Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Lying Detective"?  

70 members have voted

  1. 1. Add your vote here:

    • 10/10 Excellent.
    • 9/10 Not quite the best, but not far off.
    • 8/10 Certainly worth watching again.
    • 7/10 Slightly above the norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly sub-par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly below average.
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
      0
    • 1/10 Awful.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

To be honest, except for that sequence where he collapses in pain and ends up walking on the walls, I think he's got it relatively under control most of the time. He's affected, but not out of it, it seems to me.

Posted

If that were the case, and he were trying to convince John it wasn't, shouldn't he be more bedraggled? (And yes, I do realise the depths I've sunk to in discussing the state of a fictional man's facial hair.) 

Posted

Ummmm .... there must be a logical explanation ... er, Sherlock has deleted what "bedraggled" looks like from his hard drive?

Posted

Perhaps he couldn't bear looking so unsexy. ;) 'John will never save me like this, I look hideous.'

  • Like 1
Posted

Was anyone else oddly concerned with whether Sherlock smelled bad? Probably my OCD showing, but his hair definitely looks greasy when they go to the hospital, and considering he is high in that scene and was hoodwinked into Mrs H's boot (ie no time for a quick shower) I can imagine he must be pretty ripe.  :blink:

  • Like 1
Posted

Ha! I also kind of wondered how he smelled at that point. And it is not something I wonder about in general. Really.

Posted

Good, not just me then!  :lol:

  • Like 1
Posted

No-pe.
 
By the way, (and I'm probably going to regret asking this) when he comes out of the toilets, and says "Say what you like about addiction; the day is full of highlights" ... is he referring to anything specific?

Posted

My guess would be the, er, runs as it were. Though don't know for sure. 

Posted

That's what I was afraid of....

Posted

That makes sense, because he says he's "psychedelic" when the nurse asks how he feels. Although when would he have done it? In the toilet? Do drugs affect one that quickly?

Posted

I don't know, it sounds more sarcastic than that to me, and I don't know if John would stand placidly by whilst he went to inject himself in the toilets. Yes, he'd know Sherlock would need it to operate for the rest of the day but can't imagine him not kicking off at any chance he gets. I kind of hope it was just another hit, because I really really don't need to know about Sherlock's bowel movements. Sherlock is like the Queen, he doesn't do things like that.

  • Like 2
Posted

Just had this set of gifs pop up on my dash to restoke my fury, just when I think I've managed to get past it. I shouldn't post this but I have to vent before I get so angry it affects my actual day.

I know no one agrees with me on this delightful little scene, but look at the way he spits this at him. He's still acting so angrily towards a man with stitches in his eyebrow and burst blood vessels in his eye that John himself caused, a man he knows was willing to sacrifice himself yet again to save him, and what does Sherlock do? Sits there and takes it. Again. 

 

tumblr_ojjdr7tP311s3f8vfo6_400.gif   tumblr_ojjdr7tP311s3f8vfo10_400.gif

 

Yes, yes, the anger is meant to be directed at John himself, I get all that, but when the hell does it get to a point where it's not okay to keep lashing out? Once everything is fixed by the following magic hug I guess. Oh John, I really don't think I like you anymore :(

 

The gifs were signed off with the quote 'romantic entanglement... would complete you as a human being.' And accompanied with little Johnlock gif moments supposedly demonstrating that Sherlock has those entanglements already. That lovely throwaway little quote makes me so angry I could scream. 

 

It even makes me angry that I am angry, because I hate it when people harp on and take offence at things they should just ignore. 

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

I thought John was unwittingly making a bit of a fool of himself there. I mean, comparing what Sherlock and Irene have to his and Mary's marriage and suggesting that Irene would make Sherlock live up to any kind of standards worth mentioning, that's more than a little ridiculous.

 

But I think Sherlock understood it as the self-revelation on John's part that it really was and reacted to that rather than the actual words. I thought the whole scene was rather beautiful.

 

Come to think of it, the whole episode was pretty much about Sherlock knowing John extremely well. Mary totally underestimated him there, he would have probably come up with just the same plan on his own as she suggested in her posthumous message. But the DVD is needed so that John finally gets what is going on, because I don't think John would believe Sherlock had any altruistic motive for his actions at all. If Mary hadn't so blatantly pointed out that Sherlock had walked into the Lion's den to "save" him, he would have just gotten angry again at having fallen for another one of Sherlock's hoaxes.

 

I always knew John would need someone to point out to him that Sherlock does a lot of crazy shit for his sake, but I had always hoped it would be Molly. Oh well. Can't have everything, I suppose.

  • Like 4
Posted

...

Yes, yes, the anger is meant to be directed at John himself, I get all that, but when the hell does it get to a point where it's not okay to keep lashing out? Once everything is fixed by the following magic hug I guess. Oh John, I really don't think I like you anymore :(

 

The gifs were signed off with the quote 'romantic entanglement... would complete you as a human being.' And accompanied with little Johnlock gif moments supposedly demonstrating that Sherlock has those entanglements already. That lovely throwaway little quote makes me so angry I could scream. 

 

It even makes me angry that I am angry, because I hate it when people harp on and take offence at things they should just ignore. 

 

As well as anger, I wonder if there is a bit of jealousy there too? In the sense that, he sees Sherlock as someone who can love and be loved, and chooses not to? Whereas John seems to have quite a low opinion of himself, after the way he has treated Mary, followed by her death and possibly no longer feels capable of love or deserving of it?

 

I don't like him not respecting Sherlock's choice to be alone, or saying it means he isn't complete. I'd like to see Sherlock happy with someone myself, but if he doesn't choose that, it doesn't mean he isn't a 'whole' person.

 

I think part of the problem with the comparisons John tried to draw here is that Sherlock not being with Irene is like him not being 'fully' with Mary. But his problems with Mary happened because of the mistrust and potential infidelity between them. He's describing Sherlock as if he's turning down a chance to be in a relationship like John had with Mary. But, the truth is, Sherlock probably rather enjoys the fantasy of Irene, and the occasional suggestive text message. Whereas John didn't seem to enjoy much of his relationship with Mary, at all. Who would really want a marriage like that? Sherlock seems to accept Irene as she is and find a way that works to have her in his life (which is just to a very small extent). I don't think John ever really accepted his wife as she really was. It makes most of his advice ring hollow to me, because it comes from a place where John is not being honest with himself. 

 

I thought TLD and TST revealed a few unpleasant surprises about who John really is. Though, for me, this scene was marvellous. For me, it is more about who John allows Sherlock to show himself to be. Their friendship has proved to be beneficial for Sherlock, as portrayed on the show, but I'm not sure the same can always be said of John.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

As well as anger, I wonder if there is a bit of jealousy there too? In the sense that, he sees Sherlock as someone who can love and be loved, and chooses not to? Whereas John seems to have quite a low opinion of himself, after the way he has treated Mary, followed by her death and possibly no longer feels capable of love or deserving of it?

 

 

That's an interesting idea, I hadn't looked at it that way. Hm. Maybe. 

 

I wish they had addressed the fact that John never seemed happy in that life a bit more fully, the text messages make it clear he isn't happy, but why exactly? He has everything he wanted, a famlly, a steady job, a frisson of danger from having a dangerous wife. Maybe it's, as you said, that he could never fully accept her once he knew the truth.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

He's describing Sherlock as if he's turning down a chance to be in a relationship like John had with Mary. But, the truth is, Sherlock probably rather enjoys the fantasy of Irene, and the occasional suggestive text message. Whereas John didn't seem to enjoy much of his relationship with Mary, at all. Who would really want a marriage like that? Sherlock seems to accept Irene as she is and find a way that works to have her in his life (which is just to a very small extent). I don't think John ever really accepted his wife as she really was.

I agree. And I also get the impression that both Sherlock and Irene are quite happy with their standing flirtation and maybe an occasional spicy rendezvous somewhere, who knows.

 

Sherlock's emotional anchor is John, anyway. And John is also the person who most makes him want to live up to an ideal version of himself. But of course John doesn't understand that... He never has and never will, I think.

 

  • Like 3
Posted

 

 

As well as anger, I wonder if there is a bit of jealousy there too? In the sense that, he sees Sherlock as someone who can love and be loved, and chooses not to? Whereas John seems to have quite a low opinion of himself, after the way he has treated Mary, followed by her death and possibly no longer feels capable of love or deserving of it?

 

 

That's an interesting idea, I hadn't looked at it that way. Hm. Maybe. 

 

I wish they had addressed the fact that John never seemed happy in that life a bit more fully, the text messages make it clear he isn't happy, but why exactly? He has everything he wanted, a famlly, a steady job, a frisson of danger from having a dangerous wife. Maybe it's, as you said, that he could never fully accept her once he knew the truth.

 

 

They needed to tell us more about John. I know the show is about Sherlock, but what they don't seem to get is that when they leave out important aspects of the other characters, people can't understand what is going on between that character and Sherlock, and that hurts our understanding of the main character. I too, do not understand why John couldn't be happy with the mix of normality and danger he found with Mary. But in season three as well, I found John was often finding reasons to feel affronted by the people in his life. In season 4, are we supposed to believe John was married to Mary, with a new child, but unhappy enough to make acerbic comments about not liking her anymore, and texting other women, and Mary was either oblivious or choosing not to comment? What were either of them getting out of this situation?

 

I hate to say it, but I never saw anything in his relationship with Mary to say that they should marry or that they were the loves of each others lives. It just wasn't there for me, in the writing. Part of the problem might be we fell into an established relationship, due to the timing. Of course MF and AA have a natural chemistry, but to me the characters just seem quite familiar, like friends. I don't see any heat or passion between them. I actually don't know that the writers are good at that sort of thing- I think the main problem might be a lot of John's story was about his love life, and they prefer to avoid writing all that stuff, and possibly even can't do it. They're delighted to write him punching someone when everything about it goes to hell, though.

 

 

 

He's describing Sherlock as if he's turning down a chance to be in a relationship like John had with Mary. But, the truth is, Sherlock probably rather enjoys the fantasy of Irene, and the occasional suggestive text message. Whereas John didn't seem to enjoy much of his relationship with Mary, at all. Who would really want a marriage like that? Sherlock seems to accept Irene as she is and find a way that works to have her in his life (which is just to a very small extent). I don't think John ever really accepted his wife as she really was.

I agree. And I also get the impression that both Sherlock and Irene are quite happy with their standing flirtation and maybe an occasional spicy rendezvous somewhere, who knows.

 

Sherlock's emotional anchor is John, anyway. And John is also the person who most makes him want to live up to an ideal version of himself. But of course John doesn't understand that... He never has and never will, I think.

 

Yes, to me too, Sherlock so often is doing so much to be a better man in John's eyes. Why does John think anyone needs a romantic partner to do that? For me, the best John is the one in TSOT who saves the soldier by focusing on the person at the heart of the case. yet so often in his personal life, he seems to miss the most important things about the people closest to him.

Posted

 

Come to think of it, the whole episode was pretty much about Sherlock knowing John extremely well. Mary totally underestimated him there, he would have probably come up with just the same plan on his own as she suggested in her posthumous message. 

 

I'm not sure about that. Remember initially Sherlock didn't even try to carry out Mary's plan. He was sitting in his apartment, drowning himself in drugs for weeks until Euros (as Faith) visited him. 

 

Also the plan relied on knowing that John would never refuse to give help to someone. I don't think Sherlock understands John's emotional identity enough to figure out that John would do that.

 

 

I wish they had addressed the fact that John never seemed happy in that life a bit more fully, the text messages make it clear he isn't happy, but why exactly? He has everything he wanted, a famlly, a steady job, a frisson of danger from having a dangerous wife. Maybe it's, as you said, that he could never fully accept her once he knew the truth.

 

 

I thought John wasn't happy because Sherlock and Mary were superhuman and that made him feel left out and inadequate. Sherlock jokes about this in The Six Thatchers but I think that joke may have hit John harder than Sherlock thought it would. Also the reason why Mary runs away from him is because he isn't superhuman and she doesn't trust him to be able to keep himself safe when Ajay returned. John felt overwhelmed so he developed interest in a down-to-earth girl on the bus.

 

 

They needed to tell us more about John. I know the show is about Sherlock, but what they don't seem to get is that when they leave out important aspects of the other characters, people can't understand what is going on between that character and Sherlock, and that hurts our understanding of the main character. I too, do not understand why John couldn't be happy with the mix of normality and danger he found with Mary. But in season three as well, I found John was often finding reasons to feel affronted by the people in his life. In season 4, are we supposed to believe John was married to Mary, with a new child, but unhappy enough to make acerbic comments about not liking her anymore, and texting other women, and Mary was either oblivious or choosing not to comment? What were either of them getting out of this situation?

 

I hate to say it, but I never saw anything in his relationship with Mary to say that they should marry or that they were the loves of each others lives. It just wasn't there for me, in the writing. Part of the problem might be we fell into an established relationship, due to the timing. Of course MF and AA have a natural chemistry, but to me the characters just seem quite familiar, like friends. I don't see any heat or passion between them. I actually don't know that the writers are good at that sort of thing- I think the main problem might be a lot of John's story was about his love life, and they prefer to avoid writing all that stuff, and possibly even can't do it. They're delighted to write him punching someone when everything about it goes to hell, though.

 

 

What do you usually look for in writing to determine whether two characters are truly in love?

Posted

Yes, to me too, Sherlock so often is doing so much to be a better man in John's eyes. Why does John think anyone needs a romantic partner to do that? For me, the best John is the one in TSOT who saves the soldier by focusing on the person at the heart of the case. yet so often in his personal life, he seems to miss the most important things about the people closest to him.

I wonder if it's because John is supposed to be someone who misses the obvious. That's part of his role in the show; to make Sherlock look more brilliant by not being able to notice things by himself. Not because he's stupid, but because he doesn't really bother, unless he's forced to. More immediately practical things are more important to him, perhaps, like being able to save a life; so he misses the things he doesn't consider as important?

  • Like 1
Posted

 

What do you usually look for in writing to determine whether two characters are truly in love?

 

 

I guess I would look for something in the dialogue between those characters that suggests they see something in each other that is unique, that they make each other very happy, and also the sense that they have a really strong and lasting attraction? It isn't necessarily all in words, but in actions too.  In TV terms, I suppose you would usually see people go to extraordinary lengths for each other. 

 

Especially once John knew about Mary's past, what disappointed me was him forgiving her (which was the first time I was impressed by the fact that he loved her more than I had thought previously) and saying he didn't want to know, and then shortly after treating her like he resented her (in TST). 

 

Having said that, of course I accept that they did love each other because the show says so, it is just to me sometimes the relationship was a bit bland, which then made it (for me only, I'm sure most would disagree) a bit less tragic when it was over. Even though I liked Mary in the show a lot, though actually I found her scenes with Sherlock sometimes more fun than the ones she had with John.

 

 

Yes, to me too, Sherlock so often is doing so much to be a better man in John's eyes. Why does John think anyone needs a romantic partner to do that? For me, the best John is the one in TSOT who saves the soldier by focusing on the person at the heart of the case. yet so often in his personal life, he seems to miss the most important things about the people closest to him.

I wonder if it's because John is supposed to be someone who misses the obvious. That's part of his role in the show; to make Sherlock look more brilliant by not being able to notice things by himself. Not because he's stupid, but because he doesn't really bother, unless he's forced to. More immediately practical things are more important to him, perhaps, like being able to save a life; so he misses the things he doesn't consider as important?

 

 

Yes, this must be part of it, he is there for contrast. I think we lost something this season in that as Sherlock became more emotionally aware sometimes John seemed even less so. Sometimes I think John deliberately won't face emotional conflict too. We also saw a bit of that in HLV when John seemed to be burying his head in the sand about how bad his marriage was, until Sherlock stepped in to try and help. And again in TLD when he can't face his guilt over the texting and takes out so much of his anger at himself on Sherlock. But I do hope they aren't totally compromising John's character just to make Sherlock look more emotionally evolved.

Posted

 

 

 

What do you usually look for in writing to determine whether two characters are truly in love?

 

I guess I would look for something in the dialogue between those characters that suggests they see something in each other that is unique, that they make each other very happy, and also the sense that they have a really strong and lasting attraction? It isn't necessarily all in words, but in actions too. In TV terms, I suppose you would usually see people go to extraordinary lengths for each other.

Isn't part of what you're describing what you sense as chemistry between the actors? That's the most subjective part of entertainment. Writers can write couples or relationships but if the actors don't have that it part between them it may never come across onscreen. I mean many a romantic comedy/dramatic movie has flopped based on whether actor chemistry exists.

Posted

Sherlock's emotional anchor is John, anyway. And John is also the person who most makes him want to live up to an ideal version of himself. But of course John doesn't understand that... He never has and never will, I think.

 

Shouldn't John understand that from Sherlock's best man speech?
Posted

Hearing someone say nice things about you, and believing inside yourself that those words are true ... those are two entirely different things. I think that's a point they've been making in both this episode and the previous one ... both Mary and Sherlock look up to John, but John himself doesn't think he's all that great. Which may mean that he is too hard on himself, or it may mean he knows himself better than those two do. Or both at once, actually. Call it low self-esteem, or just humility, but I think a lot of people tend to magnify their own worst faults and overlook their own best features. It's a little sad if John turns out to be one of those, but it's also very human.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 104 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.