Surelock
Detectives-
Posts
381 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Surelock
-
I never really thought of that. In that case I have to ask: what does actual deductive reasoning look like when it's used to solve a case?
- 1,402 replies
-
So in South Carolina, some guys were waving the Confederate flag around and an African American decided to 'protest': https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LNGnW9Js5h0 Why did the police have to arrest the African American protester? Honestly he deserves a medal for his efforts. :D
-
I think they went for a new look for all the main characters in Season 4. It's not just John and Sherlock that look different. Lestrade has some gel on his hair that he didn't have before. Molly's makeup or something looks slightly different as well. I think Moffatiss were just going for a new aesthetic in Season 4. It was presumed to be posthumous message asking if Sherlock missed him after his death in reality it was referring to Euros. What do you mean by 'Sherlock can lose sight of him'?
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
No D.
-
I think Dr. Strange looks a lot older than pre-Season 4 Sherlock. I mean look at how he's depicted in some scenes: If Benedict Cumberbatch had to look like this while filming Dr. Strange then I can see why he looks older in Season 4 of Sherlock (which began filming right after filming for Dr. Strange was finished).
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
-
Well Benedict Cumberbatch did have to get the wise old look for Dr. Strange so I don't find it strange that he looks older in Season 4. Honestly I'm more concerned about John's hairstyle.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 4
-
-
I can't have three guesses at once? Okay then I'll guess one by one. I think it's most likely to be Warriors Orochi 3 Ultimate because it's the latest title. Am I right?
-
So today marks the one month anniversary of the Trump Presidency. I decided to celebrate by posting Trump's most presidented tweet here. It was a tough choice. Trump sent out a lot of presidented tweets ever since winning the election. However I think his best one would have to be this: Yeah Trump I'm sure you're doing all you can to ensure that the country is not 'divided, angry and untrusting.'
-
Well that's what wikis are for. They show us all the titles that a character appears in. Let's check out Xu Shu in Koei wiki: http://koei.wikia.com/wiki/Xu_Shu#Warriors_Orochi So other than Dynasty Warriors, Xu Shu also appears in: - Warriors Orochi - Warriors Orochi 3 Ultimate - Kessen II So I'm guessing one of these games is where that screenshot is from?
-
Well we don't really know why John chose Mary. We never saw how they first met. However I wouldn't say it's impossible if each of them realied that the other was recovering from past traumatic events (Mary should have an idea, at least, because John kept being featured in the papers with Sherlock). I don't think they gave each other all the details or anything but I think they may have been able to tell through mannerisms, behavioural patterns etc. I think what you're trying to say is that you don't like how Mary's past was revealed to John? You believe it wasn't used effectively to push their relationship further when it certainly could have. That much I agree with you. I thought it was strange how in His Last Vow, the episode jumped from John arguing with Mary in Sherlock's flat to John and Mary in the Holmes' parents' cottage. As for John choosing Mary at a chance at normalcy, I don't think that was true. I think the actual reasons for why John chose Mary are left quite vague. However I think John got sick of people lying to him and justifying it based on his personality. First Sherlock did it with his 2 year absence and now Mary. Maybe through Rosie growing up with him and saying he's just like how her mummy used to describe him?
- 793 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Already deleted it from your Memory Palace? We had this discussion 5 days ago in The Final Problem thread: http://www.sherlockforum.com/forum/topic/3549-episode-43-the-final-problem/page-50 Actually I was the one that said that.
-
I guess I would look for something in the dialogue between those characters that suggests they see something in each other that is unique, that they make each other very happy, and also the sense that they have a really strong and lasting attraction? It isn't necessarily all in words, but in actions too. In TV terms, I suppose you would usually see people go to extraordinary lengths for each other. Especially once John knew about Mary's past, what disappointed me was him forgiving her (which was the first time I was impressed by the fact that he loved her more than I had thought previously) and saying he didn't want to know, and then shortly after treating her like he resented her (in TST). Having said that, of course I accept that they did love each other because the show says so, it is just to me sometimes the relationship was a bit bland, which then made it (for me only, I'm sure most would disagree) a bit less tragic when it was over. Even though I liked Mary in the show a lot, though actually I found her scenes with Sherlock sometimes more fun than the ones she had with John. Here's my criteria of whether two characters should be in love: Often in stories or sub-plots about love and romance, I notice that writers follow a certain formula to depict two characters falling in love. Usually the two characters that fall in love have a similar experience that nobody else in their close circles have. It's often the experience that subtly draw the two characters together into love. The most classic example of this would be in Romeo and Juliet. Romeo and Juliet are two children that are caught up in their family disputes and are forced to have their lives revolved around it although they had no choice to enter it in the first place. The most recent example I've seen is in the backstory of a woman named Evelyn in the video game Uncharted 4. Basically Evelyn was an American historian and explorer during the middle of the twentieth century but she was looked down upon because she was female. Later after World War II ended, she met a Japanese-American man named Kenichiro who had suffered discrimination after Japan's bombing of Pearl Harbour. Both Kenichiro and Evelyn had suffered discrimination; Kenichiro for his race and Evelyn for her gender. This common experience drew the two of them together and eventually the two of them got married. Mary and John fit this criteria as well. Both Mary and John are suffering from the ghosts of their past. Mary does have regrets from her life as an assassin and John feels depressed not just because he lost Sherlock but also because he may have been able to save Sherlock if he hadn't fallen for the false alarm (Sherlock tricked John into thinking Mrs. Hudson was in danger to get John to leave him alone). John and Mary satisfy the criteria so I do find their relationship to be believable. I think the main problem in how their relationship is depicted is that we don't see the 'falling in love' part. When we first see the two of them, they're already so much in love that they're ready to get married. It's like when you start watching a romance movie in its last 15 minutes. It feels a bit too rushed. In comparison, I think John's relationship with Sarah is more plausible because at least we saw how it started (too bad we didn't see how it ended). I think it would have been better if the opening of The Empty Hearse would have shown us how John and Mary first met rather than just have John spell it out to Mrs. Hudson.
- 793 replies
-
Hi, I'm bedelia's significant other and I can tell you that you are 100% correct wrong I'd like to question you about your relationship but I don't think that's an appropriate subject to discuss on a public forum so instead I'll ask you this: Do you believe John resented Mary in The Six Thatchers? Why or why not? You're a male right so could you read something significant in John's behaviour?
- 793 replies
-
I suspect we all have different perspectives on John's view of Mary because we're all projecting our own experiences of disillusionment with our significant other. If you ended up resenting one of your significant others in the past then maybe that's why you believe that John resents Mary? Similarly if you didn't ever resent any of your significant others then maybe you don't have as negative of a viewpoint?
- 793 replies
-
Okay, fair point. We don't know if Sherrinford is run by MI6 but we do know that it won't be difficult for Sherrinford to contact MI6 and send their personnel to Sherrinford's HQ. Then Euros could easily brainwash whatever MI6 agent is sent and then use them to gain information. By Sherlock having a heart of gold I'm referring to how John always said that Sherlock loves playing the hero. Moriarty recognised this early on in The Great Game: http://arianedevere.livejournal.com/45923.html JIM: I’ll burn the heart out of you. (His face is a snarl as he says the word ‘heart’ but at the end of the sentence he looks almost regretful.) SHERLOCK (softly): I have been reliably informed that I don’t have one. JIM: But we both know that’s not quite true. I do find some of Sherlock's social deductions (for lack of a better word) to be inconsistent. I think the best example of this would be how Sherlock behaved when he first met John along with Mary after his 2 year absence in The Empty Hearse. Sherlock couldn't tell that John would be upset over him faking his death because apparently Sherlock doesn't know anything about human nature. On the other hand, Sherlock could tell that Mary didn't like John's mustache by just looking at her.
- 1,402 replies
-
By 'resent' are you referring to how John cheated on Mary? You sure 'resent' is the right word for that? Just because you cheat on someone doesn't necessarily mean you have hard feelings against them.
- 793 replies
-
Why couldn't Euros find out about all this stuff later? I mean Euros had brainwashed people that were working up to MI6. There are obviously records of previous cases of Sherlock. It wouldn't be difficult for Euros to get her hands on them considering she had mind control powers. I think the only reason which can suggest that Euros meet Moriarty again is if she had some kind of information about Sherlock that only Moriarty could provide her. I don't think anything you listed seems to be in that category for the following reasons: 1. Sherlock was working with Lestrade during the events of The Great Game. The police would obviously have records on what happened. 2. How would Moriarty know that Sherlock cared more about solving the puzzle than saving the person? I thought only John knew that. Wasn't Moriarty the one who saw through Sherlock's act and realised Sherlock actually had a heart of gold? 3. Once again why couldn't Euros just check police records? Euros' mind control powers make her pretty omniscient. She doesn't really need to go to people for information when she can just brainwash someone else to go do it for her.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 1
-
-
Now that you mention it, that's true. ABC news has uploaded a video: https://twitter.com/JohnnyHeldt/status/833871534662045696 But it looks like this is just the House of Commons. I think it still needs to be voted on by the upper house. Come on upper house, vote NO.
-
So the British Parliament just voted to NO to a planned state visit by Donald Trump. This is the first time in history that they've voted NO to a state visit by a US President. It looks like online petitions can work.
-
Probably not because I don't think she started going out until she had brainwashed everyone in Sherrinford and I think it took her a few years to do that.
- 1,402 replies
-
True but I don't think those are likely possibilities because the games were about Sherlock and Mycroft and not Euros. I'm not sure about that. Remember when Mycroft allowed Moriarty to visit Euros, Moriarty was still a low profile criminal. Mycroft said so himself that they didn't have any clear evidence against him at that point. However by the time of The Hounds of Baskerville, Moriarty is a high profile villain and the government does have evidence against him as they have him locked up and are interrogating him for information about his network. If Euros wanted to arrange another meeting with Moriarty via her sojourn, she would probably only be able to do it before the government had strong evidence against Moriarty. The reason for that is because all the people that Euros had brainwashed were working with the administration of Sherrinford. If Mycroft found out that someone from Sherrinford was contacting Moriarty then he would suspect that Euros had broken free. Euros didn't want to alert Mycroft of her plans so she would tell her sojourns to avoid any suspicious activity. Also according the Governor implied that he started letting people see Euros after Mycroft let Moriarty see her. He also said that Euros had become much more active after then. I'd say Euros had started brainwashing psychologists etc after she met with Moriarty. This doesn't give her much time to send out a sojourn and arrange another meeting with Moriarty. I mean it must have taken a while for her to brainwash the top branches of Sherrinford. Moriarty probably died less than a year after meeting Euros. So I think the post probable scenario is that Euros only met with Moriarty once for 5 minutes. I think that's the extent of their relationship.
- 1,402 replies
-
I'm not sure about that. Remember initially Sherlock didn't even try to carry out Mary's plan. He was sitting in his apartment, drowning himself in drugs for weeks until Euros (as Faith) visited him. Also the plan relied on knowing that John would never refuse to give help to someone. I don't think Sherlock understands John's emotional identity enough to figure out that John would do that. I thought John wasn't happy because Sherlock and Mary were superhuman and that made him feel left out and inadequate. Sherlock jokes about this in The Six Thatchers but I think that joke may have hit John harder than Sherlock thought it would. Also the reason why Mary runs away from him is because he isn't superhuman and she doesn't trust him to be able to keep himself safe when Ajay returned. John felt overwhelmed so he developed interest in a down-to-earth girl on the bus. What do you usually look for in writing to determine whether two characters are truly in love?
- 793 replies
-
So I just typed a long post interpreting Euros and Moriarty's alliance but the forum keeps giving me an error when I try posting. Thus I've resorted to screenshotting my post and just posting the images instead:
- 1,402 replies
-
http://arianedevere.livejournal.com/31651.html JIM: MOFFATISS: I knew you’d fall for it. That’s your weakness – you always want everything to be clever.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 3
-
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)