Surelock
Detectives-
Posts
381 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Surelock
-
http://arianedevere.livejournal.com/92287.html EURUS: I’m letting the water in now. You don’t want me to drown another one of your pets, do you? At long last, Sherlock Holmes, it’s time to solve the Musgrave ritual. (Sherlock stumbles back from the screen.) EURUS: Your very first case! And the final problem. (Her voice drops to a whisper.) Oh. Bye-bye. The Final Problem is ironically also Sherlock's first problem: Euro's song puzzle.
- 1,402 replies
-
Yes but I'm not sure how that works because I don't see how Moriarty told Sherlock about Euros. In case you didn't notice in my previous post I was implying that Moffatiss clumsily linked The Final Problem with Moriarty's words in The Reichenbach Fall. This is similar to how they clumsily linked Sherlock's past with Euros.
- 1,402 replies
-
I'm sure this video interview of a Trump supporter will interest you: https://twitter.com/BeardedGenius/status/833271625508409345 All I have to say is that I think there are a lot of lonely people in the US.
-
In an interview, Gatiss said that they named it 'The Final Problem' so they could link Euros to how Moriarty kept using the phrase 'The Final Problem' in The Reichenbach Fall. I don't think Moffatiss were trying to live up to The Final Problem story. They were just trying to retroactively link Euros to Moriarty (in a similar way to how they retroactively linked Euros to Sherlock).
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
So yesterday during his rally, Trump implied that there was a security incident last night in Sweden: http://www.news.com.au/finance/work/leaders/donald-trumps-implied-sweden-terror-attack-lastnightinsweden-takes-off/news-story/3d82f08cd1f7e7bdba4cb100d3d062d8 Except there wasn't any incident. i swear Trump is praying for a terrorist attack to happen in the US. The moment one occurs, he's going to start pointing his finger at the Federal judges and say it's all their fault for blocking his Muslim ban. When Trump gets enough support from his followers, he'll start going after Federal judges.
-
True but remember The Abominable Bride was written after Season 4 was plotted (that's why it was able to foreshadow events in Season 4 so well). The Abominable Bride was a special episode and wasn't initially planned. According to the interviews, Moffatiss had Season 4 and 5 plotted as far back as 2013 but The Abominable Bride was first announced in mid-2014. Here's the problem: I don't see Molly being that good of an actor to pull all of this off. Honestly if Sherlock died, I would expect Molly to be more grief stricken than John. I'd expect her to be crying all the time. I would expect her to take weeks off work. That's what I believe anyone who knew her would expect her to do. However I'm supposed to believe that Molly was able to forge paperwork etc without arousing suspicion of anyone around her? Wouldn't anyone say, 'The guy you liked died. You shouldn't be working. Just go home.' I don't see Molly as being clever enough to talk herself out of these situations. I just don't see Molly as being a capable actor. I don't think she's someone who can lie with a straight face. I don't think she'd be able to tell John, Lestrade etc that Sherlock is really dead. Honestly that's one thing I dislike about how Moffatiss depicted Sherlock's 2 year absence in London. I don't think they ever showed us what was going on with Molly. This is why Molly's inclusion in the plan always sounded forced to me. Mycroft's's inclusion made sense. He was part of an intelligence agency. Obviously he would be a capable actor. Molly, on the other hand, has none of his skills in subterfuge. Yes Is it possible to be attracted to a person and also really like/love another person? You're probably right about when Sherlock had constructed his plan. However remember in The Empty Hearse, Sherlock said this about Moriarty: SHERLOCK (voiceover): Mycroft fed Moriarty information about me. (Flashback to Mycroft walking into Jim’s cell, and Jim closing his eyes delightedly.) SHERLOCK (part voiceover, part into the camera): Moriarty in turn gave us hints – just hints – as to the extent of his web. We let him go ... (Flashback to Jim being taken into court for his trial.) SHERLOCK (voiceover): ... because it was important to let him believe he had the upper hand. (Into camera) And then I sat back and watched Moriarty destroy my reputation bit by bit. (Flashback to Sherlock sitting on the floor in the lab at Bart’s, repeatedly bouncing a small ball off the cupboard in front of him.) SHERLOCK (voiceover): I had to make him believe he’d beaten me, utterly defeated me, and then he’d show his hand. In other words, Sherlock was always acting out that he was being beaten by Moriarty. Now you could argue that he may not have been acting when he was around Molly but remember when Molly said that stuff about how Sherlock looks worried like her father, John was also with them. I'm sure Sherlock was always pretending to be worried when he was around John. So in hindsight it looks like Sherlock was pretending to be genuinely worried all along and he only responded to what Molly said about her father because it helped with his act. I thought that scene of Molly making a comparison between Sherlock and her father was a good character moment but it looks like it got nullified with the I-was-acting-all-along plot twist. Okay but I'm not sure if this line indicated a clear acknowledgement of Sherlock taking advantage of her crush for him to manipulate her in the past. It could just be a reference to how Sherlock asked Molly to cooperate with him in The Reichenbach Fall to enact his plan. Molly wasn't being manipulated then. She was just in on the plan. Was that really appreciation? Remember Sherlock often went out to eat with John as well. He was using Molly to act as John. You could argue him inviting Molly to go get some chips with him afterwards was just another way for him to use Molly to fill in the void in his heart due to John's absence.
-
I forgot about that scene in The Blind Banker. It does look like Sherlock was manipulating her but that scene looked like it was written more for comedy purposes than anything else. I find Molly to be somewhat difficult to understand because the writing around her seems to be inconsistent. For example I'm not sure if Sherlock is actually supposed to be aware of Molly's infatuation for him. It's true that he seemed to manipulate her by taking advantage of her feelings for him in The Blind Banker. However in A Scandal in Belgravia, he did this deduction of how Molly bought a present for someone she has feelings for but he didn't consider that person may have been him. Sherlock ended up unintentionally hurting Molly's feelings. However how could he have made a mistake like that if he was aware of her feelings for him? The problem with The Reichenbach Fall is that Sherlock was acting out a plan during the entire episode so it's difficult to tell how much of his actions were genuine character moments and how many of them were just pretense. Remember Sherlock and Mycroft's plan was to trick Moriarty into thinking that he had won. So Sherlock had to pretend he was genuinely worried about his life. Thus when Molly 'sees' that Sherlock fears for his life and compares him to her father, it can be argued that she's just being duped by Sherlock's acting. She's not really seeing anything. This is one reason why I strongly dislike the I-was-just-acting-all-along plot twist that is quite popular in detective, spy, thriller etc fiction. It usually reduces everything the character does to pretense so it renders most, if not all, the character development as mute. This is seen in The Reichenbach Fall with not just Sherlock and Molly but with Mycroft and John as well. Remember initially we're led to believe that Mycroft gave Moriarty information about Sherlock's past in order to talk. Moriarty uses this information to support his story of Sherlock being a fraud. Now Mycroft regrets his actions and wants John's help. John scolds Mycroft for using his brother for his own purposes. Mycroft looks genuinely sad an regretful during this scene. This could have led to some great character development for Mycroft. But wait it was all an act. Mycroft was never really worried. He was just pretending. So all those great character moments for him in The Reichenbach Fall amounted to absolutely nothing. I preferred how the I-was-just-acting-all-along plot twist was used in The Lying Detective. That episode actually used it to further character development rather than nullify it like in The Reichenbach Fall and that's one reason why I believe The Lying Detective was, overall, a better written episode than The Reichenbach Fall. Personally, I think it's very difficult to use I-was-just-acting-all-along plot twist in a way that furthers character development. Anyway I never really saw how Molly fitted well into Sherlock's plan in The Reichenbach Fall. I've always founded her inclusion to just be a forced attempt at making her important. Sherlock said that he needed her to find the corpse of the doppelganger that Moriarty used to kidnap those children. However Sherlock had all of MI6 helping him. He didn't need Molly's help to find one corpse. I'm not sure if Sherlock asking Molly to help him with cases in The Empty Hearse was a sign of respect. Remember Sherlock kept thinking of John when he was with her and even called her John once. In other words, Sherlock was just using Molly to fill a void in his heart. He was using Molly in a similar way to how Molly was using Tom. I don't think Sherlock was actually trying manipulate Molly but he didn't seem very appreciative of her when they were solving cases. Where is the line from His Last Vow's original script in which Molly tells Sherlock that she knows the he flirted with her in the past to take advantage of her? I don't see it. It's true that John said that Molly had learnt to look past Sherlock but I'm not sure what he was referring to. Honestly that sounded to me like another forced line to make Molly sound important. It's like Moffat doesn't know what to do with her character. I think he loves Molly as a character but maybe he just can't figure out what kind of role she should have in the story.
-
The funny thing is that despite Moffat's efforts to prove his respect for women, I can still see some feminists finding fault in his writing. I can easily see a feminist label Euros as a damsel in distress. She's a little sister that needs to be saved by her big brother. She also is so obsessed with getting her big brother to play with her. Why doesn't Euros ever want to play with girls? Are girls boring? Why did Euros hide behind the mantle of a male villain like Moriarty? Euros said she was Moriarty's backup plan. So is that all Euros was? A plan to another man? Similarly I can see Mary being labelled as a women in a refrigerator. In case you don't know 'women in a refrigerator' is a term given to a female character that dies to advance the story of a male character. Mary fits this label very well. She dies to advance Sherlock and John's relationship in some respect.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 3
-
-
Did the dynamic between Sherlock and Molly really change? I thought Molly was always mostly tolerant of Sherlock's behaviour but resorted to a more no-nonsense when he went too far (such as his deduction of her during Christmas in A Scandal in Belgravia). I always thought Sherlock's Mind Palace, especially in Season 3, reflected past events in his life. This is how real Mind Palaces work. You use visual memories of previous places, events etc in order to recall important information. In The Sign of Three, Sherlock's Mind Palace was a court room because that's how he saw himself when he was interrogating those 4 ladies on the Mayfly man. In His Last Vow, Sherlock's Mind Palace had Molly, Mycroft, Anderson and Moriarty in it. The reason for this is because he was dying after getting shot so his Mind Palace reflected his memory of almost dying previously. The last time Sherlock almost died was in The Reichenbach Fall. Moriarty's plan was to kill him. Anderson fell for it. Sherlock employed Mycroft and Molly's help to survive. That's why I believe only those 4 characters appeared in Sherlock's Mind Palace after he got shot. We didn't see John in the Mind Palace because John wasn't part of the plan.
-
I think when Sherlock first came up to Molly and said he needed a 'bolthole' he was happy to just stay in her living room and sleep on her sofa. However I think Molly offered him her bedroom. Molly is infatuated with Sherlock so she's always trying to win his favour. She probably said something like 'If you're ever in a tight spot, you can use my bedroom. I'll just sleep on the sofa. It's fine.' I don't think Sherlock ever manipulated Molly. Honestly I don't think Sherlock ever needed to manipulate Molly. Molly would readily agree to basically all of his requests.
-
In a video interview he did last year, Moffat as good as admits that's what he was trying to do in The Abominable Bride: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bzbi_6RWsao#t=03m05s I'm guessing he also tried to do the same thing in Season 4. I wonder if ladies like you appreciate Moffat's concern?
- 1,402 replies
-
I had a reply written up to this post of yours a few hours earlier but this forum is so random sometimes. Usually it auto saves what you're typing every few minutes but sometimes it just refuses and when you click 'Add Reply' it takes you to a 'Forbidden Error' page. Then when you click 'Back' you're taken to an empty Reply box and have to type up the post again. It's so annoying. Anyway this is my second attempt at replying to your post: Here's the original script and I think Molly's words about Tom needing 'space' that you're referring to are on Page 20: http://www.emmys.com/sites/default/files/Downloads/Sherlock_Ep3_Script.pdf MOLLY How dare you throw away the beautiful gifts you were born with, and how dare you betray the love of your friends. Say you’re sorry. SHERLOCK ... I’m sorry your engagement is over. (Stroking his slapped face) Though I’m fairly grateful for the lack of a ring. MOLLY Stop it, just stop it. JOHN Jesus, Sherlock. MOLLY And we’re just having a break! It was a mutual agreement that he needed more space. JOHN (To Sherlock) If you were anywhere near this kind of thing again, you could’ve phoned, you could’ve talked to me - I've bolded the lines that got cut according to Ariane DeVere's transcript of the actual episode. Anyway I don't think the deletion of these lines necessarily means that Moffatiss changed the reason for Molly and Tom breaking up. Most scenes in films have a number of takes and only the one with the best acting make it into the final cut. However sometimes actors can forget their lines or speak their lines before another actor is finished. In such cases, the directors might reshoot the scene but only if the lines are important. If the lines aren't important but if the acting and everything else are spot on then the directors still might use these scenes in the final cut even if they actually aren't verbatim from the script. I think it's possible that's what may have happened here. These two lines that got cut aren't really important to this scene in this episode. Maybe Brealey forgot her line or Freeman spoke too soon. However their acting was spot on in the rest of the scene so perhaps the director decided to use it anyway. Anyway I think it's important to understand the context behind how Molly uses the word 'space'. She uses it another time in the episode. When Sherlock mysteriously leaves the hospital to reveal Mary's secrets to John, Mycroft tries looking for Sherlock. He goes around asking all of Sherlock's friends if they know where Sherlock goes to hide. When he asks Molly, she says: MOLLY: Just the spare bedroom. ... (Awkwardly) Well ... my bedroom. We agreed he needs the space. So once again Molly uses the word 'space'. It looks like she uses it to refer to a place of residence. We can use that to understand what she was referring to when she mentioned 'space' in her deleted line. Anyway now let's take another look at Molly's deleted line: MOLLY And we’re just having a break! It was a mutual agreement that he needed more space. I think what Molly was trying to say is that Tom wanted to live alone. He needed more space to be independent or whatever. That's what Molly is referring to when she says 'more space' in her deleted line. However I think that's just an excuse. I think what really happened was that Tom broke up with her. It wasn't Molly breaking up with Tom. It was the other way around. However I think Tom did it in a subtle way. I think Tom told Molly that he wanted his own place to live for a while so he was going to move into his own flat. He reassured Molly that he still loved her. He was just having a bit of a break to think things through about their future. He would return to her soon. However all of that was a lie. Tom wanted to break up with Molly. I'm not sure why but I guess he noticed that Molly was infatuated with Sherlock and was just using him to fill in a void in her heart. So he moved out of her flat. Then he probably blocked her on his phone and stopped seeing her. Molly eventually realised that Tom had lied to her and wanted nothing more to do with her so she got rid of his engagement ring. However when Sherlock pointed that out, it irked her. It reminded her of how Sherlock had told her that Jim was gay. So Molly decided to use the 'Tom just wants a break' excuse. She doesn't believe in it anymore but she doesn't want to admit that once again Sherlock was right about her love life not working out. As for Jim, I still think Molly was just using him. However I do think she appreciated the belief of Jim actually loving her. I've always seen Molly as some lonely lady who's looking for love in her life to fill a void in her heart. When Sherlock pointed out that Jim didn't really love her, I think it hurt her more than she expected it to.
-
This pretty sums up my opinion as well but I'm curious to see if you agree with the it being obvious that Sherlock is going to fall in love and the Irene angle being used to prevent JohnLock? I didn't get either impression from season 4. Neither did I. When I read that I started to suspect the author of that article was a Johnlock shipper herself and was just looking at things in Season 4 to lash out at. Her article is fairly well written except when it comes to the Johnlock stuff that sounds like a lot of nitpicking. I think that scene with Irene texting Sherlock was more to reflect a change in John's character than in Sherlock's. In the past, John would have been passive and would have just said 'Whatever' if he found that Sherlock was ignoring Irene's texts. However losing Mary has caused John to appreciate life more. Even the little moments that John used to take for granted, he now cherishes. He doesn't want Sherlock to take anything for granted like he did so that's why he tells Sherlock to text her back. I'm not even sure if John was certain there was a thing between Irene and Sherlock. However he didn't want to take anything for granted. That scene was more about John showing concern for Sherlock than anything to do with Sherlock and Irene's relationship. It was about John telling Sherlock to make the most of his life. That's what I got out of that scene.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 4
-
-
Wow Canada's Prime Minister knows how to explain quantum computing. On the other hand, the top rated comment of that post tells us what Trump would say if he was asked to explain quantum computing: Honestly, judging by Trump's intelligence, I wouldn't be surprised if he has numerous ties to Russia and is simply unaware of them.
-
I thought Molly and Moriarty only met for a few days or so. I doubt they became intimate. Also Molly didn't really like Moriarty. She was just using him to try and make Sherlock jealous. That's why I doubt she had sex with Moriarty. I'm not sure if Sherlock noticed that Molly was trying to make him jealous but I guess John could have told him later on. As for what Sherlock would say about her relationship with Moriarty, I imagine it would be something like: 'Taking advantage of someone's feelings in order to obtain something that you want. I've done that before as well (referring to Janine).' Which reminds me what did Molly think of when she found out about Sherlock's relationship with Janine? Maybe that's why she broke up with Tom?
-
I've always seen shipping as mostly a marketing tool. The creators keep putting suggestive elements between two of their fictional characters so all the shipping fans will dig deep into their work, keep buying it and spreading the word of it. I think shippers are some of the most passionate members of any fanbase so appealing to them is a good way of marketing your work. That's why I don't see why Moffatiss would try to keep Sherlock and John apart just to dispute Johnlock. I think the primary reason why John and Sherlock were apart in this season is because of the focus on character's pasts (Mary and Sherlock). John didn't really fit in well with either of them. Honestly this author sounds a bit like Johnlock shipper herself. Maybe she was disappointed that this season didn't do enough to advance Johnlock? I have a theory that there are more people in the Sherlock fanbase that support Johnlock than we think. However since Johnlock has developed a bit of stigma around itself, I believe some fans nowadays won't admit that they support Johnlock. So in essence they're closeted Johnlock shippers. I do agree with the other points of the article though.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
Shoot the Wall (A.K.A. The Rant Thread)
Surelock replied to Banshee's topic in Miscellaneous Musings
You have a niece-in-law that was a captain in the Marines? Didn't you also say in the Speedy's Cafe thread that you had a nephew that was a soldier stationed in Afghanistan? It seems you have a very military family. -
http://www.businessinsider.com.au/pregnant-trump-putin-hater-photos-2017-2?utm_content=buffer2b7da&utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook.com&utm_campaign=buffer&r=US&IR=T Looks like memes are entering real life. They're not just on the internet anymore. Also during his press conference, Trump gave a scholarly definition for uranium: https://twitter.com/tonyposnanski/status/832301506179301382 More scholars need to use the word 'thing'. It's a very smart word.
-
So Betsy DeVos was blocked from entering a school by protesters. Some Right Wing cartoonist decided to depict DeVos' 'noble struggle' by drawing a picture of her that rips off a picture from the African American Civil Rights movement: So a 6 year old African American girl being the first girl to attend an all white school and facing abuse from her peers in 1960 is equivalent to Betsy DeVos being blocked from entering a school by protestors today. If I were an African American, I'd be extremely offended by this cartoon.
-
Do you know which anime that opening music is from? It's from Neon Genesis Evangelion; one of the best written animes. It should be a crime to associate anything well written with Trump. Trump's anime opening should only have music from poorly written animes.
-
There's a lot of crazy Trump fan art out there. My favourites would have to be the Trump anime openings. Here enjoy :D: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4AcDGTj3DRE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r9ZJyLT89y8
-
So in 5 days it'll be the one month anniversary for the Trump Presidency. Yeah one month. It hasn't even been one entire month yet. Why does it feel like we've had Trump as president for like a year already? I guess it's because nobody expected even Trump to be this bad during his first month in office. I shudder to think what the US will be like in a year's time.
-
Dynasty Warriors 8? Not sure which installment this image is from but the character looks like Xu Shu from Dynasty Warriors.
-
Just because casting is lazy doesn't mean it doesn't work out well. It's not just in Sherlock but in other shows, films etc as well. For example Robert Downey Jr. is praised for his portrayal of Tony Stark. Tony Stark has a lot of alcohol and behavioural problems and one of the main reasons why Downey can act out those problems so well is because earlier in his career he suffered from the exact same problems. Similarly Peter Dinklage is praised for his portrayal of the dwarf Tyrion Lannister in Game of Thrones. Tyrion feels mistreated by the people around him because he's a dwarf and the reason why Dinklage can act out his frustrations so well is because Dinklage himself has suffered similar abuse in his real life as he suffers from achondroplasia. Usually actors have gone through similar experiences to the characters they portray end up portraying their characters extremely well. From a casting standpoint, it just makes sense to always get an actor that has already experienced what the character they portray is going through.
- 1,402 replies
-
I'd say casting relatives work when their relation fits in with the characters they're trying to portray. Like casting Benedict Cumberbatch's parents as Sherlock's parents was a good move because they already have good chemistry. Similarly casting Amanda Abbington as Mary works because she was Martin Freeman's wife so she had great chemistry with him. However what does Moffat's son have any relevant relationship to his role? It's not like Moffat's son is related to Benedict Cumberbatch and knew him when he was a child or anything. It looks like he just got the role because he was Moffat's son.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)