Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

He survived because he never fell.

snail.JPGNowhere to go but down.  Sooner or later, we have to have the courage of our convictions.  I am posting this here and not that other big forum, because the people who post here seem to me very smart, very well-informed, thoughtful and usually are not grinding some ax.  I don't want to Tweet it until it's been vetted.  Anyway - here's the link to the very long blog post: The Reichenbach Evidence: Surviving the Fall.
 
What I have believed from the first time I saw the episode was that A.) Whoever or whatever John is looking up at, is not Sherlock Holmes.  B.) Sherlock is on another roof close by talking to John on his mobile.  Here's the essential point from the post:
 
How Sherlock Survives the Fall

"Through the magic of television.  Or at least, of clever editing of the digital "film."   Whatever is on the roof being made to look like Sherlock, could be a dead body, though getting it upright and stable would take some hidden structure (or extremely convenient rigor mortis).  Possibly Molly (in the Canon story Mrs. Lestrade manipulates the wax figure to make it look as if it moves) when she pushes it off, has a fairly simple cord set-up to make it's arms rise to convince everyone watching it is a living person.

How Sherlock survived the fall is: he didn't fall.  Exactly.  He had to get to ground as quickly
tree3.JPG
as possible, in almost the same time as the substitute.  There was a tree.  It's unclear how tall it is, or if there was another way for the very agile Sherlock (jumper of roofs in pursuit of cabs and of balconies to gain access to locked apartments) to have made his way down the building.

Theoretically he could have simply climbed down.  Or used the tree that could also have blocked John's sight-line when they were talking.  The truck would also have blocked the sight-line between John on the ground and the tree, until he was behind the building."
 
 
(The picture is of the people looking to the right as Watson is running up, in the B.G. is the tree.)
 
 
 
The elements of the theory are at the link.  The point, I think, is that there is no bouncy house of any kind involved.  It's simple: they tossed something (I vote for body) off the roof and scoop it into that laundry truck, Sherlock gets on the ground and the kid doctor gives him an injection that stops his heart.  They fool us with editing.  If you look at the cuts, every one of them, (I have an embarrassingly large number of stills) they are using the experience of viewers used to cuts in scenes meaning something, leading from one logical place to the next, but they are actually cutting to a different location.   They expect us to see, but not observe.
 
When Sherlock tells Molly he thinks he is going to die, he's not kidding because he is.  He's worried he's not going to make it back.  I think, in the end, he wouldn't put himself fully into the hands of Mycroft's people.  He wanted a doctor around who would do anything to save him, that would be Molly, whom he has always trusted.
 
BTW, I have this personal belief, that in this situation, we will see nothing of real import we have not seen before in some form.  I know the injection seems a bit fanciful, but we saw Adler do that very thing right through his suit sleeve.

Posted

He survived because he never fell.

 

snail.JPGNowhere to go but down.  Sooner or later, we have to have the courage of our convictions.  I am posting this here and not that other big forum, because the people who post here seem to me very smart, very well-informed, thoughtful and usually are not grinding some ax.  I don't want to Tweet it until it's been vetted.  Anyway - here's the link to the very long blog post: The Reichenbach Evidence: Surviving the Fall.

 

What I have believed from the first time I saw the episode was that A.) Whoever or whatever John is looking up at, is not Sherlock Holmes.  B.) Sherlock is on another roof close by talking to John on his mobile.  Here's the essential point from the post:

 

How Sherlock Survives the Fall

 

"Through the magic of television.  Or at least, of clever editing of the digital "film."   Whatever is on the roof being made to look like Sherlock, could be a dead body, though getting it upright and stable would take some hidden structure (or extremely convenient rigor mortis).  Possibly Molly (in the Canon story Mrs. Lestrade manipulates the wax figure to make it look as if it moves) when she pushes it off, has a fairly simple cord set-up to make it's arms rise to convince everyone watching it is a living person.

 

How Sherlock survived the fall is: he didn't fall.  Exactly.  He had to get to ground as quickly

tree3.JPG

as possible, in almost the same time as the substitute.  There was a tree.  It's unclear how tall it is, or if there was another way for the very agile Sherlock (jumper of roofs in pursuit of cabs and of balconies to gain access to locked apartments) to have made his way down the building.

 

Theoretically he could have simply climbed down.  Or used the tree that could also have blocked John's sight-line when they were talking.  The truck would also have blocked the sight-line between John on the ground and the tree, until he was behind the building."

 

 

(The picture is of the people looking to the right as Watson is running up, in the B.G. is the tree.)

 

 

 

The elements of the theory are at the link.  The point, I think, is that there is no bouncy house of any kind involved.  It's simple: they tossed something (I vote for body) off the roof and scoop it into that laundry truck, Sherlock gets on the ground and the kid doctor gives him an injection that stops his heart.  They fool us with editing.  If you look at the cuts, every one of them, (I have an embarrassingly large number of stills) they are using the experience of viewers used to cuts in scenes meaning something, leading from one logical place to the next, but they are actually cutting to a different location.   They expect us to see, but not observe.

 

When Sherlock tells Molly he thinks he is going to die, he's not kidding because he is.  He's worried he's not going to make it back.  I think, in the end, he wouldn't put himself fully into the hands of Mycroft's people.  He wanted a doctor around who would do anything to save him, that would be Molly, whom he has always trusted.

 

BTW, I have this personal belief, that in this situation, we will see nothing of real import we have not seen before in some form.  I know the injection seems a bit fanciful, but we saw Adler do that very thing right through his suit sleeve.

 

Is it okay if I ask a few question to refute this?  All in good spirit, please don't get upset about it.

 

1. If it is a dead body, how does the person on the way down flail his or her arms and legs?

 

2. Why would the kid doctor stop his heart when all Sherlock needs to do is fool John is to mask the pulse in his arm (which he can do with the squash ball)?  If the kid doctor was already working for him, he doesn't have to do anything fancy to stop his heart- he just has to make sure John can't take the pulse in Sherlock's carotid artery.

 

3. Even if they had thrown a body from the roof, it still would not have landed the way Sherlock was facing on the ground.  Why would Sherlock lay in a different position than the body was laying if the change in position could have been seen by John before Sherlock could switch out?

 

4.  Going down a tree is really risky and not easy to do quickly.  The top branches of the tree will not be very strong, and definitely will not be strong enough to support a man's weight.

 

5. Why go through all of the trouble of the dead body, tree and injection when a simpler theory would work better and with less risk?

 

 

I would look at what we know for certain.

 

 

1. Sherlock sent a text to Moriarty telling him to come to St. Bart's, on the roof.  We have no evidence that he changed this.

 

2. A live body was falling from the roof, because dead bodies cannot move his arms and legs like that.

 

3. Sherlock is laying in a different position from which he fell.

 

4. John could not see the impact because of the building in the way, and then was knocked over.

 

5. John felt no pulse in Sherlock's wrist.

 

6. Sherlock was carried inside.

 

 

I see no reason NOT to believe that the inflated mat was used to break Sherlock's fall.  Even if someone else jumped for Sherlock, they would STILL need something to break that person's fall.  Given that, why WOULDN'T Sherlock take the fall himself, if he could do it as successfully as someone else (and indeed, who would jump off of a roof for him?).

 

Also, here are some theories regarding the spoilers:

 

 

 

 

The pictures of filming suggest that Sherlock had another body brought out to be his "placeholder".  He then jumped down, ran and hid for a moment (while others took away the mat and another group gathered around his body), got prepared with the blood and squash ball, and then when John is knocked down, he runs over and takes the place of the body.  Once he's taken inside, it seems as if he comes out again immediately, because there is still blood on his forehead.  It's possible that he really did cut his head on the landing, but I am guessing that it is fake blood that he didn't have time to wipe off.  This would mean that he is either trying to escape very quickly, or he's trying to find someone before they run off.  We don't know, and there are other "spoilers"- but I believe that the Moriarty clip and Hypnotist are more red herrings to throw people off.

 

 

 

 

Anyway, hope that helps to vet your theory a bit.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

Is it okay if I ask a few question to refute this?  All in good spirit, please don't get upset about it.

 

Of course I won't be upset, I put this here so it could be vetted.  Although, it might work better if you read the post at the link, which will have answers to some questions.  I have to get to the post office and will come back and discuss your questions.  I hope to have a vigorous debate - but you also said something about a simpler theory.  What theory would that be?  I'd love to hear a simpler theory.

Posted

WARNING- this post may contain some spoilers, however, they are used in conjecture.  

 

 

We both agree that John is taking Sherlock's pulse.  However, I we differ on the manner of Molly's involvement.  Sherlock doesn't need her to make him look dead- he needs her to help organize everything below and then fake the autopsy and death certificate afterwards.  Why would he take a drug to stop his heart just to fake out someone that he could fake out easily enough by putting a squash ball in his armpit?  It's also too unpredictable- something could go very wrong and he would end up actually dead.  No, Sherlock needed Molly to help arrange everything.

 

They could be Mycroft's people- or they could be Sherlock's homeless network, or people that Molly knows.  There's really no way to be certain at this point for whom they are working, but there is no evidence that they work for Mycroft.  Sherlock and Mycroft even make a point of not contacting each other (that we can see).  Sherlock DOES, however, mention his homeless network earlier in the episode - they are "quicker and more lax about taking bribes".  I'm not saying that Mycroft isn't involved- I'm just saying that there isn't any evidence that he is involved at this point.

 

John is looking at Sherlock.  Why do I say that? Because the figure moves.  And we can see Sherlock's back as he falls off of the roof.  He also throws his phone down on the roof.  If there was someone manipulating a dummy, then how are those shots explainable?  He wouldn't fall that way to go down a tree, and no one else is going to fall for him.    We also see a midrange shot of him on the ledge looking for John's cab when it pulls in.  And also dummies can't flail their arms and legs like that.

 

Why does he lift his arm up when talking to John?  Because he is giving the signal down below to the people who cannot hear him to get ready.  We also don't see enough of the tree to make any judgements about it's size - but from my experience in living in a big city with trees planted along the sidewalks, I will say that those trees are usually planted in a planter far out on the sidewalk so that the tree won't grow too close to the buildings (roots are more dangerous than branches, as they can grow into a building's foundation and cause structural integrity), and that they are usually ornamental trees, which don't grow very tall, or maples, which are straight up and very flimsy but fast growers.  That tree is too far away to make a judgment call, but again, there's absolutely no evidence that the tree is even close enough, tall enough or sturdy enough for it to be an option- or that Sherlock is considering using the tree to climb down. 

 

But for the sake of argument, let's assume he is thinking of it and does use a dummy that is being manipulated by Molly- if he is using a dummy on the roof, why not take the safe way down INSIDE the hospital while the dummy is up on the roof?  I don't really see how it is plausible to make a corpse or dummy move like a man, and definitely don't see how someone could manipulate the arms and legs as the dummy goes down.

 

You did ask for a simpler theory, though- Sherlock DID jump.  And I'm going to use some of the spoilers from the shoot to back up my claims.

 

Sherlock's on the roof and looks down while talking to Moriarty.  He may see things starting to come together down below, and he realizes that he can spring his trap to get Moriarty to kill himself- because he can't pull off his jump unless Moriarty is no longer there.  He somehow forces Moriarty's hand, Moriarty eats a bullet, and then Sherlock acts distraught- but why would he act distraught if he was planning on Moriarty to die all along?  He touches his head very strangely- like he is putting something on it.  He also covers his mouth and nose.  He goes to the ledge (which has a mark on it, btw), calls John, boo hoos, holds out his arm, letting everyone below know he's ready, and then does a Peter Pan off of the ledge onto something below that breaks his fall (maybe the blue inflatable thing) and then runs and hides in order to bloody his face and put the ball in his armpit (which he did pocket on his way out of the lab- watch that scene very very closely and you will see that).  People below have already set up a dead body with blood on the sidewalk, which is what John sees when he immediately rounds the corner.  However, he gets knocked over by the guy on the bike, giving Sherlock a moment to run over to the crowd of people and take the body's place as it is dragged away.  John goes over, can't feel Sherlock's pulse, is distraught, and Sherlock is loaded up on a gurney and taken inside.  Notice, however, as he is rolled in- the pigeons on the window above him fly away.  Molly was watching out of the pathology window the entire time, and the only way for her to see all the way down would be to open the window and look over the ledge.  Sherlock is then taken inside the arches, but then wipes some of the blood from his face and takes off from the hospital.  Molly will take care of the rest, by faking his autopsy and papers.  If you want me to, I will gladly put up pictures to support this entire theory.

Posted

I'm sure you'll get plenty of discussion here! I will just mention a few things that kind of jump out at me (and I admit that I haven't read your linked-to post).
 

What I have believed from the first time I saw the episode was that A.) Whoever or whatever John is looking up at, is not Sherlock Holmes.  B.) Sherlock is on another roof close by talking to John on his mobile.


You may have -- consciously or subconsciously -- noticed that the filming was done using two different roofs. The scenes filmed from the roof used one building, and those filmed from the ground used another. This has spawned a number of theories, but if we are to believe Moftiss (and I choose to do so in this case), it was simply a matter of real-life logistics.

 

Whatever is on the roof being made to look like Sherlock, could be a dead body... Possibly Molly ... when she pushes it off, has a fairly simple cord set-up to make it's arms rise....


A dead body or a wax figure, either way, wouldn't look that much like Sherlock without a lot of time-consuming attention to detail. Making it move like a marionette while it fell would seem to require a well-oiled (and invisible) pulley system, an additional complexity.

To my mind, it's easier to say that Sherlock really did fall, but had arranged to land on something sufficiently resilient -- such as whatever was in that truck at the curb. It's logistically simpler, involving far fewer variables (AKA things that could go wrong).

By the way, you mention "Mrs. Lestrade" in canon, but I'm sure you meant to say Mrs. Hudson.

 

He had to get to ground as quickly as possible....  There was a tree....  The point, I think, is that there is no bouncy house of any kind involved.


The big inflated pad in one photo that I posted was for the stunt double to land on, and the "bouncy castle" post was a joke -- again, the real world intrudes. But that's a mere quibble with your wording.

 

It's simple: they tossed something (I vote for body) off the roof and scoop it into that laundry truck, Sherlock gets on the ground and the kid doctor gives him an injection that stops his heart.  They fool us with editing.


Again, our versions of "simple" don't jibe. Though I will offer a variation on your theory that I think is just a bit more tenable: Someone posted -- somewhere -- the amount of time that it minimally takes for a cab to drive from St. Bart's to Baker Street and back, and it's far longer than shown, so right, editing. Sherlock had plenty of time to come down off the roof after Moriarty died, but before John showed up. If that wasn't him that John saw on the roof, then he could have been anywhere nearby (e.g., in that conveniently-located doorway). The subsequent closeups that we saw of him on the roof were merely a cinematic device to indicate what close attention John was paying to the figure that he thought was Sherlock -- John's mental "zoom lens" as it were.

But I don't really think that's the way it happened.

 

He wanted a doctor around who would do anything to save him, that would be Molly, whom he has always trusted.


I agree that Molly was involved, but my assumption is that -- because she's familiar with St. Bart's -- she was in charge of lining up some of the people and materials.

Posted

2. Why would the kid doctor stop his heart when all Sherlock needs to do is fool John is to mask the pulse in his arm (which he can do with the squash ball)?  ... the kid doctor ... just has to make sure John can't take the pulse in Sherlock's carotid artery.

Which he did, by keeping his own hand on Sherlock's carotid. And the other people were preventing John from getting close enough to reach anything except one of Sherlock's wrists.

 

I agree with the great majority of what you say, though I'm not terribly convinced by some of your spoiler.

 

Of course, it's always possible that what seems "obvious" to you and me is actually just a bit too obvious, and therefore a subtle red herring. (Moriarty did say that Sherlock likes to make things complicated ....)

Posted

 

He had to get to ground as quickly as possible....  There was a tree....  The point, I think, is that there is no bouncy house of any kind involved.

The big inflated pad in one photo that I posted was for the stunt double to land on, and the "bouncy castle" post was a joke -- again, the real world intrudes. But that's a mere quibble with your wording.

 

 

 

I just wanted to add why I think the inflated pad IS what he landed on.

 

 

 

 

We don't see any other device used for him to fall on while they are shooting- and whatever he DOES fall on will have to be able to feasibly withstand someone falling from that height (it couldn't be the truck, it's too far off and someone would probably die hitting it- it DOES however, make a great red herring).  They did several shots of him being helped off of the pad by the extras, who then immediately rush the pad away.  The stunt double does use the pad- but Cumberbatch was also taking turns falling off of the crane onto the pad.  The stunt double is also seen wearing the helmet cam- meaning that the shot would be from Sherlock's POV.  If Sherlock is falling face-down, he would see the blue pad. before he turned and landed on his back (which is safer than landing face down).

 

It's all a trick, just a magic trick :)

 

 

 

 

That's fine if you disagree with some of my assumptions because they seem to obvious...I would not be at all surprised to see something completely out of left field when it actually airs.  But I'm hoping that it seems obvious because it makes sense- I definitely didn't come up with all of it the first or even 10th time watching it- so I hope it's obvious in a good way :)

Posted

WARNING- this post may contain some spoilers, however, they are used in conjecture.

... which is fine, as long as the conjectures are not themselves based on recent (major) filming spoilers. Just use your best judgement.

 

 

I'm not saying that Mycroft isn't involved- I'm just saying that there isn't any evidence that he is involved at this point.

I think there is some evidence, in that Mycroft appears to buy into Moriarty's "computer key code" scam, even though he must have people in his organization who would have immediately seen through it. Furthermore, Mycroft reinforces the "key code" concept in John's mind.

Posted

 

WARNING- this post may contain some spoilers, however, they are used in conjecture.

... which is fine, as long as the conjectures are not themselves based on recent (major) filming spoilers. Just use your best judgement.

 

 

I'm not saying that Mycroft isn't involved- I'm just saying that there isn't any evidence that he is involved at this point.

I think there is some evidence, in that Mycroft appears to buy into Moriarty's "computer key code" scam, even though he must have people in his organization who would have immediately seen through it. Furthermore, Mycroft reinforces the "key code" concept in John's mind.

 

 

I will always hide something if I'm straight up talking about something during filming.  :)

 

As far as the Mycroft bit, I was referring to the blog post where it talked about the people on the ground being Mycroft's people.  I was simply mentioning that outside of the key code and talking to John, we have no real "evidence" that Mycroft is helping them.  Sherlock may have called Mycroft while we weren't looking- I would not be shocked at all if he did.  But it wasn't something captured on film, so we can't make any real connections to him.

Posted

OK, I see what you meant about Mycroft.

 

As for the truck being too far from the building, whatever was on it could have been offloaded to the sidewalk, then put back after Sherlock landed on it.  Of course, what was hidden there could have been that blue pad (inflated after unloading), but I still believe that was a "real world" item, both because it was clearly being used for stunt work, and also because I believe Moftiss have been quoted as saying that everything we need to figure it out is in "The Reichenbach Fall" -- and the big blue pad sure as heck was not.

 

Posted

OK, I see what you meant about Mycroft.

 

As for the truck being too far from the building, whatever was on it could have been offloaded to the sidewalk, then put back after Sherlock landed on it.  Of course, what was hidden there could have been that blue pad (inflated after unloading), but I still believe that was a "real world" item, both because it was clearly being used for stunt work, and also because I believe Moftiss have been quoted as saying that everything we need to figure it out is in "The Reichenbach Fall" -- and the big blue pad sure as heck was not.

 

Well, I think it's pretty easy to infer that he landed on something, even if we don't see the thing itself- but if we saw it, or even got a glimpse of it, that would ruin the whole trick, wouldn't it?  The information we need to figure it out is that:

 

a. people are helping him

b. Sherlock is the real jumper and wasn't wearing any sort of device

c. John (nor the audience) can see what is going on

d. Sherlock isn't laying in the same position as he fell

e. He's alive at the end

 

Just from those facts alone, we can reasonably assume that he landed on something big enough and soft enough that he could walk away unharmed.  I guess it's ticky tacky to argue about what he fell on- only that he did fall on something that could break his fall from that height.

Posted

Right.  I was quibbling again.  I do that sometimes.   ;)

 

Posted

I'm sure you'll get plenty of discussion here! I will just mention a few things that kind of jump out at me (and I admit that I haven't read your linked-to post).

 

Well, lots of good ideas and arguments here.  Carol, before I get some dinner and settle down to this complex discussion, it occurred to me with dial-up, you might not be able to load the blog, anyway, it has a LOT of pictures and an animated gif.  I don't care if you read it, but would you try clicking the link and just see if you get there and let me know? 

 

Off for sustenance, you guys demand actual brainwork!

 

http://thesherlockblog.blogspot.com/2013/02/the-reichenbach-evidence-surviving-fall.html

 

Oh yeah, one thing, my "bouncy house" comment was supposed to be a tongue-in-cheek reference.  Too far in?

Posted

I think I'll need to do separate posts or the discussion will become too unwieldy.
 

bborchar: 3. Sherlock is laying in a different position from which he fell.

 
The body we see hit the sidewalk, hits that sidewalk in the same position as Sherlock's body as seen later, perpendicular to the angle of the fall. 
 
These two frames are a split/second apart.  In the first, in a continuous sequence, we see the body hit head first.  In the second, we see the body lying flat.  There's nothing for this body to have landed on.  There is a r ten-second gap between this and John seeing the body on the ground just as the bike hits him, at which point the phone in the booth starts to ring. (WE all know who rings phones in booths at will.)
 
bodyhit1a.jpg


The blur at the bottom of the screen is hair.  We are looking straight up the sidewalk parallel to the building, the body's head is nearest is, not to the right so we are looking at the side of the body.  We can see the light on the back of the coat collar, the left arm splayed out.  Nothing can be seen at all suggesting anything this body could land on, or any room to conceal something that could possibly break the fall.  We see this body hit with no possible time for it to have stopped somewhere along the way. 

 

bodyhitsb.jpg

 

They needed a real body to hit the real ground going about 60 mph.  No mat is going to cushion this fall.  Now, as I have always maintained, there will be no explanation that matches what we see on the screen.  These people are too lazy to use Google to look up tetanus, so, they can throw down a kid's air mattress and say it worked.  It wouldn't.

 

There is obviously nothing large enough to have broken any fall or any place to conceal such a device effectively from observers in other buildings.  They needed a body.  A broken one in case Moriarty's men dug up the grave.  One with a "bashed-in face" that couldn't be recognized.  No one saw the face at the scene but John and Mycroft's people. 

 

Posted

It loaded, no sweat.  Only about a dozen photos, and I'm guessing (haven't checked) that all of the image files are just big enough to look good.  (Have you seen Tumblr?!)

 

I suspect we both need to make more use of smileys.  People seem to have taken seriously my tongue-in-cheek comment that Sherlock survived the fall by landing on that big blue air mattress that was clearly used to protect the stunt double -- at least, I thought it was clear (though come to think of it, that would be a perfect cover for filming the reveal).  I shall go back and insert something!  OK, did that, and put the photo into a spoiler box while I was at it.  Now it's kosher, I think, though ain't nothing perfect.

 

Comments on your blog page (except for parts I've already commented on, or am still digesting):

 

Thanks for posting the hand photos.  I think you've pretty well established that it really was Sherlock on the sidewalk, at least when John got there.

 

I'd already seen a reference to the phone ringing, and listened for it, and yes, it's faint but it's there.  I think the person whose post I read thought it was John's cell phone, and sounded faint because John was woozy.  But you're right, there's a phone nearby, yet not really close.  Aha!  And you're right, we know who can make phones ring.  Hmm.  A signal to someone, apparently, but to whom, and meaning what?

 

 

 

... idiot boy-doctor ... thinks shaking a person who has fallen from a height and probably has spinal cord damage is a dandy idea.

 

That's a valid point only if boy-doctor (who is probably an actual adult, by the way, just not quite as experienced as you and I) doesn't already know that Sherlock's injuries are fake.  If he is in the know, the shake could be a signal to Sherlock that it's time for -- something.  (I am of the tentative opinion that all the people on the sidewalk are in on it.)  Or if you're right, maybe he's checking to see whether Sherlock is comatose yet (I had an idiot anesthesiologist do that to me once).

 

I like your streets-blocked-because-of-construction idea.  I had also decided that the little street between the two buildings must have been blocked, but hadn't thought of the retrofit being used as an excuse, partly because Moftiss said they had decided not to use that idea.  So much for believing them.  Perhaps.

 

 

And on to your recentest post:

 

We see this body hit with no possible time for it to have stopped somewhere along the way.

 

Forgot to mention that I think there actually is a fake body, but it's used only for the "thud!" sound effect, for John's benefit.  Admittedly, if it's an actual body, it would have to be thrown off the roof in order to achieve an appropriate velocity, but using something heavier and/or squishier would yield the same effect.  So it could have been dropped out of a window or possibly even off the truck.  And then it was carted off, and Sherlock laid down in its place (more or less), because seeing his recognizable face would definitely fool John as no faked-up body could ever do.

 

Posted

One of the things I think everyone agrees on, is that Mofftiss, in one incarnation or another, said all the information necessary to explain Sherlock being alive is in the episode.  In this discussion, nothing from the filming of S3E1 should be considered evidentiary.  What Moffatt or Gatiss say can be, but it also has to be referenced or quoted, not paraphrased.   Not because I think I should make up arbitrary rules, but because writers will skirt the truth in public statements to maintain their fictional world's mystery.  So, we all have to be able to examine exactly what was said to see if we agree it seems straightforward, and not be interpreting what we remember for one another which will only lead to more confusion.  

My question right now about the Mofftiss statements is: Did they just say they shot from different rooftoops?  (Which I thought they made purposely obvious on my first watching, otherwise why the semi-panormatic fisheye of the rooftop?)  Or did they say specifically that viewers should ignore that completely when theorizing about the fall?
 

bborchar: If it is a dead body, how does the person on the way down flail his or her arms and legs?

First, we have no shot of John/falling body in the same frame.  We have reaction shots of John seeing something and then we see a falling body. The one we do see may be Sherlock, we might never have seen the other body at all until it strikes the ground.  There are three separate sequences of a falling body that are cut together.  They are all in the wrong position relative to the angle of impact.  Mofftiss Error?  Or, are they all of Sherlock, jumping from a different location and aiming for something?

 

The first frame is when we see what we believe is Sherlock falling forward after raising his arms.  The second is the very next cut.  That sure isn't the rooftop Sherlock entered to confront Moriarty or the one John is looking up at.  Another Mofftiss Error?  (Maybe I should just call that the EM factor.)

 

711a2.jpg
 

711b2.jpg

Posted
My question right now about the Mofftiss statements is: Did they just say they shot from different rooftoops?  (Which I thought they made purposely obvious on my first watching, otherwise why the semi-panormatic fisheye of the rooftop?)  Or did they say specifically that viewers should ignore that completely when theorizing about the fall?

 

They mentioned that they used one roof for Sherlock to step off of, because there was a wide ledge or another roof just a few feet below, for Cumberbatch to land on.  Then they used a different roof for the shot where he's seen falling (on a wire).  I don't recall whether they make any explicit declarations regarding "canon" aspects of the scene.  And of course everything I've said is mere paraphrase.  Even if it were an exact quote, though, people have been known to do amazing things with weasel words.  Contrariwise, I personally wouldn't base any theories on the two roofs unless there's other evidence to support the same aspects of the theory.

Posted

bborchar: Sherlock sent a text to Moriarty telling him to come to St. Bart's, on the roof.  We have no evidence that he changed this.

Why would he have?  Of course he was with Moriarty on the roof of Saint Bart's  But that's a complex building, with two wings and more than one roof area.  There are also additions, and those newly-built buildings have their own adjoining roofs.  We've seen this in other shots of St. Bart's. As it says in the blog post, Sherlock  isn't far away, he's just on the next roof. He glances over his right shoulder toward Moriarty's body, which I imagine he does see.

 

I had an alternative for where Sherlock could be standing on the roof, but Moffat stuck that pan in there from John on the ground to Sherlock on the roof, so there's not much choice. 

 

bborchar: Why would the kid doctor stop his heart when all Sherlock needs to do is fool John is to mask the pulse in his arm ...

 

I disagree with this presumption.  But I've always found them treating John like a medical moron exceedingly irritating, so in their world you may be right.  But in fact, you cannot convince a former Army doctor with combat experience that a person is dead by absence of a radial pulse.  When they roll the body, the eyes are open.  Respiration is necessary if Sherlock is faking it.   No one knows if they will be able to keep Watson from insisting on examining Sherlock more thoroughly, though they have a lot of hands to help.  He's killed people.  He has bad days.  Sherlock can't just hold his breath and he certainly can't control his pupillary reaction.  He needs to be dead.

 

eyesopen.JPG

 

If the kid with the stethoscope is actual doctor, he has done everything you can possibly do wrong with a fall victim.  He has rolled him, shaken him rolled him some more. 

 

However, this show is consistent in presenting us with ludicrously improbable medical situations and expecting everyone to just ramp up their suspension of disbelief.   My theory is based on presuming they took real care with this.  

 

Posted

We only see a small shot of the "body" hitting the ground.  That could easily be Sherlock laying down quickly, or the guys flopping down the body.  That shot of the body hitting the ground doesn't necessarily happen in the time sequence it looks to be- here we have a bit of clever editing.  IF they were really going to have a body hit the ground, why not show more than a quick snippet and then nothing else until John makes his way around the corner.  There's also no way that a body falling face down and perpendicular to the building could hit in such a way that it would lie in even a slightly parallel position.

 

There's also no way to see the shot of Sherlock falling AND John watching him- they are too far apart.  I think it would be disingenous to say that John isn't seeing Sherlock fall because we don't see them in the same shot.  We see the camera pan up from John TO Sherlock earlier in the scene, therefore validating that we are indeed seeing Sherlock talking to John from the ledge of the roof.

Posted

They needed a real body to hit the real ground going about 60 mph.  ... as I have always maintained, there will be no explanation that matches what we see on the screen.

 

.... They needed a body.  A broken one in case Moriarty's men dug up the grave.  One with a "bashed-in face" that couldn't be recognized.  No one saw the face at the scene but John and Mycroft's people.

Right, no single explanation would explain everything we saw. Which is why I agree with you that there were two bodies. Or something like that.

 

Nobody saw the face except John and whoever-those-people-were -- and Moriarty's henchmen looking through their telescopes and gun sights. I'm still wondering about the guy in the staircase, who appeared to have a clear view of the sidewalk.

 

But one thing we're overlooking is the filmmaker's prerogative of simply ignoring anything they can't explain. (Like why didn't the Tong kidnap Van Coon and Lukis, and torture them till one of them told where the hairpin was -- instead of killing them both immediately, so nobody would have ever found it if Sherlock hadn't figured things out?)

Posted

Respiration is necessary if Sherlock is faking it.   No one knows if they will be able to keep Watson from insisting on examining Sherlock more thoroughly, though they have a lot of hands to help.  He's killed people.  He has bad days.  Sherlock can't just hold his breath and he certainly can't control his pupillary reaction.  He needs to be dead.

Hidden in there is actually an argument against your poison theory. Sherlock's pupils were not dilated. I rather suspect that John will eventually notice this upon playing back his memories, but will chalk it up to wishful thinking.

 

As for the respiration, Sherlock can control his breathing sufficiently to make it very shallow for a short time. (Heck, even I can do that!) And John was being jostled and held back.

 

You're right about John, we've seen him play Loose Cannon a few times. But there are way more of them, and who knows, they may also have martial-arts skills.

 

I'm going to bed!

 

Posted

It loaded, no sweat.  Only about a dozen photos, and I'm guessing (haven't checked) that all of the image files are just big enough to look good.  (Have you seen Tumblr?!)

 

Thanks for checking, I was thinking of taking my gif down, but if you had no trouble, I think it's fine.  This is my Tumblr blog.  It's just pics and I don't get there much. (No spoilers, just nice BC pics) I use it to keep up with  Johnlock.   I was the only one with this one for about - oh -  the five minutes it took me to tweet it!! 

 

st12.JPG

 

 

I suspect we both need to make more use of smileys.

Yes, or we need a chat thread to just hang out in and get to know each other and stuff so we can hear each other's voices. You seem to have the same sort of "subtle wit" (sure - that's it, right?) that I do.

 

I'd already seen a reference to the phone ringing, and listened for it, and yes, it's faint but it's there. I think the person whose post I read thought it was John's cell phone, and sounded faint because John was woozy. But you're right, there's a phone nearby, yet not really close. Aha! And you're right, we know who can make phones ring. Hmm. A signal to someone, apparently, but to whom, and meaning what?

It starts the second John hits the ground. My thinking is, it signals them that he can't see the impact area and they can make the switch with Sherlock.

 

That's a valid point only if boy-doctor (who is probably an actual adult, by the way, just not quite as experienced as you and I) doesn't already know that Sherlock's injuries are fake. If he is in the know, the shake could be a signal to Sherlock that it's time for -- something. (I am of the tentative opinion that all the people on the sidewalk are in on it.) Or if you're right, maybe he's checking to see whether Sherlock is comatose yet (I had an idiot anesthesiologist do that to me once).

I at first thought it was a signal until I became convinced the only way Sherlock is afraid he's going to die, as he tells Molly, is that he has to be pretty dead.  I made a leap that he was trying to help get the drug into Sherlock's system, but I LOVE your personal experience - an anesthesiologist trying to determine if you were out.  That fits.

 

I like your streets-blocked-because-of-construction idea. I had also decided that the little street between the two buildings must have been blocked, but hadn't thought of the retrofit being used as an excuse, partly because Moftiss said they had decided not to use that idea. So much for believing them. Perhaps.

Can we find exactly what he said?

 

And on to your recentest post:

 

We see this body hit with no possible time for it to have stopped somewhere along the way.

Forgot to mention that I think there actually is a fake body, but it's used only for the "thud!" sound effect, for John's benefit. Admittedly, if it's an actual body, it would have to be thrown off the roof in order to achieve an appropriate velocity, but using something heavier and/or squishier would yield the same effect. So it could have been dropped out of a window or possibly even off the truck. And then it was carted off, and Sherlock laid down in its place (more or less), because seeing his recognizable face would definitely fool John as no faked-up body could ever do.

 

 

I'm just going back to what I said: there's no time.  Look at those pics I posted of the body hitting and on the ground.  Where would Sherlock be?  Honestly, bodies just don't fall outward no matter how much their arms flail - he cannot have gotten into the truck bed, which is, as far as I can see, the only option for falling safely and being concealed.   If Mofftiss tell us that, it will be so very disappointing to me.  If you watch the fall/hit again and can find any time, I'm so ready to hear a new explanation. There's just no time between watching the fall and the thud for anyone to have caught Sherlock, gotten out of frame (which we see is empty) and seeing the body hit.

 

BUT - there are ten seconds almost exactly between that body hitting the ground and John coming around the building.

Posted

OK, so I'm not in bed yet.

 

Could be that the "thud" came before Sherlock himself landed, especially if the "body" was thrown out of a window.  Ten seconds is enough time for lots of shenanigans.

 

Posted

 

bborchar said: 4.  Going down a tree is really risky and not easy to do quickly.  The top branches of the tree will not be very strong, and definitely will not be strong enough to support a man's weight.

 

 

 

 

I don't think the risk is the deciding factor here as much as the spindlieness of those top branches.  When I saw the threes, I was mostly thinking how well they would conceal Sherlock from John if he ever happened to glance in that direction away from the figure on the ledge.  But then, they don't have to support his weight as much as break his fall.   What he needs is to get to the ground very fast - in a few seconds. 

 

I also noticed in the second picture, there seem to be two trees.  There could be something suspended between them for him to fall into, but that gets us into imagination and not BBC Canon.  Of course, in Sherlockworld, those threes can be as strong as Moffat wants them to be.  I'm not that delighted with the tree as landing site, either.  I'm just not seeing one other thing in the scenes that seems logical at all.

Posted

 

bborchar: Sherlock sent a text to Moriarty telling him to come to St. Bart's, on the roof.  We have no evidence that he changed this.

Why would he have?  Of course he was with Moriarty on the roof of Saint Bart's  But that's a complex building, with two wings and more than one roof area.  There are also additions, and those newly-built buildings have their own adjoining roofs.  We've seen this in other shots of St. Bart's. As it says in the blog post, Sherlock  isn't far away, he's just on the next roof. He glances over his right shoulder toward Moriarty's body, which I imagine he does see.

 

I had an alternative for where Sherlock could be standing on the roof, but Moffat stuck that pan in there from John on the ground to Sherlock on the roof, so there's not much choice. 

 

bborchar: Why would the kid doctor stop his heart when all Sherlock needs to do is fool John is to mask the pulse in his arm ...

I disagree with this presumption.  But I've always found them treating John like a medical moron exceedingly irritating, so in their world you may be right.  But in fact, you cannot convince a former Army doctor with combat experience that a person is dead by absence of a radial pulse.  When they roll the body, the eyes are open.  Respiration is necessary if Sherlock is faking it.   No one knows if they will be able to keep Watson from insisting on examining Sherlock more thoroughly, though they have a lot of hands to help.  He's killed people.  He has bad days.  Sherlock can't just hold his breath and he certainly can't control his pupillary reaction.  He needs to be dead.

 

eyesopen.JPG

 

If the kid with the stethoscope is actual doctor, he has done everything you can possibly do wrong with a fall victim.  He has rolled him, shaken him rolled him some more. 

 

However, this show is consistent in presenting us with ludicrously improbable medical situations and expecting everyone to just ramp up their suspension of disbelief.   My theory is based on presuming they took real care with this.  

 

 

They don't treat him like a medical moron- far from it...he would known that Sherlock was a goner from that height.  Sherlock is a master manipulator and knows John better than he knows anyone, so he knows how to convince John he's dead.  John just saw his best friend, basically his brother, jump from a tall building after listening to his last words and being unable to help him.  No doctor would be thinking straight or clearly after that- he's in shock.  There's a reason many doctors don't operate on their loved ones.  Sherlock is counting on John's distress (and indeed, he does everything he can to increase it), and add on top of that a mild concussion, and you have an extremely good reason why John was in shock.  Several people are pulling him away from Sherlock when he tries to get to him.  They are supposed to do that, that's why they are there.

 

I know you don't have much of an opinion of these writers- but have you seen many other tv shows?  This show is one of the best written and best researched tv shows or movies out there.  They will occasionally mess something up- but I guarantee you, they did not mess this up.  The roof change was necessary because the wider roof did not have a clear area where they could shoot the scene- that's why they moved to the smaller roof.  It's not a ruse to throw people off- it's just a necessary evil of filming.  Everything they did in the fall scene was carefully edited and shot so that the clues would be there, but without giving it away.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 99 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.