Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi fellow 'Sherlock' fans (or do we have a name? Sherlockians?)

 

I'm a relative newbie to 'Sherlock', I only started watching it a few weeks ago as I heard a lot of buzz about the new series coming out and figured I'd give it a go being as people love it so much. So that's it, I'm hooked, it really is the best thing I've seen on TV in years, it's even surpassed 'Breaking Bad' in my humble opinion, and that's very high praise indeed from me. I'm kinda glad I only discovered it recently as I've had a back-to-back marathon with no long waits in between series. it's been lots of fun.

 

I joined the forum because no one in my small circle of peeps is bothered, and rather than annoy them by banging on about it, I figured I'd be better of banging on to people who actually agree with me that it's bloody marvellous. (Although I will still try to convert them, currently working on my mum who can't watch it because she 'can't stand the guys face'. I have the first 2 series on order and intend to force-feed her until any face-aversion is numbed out of her. Actually, that's probably more annoying than banging on about it... ah well, it's all in a good cause, you can't just go around hating people's faces can you? She needs help).

 

So that's me *Awkward exit* I never know how to end these things :/

 

 

 

 

Posted

 

Hi fellow 'Sherlock' fans (or do we have a name? Sherlockians?)

 

  It seems, from what I have read, that if your from England and Europe, you're a Holmesian. Americans, for what ever reason, are called Sherlockians.

 

  Welcome to the Forum, Riddle!

Posted

Hello Riddle and welcome to the forum! .wave:

 

We all know the problem of friends and family just not understanding how brilliant this show is, so it's good we have this place to chat about it before they have us committed :D.

Posted

WE Holmesians and hurrah for that

 

 

Hi fellow 'Sherlock' fans (or do we have a name? Sherlockians?)

 

  It seems, from what I have read, that if your from England and Europe, you're a Holmesian. Americans, for what ever reason, are called Sherlockians.

 

  Welcome to the Forum, Riddle!

 

 

Posted

WE are not 'Sherlockians we are fans of sherlock

Hi fellow 'Sherlock' fans (or do we have a name? Sherlockians?)

 

I'm a relative newbie to 'Sherlock', I only started watching it a few weeks ago as I heard a lot of buzz about the new series coming out and figured I'd give it a go being as people love it so much. So that's it, I'm hooked, it really is the best thing I've seen on TV in years, it's even surpassed 'Breaking Bad' in my humble opinion, and that's very high praise indeed from me. I'm kinda glad I only discovered it recently as I've had a back-to-back marathon with no long waits in between series. it's been lots of fun.

 

I joined the forum because no one in my small circle of peeps is bothered, and rather than annoy them by banging on about it, I figured I'd be better of banging on to people who actually agree with me that it's bloody marvellous. (Although I will still try to convert them, currently working on my mum who can't watch it because she 'can't stand the guys face'. I have the first 2 series on order and intend to force-feed her until any face-aversion is numbed out of her. Actually, that's probably more annoying than banging on about it... ah well, it's all in a good cause, you can't just go around hating people's faces can you? She needs help).

 

So that's me *Awkward exit* I never know how to end these things :/

 

Posted

 

WE are not 'Sherlockians we are fans of sherlock

 

   Yes, we are. "Sherlockians" is just a label like everything else....and it's supposed to be a positive thing meaning we take our Sherlock very seriously.

  • Like 1
Posted

Welcome to the Sherlock Forum, baergelbi!

 

   We get three episodes because the BBC wanted 90 minutes episodes not a 60 minute format, so it takes longer to write and longer to shoot. Their meant to be more like movies, not just a tv episode.

Posted

:welcome: Riddle!  Glad you found us!

 

Your full name wouldn't be

by any chance? 

 

:wacko:

 

Why yes it would :)

Posted

 

Hi fellow 'Sherlock' fans (or do we have a name? Sherlockians?)

 

  It seems, from what I have read, that if your from England and Europe, you're a Holmesian. Americans, for what ever reason, are called Sherlockians.

 

I've heard that too (maybe from you, Fox!), but aren't those the terms for fans of the original stories and/or Sherlock Holmes in general?  Which seems to leave us without a specific name for fans of this program, other than "Sherlock fans."

 

Welcome to Sherlock Forum, Riddle and baergelbi!  :welcome:

Posted

 

but aren't those the terms for fans of the original stories and/or Sherlock Holmes in general?  

 

   Since these are just the stories updated from the original....is there really a difference? Mofftiss makes it clear that they always consult the "Great Man", meaning Sir Arthur.....but if people don't like Holmesian/Sherlockian.....any other little label will do, I suppose.

Posted

I'm just remembering the response that we early Star Trek fans got from science-fiction fans.  We thought we were science-fiction fans, too, but they looked upon us as intruders into their cozy little community.  In hindsight, I can see their point -- we kinda thought that science fiction began and ended with Star Trek.

 

So I'm thinking that old-line Holmes fans might take exception if we try to co-opt "Sherlockian" for ourselves.

 

Posted

I haven't heard or received any objections so far. So I say, what the heck, they don't have any official claim to anything....and these are canonical.

Posted

Oh, I'm not saying they might have the name trademarked or anything, just that calling ourselves Sherlockians could be confusing and might annoy some Conan Doyle fans.  I think it's much clearer to call myself a Sherlock fan (or a fan of Sherlock).

 

And I strongly suspect that there are more than a few Conan Doyle fans who don't think Sherlock is canonical at all.  ;)

 

Posted

We are Sherlocked... :sherlock2:  :violin3:

Posted

I do seem to have started something here don't I? Apologies if I've resurrected a long running debate about what to call us, it's just something I read. Forgive me. I'm a newbie ;)

 

Personally I don't like the name, or any names like that. I'm just fascinated with the current trend for naming every fan-base, also the putting of 2 names together to make one name. It's a strange phenomena that kind of just happened while I was looking the other way and now it's everywhere. Interesting pop-culture stuff... well to me anyway :/

Posted

 

Personally I don't like the name, or any names like that. I'm just fascinated with the current trend for naming every fan-base, also the putting of 2 names together to make one name. It's a strange phenomena that kind of just happened while I was looking the other way and now it's everywhere.

 

Argh! Portmanteau names! I am a resident hater of them, for all they're a bit of 'harmless' fun though I'll agree it's a strange phenomena.

 

I even started a poll/discussion about it here if you want to see what other people thing.

Posted

Oh no, you didn't start any thing. I don't usually think about labels of any kind, kind of hate them myself. To easy for people to get caught up in them and think of nothing else. Sherlockfan...Sherlockian....or any other thing any one would want to call us....it's all the same. We know who and what we are talking about.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.