Surelock
Detectives-
Posts
381 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by Surelock
-
The wall is art. Every bureaucrat loves the artistry of walls, castles, mansions etc. They just hate it when art reflects anyone other than them, their friends or family. Also can someone please explain to me what an 'illegal criminal' is? Trump mentioned them in his tweet: 'Illegal criminals' huh? So there are 'legal criminals' as well? Who are the 'legal criminals'? Trump and his entire cabinet? :D
-
And all too often I think they were just throwing a sop to the Sherlolly fans. :( If they were, they could have given us a more consoling sop! I'm available if they want advice on the next one... like Sherlock has to kiss Molly or the villain will blow up Scotland Yard... or they have to go on a romantic holiday to Paris or else an assassin will take out poor Mrs Hudson... or they have to spend the rest of their lives together or else the puppy gets it... Considering the original scene was different and was rewritten at the last minute, I think they just pandered to fan service with that scene. I also think being rewritten at the last minute is why that scene never paid off. I had been assuming that when they said they re-wrote it, it was just in the sense that they made the coffin more hypothetical, rather than Molly actually being in one? But do you think they changed the whole spirit of the scene at the last minute? That seems really risky in such a big episode, and when they've presumably put a bit of planning into what they were doing with Molly this season. I strongly suspect that the Molly scene was rewritten at the last minute and that's precisely why the whole 'I love you' scene never amount to anything. Originally the Molly scene involved Sherlock having to solve a puzzle to save Molly in a coffin. There was no 'I love you' or anything. If all Sherlock did was save Molly then it would make sense for Molly to be all happy in the epilogue while visiting Sherlock's flat. However if Moffatiss decided to replace that scene in the last minute with the 'I love you' scene then it makes sense for the latter to lead nowhere. I mean they probably didn't have time to insert extra scenes that could add a resolution to that situation. So they just went with Molly smiling in the epilogue although that doesn't make sense with the 'I love you scene'. For Molly to stay on the show, doesn't she have to either get over Sherlock or be in a relationship arc? I mean haven't they gotten all they can get out of the unrequited love arc? Let's be honest. Molly doesn't really have a role in the series beyond her romantic interest in Sherlock. Considering the original scene was different and was rewritten at the last minute, I think they just pandered to fan service with that scene. I also think being rewritten at the last minute is why that scene never paid off. I agree that Molly's role in the show is to portray romantic interest but that's my point, hasn't that run its course? How many more seasons do they think they can get out of that? Season 4 was emblematic of that, like they got bored with that route so you saw much less of her since they have not yet bothered to flesh her out more. Well according to Moffat, the entire production team didn't like the original Molly scene so I'm not sure that it was fan service they were pandering to but the show itself. I also doubt that the lack of payoff was because of how it was written since the original Molly scene didn't have a resolution either apparently. The truth is that Moffat likely just doesn't value the Molly/Sherlock relationship that much so he doesn't write for it. The original Molly scene fit better with how Molly was portrayed in the epilogue being all happy at Sherlock's flat. If all Sherlock did earlier was rescue her from a coffin then her actions at the end make sense. There was originally no confession or anything. It was just a simple rescue scene. Also, other than a love interest, I don't see Molly having any other role in the series other than perhaps acting as a mother figure for Rosie.
-
Don't worry everyone. All that money that is cut from the arts will go to pay for the Great Wall of Trump that's supposed to stop illegal immigrants from entering the US. Trump has probably realised that Mexico isn't going to pay for his wall since he's now thinking about how to cut the price of the wall:
-
And the montage at the end of TFP is supposed to meet this objective? If so, you're right that really wasn't well written. Given Moffat's quotes about Molly and the lack of resolution to the ILY scene, it's probably more likely they just didn't give Molly much thought. Not necessarily that. If there's a 5th season which will be stated to be the final season then I can see Moffatiss doing something more. For Molly to stay on the show, doesn't she have to either get over Sherlock or be in a relationship arc? I mean haven't they gotten all they can get out of the unrequited love arc? Let's be honest. Molly doesn't really have a role in the series beyond her romantic interest in Sherlock. Molly is a metaphor for all the ladies that watch Sherlock because they think that Benedict Cumberbatch is hot. That's why Molly has to always be in love with Sherlock and have such an unexplored personality. The latter allows all the female viewers to project themselves into her so they can fulfill their fantasies of being in love with Sherlock and actually working with him at the same time. Considering the original scene was different and was rewritten at the last minute, I think they just pandered to fan service with that scene. I also think being rewritten at the last minute is why that scene never paid off.
-
Are you referring to this interview? http://www.vulture.com/2014/01/sherlock-finale-postmortem-steven-moffat-interview.html
-
There is a R. T _ E / _ _ A _ / I S / _ R A _ _ I _ _
-
Well in The Final Problem, John was the first one to protest to Mycroft's idea of crashing the girl on the plane. However you could argue that was an attempt by John to get Mycroft to 'behave better'. I don't see how helping Sherlock to 'behave better' means that John isn't a moral compass. I mean isn't the entire purpose of a moral compass to help people behave better?
-
In terms of real world politics, what Sherlock did to Magnussen can be summed up as:
-
There is a S. T _ E / _ _ A _ / I S / _ _ A _ _ I _ _
-
That's interesting, because I remember some of us, after S3, thought that Molly had gotten over her crush during Sherlock's post-Reichenbach absence, but that she well and truly fell in love with him during the wedding. Although maybe we were just projecting ourselves onto her. :D I like to think she's accepted she's never going to have him, that the best she can achieve with him is friendship. But since Tom didn't work out, and now this ... she's in limbo now, as far as I'm concerned. Which I don't like. Didn't Molly just use Tom as a substitute for Sherlock? Tom is quite similar to Sherlock in terms of appearance but lacks his brain power. I guess Molly just dated Tom during Sherlock 2 year absence to fill in the void of not seeing Sherlock anymore. However when Sherlock returned Molly could no longer hold her interest in Tom so she decided to break up with him. Also I've always had a gut feeling that Moffatiss were going to have Sherlock get together with Molly at the definitive end of the series. The reason for this is because it looks like Moffatiss have always used Sherlock's relationship with Molly to act as a metaphor for how human Sherlock is. In a way all of Sherlock's scenes with Molly somehow relate to how human he is. Since Moffatiss want to humanise Sherlock then I think it would be fitting for them to end the series by having Sherlock get together with Molly. Now I don't think Moffatiss ever expect to explore a relationship between Sherlock and Molly. I just expect them to put an epilogue at the end where Sherlock is with Molly. I don't expect it to be well written or anything (Personally I don't think Moffatiss would be good at writing romance). I just expect it to be there.
-
There is a T. T _ E / _ _ A _ / I _ / _ _ A _ _ I _ _ Also in the second word I initially placed placed the A as the second letter but I just now realised that was incorrect. A was actually the third letter. I just corrected it.
-
There are As. _ _ E / _ A _ _ / I _ / _ _ A _ _ I _ _
-
There are Is. _ _ E / _ _ _ _ / I _ / _ _ _ _ _ I _ _
-
Tbh John isn't as good as he portrays himself to be. He has pretty dark interests. Sherlock pointed this out to him in His Last Vow when he said the reason why John chose Mary is because she was an assassin. John chose Sherlock as his best friend because Sherlock was a wannabe sociopath and wanted to partake in his adventurous life. John joined the army because he wanted adventure. John couldn't stand the peaceful honeymoon life so he went to a drug den and attacked a junkie (yes I know it was self defense but John went there looking for trouble). John's dark side isn't something he can control. It needs to feed off dark and dangerous situations on a regular basis or it starts to negatively affect John e.g. his psychometric leg injury in A Study in Pink after returning from war. In The Lying Detective, John hadn't been on an adventure for weeks since he had a falling out with Sherlock after Mary's death. His dark side had boiled up so I can see it exploding in that moment and see John taking all his frustration out on Sherlock. It's not like John hasn't done very dark things in his past. In A Scandal in Belgravia, he told Sherlock that when he was in the army he actually killed people despite being a doctor. So I think it's in character for John to beat up Sherlock harshly.
-
Is hypnosis/mesmerism even real? Personally I don't think you can manipulate someone easily unless there's something mentally wrong with them in the first place.
- 189 replies
-
- Season 4
- Eurus Holmes
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Well that isn't his campaign logo. Maybe it used to be one of his logos? You know the swastika ironically used to be a symbol for peace until the Nazis came along and ruined it (which kind of foreshadows what Trump will do to the US). Some communities in Japan had swastika signs to show that they were peaceful but I heard Japan was getting rid of them in time for the 2020 Olympics.
-
No O.
-
So when you said 'It goes out after the watershed for a reason' you were saying that episodes of Sherlock air after watershed so they can be as dark as Moffatiss want them to be?
- 831 replies
-
What do you mean when you say 'It goes out after the watershed for a reason' ? Yeah I think the dead kid is darker than the beating. I mean the old man was a bad guy and you could argue Sherlock was trying to do some good by getting information about Moriarty from him. However that kid was completely innocent but died trying to please his parents and then had his corpse roasted into a skeleton. I think a kid would be more disturbed by the latter than the former.
- 831 replies
-
I just rechecked and that sounds right. Okay maybe I heard some of it wrong then. It's easy to mix up some of the words when they're talking at once (one of the other ladie said 'in Eastern London). But hey at least I still got some of the quote right.
-
Isn't the story that Sherlock told Anderson supposed to most likely be the right one? The reason for this is because the squash ball that Sherlock used to stop his pulse was seen earlier. In the Reichenbach Fall when Sherlock is waiting inside the morgue for John to return from Mycroft's place, he's playing with the squash ball. This is the same squash ball that we see him place under his arm pit in the story he tells Anderson. I know that Gatiss said in an interview that Sherlock may have not told Anderson the truth but I think Gatiss was just trying to 'challenge' the audience.
- 1,402 replies
-
- 2
-
-
I'm not sure what you mean by a girl like Molly, but one of my younger students just went off to college with plans to become a forensic pathologist. She's smart, cute, outgoing, traditional, etc. When we asked her why she chose that career, she said she just found the science really fascinating. I mean that Molly, in many ways, acts like a teenage girl. She doesn't act that much like a woman in her 30s. However teenage girls are usually afraid of dead bodies or anything related to them. However Molly isn't. I find it strange that someone with a teenage girl personality is also interested in dead bodies. It feels like an inconsistency in her character.
-
Traditionally Sherlock has been a mostly family friendly series. I know parents who watch Sherlock with their kids. Things never got too dark. Before Season 4 I'd say the darkest thing was seeing Moriarty shoot himself in the face but at least that was off screen. I don't think parents would want their kids to see The Six Thatchers just because of that scene of the kid's corpse being burnt to a skeleton. It's true that most of it is off screen but what is implied is so dark; I'd even say it's unnecessarily dark.
- 831 replies
-
Of course Trump is a figurehead. We all know the real head of state is President Bannon. I mean President Bannon is the one who comes up with all the great policy ideas like these ones below: The mark of a great head of state is getting all your policy ideas from movies.
-
There's an E. _ _ E / _ _ _ _ / _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
.jpg.e24dbe8a0c548ab9e378bc396ae750de.jpg)