Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi. So I was wondering - how has Sherlock gone down over the pond? I live in the UK and it's pretty huge here. Obviously, as it's set in London/UK us Brits are familiar with the scenery and how things work generally. I've got off the bus on Baker Street on numerous occasions, for example. How have you (non UK dwellers) come to love Sherlock? :)

Posted

I live in the state of Maine, USA and I am have no trouble being extremely impressed with this new vision of Sherlock Holmes. It was tried back in the 1980's but it didn't fly at all. In this version Holmes is poisoned, Watson cryogenically freezes him and moves the whole operation to California. Watson dies with Holmes left in frozen limbo. It is Watson's grand-daughter who finds Holmes, revives him, and cures him of the poison.

 

Anyway, I like what the BBC has done and the references to the original stories do help. But Cumberbatch brings such energy and intelligence to the role. Freeman is a very believable Watson. Savvy with the right amount of bravery and loyalty. The way he balances the frenetic Sherlock is brilliant.

  • Like 2
Posted

I quite agree. It's a well-chosen pairing. I think Mofiss have done a wonderful job. I've been reading Gatiss's novels recently and it's clear they both have a wonderful eye for character.

Posted

I didn't know Gatiss wrote novels. One busy man what with writing for Dr. Who, Sherlock, and heading up the Undershaw project. We can't always get books produced in the UK but I do know a local bookstore that will certainly try.

Posted

... in the 1980's ... version Holmes is poisoned, Watson cryogenically freezes him and moves the whole operation to California. Watson dies with Holmes left in frozen limbo. It is Watson's grand-daughter who finds Holmes, revives him, and cures him of the poison.

That's been mentioned elsewhere on this forum, and it sounds intriguing. D'you know if it's available on DVD?

 

As for how Sherlock's faring in the US, I know two types of people over here -- those who love Sherlock and those who've never heard of it. This is probably not to say that anyone who might see the show would love it, but rather that the natural audience for such a program thinks very, very highly of this version.

 

Amazon.com is good, but there are some British things that they do not carry. For those items, we order from Amazon.co.uk, which will ship just about anywhere in the world for a reasonable fee. For example, we actually pre-ordered the region 2 DVD of Sherlock's second season from them, and just about had all the episodes memorized by the time PBS ran them four months later. Of course, this takes a region-free DVD player, but we already had one. (And by the way, that's apparently what's on most laptops.)

Posted

I don't know if that Pilot can be found or not. I used to have it on VCR tape, but haven't seen it for years. I think it was called "Sherlock Holmes 1994" or something like that.

Posted

Thanks, Bakerstreet! I'll put that on my list of videos to watch next time I'm in a place that has high-speed internet service (e.g., my husband's office).

Posted

Of course, this takes a region-free DVD player, but we already had one. (And by the way, that's apparently what's on most laptops.)

 

Caution should be applied here, because some computer (laptop or desktop) DVD drives will allow you to change their region from that which is factory preset, to another, the caveat being that they restrict the amount of times this can be done (usually to 5 times) Once you have used these changes the region is locked to the final selection made.

Posted

I assume that such drives are civilized enough to make you explicitly request each region change, or at least let you know that they're making one of x allowable changes? That's be a nasty surprise otherwise!

 

Speaking of field-programmable DVD players, some of the ostensibly single-region name-brand players that hook up to your tv can actually be changed to any specific region or even to region free if you know the simple procedure. Of course the manufacturer doesn't document it, but you can sometimes find directions by Googling, or by checking Amazon reviews. That's how we got ours a few years back. (The manufacturers may have gotten sneakier by now, though.)

Posted

I had a dvd drive in my computer that wasn't region specific, but the software I used was for a certain number of watches - at that time I was using Power dvd - and that always warned me how many goes I had left. I used to just uninstall it before it got locked, then reinstall it again so I could start from scratch. Then I found VLC and didn't have to worry any more! Can't exactly do that with a dvd player. I remember when we were still in the days of watching vcrs that it was a big thing to try and get a video player that was ntsc compatible (so I could watch my Highlander videos).

 

DVDs don't have to be region specific. Joss Whedon made a point of stipulating that the Firefly dvds were NOT to be region specific.

 

My current dvd player is region free - it was the cheapest one I could find in Asda at the time!

Posted

I assume that such drives are civilized enough to make you explicitly request each region change, or at least let you know that they're making one of x allowable changes? That's be a nasty surprise otherwise!

 

Yes, the OS specifically warns you if there is a limit on region switches, and tells you how many you have left.

Posted

DVDs don't have to be region specific. Joss Whedon made a point of stipulating that the Firefly dvds were NOT to be region specific.

Bless his heart! :wub:

 

 

At first, I assumed that the DVD regions were a compatibility thing, like the VHS / Beta battle. Then I found out that it's something the big studios and the big player manufacturers are doing so we "can't" watch DVDs from other countries.

 

That's what they think!

  • 1 year later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 218 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.