Jump to content

  

17 members have voted

  1. 1. Who is your favorite villain in Sherlock Series 1 & 2?

    • Jeff the Cabbie ("A Study in Pink")
    • General Shan ("The Blind Banker")
      0
    • Jim Moriarty (throughout)
    • Irene Adler ("A Scandal in Belgravia")
    • Bob Frankland ("The Hounds of Baskerville")
      0
    • Kitty Riley ("The Reichenbach Fall")
  2. 2. Who is your second favorite (optional)?

    • Jeff the Cabbie ("A Study in Pink")
    • General Shan ("The Blind Banker")
      0
    • Jim Moriarty (throughout)
    • Irene Adler ("A Scandal in Belgravia")
    • Bob Frankland ("The Hounds of Baskerville")
      0
    • Kitty Riley ("The Reichenbach Fall")
      0
    • I have no second favorite.
  3. 3. Who is your third favorite (optional)?

    • Jeff the Cabbie ("A Study in Pink")
    • General Shan ("The Blind Banker")
      0
    • Jim Moriarty (throughout)
      0
    • Irene Adler ("A Scandal in Belgravia")
    • Bob Frankland ("The Hounds of Baskerville")
    • Kitty Riley ("The Reichenbach Fall")
    • I have no third favorite.


Recommended Posts

Posted

Please indicate your favorite(s) above.  You can explain or discuss below.  And if I've omitted your favorite, please say so!

 

Added:  Note that I'm using the word "villain" very loosely, to include antagonists, adversaries, opponents, etc.

 

Posted

As much as Moriarty is the villain of the whole piece and very effectively so, I thought the actor that played "Jeff the Poisoner Cabbie" was also very scary. I mean.....how many people watch this episode and then catch themselves eyeing passing cabs with just a hint of doubt?

 

Posted

Can I nominate Kitty Riley? Seriously. All others have motives I can at least partly sympathise with (yes, even Moriarty with his lonely insanity) but she's the one villain I love to hate, which makes her a good one in my book. If she doesn't face a comeuppance of epic proportions in season 3, at least off-screen, I shall be sorely disappointed :evil:.

  • Like 1
Posted

Can I nominate Jim, Jeff and Irene? I mean how am I supposed to decide? ;)

Posted

I've added Kitty.  It never occurred to me to think of her as a villain, since she seems to have good intentions -- but then a lot of real-life "villains" have good intentions.

 

Hmm, with only five or six villains, I hate to allow multiple choices -- BUT it seems that I can add more questions, so I'll ask for your second and third favorites.  So you won't have to choose, merely prioritize!

 

Posted

If you've already voted for your #1 favorite and now you want to add a second and/or third favorite, you'll have to delete your vote and start over.  At least that's what I ended up doing.

 

  • 5 months later...
Posted

Jim, Irene, Kitty.

 

Jim obviously because he is the sole competitor of Sherlock's level of intellect. A consulting criminal.

 

Irene, because she really knows how to make men feel dominated. (Dominatrix is the perfect name for her).

 

Kitty. Well because she had no motives but was infact solely responsible for 'The Fall'. Jim just orchestrated it.

Posted

Kitty as a villain? Interesting viewpoint. I saw her more as another one of Moriarty's dupes.

 

If Irene counts as a villain, I will have to rethink my vote here. Moriarty is of course The Villain, there's really no possible competition for him. But Irene is more than just an opponent, she's a complex character, not just evil incarnate. I think that's my only problem with Moriarty: He is fantastic, no question about it, but he does not come across as an actual human being. That is very true to the original stories, where almost everybody (aside from maybe Holmes) is either good or bad and the bad guys have often no reason or justification for being that way. But it is one of Doyle's many shortcomings, in my opinion, and I had sort of hoped the show would make things a little more realistic.

  • Like 1
Posted

Kitty as a villain? Interesting viewpoint. I saw her more as another one of Moriarty's dupes.

 

If Irene counts as a villain, I will have to rethink my vote here. Moriarty is of course The Villain, there's really no possible competition for him. But Irene is more than just an opponent, she's a complex character, not just evil incarnate....

 

You've raised a perfectly reasonable point.  Maybe I should change the thread title to "Your favorite antagonist"?  Not as catchy, though.

 

OK, I've edited the following into the introductory post:

 

 

 

Added:  Note that I'm using the word "villain" very loosely, to include antagonists, adversaries, opponents, etc.

 

Posted

Oh, I didn't mean to be critical about the title of the thread, sorry. You could count Irene as a villain, I guess (at least I'm sure Mycroft would). She is a lot more "evil" than the character they took her from, that's for sure. But there is much more to her - thank goodness.

Posted

Oh, I fully agree with you!  That ambiguity had been bothering me all along, so I'm glad you prompted me to do a little something about it.

 

Posted

Irene will always be my favourite antagonist. No competition. Moriarty will just have to take second place, even if he is the villainous glue throughout the whole series, which I'm sure would please Irene very much!

 

For my #3 I did consider Frankland as I find his role as the friend who really isn't quite fascinating, but Jeff the cabbie for sheer uncomfortableness has to win - the villain who could be anywhere, unseen...

Posted

Okay, if Irene counts here, she is my favorite antagonist. Because she is a real person and Moriarty is just a concept, albeit a superbly acted and very entertaining one (funnily enough, I've never found him really frightening).

 

The villain I felt most afraid of was the cabbie in A Study in Pink. Also a real person and scary because he looked just like an ordinary guy on the street. I am kind of glad I am not rich enough to take taxis on my own a lot - I wouldn't dare anyway, now.

Posted

 

The villain I felt most afraid of was the cabbie in A Study in Pink. Also a real person and scary because he looked just like an ordinary guy on the street. I am kind of glad I am not rich enough to take taxis on my own a lot - I wouldn't dare anyway, now.

 

 It would be interesting to take an "on the street" poll and find out how many people feel the same way since watching that episode.

Posted

He would certainly be the most dangerous to the average person, since his motive for murder has nothing to do with his victims.

 

Posted

 Absolutely, his kids were getting paid by the body count, it would be like a crap shoot...and in fact...the "lady in pink" did have a choice. There was another cab right behind Jeff's. She just chose the wrong one.

Posted

The more we talk about "Hound of the Baskervilles" Dr. Frankland looms large.  I mean here is this man who is not only able to beat a trusting friend to death, but then sits out to drive his son mad by drug testing, sleep deprivation, and instilling a deep canine phobia into him. Now that, is creepy.

Posted

Yes, Dr. Frankland is certainly evil. But like Moriarty, he is little else. I prefer those antagonists who offer a bit more than just being bad guys.

 

I still wonder what Frankland ran from in the end. And why did we hear the howl of a dog after the hound had been shot?

Posted

Maybe the thing had a mate?  I used to watch the X-Files, a lot. And a lot of times when Scully and Mulder thought they had the case all nicely resolved, low and behold....maybe not so much.

Posted

Ooooooh, the X-Files... That was so much fun to watch, at least as long as they had the original duo of actors.

 

A mate? But the innkeepers only bought one dog! Where would the other have come from? Of course, the howl could have been a drug-induced hallucination, but then why did everybody there hear it at the same time?

Posted

Just because the innkeepers bought one dog doesn't mean there wasn't another one?  How long had it been when Henry started noticing tracks of the gigantic hound in the "Hollow"? I doubt that the one that was finally brought down by Lestrade and John had been around for the full twenty years.

 

  Could it have been a pregnant female? Did anyone mention the gender of the hound in the episode? I don't remember.

Posted

As I interpret it, the innkeepers didn't buy the dog, it had been hanging around and they just "adopted" it.  Here's that bit of dialog from Ariane DeVere's transcript:

 

GARY: Look, we were just trying to give things a bit of a boost, you know? A great big dog run wild up on the moor – it was heaven-sent. It was like us having our own Loch Ness Monster.
LESTRADE: Where do you keep it?
GARY: There’s an old mineshaft. It’s not too far. It was all right there.

 

So yeah, there could well have been another one, even a small pack of them.  But Ariane DeVere's interpretation is that their first round of shots hadn't actually killed the original dog, and it revived:

 

HENRY (tearfully): He found something out, didn’t he, and that’s why you’d killed him – because he was right, and he’d found you right in the middle of an experiment.
(Frankland gets to his feet but before he can say anything there’s a savage snarl from behind the group. Everybody spins towards the dog as it whines in pain but gets up off the ground. John aims and fires towards it twice and it goes down again. Frankland takes the opportunity of the distraction to turn and run off in the opposite direction. Like the single-minded idiot that he is, Sherlock runs right across John’s line of fire, forcing him to lower his pistol, and chases off after the scientist. John turns and follows him up the slope.)

 

I don't believe anyone had ever checked to make sure it was really dead the first time, so she may well be right.  The scene is so dark that I've never been sure what I was seeing.

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 207 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.