Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I have a (totally unfounded) impression that this might be an alternative "reunion" scene.

 

It looks to me like some of those photos could have been from an almost-reunion scene, sort of a teaser before the real thing.  There's one shot of John (#14 according to the URL) looking straight at Sherlock through the window and looking shocked, and there's another one (#12), a closeup, where John could be saying to himself, "I couldn't possibly have seen what I just saw -- could I?"  And others (e.g., #7) that could be Sherlock having come back there after John has left, and sitting there thinking what he should do.  (And about half are apparently just behind-the-scenes shots of Cumberbatch and Freeman.)

 

And also because they apparently recycle some of their deleted ideas into other stories. Waste not, want not! :)

 

Quite true.  (According to the Leverage commentaries, they did the same thing on that show, and their expression for it was "We use every part of the buffalo.")

  • Like 2
  • 1 month later...
Posted

To get back more on topic,

The alternative "reveal" scenes that they put in the show during the "Empty Hearse" episode are seemed to be designed to put doubt on ANY true answers given throughout the episode (assuming any of the answers were real...)

There where many theories throughout the time before the show hit the screen; and I maintained over this period of time that the answer lied somehow in the WAY that Sherlock fell from St Bart's. (He fell straight down, face first, but landed on his side?) Now if the final "answer" that was said by Sherlock to Anderson is correct and he did fall onto a bouncy castle (turning at the last minute to land), it proves that I was right!

Anyway.

My point here is that because of these false scenes scattered throughout the episode "Empty Hearse" doubt is still on exactly what happened on the roof of St Barts.

Which brings us back to the newest mystery, [season 4 spoiler ahead!]

 

 

Jim Moriaty's apparent return, "Have you missed me?"

 


So Moffett's been bad and has been keeping us in the dark since the "Reichenbach Fall". Naughty Moffett! :moffat:  :whip:

Thoughts anyone?

 

Posted

We have discussed if it were possible for Moriarty to survive blowing his brains out. I know it is possible to survive shooting yourself through the mouth because I know someone who did. While being shot in the head is usually fatal, it isn't always.

 

So then it becomes a matter of how big was the exit wound and how much brains & blood were lost. (In other words: we wait til the Christmas special and pray that Moftiss actually does a better job of answering it than they did with Sherlock's survival.)

Posted

Thoughts anyone?

Just that you could be right! :D I'll be really surprised if they address The Fall anymore, though. Actually, I'll be surprised by almost anything they do, as everything seems equally possible to me at this moment .....

Posted

 

Thoughts anyone?

Just that you could be right! :D I'll be really surprised if they address The Fall anymore, though. Actually, I'll be surprised by almost anything they do, as everything seems equally possible to me at this moment .....

 

 

I could see a potential for a flashback especially if Sherlock goes into mind palace mode just to review what happened up there to Moriarty before Sherlock jumped.  I can also see a potential for a what happened to Moriarty's body after the gun shot & Sherlock's jump scene or discussion there of.

Posted

I always find it really hard to balance the fact that Sherlock is supposed to be this "all knowing" being and then he mucks it all up and somehow doesn't realise that Jim is still alive! Or didn't know that Mary was an assassin (I by the way, did know that Mary was a liar; not only because she was suspect but because of those LIAR words that floated around her when Sherlock first laid eyes on her!)

 

So anyway, here's a few theories I've been working on:

  1. Jim "somehow" faked being shot in the head
  2. Jim survived and "somehow" survived being shot in the head
  3. Jim didn't survive and this "did you miss me" guy is just a copycat pretending to be Jim (either because Jim asked him to in the event of Jim's death or not)
  4. Jim didn't survive and this "did you miss me" guy is the brother/cousin/sister of Jim. (Sherlock has a brother, why can't Jim? -Except it's not in the cannon, but neither is Jim's return)

I've only read a few of the cannon books so forgive me if I've mucked something up! :D

So what do you think?

Posted

 

4.Jim didn't survive and this "did you miss me" guy is the brother/cousin/sister of Jim. (Sherlock has a brother, why can't Jim? -Except it's not in the cannon, but neither is Jim's return)

 

I've only read a few of the cannon books so forgive me if I've mucked something up!

Well actually, you're in luck! Professor James Moriarty has at least one brother in canon.  There's a Colonel Moriarty mentioned in "The Empty House," who has been writing letters to all the newspapers, insulting the memory of Sherlock Holmes (kinda like what Jim did by feeding his lies to newspaper reporter Kitty Riley ).  Oddly enough, his name is also James.  (So "our Jim" might actually be the Colonel rather than the Professor.)

 

Then in The Valley of Fear, the Professor has a younger brother who's a railway station master.  Nothing else is mentioned about him, so he may or may not be the same man as the Colonel.

Posted

Very interesting Carol...

But on the funny side, Jim's parents must not have had a very strong imagination.. :D 

  • Like 2
Posted

When watching HLV, I honestly thought that it was just a ploy of Mycroft/Johns to get Sherlock back from exile. I didn't think that Mycroft would show his 'shock' at how it was possible, I would have thought that he would be all stoic and put his big pants on to deal with it, and John hardly seemed bothered! In fact, Mycroft got over the 'Its not possible, its simply not possible!' fast enough to seem coy on the phone to Sherlock about coming back from exile, and I reckon John knew it was going to happen, from his blatant nonchalance when Mary is panicking.

However, I do really hope that Moriarty is back - it wouldn't be quite as exciting without him ;)

  • Like 2
Posted

If Mycroft pulled off the whole Moriarty thing to save his little brother...

 

tumblr_m31bhciRkT1rnmhpu.gif

  • Like 4
Posted

If Mycroft pulled off the whole Moriarty thing to save his little brother...

 

tumblr_m31bhciRkT1rnmhpu.gif

Of course we'll all be disappointed if Jim doesn't return.

Every fairy-tale needs a good old fashioned villain...!

  • Like 2
Posted

Nah, I don't miss him. I wish they hadn't killed him off so soon, but now that he's gone, I don't want him back. Or his twin, either. I'm bored, I want something NEW. :p

Posted

If Mycroft pulled off the whole Moriarty thing to save his little brother...

 

tumblr_m31bhciRkT1rnmhpu.gif

 

Mycroft would, definitely. He and Sherlock fight and bicker a lot, but he cares about Sherlock so damn much.

 

Also this gif of Andrew Scott hurts my soul, it's so beautiful :cry:

  • Like 2
Posted

To be honest, I may be reading too much into it (who am I kidding, how can you read too much into Sherlock?) but I just don't see it being a real 'at the right time/place' occurrence.

 

What I *am* hoping, is that both theories are true. He did somehow survive, but this was not his doing. So perhaps Moriarty was out there somewhere, lounging on a sofa when all of a sudden, he pops up on television. Can you imagine his rage face? :p

  • Like 1
Posted

Of course they have other ways of bringing Moriarty back... as they did in the mind palace sequence of HLV.    I do think he's dead, but he's not dead inside Sherlock's mind.  He may be the "ghost" that haunts forever.

Posted

Of course they have other ways of bringing Moriarty back... as they did in the mind palace sequence of HLV.    I do think he's dead, but he's not dead inside Sherlock's mind.  He may be the "ghost" that haunts forever.

 

I did like Moriarty in the mind palace.  If Moftiss decides that Moriarty is indeed dead dead, then please bring him back in Sherlock's mind palace.  I like Andrew's performance as Moriarty and would like to see more of it in just about any capacity.

Posted

I would like to see him, just to see more of Andrew Scott. He absolutely won my heart at the Con.

Yeah, well, okay, I'll grant you that!

Posted

Maybe Jim was alive but didn't intend to come back; then he found out Sherlock was going to be shipped of then most likely killed and so he thought "Gotta save Sherly and the only thing that will is my return!"

 

Thus, "Did you miss me?"

 

 

As for something new...well they kinda tried that in season three with the "king of blackmail". Did you like that new? I didn't. Bring back my ol' fashioned villain...

Posted

I love season three, I really think it is my favorite.

 

I understand the impulse to just keep repeating what works, but I don't think this is that kind of show. They've made it pretty clear, it seems to me, that they're going to keep evolving. Pretty risky, that, but I also understand the impulse to create something new. Call it the artist in me, perhaps!

  • Like 2
Posted

I think if Moriarty came back over and over it would get a bit old.  Sherlock facing the same nemesis would get old.  So I'm not quite sure  One enemy shot himself, and the other one Sherlock killed.  The stories are getting more and more personal for him and I suspect S4 will be even more so.

  • Like 2
Posted

Of course if Jim kept coming back it would be terrible, but I mean I think we haven't worn out that avenue just yet! ;)

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 109 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.