-
Posts
48 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
3
Everything posted by Brainy
-
Thanks for the explanation, aely!
-
that's interesting hmm.. so I could order it.. should I, shouldn't I..
-
Is "The Mentalist" a Take on Sherlock?
Brainy replied to Banshee's topic in General Sherlock Holmes Discussion
Personally, I don't like The Mentalist very much.. In both series viewers won't be able to find the solution to the problem when watching the episode for the first time. However, when watching Sherlock everything seems logical in the end. When watching the Mentalist I often think 'ok, so that's the solution.. but it doesn't make any sense'. In Sherlock you can add up all the bits and pieces (maybe having to watch some scenes again to fully understand), and in the end you will always say 'yes, this makes perfectly sense'. The Mentalist often comes to conclusions which don't make sense to me. Many times there aren't any hints that lead you to the culprit and in the end someone totally out of context is the murderer. At least that's my impression which is why I wouldn't like to compare The Mentalist with Sherlock. -
really? I thought this game is about finding a murderer. So, if I'm not the murderer, the other player has to be. So how is it possible to play with two players?
-
200 400 600 700 -- 1,000 members now!
Brainy replied to Alice Holmes's topic in Forum News and Updates.
Hmm.. maybe you should promote this forum via Facebook, ask Sherlockology/other fansites whether you could share links etc.? I like this forum very much, but I have to confess that a livelier discussion would definitely add to the fun. More active users - more discussion. -
Sherlockology & Other Resources
Brainy replied to SherLOCKED221's topic in BBC Sherlock General Discussion.
I love Sherlockology! Shame I didn't win the hand-signed casebook in the last competition.. -
Cluedo has to be played by at least 3 players, hasn't it? So it unfortunately won't work for me since nobody else in my family is interested in either board games or english..
-
Moffat's next "Three Words" (Spoilers!!!)
Brainy replied to Carol the Dabbler's topic in Rumours & Speculation
I'm soooooooo excited!!! -
Yes, in Germany, couples normally wear their wedding ring on the right hand. If you wear it on the left, it usually means that your partner has passed away. Not all people stick to that tradition, of course. But that's like the 'general rule' here in Germany. Ohhhhh.. I didn't get that until now! Thanks for pointing it out!
-
I don't think that the vest is a dummy. I was also wondering why Sherlock decided to aim at the vest rather than Moriarty himself. But then I thought.. maybe he wants to show him that he is ready to do anything 'for the greater good' (switching to Harry Potter here, sorry ). I mean, he and John show Moriarty that they aren't afraid of him at all, that he can't play the 'game' as he had planned because Sherlock and John are willing to change it, even though that means that they're putting themselves into danger. And that is what surprises Moriarty. His plans have always worked out because he pulled the strings. Now, there are two individuals who understand his game and are willing to break the pattern. So it's probably 'just' a power play between Moriarty and the others, establishing Moriarty and Sherlock as equals. When I think about that scene I also have to think about the scene in Reichenbach Fall where Sherlock says something like 'I might be on the side of the angels but don't ever think I'm one of them'. He knows Moriarty's 'style'. Sherlock is capable of thinking as evil as Moriarty, but he will always change the plan for a better outcome, no matter what it takes.
- 607 replies
-
- 1
-
-
- Episode Discussions
- Series 1
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
What would Sherlock make of the Olympics?
Brainy replied to Banshee's topic in BBC Sherlock General Discussion.
Yes, that would be nice, too. And I guess Sherlock would by really annoyed by Mycroft's 'duties'. Surely he'd be entitled to hand over the gold medals for GB -
Hi Our Division! Have fun!
-
What would Sherlock make of the Olympics?
Brainy replied to Banshee's topic in BBC Sherlock General Discussion.
I guess he'd make a gender study out of it You know, human's psyche and people's need for power and those things. How the body reacts to pressure etc. Or he wouldn't be interested at all Oh and he would be annoyed by the huge amount of traffic, a lot more people using the tube and needing cabs. That would really annoy him I guess. Sherlock would receive VIP Tickets because of all his achievements, handing them over to John, who is happy to spend a day away from Sherlock - and with Sarah. -
I'm not sure but that's how it is in the canon isn't it? Mycroft supporing Sherlock while he's 'away'? (sorry, just started reading the stories and I only listened to a few audio books so far) *edit* - sorry, I didn't read your post thoroughly enough - so it is in the book. I can't decide which version is more realistic.. Sherlock and John hugging after a moment of perplexity - or John giving Sherlock the silent treatment. I would prefer the 2nd version.. this way the producers can include a flashback to the 'sherlock-free' months/years. Maybe Sherlock (after he's back) gets himself into some kind of mess or dangerous situation and John realizes that and helps him even if he's angry with him. John rescues Sherlock and Sherlock apologizes - and they both hug. This would be my little female dream.
-
I found you here: http://fanlore.org/wiki/List_of_Sherlock_Holmes_Communities_and_Forums
-
I never thought about this - interesting point! I'll also have to re-watch the jumping scene and pay attention to the 2 different shirts. Thanks for pointing that out! Naturally I also have my theories and they've been mentioned in this thread so I won't repeat them. (the Rhododendron ponticum theory sounds quite good to me, but so do many theories..) However, I was wondering whether you think that Lestrade is in on it, too? After all, apart from John and Mrs Hudson he's Sherlock's 3rd friend and probably Sherlock and Molly will need a good connection to the police to cover up the fake? And what I'm always thinking about is whether Sherlock knew that Moriarty would 'kill' himself or whether this twist came to him as a surprise.. What do you think?
-
Oh yeah, I noticed that too. I think he has a fair point. Even though Sherlock isn't an easy character to live with, he's provided him with a home, a friend and a 'job', more or less. And the most important thing is - they trust each other very much. So one will always owe the other one something, because they risk their necks for their friendship. (Although having a friendship doesn't require 'owing' anything to anybody - but I hope you understand what I mean ) And concerning Molly.. I think she'll play a huge role in the next episode. But I guess that discussion better fits in the rumours and speculation board.
- 1,303 replies
-
- 1
-
-
- Episode Discussion
- Polls
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Maybeee we'll all have to change our opinion on that topic after we've seen the solution to Reichenbach Fall. Even though I think I'd always pick Sherlock as my favourite character, I think Molly might be a good choice as well.
- 243 replies
-
- 2
-
-
- Polls
- Characters
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
So true! Every time I watch an episode there seems to be something new. For example, I never noticed the I O U graffiti in Reichenbach Fall until recently. I love films that give you something to think about and that make you want to watch them over and over again.
- 1,303 replies
-
- Episode Discussion
- Polls
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Since I'm very much interested in languages (I study German and English language) I really love the play on words in this episode.. "I love newspapers...fairy tales..and pretty grim/Grimm ones, too." - I love that sentence! It shows that the producers really are interested in detailedness.
- 1,303 replies
-
- 1
-
-
- Episode Discussion
- Polls
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Stories Behind Your User Names & Avatar Pictures.
Brainy replied to Carol the Dabbler's topic in Introduce yourself here.
Hi everyone! I'm Brainy because brainy's the new sexy, isn't it? And who's sexy? --> Benedict! So that explains my avatar. -
Hi everyone! I'm Brainy from Germany. I'm really glad that I found this message board since I became a huge Sherlock fan over the past months. It's been such a long time since I've watched such a wonderful TV series with so much content and so much to talk about. Naturally, as I'm female, I'm also a teensy bit cumberbatched and I really hope there's much more to look forward to, 3rd season etc. In the meantime I'd love to talk to you about all the great stuff that is in Sherlock 1+2. Apart from Sherlock I like music, reading and the English language and London. I've been to London many times and I'm really fascinated by this city. If you have any questions, feel free to ask! Now I'll start exploring this message board.
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)