Jump to content

What Did You Think Of "The Great Game?"  

67 members have voted

  1. 1. Add Your Vote Here:

    • 10/10 Excellent
    • 9/10 Not Quite The Best, But Not Far Off.
    • 8/10 Certainly Worth Watching Again.
    • 7/10 Slightly Above The Norm.
      0
    • 6/10 Average.
      0
    • 5/10 Slightly Sub-Par.
      0
    • 4/10 Decidedly Below Average.
      0
    • 3/10 Pretty Poor.
      0
    • 2/10 Bad.
      0
    • 1/10 Terrible.
      0


Recommended Posts

Posted

And anyway, he was at the lab when he first discovered the pesky things, so he might have viewed them on the electronic microscope, especially if Moriarty had taken the precaution to freshen up the batch ( he gives him another hint in the third case!), and then transferred to his preferred one just before Jim made his appearance! Gosh, I love that scene when he explains how it would be kinder to Molly in the long run! :moriarty:

Posted

I have an alternative explanation:  What we see is not the slide that's in Sherlock's microscope, it's an image from his memory palace.  He has matched up what he does see (but we don't) with an electron-microscope view that he had saved for future reference.

 

  • Like 1
  • 2 months later...
Posted

I partially rewatched The Great Game yesterday (it is possibly my favourite episode of all) and wondered all over again what exactly John expects Sherlock to do in that scene at 221B where he gets angry / feels disappointed with Sherlock. The first time I watched the episode my reaction to John's reaction was :blink:  and it hasn't evolved much in subsequent rewatches: so far I just ignored it in favour of the myriad other interesting things going on in this episode, but now I really need to understand what exactly John wanted there.

Did he just want Sherlock to state, out loud, how sorry he was that so many died in that blast? That would be just silly considering (a) John knows how focussed Sherlock is on the work and can hardly be expected to waste time mourning strangers when he's on a case, and (b) Sherlock's expression there conveys that he does regret the needless death of so many innocents.

 

Or maybe (a) above is not (yet) true, that at this point John doesn't really know Sherlock? Even so, is that reason enough for him to be angry? 

(It is possible that if i keep on typing and expanding this post I may just hit upon the answer myself but who knows how much time that will take :D )

I read through some of the early posts in this thread which touch on this scene but I don't think any of them really answers my question.

Any ideas please? 

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, here's my take on it ... I think John's disappointed in Sherlock's unwillingness, or inability, to show his humanity. Whether Sherlock likes it or not, emotions are part of the human condition, and a "decent" human shows decent emotions ... remorse for failing to save the victims, in this case. Plus, it's a form of respect for the dead to mourn their passing. But what John gets instead is Sherlock whinging because he didn't get credit for figuring out the right answer, and admiring the cleverness of his opponent. Technically Sherlock is correct ... simply having emotions won't save anyone ... but his lack of remorse disrespects the fallen. Something John as a soldier would be especially attuned to, I imagine. Anyway, that's how I read it.

  • Like 2
Posted

Sherlock is learning bit by bit and perhaps someday he can make peace between societal expectations and his true self.

  • Like 2
Posted

Thanks Arcadia

Mark of respect, yes; though what form might John expect it to take - words?

Especially as it didn't look to me as if Sherlock was feeling no remorse; he was clearly affected by it, he just managed to shrug it off quickly rather than dwelling on it. Instead of assuming Sherlock wasn't human enough and being angry about it, I expected John to see it as Sherlock's extreme self-possession and focus, and feel a bit of admiration.

  • Like 2
Posted

Thanks Arcadia

Mark of respect, yes; though what form might John expect it to take - words?

Especially as it didn't look to me as if Sherlock was feeling no remorse; he was clearly affected by it, he just managed to shrug it off quickly rather than dwelling on it. Instead of assuming Sherlock wasn't human enough and being angry about it, I expected John to see it as Sherlock's extreme self-possession and focus, and feel a bit of admiration.

 

I think it's more about what he did do, though, than what he didn't do. Remaining silent, or stoic, is one thing; complaining about losing, then admiring the villain's m.o., is something else. Or as John might say ... timing, Sherlock! :smile: I think John wants Sherlock to be a "good man" -- a hero -- just as much as Lestrade does, and a "good man" doesn't place his own selfish desires before the welfare of others.

 

The irony, of course, is once Sherlock finally puts someone else before himself, he ends up committing murder. Complicated business, this morality stuff.

  • Like 3
Posted

Absolutely devastating business acquiring sentiments, dear Arcadia: leads to homicide in HLV! But Sherlock is affected more than John and Lestrade in Lestrade's office, while the two others, who have seen fellow policemen/army personnel probably die right next to them are much more stoic. This Dr Watson is an angry character, certainly not anybody's best friend, and is consequently upset by the remark that Sherlock had technically won. Just a plot device for Sherlock gently to remind him not to make anyone into a hero with his very precise assessment of "not much cop this caring lark", to put the good doctor in the proper frame of mind so that they can go on solving crimes together efficiently.

  • Like 1
Posted

Hmm...thanks Arcadia and Inge, those two comments from you seem to be the solution I'm looking for: John Watson as someone easy to anger plus Sherlock's comment being just the trigger to unleash his anger.

May also explain why John bothers correcting Sherlock's manners throughout the series - its the one way he gets some of his own back after playing second fiddle. And Sherlock must have a lot of patience to resign himself to so much 'correcting'. To me Sherlock will always be the better human being of the two, not just in this series but even in the canon.

  • Like 1
Posted

Dear Boswell, ( this does not bode well, with your nickname on the forum) one should always remember that Sherlock Holmes solved upward of three thousand cases in his career, both before and after Dr Watson's entrance and departure from his life! Of course he's the better character, the more perceptive, the more sensitive to others' feelings, all the while proclaiming he has none of his own, analytical reasoner and all that tommyrot! Dr Watson is just a chronicler, an early PR man, a follower, an admirer, but never such a person as Sherlock, even if this latest variation has acquired concepts like "bit not good", "Sherlock, the showing off thing, we've discussed it before" and other such corrective (but totally superfluous) one-liners.

Posted

Oh, I can't agree with either of you in your assessments of "our" John Watson; I find him patient, level-headed, decent and reliable. None of those things are very "sexy" or even all that unusual, so in that way he doesn't measure up to the far more flamboyant Sherlock; but I would argue that it would be hard for Sherlock to find better qualities in a friend. In fact, I think that's why Sherlock chose him as a friend; those are the qualities he values in a person. Sherlock needs someone to correct him when he errs, as he doesn't seem prone to do it himself. :smile: Ergo, Molly and Lestrade, as well. They all help keep him grounded; even Mrs. Hudson, in her rather flaky way. Not sure where Mary fits into this, though.........

  • Like 3
Posted

 "our" John Watson; I find him patient, level-headed, decent and reliable. 

 

See Inge, that happens too  :D

 

Seriously though, this image of Watson as the overall better guy is so widespread and deep-rooted that I was working from that assumption too, until I realised it is what was confusing me all this while about that scene. John isn't the calmest person in the world, certainly not as calm & collected as Sherlock is, despite his military experience (or maybe because of it). 

And when you spelled it out, it just clicked into place with what Arcadia said about Sherlock's insensitive comment triggering John's anger and the penny dropped in my head.

 

I do agree with Arcadia that John is the perfect friend for Sherlock: his emotional nature and admiration for Sherlock ensure his complete loyalty to the detective, his adventurous side, intelligence, and skill with weapons make him a most reliable companion when it's time for action, and even if he initially has trouble coming to grips with Sherlock's motivations & principles he must be given credit for making an effort to understand. How else could he live with him for so long?

What I do not like is his near-presumption of moral superiority when he 'corrects' Sherlock, I find it actually annoying at times. And the fact that the writers insinuated the "you keep me right" bit into the best man speech was, to me, proof that the whole episode was a JohnLock fantasy-feeder (as if that fantasy needed any more feeding!)

 

Coming back to topic though,...er.. sorry I've no idea how to do that now  :wacko:

  • Like 1
Posted

Hmmm... I was always wondering how easily our level-headed John almost strangled Sherlock in TSIB. :D

Oh, sure Sherlock provoked him, but you must be provoke-able first.

  • Like 1
Posted

But Sherlock is affected more than John and Lestrade in Lestrade's office, while the two others, who have seen fellow policemen/army personnel probably die right next to them are much more stoic.

Maybe the blueish Monday muddles my head, but I think quite the opposite.

 

When the old lady was blown up, Sherlock was shocked, but not because he was feeling sad for her.

I think he was surprised. About how far Moriarty cared to play. That he didn't play according to rule and there was a hidden rule. Why he didn't see it coming sooner. And if there was more elaborate plan that he was not aware of. He might be trying to deduce Moriarty, who he had not met but Moriarty had been a aware of Sherlock all this time. Based in Carl Powell's case. Moriarty had not been mentioned at this stage. Maybe he was trying to make connection to previous cases, Pink (he was expecting this) and trying to enter Moriarty's head and find his motive, target and way of playing.

 

Long story short, I think, whatever in his head, is the game, the nemesis, the brain exercise, nothing about sympathy. At all. If that makes sense.

 

Or, maybe I shouldn't try to think on Monday.

  • Like 3
Posted

No, please, think away! I see it as an absolutely valid interpretation. For Mondays at least. Tomorrow it might be different. That's what makes it fun!

 

But seriously, I suspect that at least 80% of the reaction is what you say. Then the feeling of defeat. Maybe a little bit of sympathy, but he wouldn't admit it, even to himself.

  • Like 2
Posted

What I do not like is his near-presumption of moral superiority when he 'corrects' Sherlock, I find it actually annoying at times.

I agree, "moral superiority" is a phrase that doesn't sit well. How about we compromise on "more socially adept"? :D I think John facilitates Sherlock's passage through the world by blunting his sharp edges; i.e., people are more willing to give Sherlock-at-his-worst a pass because they see that John accepts him in spite of his faults; and John appears (at least by contrast) to be a decent sort. Whether he actually is a decent sort or not doesn't really matter, because he's socially adept enough to act as if he is. And frankly, it wouldn't kill Sherlock to learn that skill... :P

 

Hmmm... I was always wondering how easily our level-headed John almost strangled Sherlock in TSIB. :D

Oh, sure Sherlock provoked him, but you must be provoke-able first.

I think a punch in the face would provoke just about anyone... although perhaps with different results. Me for instance; I'd be provoked into bursting into tears!

 

But yeah, I'll concede that Sherlock is the less "provoke-able" of the two. See, he does have some good qualities! :applause: Good boy.

  • Like 2
Posted

By "human", in this instance, you mean "stupid" -- ? :D

  • Like 1
Posted

But seriously, I suspect that at least 80% of the reaction is what you say. Then the feeling of defeat. Maybe a little bit of sympathy, but he wouldn't admit it, even to himself.

 

Maybe because he thinks by having sympathy, he would get hurt.

Which is true. That is sad.

And he tries to think and lives by the word of his big brother.

Which is true as well. Makes sense. Smart thinkers don't allow anything clouds their brain, they should be above that.

But with that messy looking brain, we have that shinny looking heart. And they don't like to work together.

Complicated, eh..?

 

 

Hmmm... I was always wondering how easily our level-headed John almost strangled Sherlock in TSIB. :D

Oh, sure Sherlock provoked him, but you must be provoke-able first.

 

But yeah, I'll concede that Sherlock is the less "provoke-able" of the two. See, he does have some good qualities! :applause: Good boy.

 

Well.. unless you happen to hurt his landlady.. or his best friend.

That is actually a better quality in him.

That he is far more protective to people he loves than himself.

  • Like 4
  • 3 months later...
Posted

I was just re-watching this with my boyfriend, and he suggested that when we see Sherlock's notice board full of details on Moriarty's history, that the second school photo of Carl Powers has a resemblance to Andrew Scott. I wonder could that be a hidden clue that Powers will turn out to be somehow related to Moriarty? 

 

I'm not convinced myself, I thought he didn't look like him at all in the first one, but in the second one I think he sort of does.

Posted

Well, since both Moriarty and Carl Powers are dead, it's kind of a moot point, isn't it? :P  To be honest, I'd be really surprised if they ever go back to that story line. I think they've got something more dramatic in mind.

Posted

To be honest, I'd be really surprised if they ever go back to that story line. I think they've got something more dramatic in mind.

 

 

 
I always thought that because the case sort of connected Moriarty and Sherlock as teenagers, there might be something more to it. Plus, I did think it would be cool if they snuck in an Andrew Scott school picture. But I am prepared to be proved wrong, I'm sure they do have something more surprising up their sleeves, and look forward to finding out.
Posted

I always thought that because the case sort of connected Moriarty and Sherlock as teenagers, there might be something more to it. Plus, I did think it would be cool if they snuck in an Andrew Scott school picture. But I am prepared to be proved wrong, I'm sure they do have something more surprising up their sleeves, and look forward to finding out.

As regards anything past Series 5, I suspect that the Moftisses are looking forward to finding out!  They seem to kinda go wherever the story line may lead them.

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 107 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.