Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi,

I was watching the episode: the reichenbach fall, and near the end when Watson gets the msg that Mrs Hudson is serious and reaches Baker Street, why are cops not keeping an eye on the house incase one of them turns up there? Isn't that how normally police works?

 

As I start watching episodes, I realize there are things I didn't understand but was so amazed by the stories and the actors that I over look lol

 

Please help me out.

Posted

Someone wrote a short story trying to explain that. Seems that Lestrade was covertly working with Sherlock. He had called Baker Street warning John and Sherlock that the police had a warrant and was on their way, hoping that Sherlock would take a runner. He didn't. After the "hostage" taking, Lestrade told the police that Sherlock would be smart enough not to return to Baker Street so led the police force on a merry goose chase all around London to keep them away from it.

  • Like 1
Posted

Hello, dkmystery -- welcome to Sherlock Forum! :welcome:

 

That's a very good question (I've wondered the same thing myself). I like Bakerstreet's suggestion. There must be a great many things going on behind the scenes in this episode, which will presumably be explained in the next episode.

 

 

As I start watching episodes, I realize there are things I didn't understand but was so amazed by the stories and the actors that I over look lol

Oh, my goodness, yes! I must have seen each episode several dozen times already, and I'm still noticing new things. Sometimes I think they made a mistake, but -- especially in this particular episode -- maybe I just don't understand yet.

  • Like 1
Posted

Intentional plot hole that may or may not get explained?

 

Personally I like the Lestrade leading the police astray intentionally thing.

  • Like 1
Posted

Personally I like the Lestrade leading the police astray intentionally thing.

I like it too. After working with Sherlock for so many years, I would find it very hard to believe that Lestrade would believe the man to be a fake and a fraud.

  • Like 2
Posted

Someone wrote a short story trying to explain that. Seems that Lestrade was covertly working with Sherlock. He had called Baker Street warning John and Sherlock that the police had a warrant and was on their way, hoping that Sherlock would take a runner. He didn't. After the "hostage" taking, Lestrade told the police that Sherlock would be smart enough not to return to Baker Street so led the police force on a merry goose chase all around London to keep them away from it.

 

ah, this really makes sense! the 1st time I saw the epi, I was lost in Ben and his portrayal.. the 2nd time trying to look for clues and it was only the 3rd time that I thought about the cops lol
Posted

Hello, dkmystery -- welcome to Sherlock Forum! :welcome:

 

That's a very good question (I've wondered the same thing myself). I like Bakerstreet's suggestion. There must be a great many things going on behind the scenes in this episode, which will presumably be explained in the next episode.

 

 

 

 

Oh, my goodness, yes! I must have seen each episode several dozen times already, and I'm still noticing new things. Sometimes I think they made a mistake, but -- especially in this particular episode -- maybe I just don't understand yet.

 

Thanks so much :) It is fun to be among fellow Sherlock lovers!

Did you guys see the set coming to life? I hope all our questions get answered in the coming episodes and that Watson will have some pretty things to say to Sherlock for giving him such a heart attack lol

 

This show is really awesome coz of this.. each time we notice something new, the team has done a gr8 job B)

  • Like 2
Posted

Intentional plot hole that may or may not get explained?

 

Personally I like the Lestrade leading the police astray intentionally thing.

 

Yeah and specially after his 'boss' mocked him for trusting Sherlock :angry:

I loved when Watson punched him hahahaha

Posted

I like it too. After working with Sherlock for so many years, I would find it very hard to believe that Lestrade would believe the man to be a fake and a fraud.

 

True. Watson, Lestrate, Mrs Hudson, Molly - they will always stand up for our hero.
Posted

Thank you all for the welcome :inlove:

 

And sorry, but I have another question - could be dumb but still here it goes... :)

 

In the episode where Watson reaches the Diogenes Club to meet Mycroft, why do the people there behave so strange? and then those 2 men pick him up shutting him...

 

They should have a 'spin-off', where mere mortals like me get explained everything lol

Posted

I think that was explained by Mycroft later - in that particular room, silence is the rule due to the amount of conflicting politics whizzing around, one which John broke, and that is why they were all a bit twitchy.

 

Found the quote, thanks to Ariane DeVere's transcripts on LJ!

 

MYCROFT: Tradition, John. Our traditions define us.

JOHN: So total silence is traditional, is it? You can’t even say, “Pass the sugar.”

MYCROFT: Three-quarters of the diplomatic service and half the government front bench all sharing one tea trolley. It’s for the best, believe me. They don’t want a repeat of nineteen seventy-two. But we can talk in here.

Also, the elderly gentleman with the stick who was really freaking out was Douglas Wilmer, who played Sherlock Holmes in the 1964-65 TV series.

  • Like 2
Posted

Hi Dkmystery!

 

The scene at the Diogenes club is also a salute to the original canon. Watson first meets Mycroft at the Diogenese club in The Greek Interpeter. It is a club for misanthropists...haters of mankind. They do not speak to one another in the club...ever. And this is Mycrofts' club. The original Watson has the same trouble our John has 100+ years later.

 

I love the way the writers and produces KNOW their Sherlock :)

  • Like 2
Posted

The scene at the Diogenes club is also a salute to the original canon. Watson first meets Mycroft at the Diogenese club in The Greek Interpeter. ... The original Watson has the same trouble our John has 100+ years later.

 

I love the way the writers and producers KNOW their Sherlock :)

And I'm glad that you know your Sherlock! Now I'll have to read "The Greek Interpreter" (though I'll have trouble reading the title without giggling, I'm sure). Thanks for the tip!

Posted

It is amazing to me, Carol, how very real Sherlock Homles is. As you read the Doyle stories, he becomes. That is the best way I can put it. By the end of the canon, you believe this man actually existed in Victorian/Edwardian England. And to think that he 'really' didn't, makes one (or at least me) a bit sad. The world needs Sherlock. And Watson. For sure.

Posted

My sister said something like a couple of weeks ago while she was reading "Mrs. Hudson's Diaries, a view from the landing of 221 B Baker Stree".

 

Then there is this from the last pages of the William S. Baring Gould "Annotated Sherlock Holmes" intitled "Appendix 1

L'ENVOI"

 

"And so at last we come to say farewell to an immortal three-to the Detective and the Doctor and the man who created them both. And yet-as Vincent Starrett has so truly put into words the thoughts that many of us feel.

 

.....they still live for all that love them well: in a romantic chamber of the heart: in a mostalgic country of the mind: where it is always 1895"

 

And most interesting of all. I bought a magazine called "Real CSI Cases....True stories of Authentic Forensic Science" and on the back cover and in the forward, low and behold, Sherlock Holmes is quoted. Go figure. He is not dead, nor lost to us, not even in the real world of science and deduction.

  • Like 2
Posted

Someone once asked Leo Rosten whether his "Hyman Kaplan" stories were true, and he replied, "Yes, they are all true -- but they never happened." Same applies to the Conan Doyle canon (and to Sherlock), I think.

  • Like 1
Posted

I think that was explained by Mycroft later - in that particular room, silence is the rule due to the amount of conflicting politics whizzing around, one which John broke, and that is why they were all a bit twitchy.

 

Found the quote, thanks to Ariane DeVere's transcripts on LJ!

 

 

 

Also, the elderly gentleman with the stick who was really freaking out was Douglas Wilmer, who played Sherlock Holmes in the 1964-65 TV series.

 

ah, wow.. thanks for the detailed reply!
Posted

Hi Dkmystery!

 

The scene at the Diogenes club is also a salute to the original canon. Watson first meets Mycroft at the Diogenese club in The Greek Interpeter. It is a club for misanthropists...haters of mankind. They do not speak to one another in the club...ever. And this is Mycrofts' club. The original Watson has the same trouble our John has 100+ years later.

 

I love the way the writers and produces KNOW their Sherlock :)

 

oh gosh. this is awesome. now i know why original sherlock fans have no issue with this show coz the writers themselves, as u rightly said, know their sherlock!!
Posted

ah, wow.. thanks for the detailed reply!

Detailed replies are aely's specialty! ;)

 

 

now i know why original sherlock fans have no issue with this show coz the writers themselves, as u rightly said, know their sherlock!!

I believe you're right about many (perhaps even most) Conan Doyle fans. But there are nevertheless those who refuse to watch Sherlock because it's too modern, just as there are those who won't watch Elementary because it's set in New York and Watson is a woman. Nobody has enough time to watch everything that's on television (and few of us would want to), so we each have our own criteria for choosing -- but I feel kind of sorry for Holmes fans who are missing Sherlock and Elementary for such arbitrary reasons.

  • Like 2
Posted

Detailed replies are aely's specialty! ;)

 

 

 

 

I believe you're right about many (perhaps even most) Conan Doyle fans. But there are nevertheless those who refuse to watch Sherlock because it's too modern, just as there are those who won't watch Elementary because it's set in New York and Watson is a woman. Nobody has enough time to watch everything that's on television (and few of us would want to), so we each have our own criteria for choosing -- but I feel kind of sorry for Holmes fans who are missing Sherlock and Elementary for such arbitrary reasons.

 

:)

 

I follow both, Sherlock and Elementary. Though I prefer the BBC version not because Elemantry used the same idea or that Watson became a female, I just can't associate Johnny's character with Sher :mellow: Maybe if they didn't claim to be Holmes n Watson... I watch it coz I love detective shows ^_^

and then, even when the BBC one goes for 90mins I don't skip any scene but unfortunately lately I have started forwarding scenes of Elementary n still don't feel like I missed anything.

 

No offence meant to any Elementary fans here :)

Posted

I feel much the same way. After watching Jeremy Brett and Benedict Cumberbatch's interpretations of Sherlock the CBS version seems like a fine soda gone flat. It could be that a one hour show just can't get into the finer nuances of Holmes. But I do watch it from time to time. It's not terribly bad.

Posted

I feel much the same way. After watching Jeremy Brett and Benedict Cumberbatch's interpretations of Sherlock the CBS version seems like a fine soda gone flat. It could be that a one hour show just can't get into the finer nuances of Holmes. But I do watch it from time to time. It's not terribly bad.

 

Exactly, they should have not used the name of Holmes and should have gone for shorter but tighter episodes. The moment one can miss scenes and yet not feel like missing anything, it shows the makers need to do more on the content!
Posted

I follow both, Sherlock and Elementary. Though I prefer the BBC version

You've watched both, so you're able to compare the two. It's the Holmes fans who have written off both shows without ever watching a single episode of either one who puzzle me.

 

 

Elementary is working under the handicap of being an American television series. They have to pump out 45 minutes of air time every week for 22 weeks, which comes to 16.5 hours every year -- as opposed to Sherlock's three 90-minute episodes every year-and-a-half or so, which works out to only 3 hours per year. Any direct comparison between the two would clearly be unfair, but all things considered, I think Elementary is very good. (Please bear in mind that even Sherlock has some major plot holes.)

 

That said, I make a point of watching Elementary -- but I am a Sherlock fan.

  • Like 1
Posted

You've watched both, so you're able to compare the two. It's the Holmes fans who have written off both shows without ever watching a single episode of either one who puzzle me.

 

 

Elementary is working under the handicap of being an American television series. They have to pump out 45 minutes of air time every week for 22 weeks, which comes to 16.5 hours every year -- as opposed to Sherlock's three 90-minute episodes every year-and-a-half or so, which works out to only 3 hours per year. Any direct comparison between the two would clearly be unfair, but all things considered, I think Elementary is very good. (Please bear in mind that even Sherlock has some major plot holes.)

 

That said, I make a point of watching Elementary -- but I am a Sherlock fan.

 

ah, i can't be a blind hater. it's ridiculous to pass judgement without even watching the show lol

 

n yes, after having seen both, i will prefer the BBC one. Like you said, they need to churn out episodes every week while Sherlock writers have time to bring out 3 movies each year and they are doing a fab job with that.

I too will keep watching Elementary but like I said, I skip scenes and in Sherlock I don't. Hope this changes for ele. n doesn't for Sher :D

  • Like 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 101 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.