Jump to content

Surelock

Detectives
  • Posts

    381
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Surelock

  1. I think Season 4 is most guilty of this. In Season 3 I believe Mary's character complimented John's character fairly well. Even when Mary was revealed to be an assassin in Season 3 it didn't lead to James Bond-esque fights etc. It led to John accepting that he was a lover of morbidity. Sherlock said so himself that John liked living in a dangerous lifestyle. He was a doctor who chose to go to war. He became best friends with a destructive guy like Sherlock. He got bored in his post-Honey Moon life due to the lack of adventure. Falling in love with an assassin was in-character for John. John was reluctant to admit and accept this but he finally did so in His Last Vow. That's how Mary's assassin character helped to compliment John's character in Season 3. It didn't cause John to be left behind or neglected like he was in Season 4. However one thing we didn't see in Season 3 is an explanation for why John has such a strong morbid fascination. We know he loves the dangerous life but why? John isn't exactly a normal person. He's more of a guy who has a morbid fascination but seems to want to hide it. That's how I interpret John's typical nice guy persona. I think it's just a cover John uses to hide how he's actually someone with dark interests. That's how I interpreted John's early career as a doctor. I don't think John became a doctor and then chose to work with the military. I think he wanted to join the military from the get-go. He loved the danger. However he wanted to disguise his morbid fascination so he chose to use a medical career as a ruse to enter the military while still maintaining his good guy persona. But why does John act like this? I'm not sure. Maybe it's because John had a very twisted childhood that made him dark. Maybe he wants to put it behind him but it's not always that easy. We don't get a through backstory for John and that's something that's probably missing from his character. I'm starting to think that it may have been a wiser choice for Moffatiss to make Season 4 about both Sherlock and John's backstories rather than just Sherlock's backstory. The focus on Sherlock's backstory is one of the reasons why John felt so neglected this season. However if Sherlock and John were trying to find out about each other's past then it would have been a good way to explore their backstories while still effectively developing their relationship.
  2. I got Irene Adler: I wanted Sherlock :(
  3. There's a Y. _ _ _ / _ A _ _ _ I _ _ / _ A _ _ E _ / I _ / E A S _ E _ _ / _ O _ _ O _ / S E _ _ / _ _ Y
  4. Care to elaborate? It's always interesting to read different perspectives. There are many ways the ending felt undeserved but I'd say the most telling one is what Mary says during the epilogue. She talks about how this is the story of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson but John barely had anything to do with the final episode. The final episode focused on Sherlock's family so it spent a lot of time with Sherlock, Mycroft and Euros and not enough with John. Honestly John was little more than a plot device in The Final Problem. That's why Mary's words at the end felt like they came out of nowhere. How did The Final Problem in any way lead into showing that Sherlock was the story of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson? In fact I'd say Season 4 has dialed down the relationship between Sherlock and John more than any other season. Usually each episode of Sherlock devotes a lot of time to Sherlock and John's relationship. I'd even argue that each episode has at least one big memorable moment for Sherlock and John's relationship. However I can't say that about any of the episodes of Season 4 except The Lying Detective. The Six Thatchers spent too much time on Mary and The Final Problem spent too much time on Mycroft and Euros. I honestly thought Moffatiss could have done better. A Scandel in Belgravia focused on the relationship between Sherlock and Irene but John didn't feel neglected in that episode in terms of his relationship with Sherlock. He did have that moment at the end where he lied about Irene because he didn't want to hurt Sherlock's feelings. In many ways, John felt like a side character rather than the deuteragonist of the show in Season 4.
  5. Considering how Moffatiss tried to link every single aspect of Sherlock's character to originate from Euros, I think it's notable that there's one trait that they missed: Sherlock's combat abilities. Sherlock is really good at fighting. That's how he was able to hold his own against a highly trained assassin like AJ. It also explains how he was able to destroy Molly's coffin with his bare hands. Season 4 isn't the first time that Sherlock has displayed his strength. He also did so in The Blind Banker where he held his own against those Chinese circus goons. I remember in the Behind the Scenes of The Six Thatchers, Benedict Cumberbatch spoke of how Sherlock had superior combat abilities even in the books. That's one of the reasons why they decided to have a James Bond-esque brawl in The Six Thatchers. The question is: where did Sherlock get his combat abilities from? They obviously didn't come from Mycroft. I can see, however, why Mycroft would be okay with sending Sherlock on dangerous missions like disassembling Moriarty's network. Sherlock can use his combat abilities to keep himself safe. But who taught Sherlock how to fight? Why did a clever guy like Sherlock learn to fight? Did he do it because it was the one thing Mycroft was bad at and he wanted something to tease Mycroft about? It's funny that Season 4 tried to explain how Sherlock obtained all his traits but they missed his combat abilities. I guess it's understandable because Sherlock isn't exactly famous for his fighting abilities. TBH I'm kind of glad Moffatiss didn't try to explain where Sherlock got his combat abilities. Judging by what they did in The Final Problem, I'm guessing they would have tried to somehow link Sherlock's fighting abilities to Euros. It would have been really implausible if Euros taught Sherlock martial arts. It was convoluted enough that she taught him how to play the violin when they were like 4 - 5 years old?
  6. No H There are already Os: _ _ _ / _ A _ _ _ I _ _ / _ A _ _ E _ / I _ / E A S _ E _ _ / _ O _ _ O _ / S E _ _ / _ _ _ Did you mean another letter but mistyped?
  7. Just wondering: is it normal for people to choose their coffins when they're in their 30's like Molly? I thought people only chose their coffins when they reached old age. I was a bit surprised Molly actually had a coffin. Was she expecting to die? Maybe she just chose early because she worked in a morgue.
  8. There are As, Ss and Is. _ _ _ / _ A _ _ _ I _ _ / _ A _ _ E _ / I _ / E A S _ E _ _ / _ O _ _ O _ / S E _ _ / _ _ _
  9. Oh please, Moffat is an artist not a psychiatrist. He didn't bother looking through a medical dictionary to see if 'psychopath' or 'sociopath' was the right word to describe the Sherlock. He chose 'sociopath' most likely because it wasn't used as much as 'psychopath' in everyday speech so it would be fun to make a joke out of how people call Sherlock a 'psychopath' and have Sherlock (who's always a smart aleck) rebut by claiming he's a 'high-functioning sociopath'. Sometimes I think fans look more into an artist's work then even the artists do themselves. I think that fans really need to consider if the artist's themselves got into the technicalities of a certain detail before they try to use it to interpret a text. As for Sherlock being a 'good man', I just saw that as a feeble attempt by Moffatiss to tie up all the lose ends in Sherlock. Honestly I don't see how Sherlock wasn't a good man ever since The Reichenbach Fall. By then he was already playing the hero. He was even portrayed as a good man who was saving people who were kidnapped etc. Moriarty's entire plan was about destroying Sherlock's good reputation. In The Empty Hearse, John even commented on how Sherlock loved being the hero. Sherlock was a good man long before Season 4 even started. That's why Lestrade's line at the end of Season 4 just felt like a ploy to make The Final Problem a better written episode then it really was.
  10. There are Es and Os. _ _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ / _ _ _ _ E _ / _ _ / E _ _ _ E _ _ / _ O _ _ O _ / _ E _ _ / _ _ _
  11. It's likely that everyone was in the house when Euros lit the fire. Remember it was after she hid Victor away. We hear Mr. and Mrs. Holmes arguing about what to do with her in the background. Euros also said that the last thing she asked Sherlock to do was to get her favourite hairband back from Mrs. Holmes. We don't know what Mycroft was doing but I doubt he would have left his family alone in the house with Euros. As for why Euros lit the fire, it may have been because she was angry she was being punished by having her favourite hairband taken away. Or may have been just because she seemed angry at Sherlock. Look at those pictures she drew of Sherlock. She seemed to hate him and wanted him dead. One of those pictures even has Sherlock with his head on fire. I don't know why she was so angry at Sherlock. Maybe it was just because he couldn't solve her puzzle?
  12. Mycroft mentioned his parents' line-dancing at the beginning of His Last Vow when he believed that Sherlock really had a drug problem: http://arianedevere.livejournal.com/67234.html MYCROFT (slowly walking along the hallway): You haven’t been home all night. So, why would a man who has never knowingly closed the door without the direct orders of his mother bother to do so on this occasion? (Sherlock has raised his head and flipped back his hood while Mycroft progressed. Now Mycroft reaches the door and puts his hand on the door knob. Sherlock hurls himself up into a sitting position.) SHERLOCK: Okay, stop! Just stop. (Mycroft turns the knob but doesn’t open the door.) SHERLOCK: Point made. JOHN: Jesus, Sherlock. (Mycroft releases the door knob and comes slowly back along the hall.) MYCROFT: Have to phone our parents, of course, in Oklahoma. (Sherlock looks down and closes his eyes.) MYCROFT: Won’t be the first time that your substance abuse has wreaked havoc with their line-dancing. Well technically she went from being a mathematical genius to raising three ingenious children. That offered her mental stimulation. I'm not sure what she would do in her old age though. I'm starting to think Mrs. Holmes just said that to spite Mycroft. Mrs. Holmes is very protective of her children. In His Last Vow, she said she would turn monstrous if she ever found out who shot Sherlock (which ironically ended up being Mary, the woman she was serving tea to in her cottage).
  13. _ _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ _ / _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ _ _ / _ _ _ _ _ _ / _ _ _ _ / _ _ _ I picked this quote because of its ability to confuse people. Let's see if Artemis or Inge l-w can guess it.
  14. A bigger question is why Moriarty never mentioned Euros. He loved messing with Sherlock all the time. Why didn't he ever say something like 'I visited your psychopath sister in an asylum?'
  15. My head cannon is that Mr. Holmes left Mrs. Holmes to largely deal with the children because they were all geniuses and he wasn't. He didn't see himself to be a fitting father to them. I guess this would mean that Mycroft, Sherlock and Euros never had a strong father figure in their life which makes sense because they don't seem to show any typical fatherly traits. For example, the way Mycroft is protective of Sherlock always looks more like the protectiveness that a mother has rather than the protectiveness a father has. Mycroft's habit of monitoring Sherlock and trying to get close him despite Sherlock's lack of appreciation looks more like something a mother than father would do. A father would more likely watch from a distance and be more subtle about what they're doing.
  16. I thought the majority of gun crimes in the US were committed by people suffering from some degree of mental illness?
  17. http://www.npr.org/2017/02/02/513126985/house-votes-to-overturn-obama-rule-restricting-gun-sales-to-mentally-ill So the House decide to overturn an Obama administration rule to keep guns out of the hands of the mentally ill. Great. So now mentally ill people in the US can buy guns and shoot innocent people. Way to go Republicans. Looks like the possibility of another Sandy Hook occurring in the US isn't highly unlikely.
  18. I wouldn't say Mycroft went against his own directive. He was the one who was best equipped to deal with Euros as h knew her ever since he was a child. He could decide what to do with her and nobody in Sherrinford could challenge him on that matter because nobody else had the experience he had. Also what do you mean by checks and balances in Sherrinford? The security in Sherrinford was fine. The only problem was the Governor who got cocky and thought he could tame Euros. The reason why Mycroft never found out about the psychologists committing suicide was because the Governor hid those incidents from him. The thing about Mycroft's lie to his parents is that Mycroft didn't know if his parents could psychologically withstand what Euros had become or not. All Mycroft knew is that Euros' cruelty had caused Sherlock to rewrite his memories. Mycroft was probably afraid that his parents may also end up rewriting their memories. Finding out your daughter is a monster is a traumatising event for any parent. It would make sense for Mycroft to not want to risk damaging his parents' mind. Now it's true that Mr. and Mrs. Holmes are fine with Euros at the end of The Final Problem but remember Euros at the end of The Final Problem is much different from the Euros at the start of The Final Problem. At the start of the episode, Euros was a psychopath that didn't mind brainwashing other people into killing themselves and their loved ones. If Mr. and Mrs. Holmes knew this, it might cause them great pain especially at their age. My point here is that we never really find out how Mr. and Mrs. Holmes would have reacted to the knowledge of their daughter being a mass murdering psychopath. It makes sense for Mycroft to hide such details from them. Also even if Euros bullied Mycroft when he was a kid, I don't think Mycroft would bear a grudge against her till adulthood. I mean Mycroft isn't Sherlock. He's more level headed. I took Mycroft's comments to Lady Smallwood to imply that he doesn't allow brotherly compassion to prevent him from taking necessary actions. I have to ask you one question: Do you agree with Mrs. Holmes when she says Sherlock has always been the adult one? I strongly disagree with her on that. I always thought Mycroft was more mature and adult like than Sherlock.
  19. Oh yeah that's correct. In that case it becomes ambiguous if Mycroft was ever the Governor. But even if he wasn't, I think he should have been since only he handled Euros correctly.
  20. Mycorft says that the Governor's office used to be his own office so I'm guessing Mycroft was the Governor of Sherrinford before he joined MI6.
  21. I think it was more like Uncle Rudy tried to hide away Euros secretly but Mycroft found out because he was the smartest in his family after Euros. Thus Uncle Rudy had to allow Mycroft join him in his plan. TBH I always saw Mycroft as a smart aleck when he was a kid so it would make sense to me if he found out about Uncle Rudy secretly hiding Euros away. Then he grew out of it as an adult. I think Sherlock's smart aleck behaviour may have been inherited from Mycroft except it took longer for Sherlock to get out of it. You said Moriarty mentioned the East Wind to Sherlock. When did he do this? Also I think we're not given enough information to render a value judgement on Mycroft's actions. You could argue it was foolish for him to let Euros speak to Moriarty for 5 minutes but it was still only 5 minutes. Remember Mycroft wasn't just letting her talk to Moriarty for nothing. Euros assisted him in national security matters such as when she predicted a terrorist attack by using twitter. However Euros required rewards for her services. We don't know what Euros did for Mycroft in return for letting her talk to Moriarty. It may have been something that led to saving millions of lives. It may have been worth it. Also I have to say that I don't find Mycroft's belief that he won't be manipulated by Euros to be arrogance. I think he was right. You see Euros didn't take over Sherrinford because Mycroft was arrogant. Euros took over Sherrinford because Mycroft was too humble. Mycroft chose to trust the Governor. However that was his big mistake. Once the Governor saw that Mycroft was letting Euros see people like Moriarty he got entitled and thought he could also let other people see her. That's what you see in the episode. When Mycroft asks the Governor why he let people see Euros, the Governor responds by saying that Mycroft let Moriarty see her. However when Mycroft was in charge of Sherrinford everything was fine. Euros didn't mind control anyone or break out or anything. That shows that Mycroft was right to trust only himself. Mycroft's only mistake was trusting other people with Euros so basically Mycroft should never have left his post in Sherrinford. He should have always remained as the Governor of Sherrinford and not allow anyone else to have the position. TBH I think this is all a flaw in the writing. I think Moffatiss were trying to show that Mycroft was wrong for the way he treated Euros but I think they went about the wrong way doing it. Once you examine the sequence of events it looks like Mycroft was right for treating Euros the way he treated her. However I'm pretty sure that wasn't Moffatiss' intention.
  22. That's correct. It's the first line from that song that Emily Ricoletti's ghost sings when she's about to shoot her husband in The Abominable Bride. It's only said one other time in the episode. I chose this quote specifically because I thought it was the best one to fool a repeat viewer like you, Inge l-w. It's a lyric from a song so it's interlaced with music so remembering it becomes more difficult to remember because there's more sound to process. It also doesn't fit in nicely with the rest of Sherlock's quote. Also it's from the Special rather than from a Season so it might take you a while to consider looking there. Unfortunately you were still able to guess it so I don't know how to fool you next time.
  23. Woops I'll restore the O. There are H's. T H E / _ _ I _ / O _ / T H E / _ I _ _
  24. Just wondering: do you blame Mycroft for sending Euros to Sherrinford and hiding her from his family? Honestly I think he made the right call for what he knew. They couldn't solve the puzzle so Mycroft could only act on what he could see of Euros. Euros was really dangerous and her parents would have been horrified if they heard of what a dangerous psychopath she had become. Mycroft is one of my favourite characters, but I think he made several wrong calls with Eurus. It wasn't his call to make, keeping her from her parents. I also think they already knew she was a psychopath, and were capable of compartmentalising that and spending time with her, as shown at the end. Taking their child from them is something he had no business doing, and he's not a father himself so he has no context to understand what he's doing. He also was just too arrogant in assuming he could contain her, doubly so if he was planning on doing favours for her like having her meet Moriarty. He basically destroyed any chance of maintaining the charade at that point- giving Sherlock's worst enemy the ammunition of a secret like that to use against him? He protected the family temporarily, but he also set them up for a spectacular fall. I do quite like the narrative effect of having the smartest character make one of the biggest mistakes in the show, but I definitely see it as a mistake. I think he meant well, and he is more human to me now as a result of this episode. I think one of the main reasons why Mycroft didn't allow Euros to interact with other people was because of her mind control powers. Remember Mycroft said that Euros could reprogramme people ever since she was 5 years old. Sian Brooke confirmed in an interview that Euros was 5 years old when she was taken away to be locked up. So Euros had her mind control abilities even when she was a kid. It made sense for Mycroft to basically not allow anyone to talk to her except himself. Now you can argue that Sherlock and their parents may have been immune to her mind control techniques. However it would make sense for Mycroft to not want to risk the possibility anyway. After all Euros' mind control abilities might get stronger as she got older. You heard what Euros did to people who talked to her. What if she one day convinced Mr. and Mrs. Holmes to kill each other? Also it's true that Mycroft let Moriarty speak to Euros for 5 minutes unsupervised but I wouldn't describe as what he did as giving ammunition. I mean Moriarty never brought up Euros with Sherlock although he could. You could argue that's a plot hole. I mean Moriarty likes messing with Sherlock. if he knew about Euros, then why didn't he ever talk to him about her? I think that Moriarty- Euros connection was just poorly written and not given much thought. It looks like Moffatiss only gave them a connection because they wanted to foreshadow Euros' impending threat but they didn't want to give it away so they used Moriarty as a ruse (via his 'Miss me?' videos).
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.