Jump to content

What did you think of "The Final Problem?"  

112 members have voted

  1. 1. Add your vote here:

    • 10/10 Excellent.
    • 9/10 Not quite the best, but not far off.
    • 8/10 Certainly worth watching again.
    • 7/10 Slightly above the norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
    • 5/10 Slightly sub-par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly below average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
    • 2/10 Bad.
    • 1/10 Awful.


Recommended Posts

Posted

You all are on fire today! Agree with everything above!

 

Oh, except ... I think John has a special place at Sherlock's side. He's Sherlock's one true friend, and he may not have regarded him as an equal before, but I think he does now.

He treats John like family but I don't think an equal.

Posted

Why does the fishing trawler near Sherrinford, the one they hijack, NOT have a clear view wheel on its front windows? They are navigating the Irish Sea, full of storms and fog, so why isn't the boat properly equipped?

Pursuant to the case of the Vanishing Balcony, the railings are there in TFP, forcing Sherlock and John to jump even further. This continuity error is an apt indicator of how much attention to detail was paid in this series.

Posted

 

 

You all are on fire today! Agree with everything above!

 

Oh, except ... I think John has a special place at Sherlock's side. He's Sherlock's one true friend, and he may not have regarded him as an equal before, but I think he does now.

He treats John like family but I don't think an equal.
I think Sherlock's character to development has allowed him an increased appreciation for those with emotional intelligence sometimes higher than his own. In that way he can see John as closer to equal because whilst Sherlock has the upper hand intellectually, John has it in other areas.
  • Like 1
Posted

 

One thing I both love and hate about this episode is how it book-ends so many of the first episode's scenes. I get the feeling the writers read over their introductory scenes with characters and echoed them- Lestrade's 'good man' comment, Sherlock's 'you know where to find me', and Molly in ASIP saying 'bad day was it?' becomes 'I've had a bad day.'

 

I think they are all lovely ways to recall the early days, but it makes me really nervous that the show isn't coming back.

Ive assumed all along it's not coming back based on LB's goodbye Molly tweet and BC's comment about it feeling like an end of an era. Of course BC backtracked a bit but it definitely seems like it would be several years from now if it does come back.

 

 

Isn't it always, though?  ;)

  • Like 1
Posted

I was thinking more like at least 5 years if at all. The normal hiatus is 2 years.

 

 

 

 

You all are on fire today! Agree with everything above!

 

Oh, except ... I think John has a special place at Sherlock's side. He's Sherlock's one true friend, and he may not have regarded him as an equal before, but I think he does now.

He treats John like family but I don't think an equal.
I think Sherlock's character to development has allowed him an increased appreciation for those with emotional intelligence sometimes higher than his own. In that way he can see John as closer to equal because whilst Sherlock has the upper hand intellectually, John has it in other areas.
I agree that John has more practical knowledge and Sherlock has appreciation for that knowledge but I still think he has limited emotional knowledge despite all of his therapy! He has trouble determining/trusting when Sherlock is telling the truth or interpreting his feelings and he couldn't tell that his wife was a total liar/assassin. His ability to read people on an emotional level is flawed. Even in the last episode, he immediately assumed the ILY must have been referring to Irene Adler when it didn't fit the scene at all or as Sherlock put it "don't be ridiculous". I think the people that Sherlock treats as equals are the ones with higher intellect and the ones that can read Sherlock himself, i.e. Moriarty, Eurus, Mycroft and Adler, because they present a challenge to Sherlock. Sherlock's friends provide him with invaluable emotional connections but not intellectual challenges. He feeds off the intellectual challenges.
Posted

Sherlock saved Molly and Molly saved Sherlock. Because after the love scene, Euros decided not to let Sherlock kill himself. Earlier, she didn't mind when Sherlock almost fell of the bridge. So she has changed, and the only reason can be that she saw the love between Sherlock and Molly, after that she wanted Sherlocks love too.

Posted

More Existentialism References:

No one has yet commented on the fact that the writers have Sherlock playing a fictional pirate: "Yellowbeard".  Why did they choose a fictional - rather than actual - pirate (like Redbeard, Blackbeard, etc) for Sherlock to play?

I think the answer lies in who, or more specifically, what "Yellowbeard" was: an absurdist comedy.  As such, it serves as a mirror to Eurus' existential horror.  Both Eurus and Sherlock inhabit the same "absurd" reality.  But, because Sherlock has a best friend - has love - instead of being terrifying, the existentialist's nightmare world is transformed into a harmless, humorous farce.

In other words, the name is an allusion to how love "saves".  Love transforms all of existence. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I think Sherlock's character to development has allowed him an increased appreciation for those with emotional intelligence sometimes higher than his own. In that way he can see John as closer to equal because whilst Sherlock has the upper hand intellectually, John has it in other areas.

 

Which brings me around to a point I was making (somewhere) earlier ... I think Sherlock also now realizes that having the upper hand is not the be-all and end-all of human interaction. (Not even with Mycroft! :smile: Although I hope we'll still see them sparring if there are any future episodes.) Other things, such as empathy, can be equally if not more important.

 

I was thinking more like at least 5 years if at all. The normal hiatus is 2 years.

Same here.

 

I agree that John has more practical knowledge and Sherlock has appreciation for that knowledge but I still think he has limited emotional knowledge despite all of his therapy! He has trouble determining/trusting when Sherlock is telling the truth or interpreting his feelings and he couldn't tell that his wife was a total liar/assassin. His ability to read people on an emotional level is flawed.

He does come across as rather gullible at times, but I'm not sure that's the same as having emotional intelligence. (???) I think the latter is more about knowing how to act when interviewing grieving parents, for example, or recognizing that Molly has a crush on Sherlock. It's the concrete observational skills that John lacks; like being able to tell how many times Carl Powers changed his shoelaces.

 

On the other hand, John's bullsh*t radar is usually tuned pretty high, and he's not afraid to take Sherlock on when he thinks the man is bluffing. ("Are you just making this up?")  But sometimes, yeah, he's just taken in. But you have to admit, Sherlock's an awfully good liar. The git.

 

 

Sherlock saved Molly and Molly saved Sherlock. Because after the love scene, Euros decided not to let Sherlock kill himself. Earlier, she didn't mind when Sherlock almost fell of the bridge. So she has changed, and the only reason can be that she saw the love between Sherlock and Molly, after that she wanted Sherlocks love too.

 

I'm sorry, Loekie, which scene do you mean? I don't remember a scene where Sherlock is close to falling off a bridge. Do you mean when he and "Faith" were taking a walk? He wasn't about to fall, there, he was collapsing in pain from the effect of the drugs he was taking. But he wasn't in any danger of falling off. If he had been, I think "Faith" might have saved him ... because she still wanted to play her game with him.

 

Did seeing his love for Molly change her mind about what she would do to Sherlock? I don't know, I think that's still a big question.

 

More Existentialism References:

 

No one has yet commented on the fact that the writers have Sherlock playing a fictional pirate: "Yellowbeard".  Why did they choose a fictional rather than actual pirate (like Redbeard, Blackbeard, etc) for Sherlock to play?

 

I think the answer lies in who, or more specifically, what "Yellowbeard" was: an absurdist comedy.  As such, it serves as a mirror to Eurus' existential horror.  Both Eurus and Sherlock inhabit the same reality.  But, because Sherlock has a best friend - has love - instead of being terrifying, the existentialist's nightmare world is transformed into a harmless, humorous farce.

 

In other words, the name is an allusion to how love "saves".  Love transforms all of existence.

I did wonder why they picked that name, because I'd never heard it before. I would have thought he would've picked "Blackbeard", since he has dark hair. But "Sherlock" is supposed to mean "bright hair", which some have interpreted to mean blonde, so I thought maybe that's why they chose Yellowbeard.

 

But you think the name is an allusion to this play? Now that's Interesting. Something else to check out! I see a movie by that name on Wikipedia ... is that the same thing you're referring to?

 

You can't say the Sherlock fandom isn't educational! :smile:

  • Like 2
Posted
you think the name is an allusion to this play? Now that's Interesting. Something else to check out! I see a movie by that name on Wikipedia ... is that the same thing you're referring to?

Yes.  "Yellowbeard" is that movie.  As to checking it out, it has been a long time since I saw it, but I don't recall it being particularly good - despite having a ton of famous comedians in it (including many from Monty Python, which is the reason I originally watched it).

 

 

 

But "Sherlock" is supposed to mean "bright hair", which some have interpreted to mean blonde, so I thought maybe that's why they chose Yellowbeard.

Of course Moftiss are known for employing terms etc with multiple meanings/depth (ex: Moriarty's line "This is where I get off").  So it wouldn't surprise me that Yellowbeard was chosen for that reference the same way Redbeard was chosen: because it worked both as the name for an Irish Setter, given its hair color - as well as for the Best Friend, who was red headed.

 

Always "deep waters" with Moftiss

  • Like 1
Posted

I know that the creative pair thinks that all previous Holmes adaptations are their private playground and open season free game, but they should have acknowledged at one point or another that one of Mycroft's catchphrases is directly attributable to Jetemy Brett at the end of The Greek Interpreter, namely 'brother mine', since it is nowhere to be found in ACD canon!

  • Like 1
Posted

It is a shame that they don't release the actual shooting scripts for the series.  I would be keen on reading the descriptions etc from this season.

  • Like 3
Posted

Yeah, several of us have wished for that. Mark Gatiss just keeps saying he doesn't think there would be much demand for it. :(

  • Like 1
Posted

If he doesn't want to publish them because he doesn't think there would be demand, then he could certainly release them for free as pdf files.  Most shows already publish them internally that way.  No reason not to simply release it - as apparently they did for the Blind Banker episode (especially since, this season, they don't have any other writers from whom they would have to seek permission etc)

  • Like 1
Posted

Of course there would be demand. Clearly the shooting scripts are full of secrets they don't want us to know! I've heard of shows that print with red ink on pink paper so you can't even copy a shooting script.

Posted

Of course there would be demand. Clearly the shooting scripts are full of secrets they don't want us to know! I've heard of shows that print with red ink on pink paper so you can't even copy a shooting script.

 

Usually that's because they don't want spoilers getting out before the show airs.  Printing names on scripts and making it difficult to copy scripts are simply techniques to make such leaks difficult - and to make leakers more easily to track, thus making people less inclined to leak. 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Yes but also, people could also infer much more from scripts even after, there are many points where we here have wondered what a character's true motivation was, and a script direction to the actor could give a lot of insight into that... making it much harder for Moftiss to change their mind about what those characters were thinking/ feeling, in five years time, when they have a new idea and want to bend the narrative to suit.

 

I'm not surprised a show that thrives on ambiguity wouldn't share its scripts, honestly. But I'd love to read them, none the less.

  • Like 1
Posted

And yet they allow individual scripts to be sold etc after airing.

Posted

Ah I didn't know that, but then surely some might make their way online, to be examined?

 

Though, some scripts may be very different from the finished product- you know, extra scenes added at the last minute (like the 'I Love you" one) not included etc?

Posted

Yes, it will depend on which draft - which colored pages - are or are not included.  Whichever version, however, I would still be very interested in reading them.

  • Like 1
Posted

Along these lines, I seem to recall reading on the forum here that some of the scripts were included in a "Collector's Edition" of one or more of the Series.  Anyone know anything about that?

Posted

Yes, that rings a bell .... *searches furiously*
 
Okay, there's this reference to a long-sold out limited edition that contained a script, http://www.sherlockforum.com/forum/topic/2960-sherlock-scripts/?p=68930

and... okay, this appears to be the same thing. http://www.sherlockforum.com/forum/topic/1982-dvdblu-ray-extras-for-series-3/?p=20914

Okay, then. Last one to eBay is a rotten egg! :D

  • Like 1
Posted

I would like any version too.

 

This is The Blind Banker, but it's my least favourite episode .  :(

 

I'll still have a look though, fascinated at how they would put scenes together etc.

  • Like 1
Posted

Sigh - so just the first two scripts.  :(

Posted

Shall we write an open letter to Mark? Or does anyone have a better idea?

I don't have enough followers on social media to start anything over there :(

  • Like 1
Posted

I'd sign it, if you have any idea how to go about getting it to him. Or to Hartswood? Who would own publishing rights, anyway? I'd pay even for a .pdf version. Heck, I'd rather have a pdf version, easier to store.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 111 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.