-
Posts
361 -
Joined
-
Days Won
1
Everything posted by BLS_Pro
-
"he thinks what he wants to believe" He has 'fooled' himself, in other words? No. "Unreliable narrator" Just because a trope exists doesn't mean it is an example of good writing. The UN is when a character somehow (honestly or dishonestly) presents reality inaccurately. When it is done to other characters (and thus to the viewer), it can be an example of good writing. When it is completely divorced from the story and instead used SOLELY to trick the audience, that is cheap, bad writing. Another example of it in Final is Moriarty coming to Sherrinford. It is presented as something happening real-time - and only LATER revealed to have occurred years ago. There is NO narrator, no character who is telling the story and presenting it to someone else. There is nothing and no one IN the story to whom a delay in this info is being delivered BY or TO. It is the writers lying (by omission) directly and solely to the audience for NO reason - not even a rationalized story reason. It is the equivalent of a meaningless jump scare in horror - cheap and useless. In the case of Redbeard in Mycroft's mind - it is the writers patching a HOLE in their writing with the hope it isn't noticed. But what is WORSE is that Mycroft's entire LIE is bad writing at this point too. IT is a plot hole the size of the ocean. At this point in the story, there is NO reason for Mycroft to lie to Sherlock about Redbeard. The ONLY reason Mycroft does it is because the story would be over in 15 minutes if he DID. It doesn't make sense for the character to still keep it secret, given the world shattering danger he says they are facing. But (like Dumbledore to Harry Potter) the plot needs that bad characterization - that bad writing - to sustain itself. Redbeard in the vision is a MINOR offense compared to this. Not to mention this is all delivered in the form of an info dump narration. Now those can't always be avoided, but this entire story involved Sherlock not discovering the facts of the 'case', but being spoon fed them by others. They TELL, rather than SHOW. They don't make it knowledge gained through conflict. They simply make it the streaming of pictures by along with the narration. That is bad writing.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
I already explained why I disagreed with your premise. You didn't contradict my argument, but simply expanded upon your own. It doesn't change or invalidate my argument. Of course, my larger point is that it doesn't matter WHICH of us is right because we both agree there is no connection between the games - it 'doesn't make sense' how or why Eurus was going from where she started to where she finished. The writers didn't provide the necessary connective tissue. They wrote her badly. Saying she is lonely doesn't have anything to do with morality. As I pointed out, and you've NOT contradicted, a completely immoral (or amoral) person can be lonely - or angry - or happy - or jealous - or feel any other emotion. That is NOT a contradiction. As you say, even YOU don't understand WHY she is bringing up loneliness. You say explicitly she might be "trying to use morality to make Sherlock guilty OR SOMETHING." You do NOT know. It is NOT clear - not at all. THAT is the problem. You know what a rationalization is - right? And you know it doesn't change one's feelings - right? That one's feelings and one's ideas are at odds with one another is NOT an indication that her characterization "doesn't make sense". In fact, it is a fact of life for almost ALL people. People DO hold contradictions. They experience feelings which contradict their ideas all the time (revealing, whether they identify it or not, that they hold conflicting ideas - ideas being the result of what one thinks). People experience these contradictions ALL the time. Eurus has such a DEEP contradiction it seems to have literally split her consciousness into two. She is desperate to resolve the contradiction - the conflict - the divide SHE cannot surmount or unite. She's tried to resolve it - all her life - and hasn't been able to resolve it. NOT by herself. THAT is what it means to say she can't land. She can't land by herself. She can't unite herself. She can't resolve the contradiction in her BY herself. She needs help. She needs the one person she knows who is somewhat like herself and who seems to HAVE resolved it. She needs Sherlock. That is why she is DRAWN to Sherlock, not matter WHICH personality we are talking about - and is why she PANICS when she thinks she's going to lose him. HE is her salvation - and she has known that since the beginning - as her poem says explicitly. The rationalized grown up is the wall she has created (like Sherlock) to repress that lonely little child inside of her. But she can NOT escape that loneliness - no matter HOW hard she tries, no matter what she does, no matter what she thinks. It remains - because she has no one to love or be loved by. No. And again, believing morality is useless - and being lonely - are NOT mutually exclusive conditions. One is an idea. One is an emotion. They can - and DO - exist together in reality. Or are you claiming heartless murderers , totalitarian dictators, those who believe in philosophies which reject the concepts good and bad, etc etc are physically INCAPABLE of feeling the emotion 'loneliness'. If so, that is simply false - and I would suggest some good criminal psychology books.
- 1,402 replies
-
Stop conflating 'liking someone because they are attractive (among other things)' with 'liking someone because they are a domin8trix'. BIG difference between the two. You: "Not only that, but recall it is NOT her sexuality or sexual proclivities to which Sherlock is drawn." Me: "Wanna bet?" Sorry. I thought you would KEEP the context of domin8trix in regard to the terms sexuality and sexual proclivities (as opposed to the context of beastiality or any other specific forms of sexuality and sexual proclivities). If you are going to DROP the explicitly established context, well I am happy to repeat my statement with that context made EXPLICIT so the statement is UNMISTAKABLY clear: "Not only that, but recall it is NOT her sexuality AS A DOMIN8TRIX or sexual proclivities AS A DOMIN8TRIX to which Sherlock is drawn, Irene NAMES it - "brainy is the new sexy". He is attracted to her MIND (as she is to HIS), NOT to her being a Domin8trix." (As noted, since physical attractiveness and being a domin8trix are NOT synonyms, the above does not preclude Sherlock also finding Irene attractive - or even nice smelling, or have good taste in beer, etc etc ad nauseum.) I presumed this context was already unquestionably clear, not ONLY because -I- explicitly specified the context, but because -you- were NOT attacking men simply for being drawn to women who are attractive or like particular football teams etc. You explicitly argued: As I stated, Sherlock was NOT attracted to Irene BECAUSE she was a domin8trix. And, as I stated, those who try to shift Sherlock's attraction from her mind TO her being domin8trix are engaging in a non-sequitur (at best - and in fact are likely engaged in much WORSE behavior). It is like saying "He's infatuated with her because her profession is Garbage Collector." That is PURPOSEFULLY misrepresenting his attraction - and thus intentionally doing a dis-service to Sherlock (and arguably to feminism) by that misrepresentation. Hopefully that clears up any possible confusion over context now.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Stop conflating 'liking someone because they are attractive (among other things)' with 'liking someone because they are a domin8trix'. BIG difference between the two. OR- wait! Do all the people you find attractive happen to be domin8trix? Is that what's happening here? Is that why you are associating the two as the same? :D
- 1,402 replies
-
Yup. Like I said, they needed to trash everything up to Sherlock arriving at the old homestead. It is almost universally bad writing. This is just ONE aspect of it. Thanks for posting it.
- 1,402 replies
-
Yes. From beginning to end, this had the feeling of horror movies (and used MANY MANY of their tropes). It didn't feel like a mystery - certainly not a Sherlock mystery.
- 1,402 replies
-
I don't see her trying to "prove" anything to him. She's studying him and his friends - trying to isolate the difference between her and them. She's trying to determine WHY she can't "land" (and what would be the purpose in landing?) Further, is is a "Morality Maze". But her purpose is to explore how emotion impacts morality. Because that wasn't the point of any of the mazes. But you are correct that there is a disconnect between the games. The fifth game is the final problem - and was planned as such from the beginning. So why ANY of the other mazes? How are they connected. WHY did the different personalities, who seem to have different focus and potentially conflicting goals, end up cooperating to get to the end game? There's no dispute between us about these points. The only thing I've said is this problem is a result of the writers not explaining her character as they needed to explain it. Put simply, character contradiction is not change nor an arc. That's a shift in her focus, not a contradiction. WHY did she shift her focus? Again, bad writing doesn't tell us. Being a ruthless dictator who tortures everyone - and being lonely person who wants a friend - are not mutually exclusive -personalities-. A brutal murderer can want to be loved. He doesn't have to have a multiple personality disorder to be both a murderer AND lonely.
- 1,402 replies
-
Is she though? And how exactly. Just saying the word "insane" doesn't make a person capable of any and all actions. It's not about predictability. Its about identification. (And indeed the little girl WAS predictable - again WHY?) These are the things which need to be explained. They weren't. That's bad writing - specifically bad characterization. This is the problem with the "insane" dismissal of the characterization requirements in art. If "anything she does is in character" then there is NO "mystery" about her actions because there is NO logic to her actions. It is complete caprice. There is nothing to "figure out" and no REASON to try. If is ONLY if you believe that there IS some logic to her actions, some consistency to her character - and you have yet to identify those things - that you can claim a "mystery" exists. No logic - nothing to solve - no mystery. EVERY thing just "is what it is" - which is the destruction of mystery storytelling entirely.
- 1,402 replies
-
Wanna bet? Sure. Point to it IN the story. :D He knew her measurements. Which, as she says, proves he knew where to look at a woman - ie paid attention (as always). It says NOTHING about being attracted to her because she is a Domin8trix. Poor deduction My Dear Watson. ;)
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Wanna bet? Sure. Point to it IN the story. :D
- 1,402 replies
-
I don't consider that a character arc there. An arc is a change in a character from the beginning to the end of the arc. She doesn't change. Both characters are there from beginning to end. THAT is the problem. And yes, they are contradictory. That is one of the problems with the writing of the episode. There is no connective tissue between the two characteristics (or personalities, if she is split - the fact that we don't KNOW if that's what's going with her, or if it's something else is a MASSIVE part of the writing problem). As I noted in a different post, If these were two different people, the writers would have had to explain their relationship, how their seemingly different POVs, apparently different goals (if not cross-purposes) were supposed to work together toward a common, EXPLICITLY PLANNED goal of getting Sherlock to the homestead and getting him to rescue the little girl. That wasn't spur of the moment. That was part of what Eurus has intended to do from the start. But HOW to get from point A, with one personality in the 'lead', to point B where the other personality is the focus, is the problem they did NOT solve. I would say the only arc Eurus experiences is the one where she goes the 'right' way this time (from the wrong way she went last time). WITH Sherlock's love, she can now 'land'. She isn't isolated or alone. But she does now have to learn how to act given that she has landed. That is what she doesn't know how to do - and why she is shut down near the end. And, beginning with music, Sherlock begins to teach her. THAT is her arc. Nothing changes for her before "the room". Neither characterization makes sense WITH the other characterization ABSENT some explanation of the linkage between them. One could argue that the adult personality is akin to Sherlock's pre-Watson personality - a rationalized, detatched facade to hide the pain of the little child within. Ultimately, since Eurus is supposed to be an alternate version of Sherlock absent John and their love, one has to SURMISE this. But the writers did NOTHING to actually lay even the most basic ground work to support what they were going for. THAT is the bad writing problem here.
- 1,402 replies
-
Not only that, but recall it is NOT her sexuality or sexual proclivities to which Sherlock is drawn. Irene NAMES it - "brainy is the new sexy". He is attracted to her MIND (as she is to HIS), not to her being a Domin8trix. Trying to shift the attraction from the mind TO her being a domin8trix is a non-sequitur (at BEST). It's like saying "He's infatuated with her because her profession is Garbage Collector." It is most certainly NOT - and does a purposeful dis-service to Sherlock (and, one could argue, feminism) by claiming it IS. (Edited because it took me forever to discover that the 403 error was because this forum software doesn't like the correct spelling of domin8trix - sigh)
- 1,402 replies
-
Yes. And he didn't even turn pale, let alone vomit at the sight. His actions here ARE out of the explicit character we have seen, been told about, and can deduce.
- 1,402 replies
-
Indeed. I believe that is why he was excluded from being the trigger man. Foregone conclusion. And we essentially get proof of it in the very next 'experiment', where he explicitly chooses who will be killed, and explicitly, essentially says 'Pull the trigger on this one'.
- 1,402 replies
-
I have to disagree with Plaidders characterizations. Sherlock isn't a murderer. Mary is not a murderer for hire (so far as we've been shown). And who exactly have we seen Mary kill who was "undeserving" of it supposedly? Killing is not the same as murder. Equivocation between the two is the obliteration of justice.
- 1,402 replies
-
I know what you are trying to say with the analogy. It's basically saying he doesn't have the courage of his convictions. He believes killing meat is right, but is too cowardly to do it himself (he can't act on his principles). My point is that Mycroft explicitly states it is murder and he will not kill. He doesn't say he agrees with murder and killing but won't do it himself because it sickens him physically. He doesn't agree with it morally. He shrinks from it because he considers it wrong. He balks on moral grounds, not from lack of integrity.
- 1,402 replies
-
Indeed, as I've stated, I agree it can cost one much. I don't dispute it at all and have explicitly said so. As I ultimately pinpointed, my complaint is with the term 'sacrifice' used to identify that cost - to identify loss. My point was and is: if you are "NOT comparing what he gains and loses" then you should not be using the term sacrifice - any more than you should be using the term profit. Both terms identify specific (and opposing) comparisons between gains and losses. If that is NOT what you are doing - if you are NOT making a comparison - then neither of the terms apply. As I said, loss (cost, toll, suffering, change - whatever term you wish to use which MEANS loss) is NOT synonymous with sacrifice. While all sacrifice is loss, not all loss is sacrifice. In fact, most loss is NOT sacrifice.
- 1,402 replies
-
It's funny you mention that, because the whole time they kept going on about everyone being reprogrammed simply by being around Svengali Holmes, I kept thinking - BOY she spent a LOT of time with Watson, including as his THERAPIST! What reprogramming and enslavement did she perform on him (and if not, WHY not)?
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
That's quite lovely, and I like the thought. But I'm comparing what he gains and loses, frankly. I'm just thinking about how difficult it is for ordinary people to make such significant changes to their lives. But Sherlock's extraordinary, isn't he? "I'm comparing what he gains and loses" And you are saying the love and relationship he gains from his sister is worth LESS to him than, what exactly? Are you similarly saying that Sherlock's relationship with John, which has caused him to lose SO much (to change so much), has NOT been a sacrifice by your definition of the term? Or are you saying that his love and relationship for John is ALSO a sacrifice? If the latter, I must COMPLETELY disagree.
- 1,402 replies
-
So when a person gives up a hundred dollars in the hopes of achieving a million dollars in the future, even if there's a chance he won't see that future, that's a sacrifice? That makes essentially every act a sacrifice, because there are never guarantees that an expenditure of anything will result in what one hoped for when deciding to lose that expenditure. Again, it is defining loss AS sacrifice. They ain't the same. Also, I'm not arguing that what he gains is the 'hope' she will get better (though that can certainly be something he would want to gain). The playing with her, the living life with her, the experience of being with her, is the gain - as it is for him with John. Not any particular result. His working with John is NOT a sacrifice if John doesn't achieve some particular goal in the future which Sherlock hopes he will achieve. One's friendship and love (for her, or John, or anyone else) is not a MEANS to some OTHER end. IT is the value. And it is MORE valuable to Sherlock than his solitude or any thing else he might give up to have that love and friendship. THAT has been the whole point of the series (what we were saying before about love being the heart of the series).
- 1,402 replies
-
Again, I don't disagree that it will be less "easy for him". I simply disagree that less easy is synonymous with sacrifice. And I disagree that there's not much "return" (and that's not including any theraputic side effects).
- 1,402 replies
-
This isn't an echo of Bride. Bride was all ABOUT Eurus. I was saying that before Final aired. And they even SHOWED part of Bride in Final. ALL of it is about Eurus (and Redbeard), right down to the Waterfall. Bride is like Sixth Sense. Once you know the 'secret', its a completely different film.
- 1,402 replies
-
I see where I'm having a problem with your statement. Loss and Sacrifice are NOT synonymous. While all sacrifice is loss, not all loss is sacrifice (in fact most loss is NOT sacrifice). It is true that Sherlock loses some things by being in a relationship with Eurus, just as there are gains for him being in a relationship with Eurus. But ALL trades, all actions, involve loss. To walk, you have to lose energy, etc. The question of sacrifice - and profit - is the relationship between the value of what you lose and the value of what you gain. If you lose something of lesser value to you than that which you gain, that is profit, not sacrifice. If you lose something of greater value to you than that which you gain, then that is sacrifice. You have given up the greater value for the lesser value - you've lost a million dollars but gained 100 (for easy example). That is a sacrifice. You lose 100 dollars but gain a million. That is not a sacrifice. That is a profit.
- 1,402 replies
-
You missed about two minutes (plus the credits). We start with the girl on the plane. She discovers everyone asleep. She becomes afraid. She hears a phone ringing, finds it, and asks for help. Moriarty answers the crying girl, saying "Hello. My name is Jim Moriarty, welcome to The Final Problem" Cut to credits.
- 1,402 replies
-
It's not for purposes of 'being interesting' and all insights into an antagonist should 'raise the suspense quotient' (it's bad writing when it doesn't). But my point is more basic. We're shown a character who makes no sense. As we keep noting, it is as if she has two different personalities (and perhaps she does - its just NOT clear). This means there is a disconnect somewhere which the writers aren't identifying - one which NEEDS to be identified and rectified, especially when they indicate that both personalities are supposedly somehow working towards a single, planned goal. Basically, if this WERE two different people, we would have to have it explained HOW and WHY they were working together toward their common goal, especially if it doesn't make sense for one of them to BE working towards it and in fact seems to be working against it. THAT's the problem. The fact that it is ONE person just means we need a bit MORE of an explanation than we should get for two people. My point is that we didn't get the two person version of the explanation we need, let alone the additional explanation required on top of that for it being one person. (Was that last part intelligible?) No. They could eliminate everything up to Sherlock's return to the old homestead. They could re-write that as Sherlock DISCOVERING his mental walls (as a result of his pulling on threads that had been flapping in his face since Bride), pulling them down brick by brick, and the catharsis involved in those things, all occurring while pursuing this woman who is supposedly a sister he didn't know he had (and all occurring BECAUSE -he- is pursuing her). The whole episode could have exactly the same themes - about Eurus being both the villain and the person who needs saving - and could have been done as DRAMA, as meaningful, plot driven conflict, rather than pointless, Eurus driven "morality" plays. They didn't need another episode. They just needed to do BETTER writing - SHOWING, not TELLING. Drama, NOT exposition dumps. My point and complaint is that they did NOT spend most of it with Sherlock. They spent most of it with Eurus, who happened to be dragging Sherlock along on a leash. BIG difference. I agree they needed to integrate 4.2 and 4.3 much better. I don't believe that required a lull however. In fact, the first 20 minutes or so (ie until we go to the island) that was pretty much boring - and useless bangs. That was too much of a lull). I don't disagree. I just don't see the "huge sacrifice" - again, what is he giving up that is supposedly the greater value? NOT having her in his life? NOT having her alive? There is a difference between easier and more valued/valuable.
- 1,402 replies
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)