Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

"Moriarty" is actually a catchall code name for expert assassins and serial killers based in London. Our Moriarty is just the latest in a long line of Moriartys, but now since he blew his brains out, we may see another.

I'm not actually sure that qualifies as crazy.... :blink:
  • Like 1
Posted

"Moriarty" is actually a catchall code name for expert assassins and serial killers based in London. Our Moriarty is just the latest in a long line of Moriartys, but now since he blew his brains out, we may see another.

 

Like the various incarnations of 007, I like this. Is cloning also involved or they come from the traditional recruitment and training basis? :D

  • Like 1
Posted

Cloning would take too long, wouldn't it?  I mean, scientists worked their way up to sheep less than 20 years ago, so even assuming that they were working on human cloning at the same time, the first ones would be barely adult by now.

 

Also, I suspect that early-childhood experiences, nutrition, and training add up to a more important factor than genetics, so I don't really see the point of cloning villains (even ignoring that it's expensive).  You'd probably be better off finding teens with appropriate tendencies and giving them an improper upbringing.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Cloning would take too long, wouldn't it?  I mean, scientists worked their way up to sheep less than 20 years ago, so even assuming that they were working on human cloning at the same time, the first ones would be barely adult by now.

 

Also, I suspect that early-childhood experiences, nutrition, and training add up to a more important factor than genetics, so I don't really see the point of cloning villains (even ignoring that it's expensive).  You'd probably be better off finding teens with appropriate tendencies and giving them an improper upbringing.

 

Long term strategy, pro-active instead of reactive. ;) Besides, this is fiction-verse, who said we have to play with real world's rules? Just twist them into suitable and believable story and entertain the audience. 

Posted

Cloning would take too long, wouldn't it?  I mean, scientists worked their way up to sheep less than 20 years ago, so even assuming that they were working on human cloning at the same time, the first ones would be barely adult by now.

 

Also, I suspect that early-childhood experiences, nutrition, and training add up to a more important factor than genetics, so I don't really see the point of cloning villains (even ignoring that it's expensive).  You'd probably be better off finding teens with appropriate tendencies and giving them an improper upbringing.

 

During the special when everything gets answered, we find out that Sherlock uncovers a Moriarty training camp that had been so secretive it managed to stay under his radar between TRF and TEH.  There is all the grooming on how to be a proper psycopathic villain with all of the class/charm that Andrew Scott's Moriarty had.

  • Like 1
Posted

... this is fiction-verse, who said we have to play with real world's rules? Just twist them into suitable and believable story and entertain the audience.

There are plenty of movies / shows that seem to play by those rules, so you'd have an audience, no problem. Doubt that I'd be in it, though, unless there was some halfway reasonable attempt to explain how they could come up with instant clones -- that sort of "movie science" drives me nuts!  :huh:

 

  • Like 1
Posted

 

Cloning would take too long, wouldn't it?  I mean, scientists worked their way up to sheep less than 20 years ago, so even assuming that they were working on human cloning at the same time, the first ones would be barely adult by now.

 

Also, I suspect that early-childhood experiences, nutrition, and training add up to a more important factor than genetics, so I don't really see the point of cloning villains (even ignoring that it's expensive).  You'd probably be better off finding teens with appropriate tendencies and giving them an improper upbringing.

 

During the special when everything gets answered, we find out that Sherlock uncovers a Moriarty training camp that had been so secretive it managed to stay under his radar between TRF and TEH.  There is all the grooming on how to be a proper psycopathic villain with all of the class/charm that Andrew Scott's Moriarty had.

 

 

That, I believe, is called as acting school. Sherlock stormed it and later get nabbed by the instructors who promised with capital P to teach him how to wow his fans as a Consulting Detective.  :lol:

 

 

 

... this is fiction-verse, who said we have to play with real world's rules? Just twist them into suitable and believable story and entertain the audience.

There are plenty of movies / shows that seem to play by those rules, so you'd have an audience, no problem. Doubt that I'd be in it, though, unless there was some halfway reasonable attempt to explain how they could come up with instant clones -- that sort of "movie science" drives me nuts!  :huh:

 

 

Oh? Not a fan of sci-fi where comparing 'their' techs with ours right now is like comparing ability to print a replacement kneecap with getting a stump for lower leg in pre-industrial age just because someone broke it and the rest have to be amputated because of gangrene? :D

Posted

You'd probably be better off finding teens with appropriate tendencies and giving them an improper upbringing.

I can't believe I just read this sentence. Next time my nephew tells me the internet is "perfectly harmless" I'm a-smackin' him upside the head.
Posted

Actually, now that I've read the rest of the comments, I may simply take an axe to his computer.... :blink:

  • Like 1
Posted

Actually, now that I've read the rest of the comments, I may simply take an axe to his computer.... :blink:

 

Don't forget his smartphone, tablet, etc then ship him somewhere remote where there's no mobile signal  :D

 

Today's crazy speculation: Kitty Riley is was used by CAM to destroy his competitor by creating scandal of unscrupulous business practice (reads; libel). One stroke, two victims - Holmes and his competitor. 

  • Like 2
Posted

... this is fiction-verse, who said we have to play with real world's rules? Just twist them into suitable and believable story and entertain the audience.

There are plenty of movies / shows that seem to play by those rules, so you'd have an audience, no problem. Doubt that I'd be in it, though, unless there was some halfway reasonable attempt to explain how they could come up with instant clones -- that sort of "movie science" drives me nuts!  :huh:

 

Oh? Not a fan of sci-fi where comparing 'their' techs with ours right now is like comparing ability to print a replacement kneecap with getting a stump for lower leg in pre-industrial age just because someone broke it and the rest have to be amputated because of gangrene? :D

 

I have no problem whatsoever with science fiction, as long as it doesn't expect us to believe that the natural laws have been repealed.  Movies can show future societies with more advanced technology, fine.  My main gripe is with stories set in the current day that want us to believe (for example) that clones are adults right out of the box, or that any computer can do anything if you just know which button to push.  If a story requires anything contrary to state of the art, they'd better justify it somehow -- a mad scientist with a new invention, for example.

 

  • Like 3
Posted

HEAR HEAR!!! (Or is it HERE HERE!!! I've never been sure.)

Posted

HEAR HEAR!!! (Or is it HERE HERE!!! I've never been sure.)

 

No no no, thy name is plausible deniability :P

 

Only in (very) poorly written fan fiction writer did not give sufficient reason for a technology. Like many Star Trek techs from TOS - TNG that had become reality and or starting to show its seeds to the public today, did it mean that they already exist when the scenario written on the first time? More like the writers originally take idea from the existing, experimental news of tech available to them that time then imagination took over (I dare you to take a look at some 1960's sci-fi, we supposed to have flying cars at 2000! :lol:  ). Given that humankind's understanding of the universe is always changing, I would not cling to today's notion about what is possible and what is not. Everything is up for question and nothing would be spared as we continue to challenge and grow with time.

  • Like 1
Posted

HEAR HEAR!!! (Or is it HERE HERE!!! I've never been sure.)

 

You had it right the first time.  :D

 

Only in (very) poorly written fan fiction writer did not give sufficient reason for a technology. Like many Star Trek techs from TOS - TNG that had become reality and or starting to show its seeds to the public today, did it mean that they already exist when the scenario written on the first time? More like the writers originally take idea from the existing, experimental news of tech available to them that time then imagination took over (I dare you to take a look at some 1960's sci-fi, we supposed to have flying cars at 2000! :lol:  ). Given that humankind's understanding of the universe is always changing, I would not cling to today's notion about what is possible and what is not. Everything is up for question and nothing would be spared as we continue to challenge and grow with time.

To be more explicit, I feel that fiction set in the current day should be reasonably consistent with current-day technology.  Fiction set in the past should be more or less consistent the technology (and everything else) of that era.  Fiction set in the future has more leeway of course, but it should minimally be plausible and also consistent with itself -- no changing what's possible from one week to the next.

 

The corollary to that would be that anyone writing a story which relies heavily on some specific technology (past, present, or future) had better be fairly knowledgeable about that technology and/or find a friend to act as technical consultant and/or do some serious Googling.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

....  Fiction set in the future has more leeway of course, but it should minimally be plausible and also consistent with itself -- no changing what's possible from one week to the next....

(Emphasis mine.)

 

Hear hear again, and I would apply that to fiction in general; the internal "rules" need to be consistent, even if they're not "real world" rules. (Exceptions may be made for comedy, satire and the like. :smile: ) Otherwise everything just becomes a trick, and the only fun in that is for the person doing the tricking. (Casts stern look in general direction of Moftiss.)

  • Like 2
Posted

 

....  Fiction set in the future has more leeway of course, but it should minimally be plausible and also consistent with itself -- no changing what's possible from one week to the next....

(Emphasis mine.)

 

Hear hear again, and I would apply that to fiction in general; the internal "rules" need to be consistent, even if they're not "real world" rules. (Exceptions may be made for comedy, satire and the like. :smile: ) Otherwise everything just becomes a trick, and the only fun in that is for the person doing the tricking. (Casts stern look in general direction of Moftiss.)

 

 

But where's the fun in following the rules :)  You know they are meant to be bent and broken on an as necessary basis, just look at society.  The rules are broken all the time there. (yes, I'm being 100% sarcastic)

  • Like 1
Posted

Sarcasm appreciated!! But I don't mean society's rules anyway, I mean the story's internal rules. For example, having Bilbo use a cell phone would break the rules that govern Middle Earth, and therefore break the story. Except maybe in satire, breaking the story is simply bad story-telling.

Posted

Okay, crazy theory #46B:  the person who faked the Moriarty gif and broadcast it all over England is ... theimprobableone, from John's blog. It's so obvious, why did I not see this before.... :wacko:

  • Like 1
Posted

Wow! He's had plastic surgery!! (Well, I guess one would have to after blowing one's brains out, wouldn't one?) :tongue:

  • Like 1
Posted

Okay, crazy theory #46B:  the person who faked the Moriarty gif and broadcast it all over England is ... theimprobableone, from John's blog. It's so obvious, why did I not see this before.... :wacko:

 

Actually -- that sounds highly probable!

 

(Well, plausible anyhow.)

  • Like 2
Posted

And therefore must be the wrong answer. Rats. :smile:

  • Like 2
Posted

Sarcasm appreciated!! But I don't mean society's rules anyway, I mean the story's internal rules. For example, having Bilbo use a cell phone would break the rules that govern Middle Earth, and therefore break the story. Except maybe in satire, breaking the story is simply bad story-telling.

 

Of course in that type of world it would be odd.  There is the possibility of writing you own story-verse that broke all conventional rules including any that may have shown up in the beginning of the story.  Or make it part of the story-verse that the rules change at whim of the writer and characters, because we all know that at some point in the story the muse and characters try to take over.  (In book #2 of a series I started writing, my protagonist was captured and had his head mercilessly/recklessly hit against the frame of an SUV.  It was not planned by me at all.  The antagonist characters seemed to love it until he escaped a few hours later. They are now tracking him in the savanna near sub-Saharan Eastern Africa in book #3 after their 2nd party (in the Northwestern corner of South Africa) regarding his demise had been stopped because he turned up alive again.)

Posted

Mycroft helped Moriarty fake his death and also set up Moriarty's dramatic return!

 

yeaaah.gif

 

So does that mean the Moriarty had plastic surgery and now looks like Tom Hiddleston instead of Andrew Scott?

 

 

Posted

 

Okay, crazy theory #46B:  the person who faked the Moriarty gif and broadcast it all over England is ... theimprobableone, from John's blog. It's so obvious, why did I not see this before.... :wacko:

 

Actually -- that sounds highly probable!

 

(Well, plausible anyhow.)

 

 

I agree which then means that Arcadia's comment after is all the more likely.  But it would be fun if she were correct.  It seems like someone was correct about the squash ball before series 3 aired if I remember correctly.

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 97 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.