Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Great Game?"  

67 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
      0
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
      0
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

This rewatch was really the first time it struck me that not only was Sherlock young when Carl Powers died, but so was Moriarty.  I'm not sure why that never really hit me before.   :blink:

 

I love that Mycroft comes to check on his little brother after the explosion, but tries to disguise it with a case.  Not that I don't believe the case is real, because it is, and I trust that Mycroft wanted Sherlock on the case, but it gave Mycroft the perfect excuse to go visit without it being a visit out of concern.  Because, heaven forbid!

 

It is amazing to think this was the first episode they filmed (post-pilot) as they were really firing on all cylinders from the start!   Impressive!   And a testament to both the chemistry between MF and BC, and for Mofftiss for casting them.

  • Like 3
Posted

I love that Mycroft comes to check on his little brother after the explosion, but tries to disguise it with a case.  Not that I don't believe the case is real, because it is, and I trust that Mycroft wanted Sherlock on the case, but it gave Mycroft the perfect excuse to go visit without it being a visit out of concern.  Because, heaven forbid!

 

That never occurred to me, but I do believe you're right -- in the original stories, I think Mycroft showed up at Baker Street just once, and the shock just about gave his brother a heart attack!

  • Like 3
Posted

 

I love that Mycroft comes to check on his little brother after the explosion, but tries to disguise it with a case.  Not that I don't believe the case is real, because it is, and I trust that Mycroft wanted Sherlock on the case, but it gave Mycroft the perfect excuse to go visit without it being a visit out of concern.  Because, heaven forbid!

 

That never occurred to me, but I do believe you're right -- in the original stories, I think Mycroft showed up at Baker Street just once, and the shock just about gave his brother a heart attack!

 

 

I don't know if it's right or not, but it's a lovely idea!

 

I'd like to see Sherlock penetrate Mycroft's facade someday. Not like in HLV, but Sherlock do something that causes Mycroft to reveal himself for a minute, and equalizes them a bit. (I'm almost as annoyed as Sherlock that Mycroft is the smarter brother!)

 

(You know you're obsessed when... )

 

  • Like 3
Posted

Well, that's my head canon at least.  ;)   I feel like it's just too convenient that Mycroft turns up that morning of all days.  That and the fact that we know he worries... constantly.  And while it hasn't happened yet:  his face and "Oh, Sherlock, what have you done?" in HLV,  the cig and danger night in ASIB, the "your loss would break my heart" in HLV.

  • Like 3
Posted

In HLV, there was something in the punch, remember? :)

But it make the other moments even stronger. Still would like to know what's the story behind the "danger night", but it's another episode.

  • Like 1
Posted

I'm finally doing my rewatch of TGG while I write a report (self-employment, I love you!), and I just noticed something I hadn't on previous watches.  At the very beginning, after Sherlock and John have the "domestic," Mrs. Hudson comes in with some shopping and stows it in the kitchen, but then she very deliberately brandishes the sales receipt and places it on the table, and Sherlock sort of blinks or nods assent.  So, while she may do some or all of his shopping for him, he's reimbursing her for it.  

 

Cool.

 

  • Like 5
Posted

She really IS a saint. :smile:

  • Like 1
Posted

Or she's afraid this will happen

 

tumblr_no4nhc1A2k1qkwi7to1_500.jpg

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Having managed to re-watch TGG, it feels extremely right as a Sherlock reincarnation on many levels:

It showcases his total disregard of other humans' problems, especially from cases 1 to 4, since 5 is the great showdown.

The grammar lesson in Belarus is extremely funny, but only so long as one remembers that the same writer made Sherlock commit two very glaring errors in TEH, therefore being inconsistent.

The combination of the Five Orange Pips with the Bruce - Partington plans, and Mycroft's first appearance at Baker Str right after the bombing coinciding with the ACD version of Mycroft being derailed, like a tram car coming down a country lane.

The whole Czech thing, starting with the envelope and culminating with Ms Wenceslas being a direct allusion to Bohemia and thus to the very first short story, A Scandal in Bohemia.

The Thames waterline, so reminiscent of so many Holmes stories, especially The Sign of the Four.

His reaction to the death of the old lady, which is momentary consternation, only to be replaced back at the flat with a sharp retort about technically winning that one.

The painting being done on canvas rather than wood, and Mr Gatiss' bewailing of that lapse: he is a true Sherlockian, whatever his scriptwriting partner may be...

The lovely double image on the modernised lens which they started using in the title sequence in SiP and have continued ever since.

The visit to the Planetarium, and his ability to grasp the minutest detail, namely the facts about supernovas no longer existing, while fighting for his life one more time.

Truth to tell, I am not so in love with the ending, as it left too many questions unanswered and was probably the trigger for all the Sherlock-John fan fiction out there, despite the fact that the denial comes very emphatically: "Now people will talk" " In my experience they do little else"!

Still, a great beginning to a great series!

  • Like 3
Posted

Having managed to re-watch TGG, it feels extremely right as a Sherlock reincarnation on many levels:

...

Truth to tell, I am not so in love with the ending, as it left too many questions unanswered and was probably the trigger for all the Sherlock-John fan fiction out there, despite the fact that the denial comes very emphatically: "Now people will talk" " In my experience they do little else"!

Still, a great beginning to a great series!

 

Totally agree that this is a great  homage to a lot of the canon stories, and it functions really well as a Sherlock Holmes reincarnation.  I wonder if, when they were writing, they worried about not getting renewed for the second season and therefore wanted to make sure a lot of the good canon references made it to screen.

 

As far as the "people will talk" line, I know they were just playing with the audience a bit, but that particular joke seems to feel a little forced.  I don't think John is meant to portray any real anxiety about people talking about him and Sherlock together, but come on, John:  Sherlock is taking a Semtex coat off you in the middle of a deserted pool deck.  Sexual innuendo should be just about the last thing on anyone's mind at that point.   :D

  • Like 2
Posted

The grammar lesson in Belarus is extremely funny, but only so long as one remembers that the same writer made Sherlock commit two very glaring errors in TEH, therefore being inconsistent.

 

Real-life spoken English has its own rules -- the only person I've ever known who actually talked like a grammar book was my Aunt Bernice.  So in Belarus, Sherlock was being persnickety, presumably on purpose.  Someone suggested a while back (probably on this thread) that he was trying to annoy the prisoner into losing his temper, in hopes that he'd blurt out what really happened.  If so, it worked!

 

As far as the "people will talk" line, I know they were just playing with the audience a bit, but that particular joke seems to feel a little forced.  I don't think John is meant to portray any real anxiety about people talking about him and Sherlock together, but come on, John:  Sherlock is taking a Semtex coat off you in the middle of a deserted pool deck.  Sexual innuendo should be just about the last thing on anyone's mind at that point.   :D

 

Something akin to gallows humor, perhaps?

 

  • Like 2
Posted

 

 

Having managed to re-watch TGG, it feels extremely right as a Sherlock reincarnation on many levels:

...

Truth to tell, I am not so in love with the ending, as it left too many questions unanswered and was probably the trigger for all the Sherlock-John fan fiction out there, despite the fact that the denial comes very emphatically: "Now people will talk" " In my experience they do little else"!

Still, a great beginning to a great series!

Totally agree that this is a great homage to a lot of the canon stories, and it functions really well as a Sherlock Holmes reincarnation. I wonder if, when they were writing, they worried about not getting renewed for the second season and therefore wanted to make sure a lot of the good canon references made it to screen.

 

As far as the "people will talk" line, I know they were just playing with the audience a bit, but that particular joke seems to feel a little forced. I don't think John is meant to portray any real anxiety about people talking about him and Sherlock together, but come on, John: Sherlock is taking a Semtex coat off you in the middle of a deserted pool deck. Sexual innuendo should be just about the last thing on anyone's mind at that point. :D

Maybe John hear about it often enough in a short time in the near past, the idea sort of stuck in the forefront of his mind. Like childhood game of repeating certain word often enough in someone's hearing, sooner or later s/he will use it in their own sentence :D
Posted

What are the two grammatical errors Sherlock makes in TEH?

  • Like 1
Posted

When he explains the Big Blue Thing to Anderson he says "Each of them were given a code name..." and 'each' takes a verb in the singular in both American and British English, and later on he says "It was vital that John stayed just where I put him." This is an either/or case: in British English he could have gone with "It was vital that John should stay where I put him" and in American English "It was vital that John STAY where I put him" because it's a subjunctive mood, but whichever you choose, the second subject verb MUST be a bare infinitive, not "stayed". Both egregious errors in such a grammarian!

Posted

Am I right? - Sherlock didn't twiddle a single thing in TGG. I miss it.

Maybe we scholuld write a petition to the makers demanding some twiddling in S4? :P

  • Like 2
Posted

Am I right? - Sherlock didn't twiddle a single thing in TGG. I miss it.

Maybe we scholuld write a petition to the makers demanding some twiddling in S4? :P

 

I'd say he was twiddling the gun in the pool scene right after Moriarty initally left.

Posted

Nope. :D He's fiddling with it, scratching his head and do other, quite dangerous things with it (I guess it was unlocked), but no twiddling.

 

BTW, Sherlock looks quite disturbed after Jim left, like for a moment the emotions took over. Another little bit that reminds me of the roof scene.

 

I think "people will talk" remark was John's attempt to relieve the tension trough humor, a bit like "Sherlock's a girl's name" in HLV.

  • Like 3
Posted

I think "people will talk" remark was John's attempt to relieve the tension trough humor, a bit like "Sherlock's a girl's name" in HLV.

 

My thoughts exactly.

  • Like 2
Posted

Am I right? - Sherlock didn't twiddle a single thing in TGG. I miss it.

Maybe we scholuld write a petition to the makers demanding some twiddling in S4? :P

Nope. :D He's fiddling with it, scratching his head and do other, quite dangerous things with it (I guess it was unlocked), but no twiddling.

 

Twiddle, fiddle, why quibble? ... it's all good, I'll sign the petition!

Posted

Nope. :D He's fiddling with it, scratching his head and do other, quite dangerous things with it (I guess it was unlocked), but no twiddling.

 

 

Technically they're the same thing according to dictionary.com and it's thesaurus counterpart.  I checked out of curiosity.  But we're not as technical as Sherlock can be so I'll go with the following bit from Robin Hood: Men in Tights:

 

King Richard: Hold this, Father.

Rabbi Tuckman: Rabbi.

King RIchard: Whatever. ...

Rabbi Tuckman: Thank you.  Here's your knife.

King Richard: Sword.

Rabbi Tuckman: Whatever

 

because I have a sense of humor about this (and can't find the movie quote I actually want that has the same thought process). :)

Posted

Nope. :D He's fiddling with it, scratching his head and do other, quite dangerous things with it (I guess it was unlocked), but no twiddling.

 

BTW, Sherlock looks quite disturbed after Jim left, like for a moment the emotions took over. Another little bit that reminds me of the roof scene.

 

 

 

Never take your firearm safety lessons from Sherlock Holmes.  Just sayin'

 

You bring up a good point about how disturbed Sherlock looked after Jim left.  I think one of the things that I take away from the first season is Sherlock learning how to work with a partner and have a friend.  In my own head canon, Sherlock went to that pool expecting to be alone.  He'd already done the calculus years ago about what he would be willing to die for, and he knew ways in which this interaction could end with his own death.  But suddenly, he has this flatmate there, who looks at him and nods that he is willing to die alongside Sherlock in order to take down this criminal mastermind.  And then Sherlock thought they both were going to die, and then they didn't have to.  It's a lot to take in all at once, and no wonder he felt disturbed over it.

  • Like 2
Posted

Oh, yes, I like it - Sherlock dealing with a partner for the first time, who: 1 was in a deadly danger, and was used against him (again, in the first seconds he surely thought John was Jim), 2 was willing to die for the cause.

 

And than all the new information - he had to re-adjust his whole mind palace to the new situation. Might be quite much, even for a brain like Sherlocks'.

  • Like 2
Posted

One more thing - i think bits like that make a big part of show's humor and attraction:

After the explosion, when all turns dark, we hear a moan. You cannot say, if it's Sherlock, or John who just woke up on Sarah's sofa. I love that.

  • Like 1
Posted

One more thing - i think bits like that make a big part of show's humor and attraction:

After the explosion, when all turns dark, we hear a moan. You cannot say, if it's Sherlock, or John who just woke up on Sarah's sofa. I love that.

 

Oh, good point!  I hadn't caught that it could also be John and his poor back from his evening on the sofa.  Hope he got promoted to the lilo or even the foot of the bed relatively quickly.  

 

Edited to add:

In the subsequent scene, where Mycroft picks up on John having slept on the sofa, not the lilo, I love the timing of Sherlock's eyes vis-a-vis the dialog.  He looks down John's body and at about thigh or knee height on his gaze says "Yes, of course," and continues down to feet and back up again.  I keep wondering what clue he saw on John's legs that would communicate the sofa?

 

(I used to have a friend in grad school who knew every time I took a nap on the couch before I saw her, because the cushion left an imprint on my cheek!)

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 113 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.