General Sherlock Holmes Discussion

101 topics in this forum

1. R.I.P........ (Holmes-related) 1 2

   By HerlockSholmes, November 15, 2017
   • 29 replies
   • 8.5k views
   • 
   • BBally1981
   • February 6

2. (non-BBC-Sherlock) Holmes-related Miscellany 1 2

   By sfmpco, May 17, 2015
   • 34 replies
   • 12.9k views
   • 
   • Carol the Dabbler
   • November 14, 2017
3. In one episode do Sherlock and John both see Mary's ghost at the same time or does she appear to them separately?

   Topic was moved to forum BBC Sherlock General Discussion.

4. Sherlock Holmes & Young Sherlock books

   By L.Homes, September 3
   • 1 reply
   • 110 views
   • 
   • Carol the Dabbler
   • September 3

5. "Anti-Social Complete Jerk" Sherlock Holmes VS "Sentimental Nice Guy" Sherlock Holmes

   By BBally1981, July 16   

   • sherlock holmes
   • 5 replies
   • 309 views
   • 
   • Carol the Dabbler
   • August 29

6. New Holmes-type deductions

   By Carol the Dabbler, August 15
   • 2 replies
   • 143 views
   • 
   • Carol the Dabbler
   • August 26

7. Which author would be recommended for reading the "Missing Cases of Sherlock Holmes"? 1 2 3 4

   By Abhay Saini, July 4, 2020
   • 84 replies
   • 4.3k views
   • 
   • Carol the Dabbler
   • April 3

8. Question for fans of ACD Holmes or other adaptations

   By Carol the Dabbler, February 27
   • 5 replies
   • 338 views
   • 
   • HerlockSholmes
   • March 4

9. Sherlock Holmes Quote on Love

   By Kathleen B., February 7
   • 11 replies
   • 491 views
   • 
   • HerlockSholmes
   • February 23

10. Transporting Conan Doyle's characters and themes into BBC Sherlock

    By Kat, February 17
    • 7 replies
    • 352 views
    • 
    • Kat
    • February 19

11. The real Moriarty?

    By Carol the Dabbler, January 20
    • 1 reply
    • 266 views
    • 
    • Jen
    • January 20

12. Sherlock Holmes's Birthday 1 2 3 4

    By RV0889, January 6, 2014
    • 89 replies
    • 9.4k views
    • 
    • HerlockSholmes
    • January 9

13. Sherlock ships 1 2 3 4

    By Valkyrie123, January 29, 2020   

    • sherlock
    • ships
    • (and 4 more)

      Tagged with:

      • sherlock
      • ships
      • sherlolly
      • johnlock
      • adlock
      • and more
    • 77 replies
    • 5.8k views
    • 
    • Arcadia
    • November 20, 2020

14. A Grand Conspiracy?

    By daffodilkhan, September 22, 2020   

    • moriarty
    • canon
    • (and 2 more)

      Tagged with:

      • moriarty
      • canon
      • films
      • adler
    • 1 reply
    • 278 views
    • 
    • Carol the Dabbler
    • September 23, 2020

15. Sherlock Holmes' Connection To Rise Of The Superhero

    By BBally1981, September 21, 2020   

    • comics
    • pulp
    • (and 1 more)

      Tagged with:

      • comics
      • pulp
      • superheroes
    • 2 replies
    • 284 views
    • 
    • daffodilkhan
    • September 23, 2020

16. kungfu A 1994 Kung Fu Movie Starring Sherlock Holmes

    By BBally1981, September 8, 2020   

    • sherlock
    • holmes
    • (and 1 more)

      Tagged with:

      • sherlock
      • holmes
      • noncanon
    • 7 replies
    • 661 views
    • 
    • Artemis
    • September 11, 2020

17. Research methods

    By Chris, June 4, 2020
    • 7 replies
    • 1.2k views
    • 
    • Carol the Dabbler
    • July 10, 2020

18. Was Arthur Conan Doyle vastly inflating his own ego when he made Holmes and Moriarty as the greatest minds in Europe?

    By Abhay Saini, June 26, 2020
    • 5 replies
    • 393 views
    • 
    • Carol the Dabbler
    • June 27, 2020

19. Ranking Original sherlockian villains

    By Abhay Saini, June 26, 2020
    • 6 replies
    • 509 views
    • 
    • Carol the Dabbler
    • June 27, 2020

20. Why didn't Holmes hide in the English countryside, wearing his inimitable getup rather than going abroad in the Final problem?

    By Abhay Saini, June 26, 2020
    • 4 replies
    • 362 views
    • 
    • Abhay Saini
    • June 27, 2020

21. Sherlock Memes

    By Valkyrie123, June 20, 2020   

    • memes
    • funny
    • (and 7 more)

      Tagged with:

      • memes
      • funny
      • sherlock
      • follow
      • sherlock memes
      • sherlocked123
      • join
      • hi
      • lots of tags lol
    • 15 replies
    • 746 views
    • 
    • Carol the Dabbler
    • June 22, 2020

22. Lestrade pronounciation 1 2 3

    By Pawse, April 9, 2014
    • 69 replies
    • 26.5k views
    • 
    • Carol the Dabbler
    • June 20, 2020

23. heading for essay that compares Doyle's work with the TV show ''Sherlock''

    By johnlock, February 16, 2016   

    • sherlock
    • sherlock holmes
    • (and 3 more)

      Tagged with:

      • sherlock
      • sherlock holmes
      • bbc
      • arthur conan doyle
      • help
    • 4 replies
    • 2.2k views
    • 
    • Valkyrie123
    • June 20, 2020

24. A Collector’s Lot 1 2 3 4 11

    By HerlockSholmes, January 13, 2018
    • 260 replies
    • 20.3k views
    • 
    • Carol the Dabbler
    • June 16, 2020

25. Which Sherlock Holmes are you? 1 2 3 4 7

    By Shadow Dweller, July 28, 2015
    • 158 replies
    • 13.5k views
    • 
    • Carol the Dabbler
    • June 16, 2020