Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I just realized I started posting without saying hello.

 

:wave:

 

I found Sherlock only about a week ago when I signed up for Netflix, which streams the full 90 minutes. I think I've watched it through at least six times by now.

 

It's almost embarrassing, I'm much too old to become a raving lunatic fan of some TV show and lead actor.

 

Too late, it seems.

 

I shall have to buy a t-shirt!

  • Like 1
Posted

Hello again! It sounds like you're more than making up for your tardiness with your enthusiasm!

 

 

It's almost embarrassing, I'm much too old to become a raving lunatic fan of some TV show and lead actor.

Hey, Martin Freeman's John Watson :watson: is my favorite character since Leonard Nimoy's Mr. Spock :llap:

 

This show just seems to have that sort of effect on people.

Posted

Raving lunatics are very interesting people, I should know. I have been known to rave and am very interesting, I'm sure. So you are in good company Allin1.

Posted

Hello AllIn1, :welcome:

 

And I am firmly of the opinion that you're never too old to be fanatical! :D

Posted

It's almost embarrassing, I'm much too old to become a raving lunatic fan of some TV show and lead actor.

That's what I thought too, even when I was a teenager, I was never obsessed with any celebrity the way I am obsessed with BC. But what can I do, I can't struggle, so I have decided to give up the battle and embrace it instead.

 

Welcome!

Posted

Raving lunatics are very interesting people, I should know. I have been known to rave and am very interesting, I'm sure. So you are in good company Allin1.

 

"There are always some lunatics about. It would be a dull world without them".

 

- Sherlock Holmes.

  • Like 1
Posted

I am firmly of the opinion that you're never too old to be fanatical!

Couldn't agree more!

 

As The Doctor has said "There's no point in being grown up if you can't be childish sometimes" and "Anybody remotely interesting is mad, in some way or another" so I'm quite happy to be madly fanatical - it's OK, The Doctor said so!

Posted Image

Posted

Hello again! It sounds like you're more than making up for your tardiness with your enthusiasm!

 

 

 

 

Hey, Martin Freeman's John Watson :watson: is my favorite character since Leonard Nimoy's Mr. Spock :llap:

 

This show just seems to have that sort of effect on people.

 

One of the mistakes that they make, I think, is under-writing his character - Sherlock told us who Watson is: a hero, nerves of steel. Watson told us what kind of doctor he is: very good. Freeman is just marvellous, but I want to scream and shout at them to make Watson more of what he should be!

 

What do you think? There must be a Watson discussion, perhaps I should go there.....

Posted

Oh I think we get some measure of Watson as a hero with nerves of steel when he can shoot and kill a mad cabbie to save the life of a man he has known barely twenty four hours. And Sherlock describes that when he is giving his deductions to Lestrade at the back of the ambulance.

 

Also he is the first person that can deal with the frenetic Sherlock and actually take the time to try to understand the man and even care enough to correct Sherlock's more socially inept traits. If that don't take nerves of steel I don't know what would.

Posted

It's almost embarrassing, I'm much too old to become a raving lunatic fan of some TV show and lead actor.

 

Too late, it seems.

 

I shall have to buy a t-shirt!

 

Oh Yes! Join the rest of us raving lunatics; don your "I am SHER LOCKED' tee shirt, and enjoy the companionship. :D

  • Like 1
Posted

I don't have a tshirt, but I do have a SHERLocked pendant...

  • Like 1
  • 1 month later...
Posted

Hello again! It sounds like you're more than making up for your tardiness with your enthusiasm!

 

 

 

So, bet it looks like I lost my enthusiam since I left and just got back! I figured I need a re-introduction, so...

 

There was this blizzard. And I got snowed in for a week. So I watched 6 episodes of Sherlock over and over. And over. When I finally got my life back, I realized I couldn't post on forums because I didn't know what I thought, yet. So, I had to stop and figure that out which I wrote down and ended up making a blog out of because I seem to be incapable of thinking without writing. (Which I would link to, but I think I need to fix a few things, first.)

 

So now at least, if I post, I'll be able to refer to something that should have a clear explanation. Maybe. Sorta.

Posted

One of the mistakes that they make, I think, is under-writing his character - Sherlock told us who Watson is: a hero, nerves of steel. Watson told us what kind of doctor he is: very good. Freeman is just marvellous, but I want to scream and shout at them to make Watson more of what he should be!

 

What do you think? There must be a Watson discussion, perhaps I should go there.....

Sorry I didn't reply to this at the time -- didn't see it, somehow. I don't recall there being a Watson discussion as such, but there is a good bit of discussion about the character here and there. If you'd like a dedicated discussion, though, just start a new topic (thread) for it. (I'll join you there!)

 

I fully agree that John is underwritten. Maybe "they" want to make it clear that Sherlock is the hero of the show. But I've been saying all along (well, ever since I discovered this forum) that I'd really like to see more of John-as-a-doctor, just for one example. In the good-news department (judging by the series-3 leaks so far), we're about to see more of BAMF John, which is fine by me.

 

 

... I realized I couldn't post on forums because I didn't know what I thought, yet. So, I had to stop and figure that out which I wrote down... So now at least, if I post, I'll be able to refer to something....

Good heavens -- thinking things through before posting. How refreshing!

 

Welcome back!

  • Like 1
Posted

I fully agree that John is underwritten. Maybe "they" want to make it clear that Sherlock is the hero of the show. But I've been saying all along (well, ever since I discovered this forum) that I'd really like to see more of John-as-a-doctor, just for one example.

YES!!!!! (John Watson: Too Dumb to be a Doctor)

 

 

Good heavens -- thinking things through before posting. How refreshing!

 

Welcome back!

 

Thanks! Not too many things make me literally LOL when I'm online, but this did. I'll try to make it a habit around here.

  • Like 1
Posted

Thanks for the blog link (that's yours?) -- couldn't agree more.

 

And you're welcome for the laugh!

  • Like 1
Posted

Welcome back, AllIn1. I have to agree with you and Carol. It's nice to see John H. Watson as some one strong enough to go toe to toe with Sherlock his soldier side. But he was more then just a good doctor and it would be very nice indeed to see that side of him in he show.

Posted

Thanks for the blog link (that's yours?) -- couldn't agree more.

 

 

Yes. See, I talk too much. So this way, instead of overwhelming threads (as I am wont to do) I can just link to something people can ignore if they aren't interested in the idea. I have to do some editing, though. But I really missed posting on a forum and having the feedback and "hive mind" effect.

Posted

Hmm, folks on this forum might be relieved if I started a blog. :P

 

 

Your ideas and feedback are most welcome here!

Posted

Wow, talk about plot holes. Read your blog, AllIn1 very observant. They really should try to do better by DR. John H. Watson because in the canon he was more then competent though there were some similar plot holes as well or rather lack of consistency in details.

Posted

Wow, talk about plot holes. Read your blog, AllIn1 very observant. They really should try to do better by DR. John H. Watson because in the canon he was more then competent though there were some similar plot holes as well or rather lack of consistency in details.

 

I know there are always holes. I once wrote an 8000 word essay explanation of Jo Rowling's appalling faux pas about "magic being a dominant" gene, including a multi-focal genetic theory of magicism as a trait. We were always having to explain away stuff, just like Sherlock Holmes fans have been doing for over 100 years and we will be doing, I suppose, for years on forums like this.

 

But I don't care. I recall when no one I knew had a TV. I've watched for many decades now. This show is like a miracle to me, amazing in it's originality. Finally, something to watch again.

 

Won't stop me from criticizing, tho.'

Posted

I remember playing cowboys and indians out in the woods even when we had a tv. But yes, we do have the space to grouse about things like did Watson have one wound, two wounds....was one a ghost pain as in the BBC Sherlock....and why can't Moffat and Gatiss do a better job at writing up our Dr. John as a higher class of physician, for heaven's sake.

  • Like 1
Posted

I spent my childhood summers reading library books and climbing trees, but then was something of a tv junkie till about 10 years ago, when Hubby and I switched to watching DVDs because there weren't any more good shows. We would never have discovered Sherlock if a friend hadn't had it on when we were visiting. I'm not entirely certain why it's hit me so hard. Hubby says it's because the acting is so good, and that's undeniably a large part of it, but I think what originally hooked me was the overall effect. It's my kinda show. And I was so glad to find this forum -- I do enjoy the grousing!

AllIn1, I don't suppose you have your "magic gene" essay online anywhere?

Posted

I spent my childhood summers reading library books and climbing trees,

I still remember the bookmobile that used to come through town. Dad would drive us to a local store to meet it. I used to have a favorite tree that I used to nestle in and read on a warm day. But Sherlock Holmes has always been a draw for me, don't know why. I collect almost anything I can find that relates to the Victorian era Holmes and now this BBC version is just riveting.

 

These discussions are interesting and enlightening. It's fun to see how many kinds of interpretations there can be out there. And yes, AllIn1, I think that would essay would be something to read as well.

Posted

HOLY COW MY REPLY SCREEN FINALLY WORKS!!!!!   :wave: 

 

phew

 

I had to switch browsers from Firefox to Chrome.  I couldn't post PM or start a topic in Firefox.  Scared me.

 

The Leaky Cauldron redid their site and they are supposed to have archives, but I couldn't find a my old posts and the essay went down with the blue screen of death on my last machine.  However, before I retired, genetics was part of my field and I can give a simplish explanation if anyone cares.  Essentially we are talking about needing three loci with multiple alleles.  The trick is, you need exactly the right combo to have magicism as a trait.  And only the M is dominant, the other two are recessive.  This means that all sorts of "normal" people have the M gene, but - it's not expressed as magicism (being a wizard or witch) unless the other two necessary recessive alleles on other chromosomes are also present.

 

This accounts for the very low % of wizards in the population.  But having that M if you are still a muggle is the difference between a house painter and a Rembrandt, a music lover and a Mozart.   There are millions of us with M, magic gene, without having the trait of magicism.  (Which I'm convinced is absolutely true.)

 

Also, in the wizarding world, you never get great art, great music and sculpture and poetry - the magicism gene combo represses certain activity in the right cerebral cortex because the magicism takes up so much biological energy in associated areas.  Hence, they are pretty much stuck with the Weird Sisters and their ilk.  

 

Anyway, the multi-local theory explain why two muggles can produce a wizard, what with Rowling proclaiming the gene dominant.  That's bare bones but covers the basics.

 

 

I'm just so relieved, I had a thread I wanted to start and this is the best place to talk Sherlock, I think.  Much less competitive, you see.   More welcoming.  Guess I'll do that tomorrow.  I hope no one else is having the same problem posting.  The only thing that worked was the post report button!  

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 118 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.