I waded through this thread and found it absolutely riveting. Although we are all following the modern version and wait for each new series to outdo the previous, which is not always the case, vid. Radio Times recent vote, with which I almost entirely agree, Jeremy Brett brought to the role the exact same otherworldliness that Benedict has been working so hard to keep up in the new version. Talk about the steepled fingers! When I took out the Speckled Band to check up on some things because of a speculation I needed to build up, I saw how they could be used expressively, and not statically, as Benedict uses them. And when Messers. Moffat and Gatiss talk about the more serious versions needing to have the cobwebs blown away from them because Sherlock and John are a comedy double act, they should bear in mind the sheer exuberance of The Second Stain! There, Brett does some wonderful things with his hands, as well. Simply brilliant!