without accidentally falling off.

 

He actually moves his arm out instinctively quite a lot as we see him close-up.  But the figure on the ledge John sees, changes relative angle because John has moved -  but his arm is not out. 

Posted

Everything I have said so far I have evidence or a reason for. Nothing I said is without a reason. I stated my reasons why it is him- you disagree, and that's fine. I said he's up there because we see him up there, on the ledge, talking. If you want to tell me where I need to look to see how Sherlock has changed places and now it is a dummy up there, I will gladly look. But I don't see how we can make that assumption based on the sole fact that it's hard to see him move (even though he clearly raises his arm at one point).

 

Sherlock CAN survive that fall as long as someone has put something for him to land on. Why needlessly overcomplicate something that is already dangerous and requires perfect timing. How could they pull it out of the way? Simple- the all run back toward the garage- John isn't looking that way at all, he's looking at the "corpse" on the sidewalk. From what I've read, those airbags inflate and deflate pretty quickly. It works. It requires perfect timing, but so does every magic trick.

 

I also can't make the determination about what is a mistake, because we don't have all the answers. Sherlock has a lot to dissect- only the writers themselves will ever get every single little in joke. But at the end of the day it's just a show, put on for entertainment, and it seems to me that that do an incredible amount of research for something most people won't remember or really pay attention to in the end. No, I didn't like the blind banker, either, because of inconsistencies in the story (and the incredibly corny ending)... But the thing that immediately struck me was that Sherlock was unable to recognize the old style Chinese numbers- even though he has a print with Chinese characters on it hanging above his bed. So no, not every one is a gem, but it's still fun to watch. And no, I'm not a teenage boy ;)

Posted

They are going to hit the ground at the same time, though.  So, looking at the picture and thinking about the scene, where's Sherlock?

 

(Oh yeah, you might notice I changed to my regular forum name from my other name which is my poker name - I was thinking "games" at the time.)

Yeah, I saw "Julia Mae" and said "who???" but then recognized your (also recently changed!) avatar. No problem (though all your old quotes will apparently still say "AllIn1," as of course will any references to you).

 

I can't see why Sherlock and the dummy/body would have to hit the ground at exactly the same time. True, it'd have to be close, or John might subconsciously notice that something was "off." Just playing with possibilities.

 

 

It is BBC Canon that it takes 10 minutes to get from Bart's morgue to the flat, John says so in SIB when Mycroft calls from the morgue to say Sherlock is on his way. John tells Mrs. Hudson that he's on his way, "ten minutes."

 

According to my timestamp, Sherlock enters the roof at 20:02 from the end, John gets back in a taxi for the trip back to Bart's at 16:02 and arrives at 9:57.

Thanks! I think that's roughly what the other person said, regarding real-life traffic. So, it's a twenty-minute round-trip, but John appears to arrive back at Bart's only ten minutes after Sherlock gets to the roof. Assuming it takes him maybe two or three minutes to climb the stairs, that leaves about seven or eight minutes unaccounted for.

 

 

3. The way Sherlock falls is the textbook way for slowing down your descent (hence we know that he is really falling). Moving his arms and legs was just to assure his audience that he was, indeed, the real Sherlock Holmes and not a fake. He is lying the way he does so that Watson is assure to only grab the one wrist that is laying out nearest him.

There's another possible reason for moving his arms and legs -- it's apparently what skydivers do if their chute fails to open, in order to steer toward a particular landing spot. True, Sherlock didn't have time to do much, but I find it plausible that he could have fine-tuned his landing a bit.

 

 

There is no way, textbook or otherwise, to slow your descent as a free-falling object in 50 feet. You can do it at height with a parachute or other device.

I refer you to flying squirrels, which manage to steer between trees by using the flaps of skin along their sides. Anything that increases wind resistance will slow a falling body to one degree or another. Extending one's arms and legs is a start, but Sherlock's also got his nifty coat. Which reminds me, I was meaning to look and see whether he might possibly have attached the ends of the hem to bands around his ankles.

 

Posted

I listened to the ringing noise when John was hit- but it just sounds like tinnitus to me (not surprising given that he is probably mildly concussed from the fall).  It's why they call it "getting your bell rung"...people seem to hear a ringing sound when they hit their heads.

 

Moving his arms and legs is probably helping him to steer himself to the landing spot.  But I think it also doubles as a way to make the audience realize that it's a live person jumping, not a corpse or dummy falling.

 

There would be time for another body to be put there- if it's done while John can't see them.  Drag it out while they are still talking on the phone.  I personally think that the "close up" shot of Sherlock falling on the ground is either the body being tossed on the ground, or Sherlock taking his position on the ground.  However, the noise we hear may have nothing to do with the picture at all- it could be the sound of him hitting the airbag (which will still make an impact sound).

 

I think the truck being there is a red herring to make people think he jumped into the truck.  Notice how we never see a clear shot of the area near the garage the whole time John is rounding the corner?  That's because the people helping him run across the street and take the airbag with them.

 

I do think he jumped onto an airbag.  After a little research, it looks like they can be inflated and deflated very quickly (in less than a minute for some models). 

  • 4 weeks later...
Posted

Alex & I have just returned to our hotel after visiting North Gower Street, St. Bart's, and the Old Bailey.

 

I have no idea how relevant this is, but The St. Bart's Tree is no longer there.

 

DSCN6520_zpsb5e94274.jpg

 

Judging by the wood-chip-filled circular openings in the sidewalk, there were originally three of them, but now there are none.  They were a fair distance down the block, by the way.

 

Note:  The photo above may disappear (or may turn into something far less relevant) unless I get a better handle on how Photobucket works!

 

Posted

Alex & I have just returned to our hotel after visiting North Gower Street, St. Bart's, and the Old Bailey.

 

I have no idea how relevant this is, but The St. Bart's Tree is no longer there.

 

DSCN6520_zpsb5e94274.jpg

 

Judging by the wood-chip-filled circular openings in the sidewalk, there were originally three of them, but now there are none.  They were a fair distance down the block, by the way.

 

Note:  The photo above may disappear (or may turn into something far less relevant) unless I get a better handle on how Photobucket works!

 

Neither is the bus shelter.  

 

bodyhitsb.jpg

 

Or those silver metal things, whatever they are.    But that green thing on the left is still there.  The "tree circles" in your picture are beyond where that door is into the jutting out building.  It looks like the trees in my picture are nearer than the green thing or level with it.  Prop trees?  Perspective is so difficult to discern in 2-dimensions.

 

BTW, get a Picasa web album and upload your pics to it.  They never ever go away and you just grab the URL.  Much easier than dealing with Photobucket, for me.   I have Photobucket but rarely use it.  I edit in Word, actually. 

 

Nice find, more pics, please!

 

 

Posted

Actually, the bus shelter IS still there, but it's mostly behind the bus in the photo.

 

I think I finally have a (tenuous) grasp on using Photobucket (though I shall definitely keep your other recommendation in mind) -- so, here's a bit of cognitive dissonance for you:

 

DSCN6524_zps03372543.jpg?t=1368385676

 

 

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Actually, the bus shelter IS still there, but it's mostly behind the bus in the photo.

 

I think I finally have a (tenuous) grasp on using Photobucket (though I shall definitely keep your other recommendation in mind) -- so, here's a bit of cognitive dissonance for you:

 

DSCN6524_zps03372543.jpg?t=1368385676

 

So the silver things are bicycle parking, moved closer to the bus stop and entrance.  In your first pic, I think we can see the holes where they were before having been filled-in.

 

In the shot of the body on the ground from the roof, there are no tree circles, either with or without trees.  So those are past the shelter.

 

 

Posted

Right, I'm virtually certain that the circles are where the trees were at the time "Reichenbach" was filmed.  So they were cut down sometime in the past couple of years, which jibes with the apparent age of the wood chips in the circles.

 

But do have a look at the ad on the side of that bus!

 

Posted

Sad that the trees are gone, but it means that they were either sick (happens a lot to ornamental trees planted in the cities because they are often genetically the same, and blights can take them out easily) or they were becoming a nuisance with their roots or branches.  I would opt for the first one, since trees planted in the city often are often picked for their lack of  sprawling roots or branches.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 114 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.