-
Posts
361 -
Joined
-
Days Won
1
Everything posted by BLS_Pro
-
That doesn't change the fact or nature of unrequited love. The fact that you see others who ARE in love the way you seek to be in love only makes that unrequited love all the more painful in contrast. Not only are you alone, but you see some others are not. Thus the jealousy part of her 'murderous jealousy'. Again, Eurus does not see in Mycroft a kindred soul - any more than Molly sees a kindred soul in Mycroft rather than Sherlock. Neither loves Mycroft. That doesn't mean Mycroft can't love or doesn't love in his own way. You seem to be very forgiving of this episode because of its thematic focus on love. I have to ask: Do you consider yourself to be a fan of love-conquers-all stories? Personally I strongly dislike stories like that. It's become such a cliche theme that it just feels lazy when writers resort to it. Sigh. Identifying a writer's theme is not the same as agreeing with that theme. However, if you think the integration they did achieve is "lazy" I suggest you try it some time. It is one of THE most difficult things in the world to achieve. It is one of the reasons Great Art is so rare (note: one does not have to agree with the themes of Art to identify it as Great. One can HATE a theme - can disagree with it completely - and still recognize the greatness of the work, of its execution.) This is Great but Flawed Art. It is flawed because it sacrifices plot and characterization to theme. That is what is wrong with it. But even there, the sacrifices are made because of the theme. The contradictions or absurdities serve to place us in the nightmare world of the character. I am not an existentialist. Nor do I believe love of others is what gives meaning to existence. I reject these principles. However, my disagreement with the ideas expressed in this art have nothing to do with whether that art is good or bad. A work of Art can be great AND one can still dislike it because of WHAT it depicts.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
That doesn't change the fact or nature of unrequited love. The fact that you see others who ARE in love the way you seek to be in love only makes that unrequited love all the more painful in contrast. Not only are you alone, but you see some others are not. Thus the jealousy part of her 'murderous jealousy'. Again, Eurus does not see in Mycroft a kindred soul - any more than Molly sees a kindred soul in Mycroft rather than Sherlock. Neither loves Mycroft. That doesn't mean Mycroft can't love or doesn't love in his own way.
- 1,402 replies
-
I never suggested Mycroft has never had a relationship with others, any more than I ever suggested he doesn't have a relationship with Sherlock or his parents. Do you think Mycroft has EVER had a relationship like Sherlock and John? No. And that's the point. Eurus has the capacity and need for a love like Sherlock had with his best friend. But, just like Molly, the person she loved did not return that love. And, like Molly, a pale substitute would simply not do. It isn't the same. She would never get from Mycroft what she needed because he is not a loving soul. Sherlock was and, thanks to John saving him, is again.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Mycroft did not evince it - certainly not like Sherlock and his best friend (and the same is possibly true of the parents). Even Sherlock was surprised by Mycroft's expression of brotherly love in Final Vow.
- 1,402 replies
-
Yes. Its all just a mishmash they threw together. The complete and astonishing level of integration, down to every small detail, including the joke "The Hungry Donkey" is just pure coincidence. It's happenstance. The writers aren't intelligent. They didn't write their story to be unified so absolutely that every action and word they wrote can be explained by the one theme. They didn't plan it. That's just an accident (just as Bride actually being ALL about Eurus is just an accident). :facepalm: This comes across quite harsh. In fact we don't know, what was intended and what was a coincidence. When a story is completely integrated to this level, where even the smallest of details is unified to the theme, to claim one can't know if that integration was purposeful or just an accident is a bizarre assertion. But hey, if you want to believe things like the entirety of TAB was just a total coincidence in turning out to be all about Eurus, if you wish to believe you can't know if it was actually planned or was an accident - if you want to be a skeptic absent evidence and in contradiction to the evidence - I can't do anything about that. I can only point TO the evidence.
- 1,402 replies
-
She could easily have killed them in any number of ways in which they could not have escaped. This is the 'I hate you, I hate you, I hate you' rage of love denied. The rage is because of the love. It is exactly what we saw when she attacks him in Sherrinford. Eurus hates that Sherlock doesn't love her and beats him. But she also knows that she does love him and doesn't want to kill him, so explicitly tells everyone to prevent her, not from hurting him, but from killing him. Edit: Just as John must have orderlies pull him off of Sherlock. Yes. Just as she knew Moriarty would not succeed in trying to cause Sherlock's death and thus had Moriarty record messages for her - knowing HE, not Sherlock, would be dead. The bomb scenario would be much easier to predict the outcome. We are never shown that Mycroft had a "best friend" ie exhibited love to others in a way Eurus would recognize. BECAUSE Sherlock exhibited emotional "context" with others is probably one of the reasons WHY Eurus loved him. She recognized a capacity in him like the one she had. The difference between Sherlock and Eurus was not ability, but circumstance. He had someone who loved him back. She did not. So Sherlock was able to exercise that ability - to love and be loved - where she could not. Mycroft is not shown to have had that capacity - and still is shown to struggle with it even today. Sherlock was the kindred spirit, not Mycroft. That is likely why she loved him rather than Mycroft.
- 1,402 replies
-
No. She hasn't plotted to kill this man (ex - she knew Moriarty would fail). If she wanted Sherlock dead, he would be dead. From the beginning, she has sought his love (which is why when he threatened to kill himself she panicked - his death is not her goal). She has certainly plotted, in the games, to kill those he loves (as well as those whom he didn't even know, thus indicating SHE knows respect and empathy are derivatives of love). And that is both anger (at him NOT rescuing her, not loving her as she loves him - ie unrequited love) and love together (as you say, love can mix with multiple other emotions as well). She uses the threats to everyone else as a clue for Sherlock to her love (and her desperate need of it from him) as well as an impetus for him to solve her 'game' and save her from being alone - from being tortured by a senseless and meaningless existence.
- 1,402 replies
-
Not in conventional scientific wisdom, where the base emotions are that people, as can be seen from their facial expressions feel happy, surprised, afraid, disgusted, angry, and sad. You miss my meaning. I was simply trying to state that one cannot have the emotions of respect and empathy absent the emotion love. Love is the -foundational- (base) emotion of which the other two are mere aspects - ie particular forms of love, of valuation.
- 1,402 replies
-
Are you suggesting that she doesn't feel emotions? If so, I have to disagree completely. Well, she does feel inadequacy, about not having the same emotional language as everyone else, so she feels something. And as you say below, anger and fear too. There are other things she is missing, besides love. Like respect. We don't kill others out of a respect for life. But she has none of that either. Not true. For instance, she feels fear (and, one can argue, anger) all the time. It is what defines her (and she feels it because she does not have love). No other emotion "conquers all". No other emotion "makes the world go 'round" because no other emotion -solves- the Final Problem. Love is valuing - it is differentiation. It is the empathy part that I am talking about, however. As a rule, people don't not murder because they are so full of love for others. We don't murder because we have empathy for others, and are capable of valuing their lives, even when we don't love them. The emotions you describe her having are very base emotions- anger and fear. But what she is angry about is, again just in my opinion, how low-functioning she is across the spectrum of human emotion. It's a text book sociopath, with only the shallow emotions accounted for. Respect and empathy are derivatives of love (of others). They are aspects of it. Love is the "base emotion".
- 1,402 replies
-
Are you suggesting that she doesn't feel emotions? If so, I have to disagree completely. Not true. For instance, she feels fear (and, one can argue, anger) all the time. It is what defines her (and she feels it because she does not have love). No other emotion "conquers all". No other emotion "makes the world go 'round" because no other emotion -solves- the Final Problem. Love is valuing - it is differentiation. IT is what makes the sameness of everything in reality all different.
- 1,402 replies
-
Yes. Its all just a mishmash they threw together. The complete and astonishing level of integration, down to every small detail, including the joke "The Hungry Donkey" is just pure coincidence. It's happenstance. The writers aren't intelligent. They didn't write their story to be unified so absolutely that every action and word they wrote can be explained by the one theme. They didn't plan it. That's just an accident (just as Bride actually being ALL about Eurus is just an accident). :facepalm:
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
The premise (theme) is NOT "the world is meaningless and inexplicable", but, to put it in trite terms: "love is what makes the world go 'round" - or as Benedict put it: "Love conquers all". These are premises "mainstream BBC" programming most certainly WOULD and DOES fund. The theme of the show is that Love is all important - IT is WHAT gives meaning to life. HOW to FIND meaning in a "meaningless and inexplicable" world is THE biggest mystery for existentalism. It is The Final Problem to be solved. So "detective fiction" is the PERFECT programme. Who better than the world's greatest detective to solve it? Which is why you should check your premises. Their premise is NOT "inside every psychopath is a child who just wants to be loved". That is NOT, for example, what they show of Moriarty, now is it? NO. So you know that is not their philosophy. She didn't "turn" into a little girl lost, but had ALWAYS been a little girl lost, seeking the love of her brother - seeking to be saved from a fate WORSE than death. Not true.
- 1,402 replies
-
On what basis in the story do you make this claim? (BTW - her main motivation is that she wants and needs love. Sherlock is simply WHO she loves and thus whom she desires to be loved by - just like Molly or anyone else.) It sounds like the below is an example of why you make this claim: The purpose of the three men is to show Sherlock that, absent his love - absent "context" - there is no way TO feel differently about their fates. Whether they live or die has no meaning absent love. Which one lives or dies (justice) has no meaning absent love. Love is WHAT enables differentiation. Without it, so the philosophy goes, all reality is the same. That is why ANY choice between them feels the same to her, as she explicitly states. There is no difference between them to her. She is the Hungry Donkey and they are the equal bales of hay. She has NO context for them. Any choice between them doesn't make a difference to her because - absent love - they are NOT different. All reality is all the same to her BECAUSE she has NO "context". Sherlock, however, CAN choose between them. HE has "context". She saw that as a child. He had a best friend. He had context and thus life had meaning for him. She was desperate for that context, knowing without it she was just a tortured child, alone and afraid all the time ( which they show explicitly). She was "doomed" without him. The three men 'game' was just another clue from her to Sherlock to show him WHY she was lost - WHAT her world was like absent his love.
- 1,402 replies
-
Her love isn't for the game. Her love is for Sherlock ("my favorite"). The purpose of the game is to get Sherlock to come and save her soul (to love her in return). That was Eurus' purpose from the start - made explicit in her code, which Sherlock finally breaks - ie finally understands.That is why she panics. If Sherlock dies, SHE is forever lost. I do agree that she really loves Sherlock in as so far as she can feel love but the first four rooms weren't necessary if all she wanted to do was get him to solve the code.I would suggest you are missing something. For a normal individual, it wouldn't have been "necessary" to threaten his childhood best friend with murder to get Sherlock to solve the code either. What I meant was getting him to solve the code wasn't her sole goal for the first four rooms. She was also showing Sherlock how well she knew him by pushing all of his emotional buttons with context. She was giving him clues about HERSELF (what her nightmare world was like absent the meaning love gives to everything - showing him the difference between them, a difference attributable to the fact HE has that love and she NEVER did "I never had a best friend"). In other words, she isn't showing "how well she knew him" but showing that he does NOT know her. Eurus is giving Sherlock all these clues so he can solve her code. And she is making them life threatening to give him impetus TO solve the code - as she had done from the start as a child. That is how important it is to her. Her lack of love is an existential threat to her, just as her threats against others are existential. It is her (and the writers) saying that they are the same. One cannot live without love. The form of death differs, but it is death nonetheless (and one could argue that those who die swiftly are given a "mercy", rather than the slow torture of life without love). The individual games are but a mirror of the first game.
- 1,402 replies
-
Eurus IS envious (to the point of 'murderous jealousy') of the people he loves. She wants HIM to love her too. She wants a relationship with Sherlock, like they have with him. Sherlock doesn't give that to her. He gives it to others and leave her abandoned and alone. Eurus is the example of unrequited love. In this regard, Molly is a mirror to Eurus. The Molly 'torture' scene is supposed to show us (and Sherlock) how others can be deeply hurt when the love a person has for another is not returned by the object of that love. Molly and Eurus feel the SAME thing for Sherlock. They BOTH love him. It is "true" of both. By making Sherlock recognize that fact in regard to Molly, she gives him the clue that unrequited love is her problem as well - and thus is a clue to solving the final problem and The Final Problem.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Her love isn't for the game. Her love is for Sherlock ("my favorite"). The purpose of the game is to get Sherlock to come and save her soul (to love her in return). That was Eurus' purpose from the start - made explicit in her code, which Sherlock finally breaks - ie finally understands.That is why she panics. If Sherlock dies, SHE is forever lost. I do agree that she really loves Sherlock in as so far as she can feel love but the first four rooms weren't necessary if all she wanted to do was get him to solve the code. I would suggest you are missing something. For a normal individual, it wouldn't have been "necessary" to threaten his childhood best friend with murder to get Sherlock to solve the code either.
- 1,402 replies
-
One - that's not how the funding works for episodes of a show. Two - you presume the BBC was told that was the theme. Again, that's not how it works. Three - as I pointed out elsewhere, the same writer (Moffat) wrote the same theme into another Who episode (Heaven Sent). It shows up in a lot of his stuff. One does not have to "imagine" it. The writers SHOW it explicitly in her song, which others see (and can't see PAST) as simple 'murderous insanity' but is explicitly her plea to be loved. And they show it explicitly when he finds her in her room. No imagination required. The writers hit everyone over the head with it! He didn't. He had a different solution to The Final Problem. His solution wasn't love. His solution was cannibalism.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Her love isn't for the game. Her love is for Sherlock ("my favorite"). The purpose of the game is to get Sherlock to come and save her soul (to love her in return). That was Eurus' purpose from the start - made explicit in her code, which Sherlock finally breaks - ie finally understands. That is why she panics. If Sherlock dies, SHE is forever lost. She would be in the exact same position as John in TLD. Like John, she needs to be saved by Sherlock.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
So we have a seeming song about a murderous sibling taunting and torturing her brother by threatening his best friend with death. But it turns out that is not the message at all. Instead it must be translated - to be understood for what it really is - the sister asking the brother to save her by loving her. Just like her two "personalities" throughout the episode. You need to understand Eurus? This is the explanation. The one is the means to the other. The writers were quite thorough in making the theme apply to every aspect of what they wrote.
- 1,402 replies
-
Yes. The purpose of the movie is to show Mycroft's psychology in relationship to others. It is specifically for the Adam and Eve quote. That is what he smiles at.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
This is really weird scene, isn't it? Eurus is insanely angry at Sherlock for not saving her from the existential nightmare she has been trapped in from childhood. It is an anger based on her being tortured all her life all alone in that plane (in her room/in her cell/absent his love). But she also realizes that Sherlock is her only salvation, so she ultimately knows she can't be allowed to kill him. Note that all the games in Sherrinford do not put HIM in life-threatening jeopardy. And it is only once he threatens to kill himself, thus forever trapping her in her hell, that she panics and leaps to her end game.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
BTW - continuing from what I said about existentialism, the whole episode is supposed to show us - and make us experience - the nightmare world in which Eurus is stuck (and we are all stuck in absent 'love of others' - absent that love, nothing makes a difference, which is the point of her games in Sherrinford - to show there is no difference to her - no "context" to provide difference - to make sense of it all). It is an absurd and meaningless world (to her due to the absence of love). THAT is the purpose of all the horror imagery and all the games Eurus plays and why we are tricked into believing Moriarty is alive, then having the rug yanked out from us (and why no explanation of how they survive the explosion or how Eurus mind-controls or how Sherlock managed such a complicated scheme at the beginning to get Mycroft to admit there is a Eurus, etc). All of it is PURPOSEFULLY designed to make us live the world of Eurus - the bewilderment and fear and anxiety of (and anger at) an absurd world - which she seeks to escape (again to "Break Free" - to "land" etc).
- 1,402 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Another BTW - the theme I identified for The Final Problem is essentially the same as The Doctor Who episode "Heaven Sent", written solely by Moffat. The difference being Who's story was amazingly written and executed while Sherlock's was a mess (so again I blame Gatiss)
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
I was wondering about this myself. Is it psychological practice to encourage the maintenance of repressed/false memories rather than try to reveal and heal them? It doesn't seem like the field would encourage repression.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Btw - nice little coincidence: Freeman's show Fargo's sixth episode (which aired in early 2014) was titled Buridan's Ass.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)