Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Lying Detective"?  

70 members have voted

  1. 1. Add your vote here:

    • 10/10 Excellent.
    • 9/10 Not quite the best, but not far off.
    • 8/10 Certainly worth watching again.
    • 7/10 Slightly above the norm.
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly sub-par.
    • 4/10 Decidedly below average.
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
      0
    • 1/10 Awful.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

:D Excellent point! She's alive Sherlock, what more do you want?

  • Like 1
Posted

He clearly isn't wired like everyone else

The whole point of S4 was that it isn't a question of wiring (determinism), but of choice (free will). Sherlock wasn't born without the desire to love (as his having a best friend as a child proves). He chooses not to love - because he had his heart tragically broken as a child. He chooses ego over empathy - bad over good. And his whole journey, according to the writers, is to choose to be good - choose empathy, choose love, instead. He is not fated to go to Sumatra (not fated to feed his Ego). He can choose to go to Sumarra instead (choose to love others).

 

I've always appreciated that Sherlock is Sherlock without needing to have a romantic interest

His rejection of romantic interests is just an example of his rejection of love in general.

 

for the implication Sherlock would be 'better' if was involved with someone, that he wasn't 'whole' being alone

That isn't merely an "implication" by the writers. That was the point of the entire episode. "Save John Watson". From what? From the "hell" of "being alone" (like Eurus - like Sherlock before John).

 

That is the writers' philosophy.

 

Would it have been "better" to leave John in his hell - just leave him "alone"? Should Sherlock not have "saved" him - not done anything he did in that episode for John? Are either of them "whole" without the other - without the love of the other?

 

I don't appreciate the pressure or the implication that I am not "enough" outside of a romantic relationship

That isn't the "implication". The implication is that one should not simply and arbitrarily reject relationships, especially romantic ones, out of hand. One should not treat them with disdain or contempt. One should not avoid them. That is what the writers are saying. Intentionally isolating one's self, as John did - as Sherlock had done all his life - just to avoid the pain of relationships, is cutting one's nose off to spite one's face. It is putting one's self in "hell".

 

Moftiss' whole point is that relationships are what make people 'human' - as opposed to treating people as things to feed one's ego.

 

The point is - people exist. You can't avoid them. The only question is: how are you going to treat them? Merely as things for your consumption - or as fellow travelers to be treated with compassion? Are you going to be a Smith, a Moriarty? Or are you going to be a Watson, a Sherlock (not as he was, but as he learns to be in the end)?

 

did anyone else think that, for a best friend, John's standards for Sherlock are appallingly low? :P "She likes you, and she's alive! So what if she's a lunatic and a criminal and insanely dangerous? She's there and she's currently breathing oxygen! GO GET HER!!"

John's statement served two purposes.

 

One: to say there is no reason not to love her - just as John loved an assassin. The whole point is: "Who you are doesn't matter". And that means 'Who they are doesn't matter' as well (as it didn't matter to John about Mary). The fact is Sherlock is loved and there is no reason to reject that love.

 

Two: to make the connection to Eurus and thus declare there is no reason not to love her either. The description is specifically limited so as to describe both women and thus set up the idea that, just as one should love Irene, so too one should love Eurus. There is no reason to treat either of them as Sherlock treats Molly. There is no reason for love to be spurned - to be completely unrequited.

  • Like 3
Posted

THIS^^^^^

 

Well said, BLS_Pro!   :applause:  :applause:  :applause:  :applause:

Posted

Ok, this is something I feel very passionately about beyond the scope of a TV show and as such I'm not going to get into a debate of why my opinion may or may not be agreed with. 

 

I will briefly say:

I never said Sherlock couldn't love, and romantic love is rather different to familial love. Rejection of one does not have to be linked to his rejection of the other.

John may feel he needs to be saved from being alone, but that does not mean that Sherlock feels the same way. Again the love and friendship he feels towards John is rather different than what is being implied by John's suggestion of him being with Irene. 

He might not be avoiding relationships to save himself pain. He might simply not be interested, and he is certainly not putting himself in hell just by doing so. 

 

There is a very different meaning between the two types of love being described interchangeably here. No, I'm not going to get into a debate on the meaning or purpose of love, because I do not feel I need to defend my opinions on it. To me, and people like me, the idea that Sherlock should be in a relationship to be whole is highly offensive. I'm not going to get into an argument about it, but I am also not going to agree that my point and my own experiences are invalid. 

  • Like 3
Posted

That is what the writers are saying.  Their whole point is that relationships are what make people human -

 

Exactly.  That's where I took issue with it.

 

 

Sherlock has relationships.  They're just not romantic/sexual ones.  They may never be.  And that should be, actually, fine.

 

Your points are well taken, I know what you are saying in context and I know what the writers were saying.  I just understand it from a different perspective, which I'd rather not argue about, so I'll be off.  =]

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted
Rejection of one does not have to be linked to his rejection of the other.

Sherlock himself links them.

 

 

I am also not going to agree that my point and my own experiences are invalid.

It was never stated 'your experiences' are "invalid".  The only thing stated was the philosophy of the writers.  Please do not conflate the two. 

 

Oh, and you are quite free to disagree with their philosophy (I certainly do).  In other words, you are free to be 'offended' if you so choose - ie you are free to choose your philosophy, just as the writers are free to choose theirs.  No one here claimed otherwise (well, at least not me). :)

Posted

 

Rejection of one does not have to be linked to his rejection of the other.

Sherlock himself links them.

 

 

 

I think that's an important point.  My interpretation of the greenhouse scene in TAB, which was, of course, Sherlock talking to himself about his attraction to Irene and his desire to notice women physically (maybe stopping just short of that being sexually or romantically) indicates that he feels that something is missing that might be made more whole by experiencing that side of human existence.  So I think that's what the writers were doing with the character.

 

And since I think I somehow got in the middle of a debate, let me add that I don't think that everyone needs a sexual or romantic love in order to be a whole person.  I think that an essential part of being human (and not being a psychopath) is experiencing some form of love, but that can be expressed in a number of different kinds of relationships.  I think it can even be expressed through love for non-humans or for aspects of one's environment.  

  • Like 1
Posted

No ongoing debate, I'm bowing out. I have so many things I could rant about to do with that scene and some of the interpretations of it that I'm not getting into it. I don't like arguments or debates at the best of times, especially not when there are 'real world' feelings involved. :(

  • Like 2
Posted

What I found most surprising about John's advice was that given Sherlock's obvious ongoing problem with drugs, he would advise him to pursue any kind of relationship. I would have thought the best thing to advise Sherlock to do in TLD would have been to go to rehab, immediately.

  • Like 1
Posted

What I found most surprising about John's advice was that given Sherlock's obvious ongoing problem with drugs, he would advise him to pursue any kind of relationship. I would have thought the best thing to advise Sherlock to do in TLD would have been to go to rehab, immediately.

 

Given that Sherlock's problems - including his boredom and need to get 'high' to alleviate it - are due to his lack of empathy (ie due to his isolating himself from human interactions -due to him making himself a sociopath), John's advice was that of 'rehab' - of 'restoring him to good health'.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

 

What I found most surprising about John's advice was that given Sherlock's obvious ongoing problem with drugs, he would advise him to pursue any kind of relationship. I would have thought the best thing to advise Sherlock to do in TLD would have been to go to rehab, immediately.

 

Given that Sherlock's problems - including his boredom and need to get 'high' to alleviate it - are due to his lack of empathy (ie due to his isolating himself from human interactions -due to him making himself a sociopath), John's advice was that of 'rehab' - of 'restoring him to good health'.

 

 

 

But a romantic relationship seems a very poor sort of 'rehab' (if I take your point correctly, is that what you mean?)

 

Not only because his problems aren't exclusively a lack or empathy. Another one is the fact that he's buried all of this old trauma, and is scarred, and repressed emotionally, both of which have resulted in some truly self destructive types of behaviour.

 

He also takes drugs quite often for reasons he says are to do with a case, but that seems a very convenient excuse for his extreme and health-threatening fondness for the aforementioned drugs.

 

There's a reason most addiction programs advise people to swear off entering romantic relationships before getting their addiction dealt with- you don't want to replace one emotional crutch with another. Much better to work out those internal issues yourself (as we see Sherlock doing with the therapist, maybe?) than to bring somebody else into the fray. Not that I think friendships and family relationships wouldn't be invaluable, but not a romantic one, especially for someone who has possibly never had one before. I'd imagine one reason is that if it doesn't work out, that person is hugely at risk to relapse.

  • Like 2
Posted

What I found most surprising about John's advice was that given Sherlock's obvious ongoing problem with drugs, he would advise him to pursue any kind of relationship. I would have thought the best thing to advise Sherlock to do in TLD would have been to go to rehab, immediately.

I didn't like that whole part of the dialogue either but to me the spirit of the whole speech was "life is short, you never know when you'll bite it so live life to the fullest". I hated that Irene was pushed so much in that context because why would you push Irene on your worst enemy but that is really the only woman that John has seen Sherlock show an interest of any kind in so maybe that's why he used her in his speech and of course Moffat did the Irene text thing again. He basically acknowledged that Irene isn't a good idea so why the dialogue wasn't left more generic I wish I knew. I think I would have appreciated the dialogue more if it were.

  • Like 3
Posted

I suspect it's partly because in canon, Irene is the only woman Holmes seemed to take any kind of interest in. But they've blown canon so wide open now, I can't see that it makes any difference any more. They can go anywhere with him now, imo.

  • Like 2
Posted

 

What I found most surprising about John's advice was that given Sherlock's obvious ongoing problem with drugs, he would advise him to pursue any kind of relationship. I would have thought the best thing to advise Sherlock to do in TLD would have been to go to rehab, immediately.

I didn't like that whole part of the dialogue either but to me the spirit of the whole speech was "life is short, you never know when you'll bite it so live life to the fullest". I hated that Irene was pushed so much in that context because why would you push Irene on your worst enemy but that is really the only woman that John has seen Sherlock show an interest of any kind in so maybe that's why he used her in his speech and of course Moffat did the Irene text thing again. He basically acknowledged that Irene isn't a good idea so why the dialogue wasn't left more generic I wish I knew. I think I would have appreciated the dialogue more if it were.

 

 

 

Yes, and I do understand how, having lost maybe the love of his life, John thinks Sherlock is crazy not to take his own chance at that. But I also think that he projects far too much on to Sherlock. The whole Irene thing is really not like him and Mary at all, in my opinion

 

 

I suspect it's partly because in canon, Irene is the only woman Holmes seemed to take any kind of interest in. But they've blown canon so wide open now, I can't see that it makes any difference any more. They can go anywhere with him now, imo.

 
I go back and forth on this. In some ways they totally broke free from canon, and I didn't mind that at all. But, what they did with Mary, suggests that they felt the need to be faithful to it?  Then again, why did they let Rosamund live, that being the case? Because even Rosamund alone changes a lot about John, and her interaction with John and Sherlock has the potential to change them both as people.
 
 Is the reason for Mary's death because Mary as a character became too big for the show to handle? Or did they feel if they adhered to some parts they could take liberties with others more freely?
 
I wonder if part of the fun for Moftiss is knowing that they have canon as a start point and that is what is 'expected', and that then they can play a game with the audience regarding whether or not the expected things will happen?
  • Like 2
Posted

 

But a romantic relationship seems a very poor sort of 'rehab' (if I take your point correctly, is that what you mean?)

Love in general, but romantic seems to have been John's context.

 

Not only because his problems aren't exclusively a lack or empathy. Another one is the fact that he's buried all of this old trauma, and is scarred, and repressed emotionally, both of which have resulted in some truly self destructive types of behaviour.

John neither knows that nor has reason to suspect it.

 

 

He also takes drugs quite often for reasons he says are to do with a case, but that seems a very convenient excuse for his extreme and health-threatening fondness for the aforementioned drugs.

I don't believe we've ever seen him take drugs for any other reason.  However, the reason he supposedly takes drugs is because he gets bored.  He doesn't have anything to entertain his ego.  When he doesn't have people to consume (ie a case), he consumes drugs.  They are the same to him - things. 

 

John's point is to stop treating them as things - as 'distractions'.  Stop being Smith.  Stop being Moriarty.  Love them.  That is what John is telling him to do.  That is what John is saying would 'save' Sherlock.  That is what would rehabilitate him - and, in fact, ultimately does.  So the good Doctor's prescription is sound.

 

The whole Irene thing is really not like him and Mary

That's because its meant to be more like Sherlock and Eurus.

 

Is the reason for Mary's death because Mary as a character became too big for the show to handle?

The reason for Mary's death is so Sherlock could realize he is a petty. ego driven "monster" just like Norbury.

The reason for Mary's death is so Sherlock could see and feel the death and destruction caused by his ego.

The reason for Mary's death is so Sherlock could abandon his ego - pursue cases not for his ego (not to be the cleverest person in the room), but out of empathy (to help others) - as he does in John's case.

The reason for Mary's death is so Sherlock can prove, once and for all, he loves John - that he will sacrifice himself if necessary to do so - that he will become a 'soldier', like John.

The reason for Mary's death is so Sherlock could do for John what John had done for Sherlock - save him.

 

Mary had to die for this season to proceed to its final destination: Sherlock becoming a "good man".

  • Like 1
Posted

 

 

Not only because his problems aren't exclusively a lack or empathy. Another one is the fact that he's buried all of this old trauma, and is scarred, and repressed emotionally, both of which have resulted in some truly self destructive types of behaviour.

John neither knows that nor has reason to suspect it. 

 

 

John does know that Sherlock is emotionally repressed. True, he doesn't know the cause, but he knows Sherlock very well, and he often notes the ways in which Sherlock is having difficulty reading an emotional context and tries to help, and also challenges him when he sees Sherlock behaving in an unfeeling way.

 

He also takes drugs quite often for reasons he says are to do with a case, but that seems a very convenient excuse for his extreme and health-threatening fondness for the aforementioned drugs.

I don't believe we've ever seen him take drugs for any other reason.  However, the reason he supposedly takes drugs is because he gets bored.  He doesn't have anything to entertain his ego.  When he doesn't have people to consume (ie a case), he consumes drugs.  They are the same thing to him - things. 

 

John's point is to stop treating them as things - as 'distractions'.  Value people.  That is what John is telling him to do.  That is what would (and ultimately does) rehabilitate Sherlock.  So the good Doctor's prescription is sound.

 

But that simplifies and also changes the true nature of what John is suggesting- which is a romantic relationship. Sherlock has already shown that he can and does value people, love people as friends. It's something he's been working on, and John's been helping him with, since the very beginning. When he apologies to Molly, when he defends Mrs. hudson, there are so many ways... that is not a new idea to him or something he needs a prescription for. It doesn't have to be romantic. He became a murderer to protect John and Mary. And he expressed his love for them on their wedding. I don't think of TFP as some sort of a magic event that finally gave the tin man a heart. In a lot of ways it was just a natural progression in the character development that was already happening.

 

In the course of their exchange, it is actually Sherlock who tells John, that he suspects they may just be human after all- he's showing he already has the qualities that you're suggesting John is prescribing to him to acquire.

  • Like 3
Posted

 

 

Not only because his problems aren't exclusively a lack or empathy. Another one is the fact that he's buried all of this old trauma, and is scarred, and repressed emotionally, both of which have resulted in some truly self destructive types of behaviour.

John neither knows that nor has reason to suspect it.

 

John does know that Sherlock is emotionally repressed. True, he doesn't know the cause

Actually John thinks he does know the cause - given that Sherlock himself continually expounds on why he is a sociopath (and himself thinks he 'made himself').

 

Sherlock has already shown that he can and does value people, love people as friends. It's something he's been working on, and John's been helping him with, since the very beginning. When he apologies to Molly, when he defends Mrs. hudson, there are so many ways... that is not a new idea to him or something he needs a prescription for.

It is a new idea that Sherlock should not be treating people as things for his consumption.  Even his friendships up to this point have been about his ego (I would agree with you about CAM, except the writers essentially reset Sherlock back to his old form immediately afterwards with his complete disregard for those loved ones in favor of cases - ie ego over love.  It is only in the end of TFP that Sherlock is shown to actually be partaking in and enjoying those relationships, rather than being forced to be a part of them begrudgingly).  It is only in TLD - in what he does for John - that Sherlock demonstrates his actions are no longer about his ego and that Sherlock knows it - that he has learned that lesson.  He is not like Eurus anymore, wanting love for her own ends.

 

TFP didn't give the 'Sherlock Tin Man' his heart.  T6T showed Sherlock that, while he might indeed have a heart, it  wasn't in the right place.  It showed Sherlock he was still a "monster".  TLD shows Sherlock putting his heart right.  And, so at the end of TLD, John is telling Sherlock:  now that your heart is in the right place, you should stop repressing your emotions.  John is telling him that such repression is but a remnant of the old Sherlock.  He's telling him a new Sherlock has been born - and he wishes that new Sherlock a "Happy Birthday".

 

TFP is simply where that remnant is finally swept away, because the trauma which created it is finally identified.

Posted

 

It is a new idea that he should not be treating people as things for his consumption.  Even his friendships up to this point have been about his ego (I would agree with you about CAM, except the writers essentially reset Sherlock back to his old form right afterwards with his disregard for those loved ones in favor of cases.  It is only in the end of TFP that Sherlock is shown to actually be partaking in and enjoying those relationships, rather than being forced to be a part of them begrudgingly).  It is only in this episode, TLD - in what he does for John - that Sherlock has demonstrated that it is no longer about his ego any more and that he knows it - that he has learned that lesson.  He is not like Eurus, wanting love for her own ends.

 

John has spoken to Sherlock about his treatment of people before though. In TGG, when he tells him he's not being kind to Molly. There is another episode, I'm fairly sure where there is a similar exchange about something he says to Mrs. Hudson. Molly herself confronts him in Scandal, after his deductions, and he apologises, and he means it too. 

 

I just don't think it is fair to him to say he just consumes people. He had a very nice friendship with Mary. He helped plan the wedding, gave that beautiful best man speech. He even forgave Mary for shooting him, a lot quicker than I think most of us average-emotional context people would have! Something else I thought was sweet was how he took John and Mary to visit his parents for Christmas, as if he knew their relationship was troubled and it might help to see a couple who had endured, as his parents had. I know he wasn't perfect before, but I just don't agree that everything he has done with his friends has only been about his ego.

 

Though... I will say that I thought a lot of the Irene Adler storyline was ego driven in a way I didn't like. I didn't like how he was supposed to have somehow turned her straight? Or outsmarted her by using her feelings for him, and thus 'beaten' her intellectually. I didn't like what that said about male/ female interactions in general, as if being emotional is some kind of weakness than can be used to get the upper hand over a woman.  And, he treated Janine very badly too. So your points have validity, but I just think they are too all-encompassing.

 

TFP didn't give the Sherlock Tin Man his heart.  T6T showed Sherlock his heart wasn't quite in the right place.  It showed Sherlock he was still a "monster".  TLD shows Sherlock putting his heart in the right place.  And, so at the end of TLD, John is telling Sherlock:  now that his heart is in the right place, Sherlock should stop repressing his emotions.  John is telling him that such repression is but remnants of the old Sherlock.  He is telling him a new Sherlock has been born - "Happy Birthday"

 

TFP is simply where that remnant is swept away, because the trauma which created it is finally identified.

 

 

 
But how is he a monster? Because he behaved arrogantly in TST and made a mistake? Any ordinary human can do that, or be led by their ego too. Or even be in denial about how they feel, or not want to admit to their feelings, or act on them. 
 
I do agree that John wants Sherlock to be less repressed. John is (almost) always rooting for him, and it is a lovely part of their friendship.
  • Like 2
Posted
John has spoken to Sherlock about his treatment of people before though

Being told something and actually understanding it are two different things.

 

 

I just don't think it is fair to him to say he just consumes people.

I didn't say "just consumes".  Sherlock is not a psychopath ie devoid of empathy/love.  Sherlock is a sociopath ie has severely limited empathy/love.  His ego rules him - drives him.  But it is not the "only" thing in him.  The conflict of the series is the concretization of the conflict within Sherlock - the battle between his Ego and his Empathy.  The villains - the monsters - are physical manifestations of his demons - his Ego.

 

Sherlock is a "monster", as John Watson himself says - because Sherlock is a sociopath ie because Ego rules him.  He's simply "our monster".  Sherlock had not stopped being a sociopath.  His behavior at the end of T6T was not an aberration.  It was not a "mistake".  It was Sherlock doing what Sherlock does - feeding his ego - trying to prove himself the 'cleverest' person in the room.

 

It was the devastating consequence of his ego-driven action - the death and destruction that feeding his ego caused - which finally made Sherlock understand what he had been doing - and thus finally act to correct it: to replace empathy for ego as that which drives him.

Posted

 

John has spoken to Sherlock about his treatment of people before though

Being told something and actually understanding it are two different things.

 

 

But then in the other example I gave, where he understands he has upset Molly and he apologises for it, he does understand how it was wrong for him to disregard her feelings. So he's both been told about it and understood it. And also, when he asks John is something is 'a bit not good' in Study in Pink, isn't that his code for understanding he's done something that's off, in terms of emotional understanding? And that's in episode one, that the idea is already there.

 

 

I just don't think it is fair to him to say he just consumes people.

I didn't say "just consumes".  Sherlock is not a psychopath ie devoid of empathy/love.  Sherlock is a sociopath ie has severely limited empathy/love.  His ego rules him - drives him.  But it is not the "only" thing in him.  The conflict of the series is the concretization of the conflict within Sherlock - the battle between his Ego and his Empathy.  The villains - the monsters - are physical manifestations of his demons - his Ego.

 

Sherlock is a "monster", as John Watson himself says - because Sherlock is a sociopath ie because Ego rules him.  He's simply "our monster".  Sherlock had not stopped being a sociopath.  His behavior at the end of T6T was not an aberration.  It was not a "mistake".  It was Sherlock doing what Sherlock does - feeding his ego - trying to prove himself the 'cleverest' person in the room.

 

It was the devastating consequence of his ego-driven action - the death and destruction his feeding his ego caused - which finally made Sherlock understand what he had been doing - and thus finally act to correct it: to replace empathy for ego as that which drives him.

 

 

Because you only mentioned consuming people, and expanded on that in terms of ego, it seemed you were suggesting that was the sole driving force of his relationships? Or did you mean that he treats people as objects for consumption and as friends? The ideas seem mutually exclusive to me, but interested to know your take?

 

I don't believe Sherlock was ever a sociopath. I think it was just easier for him to say that than to say he had trouble dealing with emotions. He was never devoid of sympathy, or other feelings. If he really, truly was a sociopath he would never have done what he did in TFP, or in HLV for that matter. He gave up his freedom to save his friends, what kind of a sociopath does that?

  • Like 3
Posted
I don't believe Sherlock was ever a sociopath

This appears to be the fundamental disagreement at the root of our discussion.  And I can only say the writers themselves state Sherlock is a sociopath.  He is a "bad man".  And his journey is that of becoming good, which they claim he has done by TFP.  In other words, by the end of TFP, Sherlock is no longer a sociopath.

 

 

He was never devoid of sympathy, or other feelings.

Please check out the distinction between psychopath and sociopath.  As I tried to identify, a psychopath is the individual who is devoid of empathy etc. not a sociopath. 

 

As already stated, Sherlock (as he himself - and the writers - state) is not a psychopath.  Sherlock is not "devoid of sympathy" etc.  He is a sociopath, and thus has empathy (as well as other emotions).  That empathy is just, as already noted, quite limited. 

Posted

 

I don't believe Sherlock was ever a sociopath

This appears to be the fundamental disagreement at the root of our discussion.  And I can only say the writers themselves state Sherlock is a sociopath.  He is a "bad man".  And his journey is that of becoming good, which they claim he has done by TFP.  In other words, by the end of TFP, Sherlock is no longer a sociopath.

 

 

He was never devoid of sympathy, or other feelings.

Please check out the distinction between psychopath and sociopath.  As I tried to identify, a psychopath is the individual who is devoid of empathy etc. not a sociopath. 

 

As already stated, Sherlock (as he himself - and the writers - state) is not a psychopath.  Sherlock is not "devoid of sympathy" etc.  He is a sociopath, and thus has empathy (as well as other emotions).  That empathy is just, as already noted, quite limited. 

 

 

Here's an article that sums of a lot of my feelings on why the term 'sociopath' is mis-used in the context of Sherlock. But in case you don't have time to read all that, basically I don't think there is much difference between a psychopath and a sociopath, from a psychological point of view, and I don't think he is either.

 

There is a quote from Stephen Moffat in the comments below the article: "He's not a psychopath, he's not a sociopath ... he's a man who chooses to be the way he is because he thinks it makes him better. It's a monastic decision. He takes himself out of touch with his sexuality, out of touch with his emotions in order to make himself better."

 

So that is also my interpretation, he's just written as a man who makes choices to live out of touch with his emotions.

 

Also, if he were a sociopath, it isn't a curable condition that could magically disappear once you are confronted with your feelings. 

  • Like 4
Posted

I tend not to get my psychological definitions from blogs, but rather from psychological sites and texts.  I stand by my statements about the distinction between psychopath and sociopath because they are drawn from such sites and from psych textbooks. 

As to Moffat's statement, it doesn't change a word of what I wrote, because - in the quote you reference - Moffat explicitly states that sociopath is the standard Sherlock upholds and aspires to.  All you've done by providing the quote is confirm both the writers and Sherlock agree he is intentionally limiting his empathy for ego-driven reasons. 

That makes my case.  :)

Posted

I'm not sure which definition you have, but isn't a sociopath just a type of psychopath (a secondary one)?

 

So, to be a sociopath, you have to be a also be a psychopath?, So it is impossible then, to say that a sociopath is not a psychopath, you could only correctly state that they aren't a primary psychopath.

 

Moffat doesn't say that Sherlock is using the sociopath as a standard, not at all. He says that he is someone who chooses not to be in touch with his emotions. He calls it monastic. Would you describe a monk as living to the standards of a sociopath? A monk is someone who lives without a sexual relationship despite having normal human feelings, and that's what Moffat compares Sherlock to. He explicitly says he is not a sociopath.

 

 

  • Like 3
Posted (edited)

I'm not sure which definition you have, but isn't a sociopath just a type of psychopath (a secondary one)?

 

So, to be a sociopath, you have to be a also be a psychopath?

No - which is why I suggested perusing medical/psych sites.  Picking one such site, written for the layman:

 

http://www.webmd.com/mental-health/features/sociopath-psychopath-difference

(Edited link because originally posted link started on second page)

 

But you can find similar on more technical sites if you wish.

 

Suffice it to say, the blog you reference is incorrect when it states "psychopaths and sociopaths are the exact same thing.  There is no difference.  Whatsoever."  As such, the author's harangue against the idea 'Sherlock is a psychopath' is but an attack on a straw man.  He is not a psychopath, nor does he aspire to that standard.

 

 

Moffat doesn't say that Sherlock is using the sociopath as a standard, not at all.

I'm sorry but that is a false statement.  Moffat's explicitly states:

 

"He’s not a sociopath, nor is he high-functioning. He’d really like to be a sociopath. But he’s so f***ing not. The wonderful drama of Sherlock Holmes is that he’s aspiring to this extraordinary standard. "

 

So, as I said: "Moffat explicitly states that sociopath is the standard Sherlock upholds and aspires to."  I was very careful and very precise in my words - because I actually did read a full version of Moffat's oft stated quote.  And, again, that quote confirms "both the writers and Sherlock agree he is intentionally limiting his empathy for ego-driven reasons. 

 

That makes my case."  :)

Edited by BLS_Pro

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 95 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.