-
Posts
361 -
Joined
-
Days Won
1
Everything posted by BLS_Pro
-
Copy. I'll ponder while working and post an answer, as time permits for a thoughtful reply.
- 1,402 replies
-
I'm at work now - locations-heavy til weekend so may not be posting as much as early week. As to Moriarty and his purpose, I think I touched upon that to some degree already. I'll try to elaborate later but one question: when you say "whole series" do you mean the whole of series 4 or do you mean the entire show from the start? (This is the problem with the Brit usage of the same term to identify an individual season and an entire series - one can't always be certain which concept is being identified)
- 1,402 replies
-
Good writing? Most certainly. I consider Sherlock as a whole an example of great but flawed Art. The flaw is not fully integrating theme w plot and characterization. The writers have a tendency to sacrifice plot and character to theme. That's the problem with this last episode - and the integration of all of them is why Lying Detective was so good.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Also, I think they integrated the story theme into the end score as well. It starts out with the lone violin, but the Problem is now solved and - as such - becomes two violins and then an entire orchestra, both showing us and letting us experience directly for ourselves, the beauty of being with others. (And is why we see the repetition of Sherlock going to Sherrinford - that is the sameness of being alive - The Problem. What makes it worth it? What gives it "context" ie meaning? That is the solution - The people. And we see that Sherlock has solved the problem. That is why we see Sherlock and everyone else happy in the montage at the end. What gives 221b its meaning? What makes it a HOME? All the people we see there, loving one another.)
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
And they set that up exactly in Bride. Immediately after he says "I made me" we hear a dog and Sherlock says "Redbeard?". It is his subconscious telling him he is wrong. And that was the theme of the episode too. I don't have the time to look it up, but he says to watson (just before the "I made me" scene) something to the effect 'We are the product of the ghosts of our past'. That includes him - and since Bride is about Eurus as THE ghost in his past - it means him specifically. More generally, the point of the series is that we are all victims of existence itself. That is the writer's view. That is The Problem. And the only way to "save" us from it is love of others. That is the 'saving' Sherlock had to do for John in 4.2, and that is the saving John did for Sherlock by entering his life and becoming his best friend.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
I don't know if they are aware of everything. But everything I've referenced is definitely purposeful on their part - as was their Sixth Sense version of Bride. They know what they're doing. They don't always execute it well, sacrificing plot and character to 'theme' etc (which is why, for instance, despite that the 'Missing Glass' scene hurts characterization, it is there because they wanted to show that the barriers people erect are not there - they wanted the hand holding scene), but they are aware they are doing it all. This level of integration does NOT happen by accident. In the manger instance what we get is the PERFECT synopsis/thumbnail sketch of Moriarty's character. When presented with supposedly the best human being who has ever lived, what does he do? He literally consumes him. He destroys him in the most disgusting manner possible. THAT is Moriarty. That is his answer to everything - to The Final Problem.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
BTW - in regard to The Hungry Donkey, Moriarty's story as a child is HIS solution to the problem of the donkey - the Final Problem. He has the donkey EAT the baby. Moriarty EATS people - he chews them up. THAT is why we got the reference to cannibals when he enters the prison.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Benedict Cumberbatch IS Sherlock Holmes in "Never Say Never Again" ;)
- 1,402 replies
-
Wasn't Sherlock the one who defined the meeting place? Re: TRF - why would she do this? Killing Sherlock would rob her of the hope for a playmate. Wait: what it Jim was her way to play with Sherlock? There are allusions to playing all over the episode. Now, wasn't it 5 years ago when they met? Would make it 2011-1012. Could work. It was Sherlock's "choice" to MEET there but Eurus is the one who told Moriarty to use it, ie the case related to water. And the writers explicitly connect it to Eurus/Redbeard with both the flash to the pool and with the flash to the falls. One can definitely argue that Eurus was playing with Sherlock indirectly through Moriarty. But as Mycroft states, it was after Moriarty had already expressed an interest in Sherlock. So Eurus wasn't behind them ultimately crossing paths. She just saw the opportunity of the crossed paths to serve her purposes.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Re-watching Fall. Now I know why Redbeard is the word she says to Moriarty. Now it can be argued Eurus is the one who gives Moriarty the idea for The Fall (ie the idea that he is a fraud etc). Sherlock: "Everybody wants to believe [the false story]. That's what's so clever: a lie that's preferable to the truth." And, of course, one can argue (especially since they explicitly included it in Final) that she met him before the end of S1.3 and told Moriarty to use the pool, since it wasn't only from Sherlock's remembered past but would be an allusion to his forgotten past.
- 1,402 replies
-
"Without doubt, she WILL kill again if she has the opportunity." Yup. You nailed it. 'Sherlock talked Eurus out of being evil'. Sherlock to Euros after helping her land: 'Help me save my friend.' So yes Sherlock did talk to her out of doing evil if it was just temporarily. You said - and I said - "BEING evil" not "DOING a single evil act". Nor was that your given (ridiculing) reference either. AND - he played her First and Final Game - and won. Releasing John was what he won. :facepalm: I'm done. Bye.
- 1,402 replies
-
They are MANY things, but "average" is not one of them. That is WHY we love the show, even if we don't love particular episodes.
- 1,402 replies
-
Do you think it would work as a Mind Palace story? Can it be - it is? Dang, I need to watch it again. Oooh, folks, I'm back. I'm soooo back. Well, Final IS partially a Mind Palace story - we essentially see a part (the core) of Eurus' mind palace: the plane. And one could argue that Eurus turns Sherrinford INTO a real life version of a Mind Palace. But no, this is not like Bride where most of the story is a Mind Palace story. Sorry ;)
- 1,402 replies
-
I do have to say, with my analysis of the episode and the series, I think it gives this episode MUCH more finality to it than I previously believed. The writers have explored and resolved the fundamental issue of the series. As they say, now we've got the mature Sherlock and Watson going off on their adventures, given they've solved the Final Problem. Once THAT problem is solved, everything else is 'easy'. Everything flows FROM it. :(
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
It's much like Bride in that regard - which I think is brilliant now in all its levels, especially the Sixth Sense one, given this season reveals Bride was all about Eurus. But I now understand why they did the story itself as they did. And I can't say it doesn't 'ring true' in general. It just doesn't 'ring' Sherlock. It isn't HIS story and HE doesn't do anything really. Again, if the story had been about HIM tearing down all his walls of repression (literally, in his mind palace - where such bond-like explosions would have been perfect) and HIM figuring out what Eurus needed, instead of him simply having to be led around in a maze by Eurus (and Mycroft), the story itself would have rung true AND been good writing AND have been unified thematically with the other levels to the story.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Thanks. And I can't disagree with you. While I now understand the episode (and can now greatly appreciate its overall writing as very good - ie extremely thematically unified), ALL my specific complaints - including those about BAD writing - remain.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
In regard to my post about existentialism as the Key to the episode and the series, and having gone back and rewatched TRF, I think I am correct is saying Moriarty is supposed to be the existentialist who accepts reality as meaningless and stops there, rejecting anything as able to provide life with meaning ("context"). His only answer to the "Problem" of living - the problem of existential dread (and the nauseating boredom of its 'sameness' - ie no differences between anything) is death ("Staying Alive" is the problem from which he wants to "Break Free"); Eurus is the existentialist who accepts reality as meaningless, knows love/others can provide it with meaning ("context"), but has no one who will give it to her, thus leaving her lost and desperate to be saved; and Sherlock is the existentialist who begins like Moriarty and is thus bored with life because of it, but who ultimately learns that love/others provide life with meaning ("context") [and it essentially doesn't matter WHO that other is, be it Irene, a hit-woman, etc as John says in The Lying Detective] and is thus saved by it (by his love for, and the Love from, John and the others).
- 1,402 replies
-
THE KEY TO THE FINAL PROBLEM I've been meaning to post my favorite joke from Final, but I kept getting side-tracked. Now I'm glad I was because I just realized it ties into the Eurus reason/good/evil/emotions theme - and is the KEY to the whole episode. When Moriarty first enters Sherrinford on Christmas Day, he plays with nativity decorations and tells Mycroft: "I wrote my own version of the Nativity when I was a child: The Hungry Donkey. It was a bit gorey. But if you're going to put a baby in a manger, you're asking for trouble." Now I burst out laughing when he said this - that is REALLY funny. But it wasn't until I went to write it down here that I realized The Hungry Donkey is actually a reference to an example used in philosophy pertaining to morality and its use as a guide to human actions. It is more commonly known as Buridan's Ass. And the example is that of a hungry ass placed equidistant between two bales of hay. In the example, the donkey starves because it has no means of choosing between the equal bales. It can't choose and thus dies. Buridan summarized the problem thusly: Should two courses be judged equal, then the Will cannot break the deadlock, all it can do is to suspend judgement until the circumstances change, and the right course of action is clear. — Jean Buridan, c. 1340 In other words, in the face of equal alternatives (of alternatives between which there is supposedly no difference), reason cannot guide one's choice. No -rational- choice can be made. Reference to some OTHER standard must be made. That certainly fits with Eurus and her personal dilemma, as well as all the games she sets up. To her, there is no difference between the choices in the world (not even moral differences - she's too "clever" to fall for those 'subjective' - ie unreal - differences). So reason cannot tell her what to do. THAT is why she is stuck in the plane and cannot land. She needs something OTHER than her intellect - something other than her reasoning - to guide her. She needs emotion to help her. But she doesn't know how to use emotion AS her guide in these circumstances. And, in fact, the only emotions she's acutely aware of (loneliness and fear) leave her helpless. She's -stuck- Existentially. This is what the existentialists identify as the individual's 'starting point' in life. It is sometimes called "the existential attitude": "a sense of disorientation, confusion, or dread in the face of an apparently meaningless or absurd world." (THAT is why this episode looks and feels like a Horror Film - and in fact draws from many of them - because that is supposedly the 'natural' condition of the individual - the one we face from the time we are children [which is why we are shown Eurus as a child - she's still stuck in that condition. She is like that ALL the time. So what we are seeing in her is NOT a split personality at all, nor a mental illness, but the state into which all humans are supposedly born].) The episode goes on to show the solution to this "Final Problem" - this existential angst and despair - is the love of others. That IT is the only thing which provides meaning - provides "context" for action - for life. And that is neither good nor bad. It just "is what it is" Turns out, this episode (maybe the entire series?) is about the 'existential problem' and how to deal with it.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Who is to say she didn't? In fact, she probably did - like any normal kid. And, like any normal kid, it wouldn't have solved her problem. You can't force other kids to WANT to be your BEST FRIEND. Your parents can't help your lack of having a best friend. You can't MAKE someone have a deep connection with you. You can't FORCE someone to love and want to be with you. And any pretense at it just amplifies the loneliness. So 'Sherlock - go play with your sister' wouldn't help. (This is one of the reasons why the "I Love You" scene with Molly is so painful for both of them)
- 1,402 replies
-
THIS is why, whether I like an episode or not, I love this show (and why I CARE if the writing is good or bad). Because they HAVE written some great stories - and have done so with wonderful depth through GOOD and layered writing. In order to achieve this, I will say they have a bit of an advantage over most other shows. Part of the reason they can do this is because they can literally show you the mental/psychological/emotional state of a character - specifically in this case, by showing her as a frightened little girl. One immediately feels sorry and protective for her, and thus for Eurus. While a regular show might have been able to ultimately make you feel for a similar villain absent those visuals and the heart-tugging acting of the little girl, it is a much harder task to do WITHOUT that 'cheat'.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
"Without doubt, she WILL kill again if she has the opportunity." Yup. You nailed it. 'Sherlock talked Eurus out of being evil'.
- 1,402 replies
-
Redbeard is the red herring. This is one of the reasons (along with Hounds) that I surmised Redbeard was ultimately going to end up NOT being a dog (but, because of Sussex Vampire, would suffer the dog's fate). We were allowed to see it for the same reason we were allowed to see the rest of the film, including the waterfall at the end. Because the whole episode was ultimately about Eurus.
- 1,402 replies
-
Because she WAS lonely. It is what she has been since she was a child. It is not "out of nowhere". It is her core - the core which NO rationalization she can concoct eliminates. She was stating FACT - and she did so to get Sherlock to solve her problem. It is what she wrote EXPLICITLY all those years ago: "I am lost. Help me Brother. Save my life before my doom. I am lost without your love. Save my soul, seek my room" It was true THEN. It REMAINS true TODAY. It has NOT changed. Eurus is NOT trying to use her emotion as the means to some end ('proving her philosophy about morality'). That philosophy is NOT her core. It isn't what drives her. It is her attempt at a defense - at suppressing that emotion - at trying (unsuccessfully) to destroy it. (Just as Sherlock attempted to do - but was saved by John, as she wants to be saved by Sherlock). The EMPTINESS - the LONGING in her heart - the LONELINESS - is her core. And is was LONG before she concocted, let alone needed to 'prove', her supposed philosophy about morality. That is but useless rationalization and PRATTLING which gets her NOWHERE - and never has. It has NEVER solved the problem of the hole - the ache - the suffocating longing - in her heart. For her, that UNENDING loneliness is the FIRST problem and the FINAL problem (and has been the driving force behind everything in between). IT is what motivates her - NOT her philosophy. If you can't admit or accept that point, no other discussion is possible here (since they all flow from, and back to, THAT point - to the issue of what is her core, what drives her). Her core is NOT her philosophy. The belief that IT drives her is a complete reversal of her characterization. Her CORE is her loneliness. It is her lack of love. So long as that point is denied, any discussion of the rest of the games would be fruitless. (As apparently is repeating the point that we both agree the writers failed to connect the two 'personalities' and that is a problem - one which I've already pointed out renders the debate about all the Sherrinford games meaningless. However, you appear dead set on arguing over assertions about something you ADMIT does NOT make sense to you and which the writers failed to put together coherently. Oh well).
- 1,402 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Still not finding behind the scenes for this episode. Not seeing it on the PBS site. :(
- 1,402 replies
-
Concerning the whole supposed 'contradiction' between what Eurus wanted and morality? John states it explicitly: J:"You gave her what she wanted. Context." S:"Was that good?" J:"It's not good, it's not bad. It's...it is what it is."
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)