Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I guess what I believe is that it's supposed to be the answer, just poorly explained. Or deliberately incomplete.

Posted

I kind of go with Anderson's response, "if it was true, why would you tell me?" (Or whatever he said to that effect.)

Posted

I kind of go with Anderson's response, "if it was true, why would you tell me?" (Or whatever he said to that effect.)

 

Soooo, no then?  :) 

Posted

More or less, doesn't mean that there wasn't bits of truth in there just not the whole of it. Which I'm perfectly ok with.

Posted

More or less, doesn't mean that there wasn't bits of truth in there just not the whole of it. Which I'm perfectly ok with.

 

A lie is most convincingly hidden between two truths. :)

  • Like 2
Posted

More or less, doesn't mean that there wasn't bits of truth in there just not the whole of it. Which I'm perfectly ok with.

The same here. I think the technical part of how he did it was more or less true but there are a few things that I think Sherlock made up or changed a bit. But it's fine. I don't really need the real explanation :)

Posted

The same here. I think the technical part of how he did it was more or less true but there are a few things that I think Sherlock made up or changed a bit. But it's fine. I don't really need the real explanation :)

Well, I guess I don't need it either ... but I sure as heck WANT it! :D
Posted

I think the technical part of how he did it was more or less true but there are a few things that I think Sherlock made up or changed a bit. But it's fine. I don't really need the real explanation :)

I think you're right. I like my own version better anyhow, and I suspect I'm not the only one like that.  (Which may be exactly why Moftiss decided to leave things a bit hazy. I just wish they'd made that decision a bit sooner, such as before they included certain problematic details in "Reichenbach" and promised to explain everything -- and then didn't.)

 

Posted

I think you're right. I like my own version better anyhow, and I suspect I'm not the only one like that.  (Which may be exactly why Moftiss decided to leave things a bit hazy. I just wish they'd made that decision a bit sooner, such as before they included certain problematic details in "Reichenbach" and promised to explain everything -- and then didn't.)

 

While I might not like the "official" explanation itself, I very much admire the way it was presented, and how they left us a way out if we didn't want to believe it. I suppose this was the main reason why they showed Sherlock telling everything to Anderson instead of John - in John's case, we'd be more pressed to take his words as gospel.

 

I wonder whether Sherlock ever told John. Probably not. I mean, when he first tried, John didn't want to hear about it, so why should he try again, and I doubt John ever brought the subject up after "The Empty Hearse". John seems to deal with unpleasant things by just closing his eyes to them. His wife is just Mary Watson, thank you very much, and Sherlock Holmes is just an annoying dick who is now back in London. He probably doesn't want to be reminded in detail of how his friend played dead and betrayed him and he'd probably just get angry all over again.

 

  • Like 2
  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

But it's kind of sad, actually. Sherlock dismantled Moriarty's network and got beat up and hunted down, all while being separated from his best friend (who is one of the very few things in the world that can keep him sane), and when he finally comes home to tell John the 13 different ways he could've faked his death he thinks John'll be wowed and amazed like usual, but once he starts to lay out his deductions John shuts him down by saying "I DON'T CARE."

  • Like 1
Posted

I wonder whether Sherlock ever told John. Probably not. I mean, when he first tried, John didn't want to hear about it, so why should he try again, and I doubt John ever brought the subject up after "The Empty Hearse". John seems to deal with unpleasant things by just closing his eyes to them. His wife is just Mary Watson, thank you very much, and Sherlock Holmes is just an annoying dick who is now back in London. He probably doesn't want to be reminded in detail of how his friend played dead and betrayed him and he'd probably just get angry all over again.

 

But it's kind of sad, actually. Sherlock dismantled Moriarty's network and got beat up and hunted down, all while being separated from his best friend (who is one of the very few things in the world that can keep him sane), and when he finally comes home to tell John the 13 different ways he could've faked his death he thinks John'll be wowed and amazed like usual, but once he starts to lay out his deductions John shuts him down by saying "I DON'T CARE."

I wonder whether there will be more fallout from those differing points of view in S4? Somehow, with the episodes being written by men, I kinda doubt it. But they may surprise me in a nice way.

 

Posted

Yeah, we need to hear John say "wow, you're amazing" to Sherlock again, don't we?

  • Like 2
Posted

John may have been kicked in the gut just once too often to bounce back very soon, and I'm not sure what either Sherlock or Mary could do at this point to regain his full trust -- though cuddling his baby daughter may give him a fresh perspective.

 

Posted

But is the baby really his?  :rolleyes:

 

Um - whose else would it be?

 

Seriously, I very very much doubt there is another man in Mary's life (at least not in that way), and if there was, and the child would turn out to be his instead of John's, it would take one hell of a writer to not make me turn away in disgust. We've had quite enough soap opera style drama on the series lately, I really would not need that extra touch!

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Yeah, I agree. Season 3 was already messed-up enough.

 

(You would not believe how loopy the rest of the Sherlock fandom gets during hiatuses. The thing about the baby not being John's is just one speculation.)

Posted

 

I think you're right. I like my own version better anyhow, and I suspect I'm not the only one like that.  (Which may be exactly why Moftiss decided to leave things a bit hazy. I just wish they'd made that decision a bit sooner, such as before they included certain problematic details in "Reichenbach" and promised to explain everything -- and then didn't.)

 

While I might not like the "official" explanation itself, I very much admire the way it was presented, and how they left us a way out if we didn't want to believe it. I suppose this was the main reason why they showed Sherlock telling everything to Anderson instead of John - in John's case, we'd be more pressed to take his words as gospel.

 

I wonder whether Sherlock ever told John. Probably not. I mean, when he first tried, John didn't want to hear about it, so why should he try again, and I doubt John ever brought the subject up after "The Empty Hearse". John seems to deal with unpleasant things by just closing his eyes to them. His wife is just Mary Watson, thank you very much, and Sherlock Holmes is just an annoying dick who is now back in London. He probably doesn't want to be reminded in detail of how his friend played dead and betrayed him and he'd probably just get angry all over again.

 

But it's kind of sad, actually. Sherlock dismantled Moriarty's network and got beat up and hunted down, all while being separated from his best friend (who is one of the very few things in the world that can keep him sane), and when he finally comes home to tell John the 13 different ways he could've faked his death he thinks John'll be wowed and amazed like usual, but once he starts to lay out his deductions John shuts him down by saying "I DON'T CARE."

 

This basically addresses my main issue with the aftermath of Reichenbach and Sherlock's return. Never mind that I don't get the entire/true explanation of the 'how'. I would have liked Sherlock to explain more of 'why' and 'what' to John. I wish John had asked. Why did Sherlock need to put John through that kind of grief? Why did he think it necessary? What was he up to while away? It's amazing, really - the two of them never really talk about what they've been through, and yet they seem to be alright as a team again by the end of The Empty Hearse.

 

Words certainly isn't their way of dealing with their issues.

  • Like 2
Posted

But is the baby really his?  :rolleyes:

 

Um - whose else would it be?

 

Seriously, I very very much doubt there is another man in Mary's life (at least not in that way), and if there was, and the child would turn out to be his instead of John's, it would take one hell of a writer to not make me turn away in disgust. We've had quite enough soap opera style drama on the series lately, I really would not need that extra touch!

 

I agree that I'll be very disappointed if it turns out Mary has another fella on the side.  She and John had already been dating for six months as of "Empty Hearse," so in order for her to be barely pregnant several months after that, in "Sign of Three" -- well, either she cheated on John or she was raped.  If the latter, it would seem very odd that she would not tell John -- unless the man threatened to expose her if she told John.  Oh dear, I don't like where this is going....

Posted

Never mind that I don't get the entire/true explanation of the 'how'. I would have liked Sherlock to explain more of 'why' and 'what' to John. I wish John had asked. Why did Sherlock need to put John through that kind of grief? Why did he think it necessary? What was he up to while away? It's amazing, really - the two of them never really talk about what they've been through, and yet they seem to be alright as a team again by the end of The Empty Hearse.

I think it's partly a guy thing (as Henry Knight said, "Mates are mates"). But John did ask Sherlock "Why?" (in "Empty Hearse") and got a less-than-satisfactory answer. At which point he seems to have simply given up trying to make sense of things. I really wish he'd asked Mary "Why?"

 

  • Like 1
Posted

 

Never mind that I don't get the entire/true explanation of the 'how'. I would have liked Sherlock to explain more of 'why' and 'what' to John. I wish John had asked. Why did Sherlock need to put John through that kind of grief? Why did he think it necessary? What was he up to while away? It's amazing, really - the two of them never really talk about what they've been through, and yet they seem to be alright as a team again by the end of The Empty Hearse.

I think it's partly a guy thing (as Henry Knight said, "Mates are mates"). But John did ask Sherlock "Why?" (in "Empty Hearse") and got a less-than-satisfactory answer. At which point he seems to have simply given up trying to make sense of things. I really wish he'd asked Mary "Why?"

 

 

Yes, definitely a guy thing, I'm sure.

 

"You know my methods, John. I'm known to be indestructible." As you say, not a satisfying answer, but John didn't press the subject further. Was he scared of reopening the wounds, thinking that Sherlock might not have had a decent reason, anyway, for keeping him in the dark? Or did he expect that Sherlock had his reasons, as usual, but they just didn't matter to John, because it still wouldn't change what had happened?

 

In Sherlock's words: "I don't like not knowing." :) Although, sometimes the answer is worse than the not knowing.

 

Sure, John should have asked Mary that question. Her reasons are even more obscure to us all. At least with Sherlock we know that he needed to stop Moriarty and his network.

  • Like 2
Posted

"You know my methods, John. I'm known to be indestructible." As you say, not a satisfying answer, but John didn't press the subject further. Was he scared of reopening the wounds, thinking that Sherlock might not have had a decent reason, anyway, for keeping him in the dark? Or did he expect that Sherlock had his reasons, as usual, but they just didn't matter to John, because it still wouldn't change what had happened?

OK, two non-satisfying answers.  What I actually had in mind was his answer to John's "Why?" -- namely that he didn't trust John to keep the secret, and I suspect he didn't press further at that point for fear of getting an even more infuriating answer.  (Which in fact he did, just a few moments later, without even asking.)  By the time Sherlock gave him the run-around, though, I think he just figured that was as good an answer as he was likely to get, plus he was feeling sort of like "Good ol' Sherlock, he hasn't changed a bit."

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Oh, you mean when Sherlock replied, "That's a little more difficult to explain" and "that was mostly Mycroft's idea"? By the way, I never did understand what Sherlock is referring to as Mycroft's idea... What do y'all think??

 

So, yes, that was very unsatisfying as well.

Posted

Oh, you mean when Sherlock replied, "That's a little more difficult to explain" and "that was mostly Mycroft's idea"? By the way, I never did understand what Sherlock is referring to as Mycroft's idea... What do y'all think??

 

I suspect using John as a witness was mostly Mycroft's idea, or it was Sherlock's idea, but Sherlock is now blaming his big brother for it, because he's realized that, in John's eyes at least, it was "a bit not good". Just like he goes "it was Mycroft!", when Mummy catches them smoking.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

 

Oh, you mean when Sherlock replied, "That's a little more difficult to explain" and "that was mostly Mycroft's idea"? By the way, I never did understand what Sherlock is referring to as Mycroft's idea... What do y'all think??

 

I suspect using John as a witness was mostly Mycroft's idea, or it was Sherlock's idea, but Sherlock is now blaming his big brother for it, because he's realized that, in John's eyes at least, it was "a bit not good". Just like he goes "it was Mycroft!", when Mummy catches them smoking.

 

 

That does make sense, except I thought from the beginning of The Empty Hearse that Mycroft seemed against the idea of keeping John in the dark. He seemed to suspect that the reunion might not go as smoothly as Sherlock planned.

 

Or it could be that Mycroft suspected trouble, but didn't care much whether or not Sherlock and John managed to bridge the gap between them. After all, he speaks the word "friends" in the same mocking tone that Sherlock used in HoB.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 144 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.