Jump to content

BLS_Pro

Detectives
  • Posts

    361
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    1

Everything posted by BLS_Pro

  1. The wink and nod: My eyes may be bad but I just don't see it. Sherlock smiles a bit with his eyes (we can't see his mouth because of the tissue), but I see that as him smiling about his own lack of understanding of human nature. "Wink and nod" is simply an expression here. It identifies that the words stated are meant to be other than the truth by the way they are stated. For example, in the last sequence, Mary tells Sherlock that he will be at the wedding. And Sherlock tells her that weddings really aren't his thing - but then ever so slightly, he literally winks at her, letting her know the truth: of course he will be there. It is the same with aftermath of the headbutt. Mary accuses him of not knowing human nature. And he uses his voice - its intonations - to tell her he definitely knows it. He goes from playful and alloof with his first "no" to wise and knowing with his second "no". It's not him "smiling" at himself, but revealing himself. Of course he knows what he's been doing. It is *why* Mary takes a liking to Sherlock and why he agrees to help him. He isn't an idiot. He hasn't been witlessly callous with the man she loves. She sees what he has been trying to do - and agrees to help him do it. As I point out to toby, this is the opposite of the truth. Take the HOUNDS example I provided. Or take the Molly example from SCANDAL. Or even the entire plot and resolution from SCANDAL. There are a dozen other big and small instances which demonstrate that he is indeed aware of, and can deal with, emotions quite well. I have to disagree here completely. I would suggest the scene with Mycroft demonstrates that Sherlock has thought a lot about "friends" and "friendship" while he has been gone. Like HOUNDS, he doesn't have to. Sherlock knows. He is not blind (if he were, the first punch would have opened his eyes). He is not stupid. He is not unreflective. He is not...fill in the blank. Whatever you want to call it, ignorance is not his problem. Indeed. It wouldn't have been a farcical comedy. It would have been a more truly heartfelt return (which is not to say there couldn't have been humor in it - simply that the humor wouldn't have been at the expense of story and character development). Humor was used here to cover up the fact that the plot they set to be resolved, isn't. This story could have been great. Instead, its not even good.
  2. That's pretty much my impression, too. But I think both would have been a bit embarrassed at their own selves if the conversation had gone on seriously. Except that Sherlock has no problem expressing his feelings to John. And John is indeed capable of accepting apologies and giving forgiveness - without it having to be forced from him. Consider HOUNDS. Sherlock insults John greviously by yelling at John, claiming he (Sherlock) doesn't have friends. This hurts John immensely because it makes John think he is not Sherlock's friend - that he isn't loved. Sherlock recognizes this fact afterwards and tells John that he is unique in the world - because he is Sherlock's only friend in the world. John is grateful and forgives Sherlock. And he does so without mawkishness or Sherlock having to undercut that revelation by then laughing at John. Neither is embarrased by their emotions or actions. Thus, in HOUNDS, Sherlock earns his forgiveness. In HEARSE, he not only fails to earn forgiveness by identifying his fault and correcting it - he actually repeats that fault (betrayal) again on purpose. Sherlock demonstrates he will lie to John and damn John's feelings. Put simply, in HOUNDS there is an actual resolution to the problem. In HEARSE, not only is there no resolution to the problem - there is actually a reinforcement of the problem. I know a lot of people enjoy the humor of the scene. But the humor comes at the expense of the story (of the resolution) rather than in service of it. It is simply bad writing.
  3. I am truly surprised by how many people simply dismiss Sherlock as an "idiot". Why are so many happy to write him off as simply not knowing what he is doing - despite facts to the contrary (for instance, his wink and nod to Mary, indicating he knew exactly what he was doing all night with John, etc). There is an enormous difference between not adhering to social expectations and being an "idiot" or an "ass" etc.. He might be callous when showing off his intellect (think Molly at Xmas in Scandal), but he recognizes when he has hurt a person he cares for and has no difficulty knowing and doing the right thing to make it up (his truly heartfelt apology and kiss, which shocked both Molly and John. Not even they get the fact that Sherlock *does* know human nature - and thus are constantly surprised when their assumption in this regard is continually contradicted.) Sherlock is not an idiot. He knew what he was doing the whole time.
  4. No. The whole thing was a setup. Sherlock knew what he was going to do before he got there. He lied to John about everything - including not having called the police etc. He intended to use the situation to force a forgiveness from John. It was all an intentional fraud to achieve the end he sought.
  5. I think you just nailed it. When John says he forgives him, for a moment, he looks so much like a child. (source) And then of course he starts cracking jokes 'cause he's not able to cope with that kind of deep emotion overload. Yeah, it does seem unfair that John is forced to be open about his emotions while Sherlock weasels out, but John always had to be the grown-up in their relationship. But Sherlock is not an ass. And he certainly can and does handle emotions well. If you note, it is John who says he doesn't handle these types of emotions well, to which Sherlock clearly states "I know". And it is true. Where Sherlock simply doesn't feel the need to express his emotions most of the time, John really has trouble expressing his emotions. For proof, look at his explanation why he never talked to Mrs. Hudson for 2 years - and how he really stumbled through the marriage proposal. It is clear that Sherlock manufactured the situation in order to get John to say 'I forgive you' - because he knows John has trouble expressing this kind of emotion. But in any real drama, such a fraudulently cajoled forgivness would be recinded immediately because of the fraud. It would be an example that the forgiveness had not been earned and thus not deserved. Here the fraud is simply laughed out of existence as if it means nothing. That is the opposite of being a "grown up". Having John simply accept - for no reason - the original betrayal and then this betrayal by Sherlock hurts the characterization of both Sherlock and John. And it destroys any actual plot/story. There is no resolution. There is simply a shrug and a giggle. That is not great drama. That isn't even mediocre drama.
  6. Concerning the Series 3 DVD/Blu Rays. Prior series have all included commentary tracks for at least two of the episodes. However I've not seen any reference to them for the Series 3 discs. Have we heard definitively if commentaries will or will not be included? I aks because those would be my only reason for buying the discs.
  7. That was a writer's cheat. It was inserted, not for any purpose of story, but to try to soften for the audience the brutal fact that Sherlock just betrayed John AGAIN. And this time, Sherlock lied for no apparant purpose BUT to lie. If that long expanse of time hadn't been there to distract the audience - to remove it from the heavy emotion of the moment - the audience would have really balked at John now forgiving Sherlock for everything. They would have wanted John to deck Sherlock again and walk away, thus leaving the reunion story unfulfilled. Does anyone have a good theory as to WHY - after demonstrating he DOES know human nature and John's nature specifically - Sherlock makes this one big joke at John's expense and for no apparent reason? More importantly, does anyone have a good theory as to WHY John now simply accepts this additional betrayal? This seems to be a really BAD characterization of both - and a really bad way to end the Reunion Plot.
  8. I must say I was disappointed by "The Empty Hearse". Gatiss' episodes have never been my favorites of the series, but this simply wasn't even close to the quality of writing and storytelling I've come to expect from "Sherlock". Briefly, the multiple plots in this episode were not really solved by Sherlock but instead relied on luck/coincidence (and not more than a bit of plain stupidity). Concerning the TERRORIST PLOT, Sherlock is essentially handed the vital clue by the mystery villain: Guy Fawkes. And even then Sherlock doesn't make the connection. Moreover, a terrorist attack is due in close proximity to Guy Fawkes Day and that connection isn't even on Sherlock's (or Mycroft's) radar?? The moment Sherlock's "rat" disappeared under Westminster, he should have solved the case. Guy Fawkes and a mystery below Parliament would simply have been too much of a coincidence to ignore. Oh, and about that "rat". Sherlock tells Mycroft that all his rats are acting normally. Yet the one rat had disappeared (apparently not to resurface till much later). And yet Sherlock finds this out, not from his homeless network, but by the sheer coincidence of a rail fan coming to him about it? Really?!!? Oh, and when shown the rail video of the man who disappears, Sherlock doesn't recognize the "rat" immediately? John recognized him right away in some grainy pictures from across the room - and did so without having been 'focused' on him for two days! Sherlock was always a step behind on this plot. It wasn't his actions or his deductions which truly solved it. He almost literally had to be hit over the head before he made the obvious connections. Concerning the REUNION PLOT (getting John to come back), Sherlock doesn't 'solve' this problem either - though he definitely got the ball rolling with his THREE PUNCHLINE PLAN. The sequence in which Sherlock is punched by John three times is not Sherlock being an idiot when it comes to human nature (as John always claims). Sherlock's 'wink and nod' response when Mary makes that very claim indicates Sherlock (as has been demonstrated over and over again) truly does know human nature. His response indicates that Sherlock has purposefully provoked John all night. Why? Because Sherlock knew John would naturally be angry - angry at three things (which is why there were three PUNCH LINES to the sequence). John would be angry that Sherlock had lied to him. John would be angry that Sherlock had told the truth to others. And John would be angry that Sherlock simply expects John to come back now. But Sherlock also knew that John would ultimately come back because he knows John does miss "this" - ie misses The Game. And Sherlock wanted John to come back now rather than later. So Sherlock purposefully provoked John's anger (which is why Sherlock's initial joke about the mustache comes across as awkwardly as his frantic fear in the train car at the end. It was all acting on Sherlock's part). In other words, instead of Sherlock letting John do a slow boil, thus taking an untold amount of time for John to satisfy and get over his anger and outrage, Sherlock brought John to boil immediately on all the things he would get angry about. And we see that Sherlock's tactic works. It only takes a day of his mind spinning (like Mrs. Hudson's brush) for him to get over it. Then it's off with the mustache. (We don't even get to see why he gets over it. We just see the conclusion that he did.) And then it takes less than a day more of boring work for John to relent and admit he does miss The Game. So in less than 48 hrs he returns to 221b on his own. So this REUNION PLOT is much more of a fizzle than any real drama. Everything is a foregone conclusion that is resolved almost immediately. There is no real question, choice, or conflict for anyone. And, though Sherlock hurried it, John is the one who 'solved' it (mostly off-screen). Sherlock did not. Concerning the KIDNAPPING PLOT, John was saved by chance event, not purposeful action. If not for the fact that the fire needed an accelerant, John would have died. Sherlock wouldn't have saved John at all. John was saved by luck. Concerning THE FALL PLOT, the story sets out to say it doesn't matter how Sherlock solved it. And it makes fun of anyone in the audience who might complain that it is important - that a story is only as good as the logic and drama of its events. So Sherlock doesn't resolve this plot satisfactorily (especially since many point out the flaws with the resolution Sherlock relates.) You are simply supposed to be grateful that Sherlock lives - and stop worrying about HOW. Put simply, the story does a "bait & switch", saying THE FALL PLOT isn't important. The how isn't important. The story says (by means of John's explicit statement), that the REUNION PLOT is the only thing which is important. Why Sherlock lied to John is what's important. But even there we don't get satisfaction. So then why did Sherlock lie to John? Because John might blab??? Please! The fact that Sherlock told so many people - including his parents(!) - makes his reason seem complete "facile". John provided a better - a truthful and important - reason to Mrs. Hudson for why he not contacting her the entire two years. And Sherlock could have been allowed some answer which mirrored John's, thus letting John see they are the same and thus forgiving him (and thus giving the audience reason to accept John's forgiveness. It would be EARNED.) That would have been good writing. Instead Sherlock is given - and gives - no real good reason. And thus John forgives for no real good reason (especially after Sherlock again betrays him in the train car and laughs at having thus lied to him once more). Far from earning the forgiveness, as many have indicated it feels wrong that John didn't punch sherlock again. In other words, the success of the REUNION plot seems out of character and totally UNEARNED. It is a complete contradiction. By having John simply accept Sherlock's original betrayal and his newest betrayal, the writers engage in a third betrayal: they betray the audience. So both THE FALL PLOT and THE REUNION PLOT - ie the two major plots of the story - are ended extremely unsatisfactorily (which is an understatement). Overall, Sherlock himself didn't really achieve anything in this story. He didn't earn anything by means of his actions. It was all coincidence, chance, and the actions of others (even Sherlock's return to London was Mycroft's act, not his own!). That is simply bad writing. And that is why I consider "The Empty Hearse" not only to be the very worst of the "Sherlock" stories but, because it is the climax of "The Reichenbach Fall" it actually diminishes one of the best of the "Sherlock" stories. I expect far better from "Sherlock"
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.