Jump to content

SolitaryCyclist

Detectives
  • Posts

    82
  • Joined

  • Days Won

    1

Everything posted by SolitaryCyclist

  1. I just finished reading The Beekeepers Apprentice, and I agree with this observation completely. The book was readable and enjoyable, except for King's denigration of Watson. For my money, she did not need to do this to cement the relationship between Mary and Holmes. It felt like a cheap shot, to me. So saying, I will read the next book anyway. I'd like to think that she mellows her attitude toward Watson, but from reading earlier comments on this thread, I fear not.
  2. Yay Helene! I'm so glad you found your way here Enjoy the conversation and speculation...just how did Sherlock survive that fall????
  3. Carol and Fox, your speculation seems the most plausible of any I've read so far. After all, Sherlock was the one who picked the venue for the final confrontation with Moriarty, so I think we have to believe that just about everything we see in the scene has been stage managed by him. He told Molly he thought he was going to die. We don't know what they subsequenlty talked about, but it was surely how to prevent this.
  4. Agreed! Those prices translate to over $200.00 per figurene. Amazing, though, the incredible detail on the sculpts.
  5. Both Sherlock fans and Tolkien fans; what a wonderful place this is! I love Martin Freeman as Bilbo, and am ecstatic that Peter Jackson has turned the Hobbit into three movies (could one ever get enought of MIddle Earth?). Tolkien was never really happy that the The Hobbit was written as a children's story: as the story progresses, you can see a change in the tone from the early chapters to a darker tone in the later ones. And all the incredible background material in the LOTR appendices just aching to be movie material. Thank God for Peter Jackson and his love and vision of Tolkiens' Middle Earth.
  6. It was good to read this discussion, as I am about to begin 'The Beekeepers Apprentice.' It is always a bit of a risk when we find a beloved character in the hands of someone not his/her creator.
  7. This all sounds very encouraging. I must admitt, my heart sank a bit when reading interpretations of 'bow' as meaning the end of the series on the BBC. The story 'His Final Bow' takes place on the eve of WWI, and of course by then Sherlock and Watson are likely in their sixties. Broadly, it is a story about Sherlock unmasking a German spy. Seems to me this could be used as a story of unmasking a cyber-spy, or something like. Plenty of espionage in the here-and-now.
  8. Doubly agreed!
  9. Sounds like a dream vacation, Carol, for all us Sherlock fans and Anglophiles.
  10. And Molly was 'overlooked' by Moriarty; a significant error on his part. Of all Sherlock's friends, she is the only one free to operate.
  11. I was skeptical that Holmes would be translated to the 21st century with his personality intact. Was afraid that producers and writers would figure 'a new angle' on Sherlock and murder him in the process. Mofitss and company have found a new angle, but in all the positive ways one could hope for! Holmes was a bohemian in the Victorian/Edwardian era, which made him edgy and intolerant of social convention. This modern Sherlock is certainly all of that, and as noted before, uses all the cutting edge tech available to him, just as he did in 1895. The respect that everyone involved has for the original canon is evident in every episode. It is a pure joy to watch. Skeptic no longer!
  12. Which speaks volumes about Peter Jackson's respect for Martin Freeman. Having seen him in 'An Unexpected Journey,' I can't imagine anyone else as Bilbo. For that matter, can't imagine anyone else as our Sherlock's Watson
  13. Coming late to the discussion, I loved Jeremy Brett as Holmes, and definitely preferred Edward Hardwicke as Watson. Hardwicke seemed to be less obsequious than Burke. The healthy Jeremy Brett was the perfect physical representation of Holmes.
  14. Welcome, Wildwoodflower! I am new here as well, and happy to find a place to share with fellow obsessives. I love the original canon, and can be skeptical of adaptations, but the BBC Sherlock is beyond awesome.
  15. Brilliant, Fox, I missed this completely! So as regards canon, maybe Moftiss are not above altering it a bit, if our contemporary Irene lives, and the ConanDoyle Irene does not.
  16. Musing on Molly, she counts precisly because she didn't. I love Molly; she is 'grace' personified: love freely given, with no thought of reward. As besleybean says, she is Sherlock's secret weapon. And as Brainy says, did Sherlock realize that at some point he might need Molly? After all, you never know when you might be in need of a spare corpse.
  17. The quality is fine. This is the second shirt I've ordered from them. The first was my Husband's Christmas gift (a geek-oriented shirt), and he love it.
  18. Rat: The Giant Rat of Sumatra "...a story for which the world is not yet prepared." This beast is mentioned in the ConanDoyle story The Sussex Vampire. So maybe, the 'rat' episode will involve vampirism; very popular these days Wedding: There are several possible wedding episodes. Mentioned here already are Charles Augustus Milverton, a blackmailer. The Sign of Four, where John meets and becomes engaged to Mary Morsten (although The Blind Banker seemed more of a Sign of Four derivative). And, A Case of Identity, also mentioned. Then there is The Solitary Cyclist, where a young women is married against her will. The Noble Bachelor, where a nobleman marries an American Heiress, and 20 minutes later she disappears! The Abbey Grange has a young Australian woman recently married to a vile noblemen, who ends up dead of a crushed skull. And, The Illustrious Client, where a young woman is engaged to a charming murderer, and Sherlock is engaged to disengage her Bow. As mentioned, His Final Bow is the name both of a short story, and the second to last collection of short stories that ConanDoyle wrote; eight stories all together: Wisteria Lodge, The Cardboard Box, The Red Circle, The Bruce Partington Plans (already alluded to in The Blind Banker?), The Dying Detective (I see elements of this in The Reichenbach Fall), The Lady Francis Carfax, The Devils Foot (parts of which I see in The Baskerville Hound), and His Final Bow. Wow...there are a LOT of possibilites in those three words!
  19. I just received my "I AM SHER- LOCKED" T-shirt from Cafe Press. The lettering on the shirt is the same format as Irene's phone; white lettering on black. They had literally pages of Sherlock and John themed shirts. Here is a link: http://www.cafepress.com/+sherlock+t-shirts Enjoy!
  20. It is amazing to me, Carol, how very real Sherlock Homles is. As you read the Doyle stories, he becomes. That is the best way I can put it. By the end of the canon, you believe this man actually existed in Victorian/Edwardian England. And to think that he 'really' didn't, makes one (or at least me) a bit sad. The world needs Sherlock. And Watson. For sure.
  21. This I don't recall; do you remember which story this would have been in? I always hoped Irene would show up again, but she never does. At least not in the stories and novels that Conan Doyle wrote. In The Empty House, the only person that Sherlock let into the secret that he was still alive is Mycroft. Maybe in this incarnation, the only one to know is Molly. As someone else stated, too many people 'in on it' and it ceases to be a secret. And yes; Sherlock NEVER gave his hand away until the very end of an investigation.
  22. Interesting, I came to this forum in search of thoughts on how Sherlock survived his fall from St. Barth's...and it made great reading! I think most folks lurk at first to get a feel for the type of conversation; no one wants to look foolish. I'm usually a lurker, but not this time. I think because of the friendly tone of all the discussion I read before posting.
  23. Hi Dkmystery! The scene at the Diogenes club is also a salute to the original canon. Watson first meets Mycroft at the Diogenese club in The Greek Interpeter. It is a club for misanthropists...haters of mankind. They do not speak to one another in the club...ever. And this is Mycrofts' club. The original Watson has the same trouble our John has 100+ years later. I love the way the writers and produces KNOW their Sherlock
  24. Oh, this is indeed great fun! I look at that scene, and I see no possible way that Sherlock alone could cut his way out of a terrorist cell, dragging Irene along with him...where is she suppose to run? But...if this is impossible, then, improbable as it may be, the whole thing has been stage managed by Sherlock, with or wihout his big brother's help. I like it either way. In what particular did Mycroft lie to John? And anyway, what have we got to do but think these things through until the third season??
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.