Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Just think in a couple of years we will be able to rank our top ten !

Posted

Just think in a couple of years we will be able to rank our top ten !

Rank our top ten...yeah right. We have a hard enough time ranking the 9 full ones that we have.

  • Like 2
Posted

Dunno about ranking them, but I'm pretty sure I can tell you right now what my ten favorite episodes will be for most of 2016.  ;)

  • Like 4
Posted

Lovely idea! I find it hard to rank the episodes as well - I like them all the best, I think.

 

So:

 

A Study in Pink: Magical. It's the best written of the lot, I think, and it has one of the two best endings. If I wanted to introduce someone to this series, this is the episode I'd show them, and not because it's the first, but because it's just so damn good. It could also totally be a film on it's own.

 

The Blind Banker: Sherlock the sociopath at his best, also Sherlock and John's friendship / working relationship at it's (dysfunctional) best. Feels the closest to the old Dyole stories. Absence of Mycroft is a big bonus, and presence of beautiful Soo Lin also (for me). It's also cool to see Sherlock as the under-appreciated genius freelancer, which is emphasized by Lestrade's replacement with the unfriendly and skeptical Dimmock. Great humor, but also great darkness.

 

The Great Game: The episode that's closest to being a thriller. I almost know it by heart, and I still think it's pretty suspenseful. I love how it's packed with great casework, I love how Sherlock is fascinated with Moriarty, I love Sherlock's characterization in this episode even more than in all the others, and I still think that the pool scene is absolutely breathtaking and that it's the turning point and most crucial moment for Sherlock in the entire series so far.

 

A Scandal in Belgravia: Most cinematic episode. Also probably the funniest. Manages the impossible, i.e. writing a love story for Sherlock Holmes that actually works. Irene Adler is superbly cast and written. Another great case, and a surprisingly dark and beautiful twist at the end, with some of the most memorable lines on the show. Very romantic episode, I must say.

 

The Hounds of Baskerville: Scary. Very scary, just like the novel it is based on. Extremely clever adaptation of said novel. Continues the gradual humanization of Sherlock as begun in the episode before this, only to, as always, pull the rug out from under our feet and prove that he's a complete psychopath after all and always will be ("I only have one friend - so I'll use said person for an extremely cruel experiment without his knowledge or consent, involving an unknown and potentially deadly drug as well as possibly triggering traumatic wartime memories")

 

The Reichenbach Fall: Most intense episode, and most fiendishly difficult to figure out. You can watch it time and time again and still no be sure what exactly you saw. Moriarty's heist at the beginning is hilarious, one of the best comic film sequences I know, and The Fall is just simply epic. In between these two scenes, there is more drama and tension and evil foreboding than most series manage within an entire season. No wonder Sherlock really kicked off after this. It's the episode the show has been building up to since it began, and the aftermath still isn't over.

 

The Empty Hearse: It's impossible to pick up where The Reichenbach Fall left off, especially after a two year hiatus. Feels like a new beginning in a lot of ways. The Reunion actually manages to live up to the entirely overblown expectations I had, while the explanation for The Fall doesn't. Feels kind of disjointed and rushed, and is definitely the episode that makes the least sense on its own. Still, it is just so good to have Sherlock back, and the boys finally together again and eventually on speaking terms, too.

 

The Sign of Three: I have no idea what this episode actually is. A Drama / comedy / mystery / romcom / sad love story / something else, it is unique in my viewing experience, and it is also the first bit of television that got a physical reaction out me (other than crying, which I generally do a lot, but didn't do here). I love how the episode is mostly just Sherlock's speech, with the various flashback scenes woven neatly into that. And it has the other best ending. The series could end here, it really could.

 

His Last Vow: Probably the most controversial of all Sherlock episodes, and just for that, I've got to love it. Incredible how 90 minutes of entertainment can fuel such debate and reflection. Has so many items of my wish list in it that I had to mentally rewrite said list after viewing, because it was almost empty: Sherlock on drugs, the fake engagement, the Milverton case... Shocking plot twist, and shocking ending - best use of the expression "Merry Christmas" ever. Most epic episode, all about bigger larger more, but has some great quiet moments as well.

 

Great that someone else grabbed the idea and went with it! It's really interesting to read people's overall impressions of the episodes, especially when they see something very different from myself. I never thought of The Great Game as resembling a thriller, for instance. It just never occurred to me. Well, all of the episodes are exciting, and most of them had me on the edge of my seat for part of the time when I first watched them. But, thriller? I'd say His Last Vow feels more like a thriller to me. It's also very much a drama, of course. The Reichenbach Fall also feels more like a thriller. I'm trying to get my head around what makes The Great Game more thriller-like, but have little success.

 

I think I agree with you about the two best endings (while I also love the very powerful graveyard speech in Reichenbach). Isn't it fascinating to compare the ending of A Study in Pink, in which Sherlock and John have just become acquainted and are walking off together, with the ending of The Sign of Three, in which it is established that they are best friends (as if we didn't know already!) and Sherlock walks away alone? There is something beautiful and a little sad - and very poetic - to the two endings. The first feels very much like a beginning, even though it's an episode ending, but the other really does have the feel of an ending to it.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

I never thought of The Great Game as resembling a thriller ... It just never occurred to me. Well, all of the episodes are exciting, and most of them had me on the edge of my seat for part of the time when I first watched them. But, thriller? I'd say His Last Vow feels more like a thriller to me. It's also very much a drama, of course. The Reichenbach Fall also feels more like a thriller. I'm trying to get my head around what makes The Great Game more thriller-like, but have little success.

I can't speak for T.o.b.y, of course, but what makes TGG seem like a thriller to me is the ever-ticking clock.

  • Like 2
  • 2 months later...
Posted

I think I'm ready to give the ranking another go, just for kicks:

 

#9: The Blind Banker

#8: His Last Vow

#7: The Sign of Three

#6: A Scandal in Belgravia

#5: The Hounds of Baskerville

#4: The Great Game

#3: The Empty Hearse

#2: A Study in Pink

#1: The Reichenbach Fall

 

Sentiment tells me to rank TSoT higher, and reason tells me to rank TEH lower than I have... Hm.

Posted

Hey, Bev -- nice to see you back on here the past couple of days!

 

  • 3 months later...
Posted

I finally finished watching all 3 seasons again this morning. (I've been rewatching them in sequence for the first time in ages, and when I got to HLV I was reluctant to watch it because it meant the series would be over! ... :cry: ... :wacko: ) Anyway, based on this last go round, I'm thinking of changing my favorite S2 and S3 episodes.

 

I hate to say it, but I realize now that TEH has indeed kind of spoiled Reichenbach for me. I watch TRF now and all I think about is that Sherlock already has every move planned, so there's not much suspense in it anymore. Scandal, on the other hand, remains SUCH a visually beautiful episode, I think it's the most cinematic one they've done. It's quite magical, even if it's not my favorite storyline. And Sherlock looks amazing in it, they got him exactly right in this one. :wub:

 

HLV; I was finally able to watch it without feeling like I'm being beaten to death. Not wholly a good thing, as the emotional impact was what made me love this episode to begin with. On the other hand, it actually makes sense to me now, although I still find "Mary is an assassin" extremely hard to swallow. (Good thing it's fiction!) I still can't bring myself to hate her for it, though; she's just too attractive a character to me in all other respects.

 

However, I continue to love TSo3 more every time I see it. I love the way all the different threads are woven together, and that it takes some brain work to sort of pick them apart and put them in order. HLV's like that too, actually, and frankly, the acting is just stunning (in both). So I'm still kind of torn between those two.

 

And as far as ranking them 1 to 9, forget it; that's still beyond me. As Mr. Cumberbatch would say, I'm rubbish at choosing favorites!

 

Alas, poor old Banker and Hounds remain at the bottom, which, as sherlockandjohn says, is not quite fair to them, but they're just ... slower, and a little more predictable, imo. Still rather watch them than anything else on TV, though.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

I hate to say it, but I realize now that TEH has indeed kind of spoiled Reichenbach for me. I watch TRF now and all I think about is that Sherlock already has every move planned, so there's not much suspense in it anymore. Scandal, on the other hand, remains SUCH a visually beautiful episode, I think it's the most cinematic one they've done. It's quite magical, even if it's not my favorite storyline. And Sherlock looks amazing in it, they got him exactly right in this one. :wub:

 

 

 

Picking between Scandal and Reichenbach is like choosing bottle from Jeff Hope, don't feel like giving it a try. (I am not an idiot like Sherlock Holmes!  :D )

 

Although I think I have decided as displayed on the profile (Dang it doesn't let me choose both)

 

However, The Reichenbach Fall will always have very special spot, and for me, The Empty Hearse never ruins it.

Just didn't choose it because I feel like I need to be 'ready' everytime I re-watch it, because it would never be easy.

While Scandal is always a feel good Sherlock's episode to me.

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, that is a good point, I might be in a different mood the next time I watch it ... and feel entirely different about it. I'm sooooo changeable! (But to be fair to myself, it is my only weakness. :) )

  • Like 1
Posted

Well, that is a good point, I might be in a different mood the next time I watch it ... and feel entirely different about it. I'm sooooo changeable! (But to be fair to myself, it is my only weakness. :) )

 You don't happen to have any snipers in your disposal are you?

  • Like 1
Posted

I'm not telling. :p

  • Like 2
  • 1 month later...
Posted

Fairly late reply, but here is my list:
9. The Blind Banker - The only episode I didn't love. It wasn't bad, but it was fairly boring and just didn't hold a candle to the other episodes.

8. The Hounds of Baskerville - Only eighth because the other episodes are better.

7. The Sign of Three - The last 30 minutes were some of the best in the show's history. Other than that, it was humorous, but not really fantastic.

6. The Empty Hearse - I don't really have anything to say about this episode. It's good, but once again, doesn't hold a candle to the top five, which are the episodes I would say are fantastic.

5. A Scandal in Belgravia - This episode is fantastic. I really liked The Woman, and the ending is very satisfying and nice.

4. The Great Game - This episode started Moriarty's reign of terror, and it was an amazing way to set it up. The cliffhanger at the end too made for a great ending.

3. A Study in Pink - The episode that started it all. I really liked the villan in this episode, and I really liked the ending as well. It started the whole thing so perfectly. It opened us up to the characters, but still maintained a great story!

2. The Reichenbach Fall - The whole thing is nerve-wracking, but the last 20 minutes is a whole new level of amazing. 

Moriarty's suicide was a little more surprising, because I knew that obviously Sherlock wasn't going to die, but it is still one of the greatest scenes in a TV show.

 

1. His Last Vow - This episode is the greatest episode of any show I've ever watched ever. The plot twists, the emotion, the acting, everything. Every little minute detail, from the reveal of Sherlock's drug 'addiction' to 

The shooting of Magnussen

, it was all crafted so perfectly and so well done. The only thing I didn't really like was the ending, but that's only 1 minute of an hour and a half of pure perfection.

 

Tell me what you guys think :P

  • Like 2
Posted

I hate to say it, but I realize now that TEH has indeed kind of spoiled Reichenbach for me. I watch TRF now and all I think about is that Sherlock already has every move planned, so there's not much suspense in it anymore....

Oh. I never thought of it that way, probably because my reason for liking "Reichenbach" is not the suspense. (Suspense? What suspense? Sherlock is gonna come out on top, it's merely a question of how, but I wouldn't call that suspense.) It's still my favorite episode, but I think that's because of the intensity. I love intensity -- well, when it's my kind of intensity, which this apparently is. John's opening and closing scenes. The "complete dickhead" scene. Sherlock's confrontation with Moriarty at Kitty's apartment. Sherlock's confrontation with Moriarty on the roof (especially the "side of the angels" part).  The final phone call.  Goosebumps!

 

However, I continue to love TSo3 more every time I see it. I love the way all the different threads are woven together, and that it takes some brain work to sort of pick them apart and put them in order. HLV's like that too, actually, and frankly, the acting is just stunning (in both).

 

I agree that both episodes are made up of various threads woven together, as is "Empty Hearse." However I find "Sign" easy to follow because it's constructed in an orderly (albeit nonlinear) fashion, whereas I'm still not sure when (or even if) some of the scenes in the other two episodes are supposed to have taken place.

 

Last time I said that, someone was kind enough to construct a timeline for me, but that's not my point at all. My favorite mode of watching a story is to immerse myself in it and just experience it as it happens. I can do that with "Sign" because of its orderly structure, whereas the other two remind me of "spaghetti code." It hardly seems fair for Moftiss to expect their viewers to construct a flowchart in order to understand what's going on.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

 

I hate to say it, but I realize now that TEH has indeed kind of spoiled Reichenbach for me. I watch TRF now and all I think about is that Sherlock already has every move planned, so there's not much suspense in it anymore....

Oh. I never thought of it that way, probably because my reason for liking "Reichenbach" is not the suspense. (Suspense? What suspense? Sherlock is gonna come out on top, it's merely a question of how, but I wouldn't call that suspense.) It's still my favorite episode, but I think that's because of the intensity. I love intensity -- well, when it's my kind of intensity, which this apparently is. John's opening and closing scenes. The "complete dickhead" scene. Sherlock's confrontation with Moriarty at Kitty's apartment. Sherlock's confrontation with Moriarty on the roof (especially the "side of the angels" part).  The final phone call.  Goosebumps!

 

 

I can very much relate to this... Reichenbach has most definitely dropped a bit for me from where it was.  

 

Empty Hearse is probably my favorite episode at this point, with Scandal being a close 2nd.  My how times change.  I'm not gonna lie... I love the TEH b/c it's got Sherlock/Molly moments galore (however you want to interpret them) and that lovely conversation between Mycroft and Sherlock about goldfish and being lonely.  The Great Game still ranks high for me, and I've really come to love Hounds for the fun, little jaunt that it is.

 

Reichenbach and HLV are great episodes, and there is so much I love about them, but there's also a heaviness to them that makes me rewatch them less.  The Great Game doesn't have that for me.

  • Like 3
Posted

Fairly late reply, but here is my list:

9. The Blind Banker - The only episode I didn't love. It wasn't bad, but it was fairly boring and just didn't hold a candle to the other episodes.

8. The Hounds of Baskerville - Only eighth because the other episodes are better.

7. The Sign of Three - The last 30 minutes were some of the best in the show's history. Other than that, it was humorous, but not really fantastic.

6. The Empty Hearse - I don't really have anything to say about this episode. It's good, but once again, doesn't hold a candle to the top five, which are the episodes I would say are fantastic.

5. A Scandal in Belgravia - This episode is fantastic. I really liked The Woman, and the ending is very satisfying and nice.

4. The Great Game - This episode started Moriarty's reign of terror, and it was an amazing way to set it up. The cliffhanger at the end too made for a great ending.

3. A Study in Pink - The episode that started it all. I really liked the villan in this episode, and I really liked the ending as well. It started the whole thing so perfectly. It opened us up to the characters, but still maintained a great story!

2. The Reichenbach Fall - The whole thing is nerve-wracking, but the last 20 minutes is a whole new level of amazing. 

Moriarty's suicide was a little more surprising, because I knew that obviously Sherlock wasn't going to die, but it is still one of the greatest scenes in a TV show.

 

1. His Last Vow - This episode is the greatest episode of any show I've ever watched ever. The plot twists, the emotion, the acting, everything. Every little minute detail, from the reveal of Sherlock's drug 'addiction' to 

The shooting of Magnussen

, it was all crafted so perfectly and so well done. The only thing I didn't really like was the ending, but that's only 1 minute of an hour and a half of pure perfection.

 

Tell me what you guys think :P

Hey, Apple, welcome to the Forum! Glad to see you jumping right in! :welcome: And it's never too late.

 

Just curious; what was it about the end of HLV you didn't like? (And which ending do you mean? :P Moriarty's gif? The plane returning? The handshake?) :smile:

 

 

 

I hate to say it, but I realize now that TEH has indeed kind of spoiled Reichenbach for me. I watch TRF now and all I think about is that Sherlock already has every move planned, so there's not much suspense in it anymore....

Oh. I never thought of it that way, probably because my reason for liking "Reichenbach" is not the suspense. (Suspense? What suspense? Sherlock is gonna come out on top, it's merely a question of how, but I wouldn't call that suspense.) It's still my favorite episode, but I think that's because of the intensity. I love intensity -- well, when it's my kind of intensity, which this apparently is. John's opening and closing scenes. The "complete dickhead" scene. Sherlock's confrontation with Moriarty at Kitty's apartment. Sherlock's confrontation with Moriarty on the roof (especially the "side of the angels" part).  The final phone call.  Goosebumps!

 

I suspect I'm using "suspense" to mean much the same thing as you mean by "intense"??? Whatever it is, I thought the episode was brilliant when I thought it was about a man doing something desperate to save his friends. Once I found out that it was all prearranged, whatever that "ense" is, it just ain't there for me anymore. Sorry, not a good explanation, maybe I'll do better after the rewatch.

Posted

I suspect I'm using "suspense" to mean much the same thing as you mean by "intense"??? Whatever it is, I thought the episode was brilliant when I thought it was about a man doing something desperate to save his friends. Once I found out that it was all prearranged, whatever that "ense" is, it just ain't there for me anymore. Sorry, not a good explanation, maybe I'll do better after the rewatch.

 

Maybe just as well that you didn't join the forum till after Series 3 aired, then! Though I'm pretty sure you didn't think Sherlock just crossed his fingers and jumped?

 

I thought all along that he and Molly, at least, had planned things as well as possible, though perhaps with very little time to do so. He had clearly jumped onto something (possibly that laundry truck). As time went on -- and I participated in forum discussions -- I started to think Mycroft might have been involved as well, meaning that the plans had probably been roughed out well ahead of time. The only "how" questions left in my mind related to details.

 

What I mean by "intensity" wasn't any concern that Sherlock might not survive -- he is, after all, Sherlock Holmes. I was more caught up in the emotions. (I believe the technical term is "the feels.") John is of course genuinely grief-stricken, not knowing that Sherlock isn't really dead -- that was a time-bomb, promising (and later delivering) an interesting resolution. Molly is willing to do whatever it takes to help Sherlock (and I still believe that was far more than just shoving a superfluous corpse out the window). Greg is caught between friendship and duty. Mrs. Hudson is bewildered. And even Sherlock seems genuinely distraught -- he's worried that John thinks he's a fraud, he may be concerned about Molly's safety if Moriarty finds out she's helped him, and of course there's simply no safe way to jump off of a four-story building (which is why the crew used a stunt man, some fakery, and far more safety gear than Sherlock had).

 

I'd be interested in how your reactions compare / contrast to mine.  Or am I missing your point?

 

  • Like 1
Posted

 

I hate to say it, but I realize now that TEH has indeed kind of spoiled Reichenbach for me. I watch TRF now and all I think about is that Sherlock already has every move planned, so there's not much suspense in it anymore....

Oh. I never thought of it that way, probably because my reason for liking "Reichenbach" is not the suspense. (Suspense? What suspense? Sherlock is gonna come out on top, it's merely a question of how, but I wouldn't call that suspense.) It's still my favorite episode, but I think that's because of the intensity. I love intensity -- well, when it's my kind of intensity, which this apparently is. John's opening and closing scenes. The "complete dickhead" scene. Sherlock's confrontation with Moriarty at Kitty's apartment. Sherlock's confrontation with Moriarty on the roof (especially the "side of the angels" part).  The final phone call.  Goosebumps!

 

 

 

I suspect I'm using "suspense" to mean much the same thing as you mean by "intense"??? Whatever it is, I thought the episode was brilliant when I thought it was about a man doing something desperate to save his friends. Once I found out that it was all prearranged, whatever that "ense" is, it just ain't there for me anymore. Sorry, not a good explanation, maybe I'll do better after the rewatch.

 

Maybe just as well that you didn't join the forum till after Series 3 aired, then! Though I'm pretty sure you didn't think Sherlock just crossed his fingers and jumped?

 

I thought all along that he and Molly, at least, had planned things as well as possible, though perhaps with very little time to do so. He had clearly jumped onto something (possibly that laundry truck). As time went on -- and I participated in forum discussions -- I started to think Mycroft might have been involved as well, meaning that the plans had probably been roughed out well ahead of time. The only "how" questions left in my mind related to details.

 

What I mean by "intensity" wasn't any concern that Sherlock might not survive -- he is, after all, Sherlock Holmes. I was more caught up in the emotions. (I believe the technical term is "the feels.") John is of course genuinely grief-stricken, not knowing that Sherlock isn't really dead -- that was a time-bomb, promising (and later delivering) an interesting resolution. Molly is willing to do whatever it takes to help Sherlock (and I still believe that was far more than just shoving a superfluous corpse out the window). Greg is caught between friendship and duty. Mrs. Hudson is bewildered. And even Sherlock seems genuinely distraught -- he's worried that John thinks he's a fraud, he may be concerned about Molly's safety if Moriarty finds out she's helped him, and of course there's simply no safe way to jump off of a four-story building (which is why the crew used a stunt man, some fakery, and far more safety gear than Sherlock had).

 

I'd be interested in how your reactions compare / contrast to mine.  Or am I missing your point?

 

I had a point? :D

 

Hmm, let me see if I can reconstruct my thoughts ... yes, I thought at the end of TRF that the bicyclist and Molly had something to do with Sherlock's survival, but that's about as far as my thinking took me on that point.

 

But more importantly to me, I thought the same thing you did; Sherlock was distraught because he didn't want to do it, because he was afraid John really would think he was a fraud, and because he knew John would suffer. And I thought he was acting out of desperation; he needed to save his three friends, so he had to come up with something, quick. So, that's what I meant by suspense.

 

But after TEH, it appears that he planned to "die" well before the episode even started; that none of his friends were actually in danger, and he knew it; that he wasn't concerned about how John would react; and therefore all his emotions on the roof were faked. I even suspect he was manipulating Molly again, with no real feeling for her at all; he'd just learned to hide it better.

 

I know there's other interpretations (many of which I prefer) but that's the one that makes the most sense to me, I'm afraid. It's just a magic trick, not a story about a man willing to sacrifice all that he is to save his friends. It's still a good tale, but it's been rather robbed of it's emotional ... intensity ... at least, for me. Maybe it had to be that way, since essentially the "sacrifice" plot was used in HLV instead.

 

I'm not necessarily wedded to this point of view, by the way; actually, I'd be delighted to be convinced I'm misinterpreting the TEH explanation! Maybe after the rewatch?

 

Does that help?

  • Like 1
Posted

Whoa, too much to deal with at once! But this seems to be at the heart of it:
 

... after TEH, it appears that he planned to "die" well before the episode even started; that none of his friends were actually in danger, and he knew it....


... and ...
 

I had to make him believe he’d beaten me, utterly defeated me, and then he’d show his hand. ***** There were thirteen likely scenarios once we were up on that roof. Each of them were rigorously worked out and given a code name. It wasn’t just my reputation that Moriarty needed to bury – I had to die.


I must admit this is the first time I've given careful thought to that precise bit of dialog. I see that I'll need to be very careful, because I don't want to leave myself in the same predicament that you currently find yourself in.

I have not deleted any dialog where I inserted a row of asterisks (see Ariane DeVere's transcript), but there's a sudden transition -- Sherlock is forcing Moriarty to show his hand, and then suddenly they're on the roof with thirteen scenarios.  I strongly suspect that he omitted a lot of "boring detail" in between -- maybe something like this:

 

Sherlock and Mycroft are forcing Moriarty's hand.  Meanwhile they're drawing up lists of possible scenarios, deleting some as they become unlikely, and adding more detail as they go along.  I don't think Sherlock realizes that it'll be the rooftop scenario -- or that he really must "die" -- until he and John are leaving Kitty Riley's apartment.  That's why he goes off without John, to work out some details with Molly and presumably to finish working out the thirteen scenarios with Mycroft.

 

So, although he and Mycroft had known for some time that something was coming, I don't think they knew exactly what until that night.

 

  • Like 1
Posted

And all that Sturm und Drang just because we take everything the scriptwriters have thought up as Gospel truth! Anyway, Caya's favourite author, PlaidAdder has done a fine deconstruction of TRF and HLV, which make sense to this reader! The way Mr Gatiss tried to render the "feels" of TRF null and void and render it as a plotted scheme in TEH is particularly telling!

Posted

Arcadia, if you meant to add a reply, looks like the editor ate it.  :P

Posted

b999839610ebc52ba40891234ede7b37.jpg

  • Like 2
Posted

Fairly late reply, but here is my list:

9. The Blind Banker - The only episode I didn't love. It wasn't bad, but it was fairly boring and just didn't hold a candle to the other episodes.

8. The Hounds of Baskerville - Only eighth because the other episodes are better.

7. The Sign of Three - The last 30 minutes were some of the best in the show's history. Other than that, it was humorous, but not really fantastic.

6. The Empty Hearse - I don't really have anything to say about this episode. It's good, but once again, doesn't hold a candle to the top five, which are the episodes I would say are fantastic.

5. A Scandal in Belgravia - This episode is fantastic. I really liked The Woman, and the ending is very satisfying and nice.

4. The Great Game - This episode started Moriarty's reign of terror, and it was an amazing way to set it up. The cliffhanger at the end too made for a great ending.

3. A Study in Pink - The episode that started it all. I really liked the villan in this episode, and I really liked the ending as well. It started the whole thing so perfectly. It opened us up to the characters, but still maintained a great story!

2. The Reichenbach Fall - The whole thing is nerve-wracking, but the last 20 minutes is a whole new level of amazing.

Moriarty's suicide was a little more surprising, because I knew that obviously Sherlock wasn't going to die, but it is still one of the greatest scenes in a TV show.

 

1. His Last Vow - This episode is the greatest episode of any show I've ever watched ever. The plot twists, the emotion, the acting, everything. Every little minute detail, from the reveal of Sherlock's drug 'addiction' to

The shooting of Magnussen

, it was all crafted so perfectly and so well done. The only thing I didn't really like was the ending, but that's only 1 minute of an hour and a half of pure perfection.

 

Tell me what you guys think :P

I think it's too bad that I didn't see your post sooner. I am kind of semi-absent as a mod right now because of my vacation... Welcome! Thanks for putting in the spoiler boxes, even though I think everyone around here has seen all episodes. Also, I am glad we finally have an His Last Vow enthusiast on board!

Posted

Arcadia, if you meant to add a reply, looks like the editor ate it.  :P

Great googly moogly! And it was such a brilliant reply, too. Too bad I can't remember what it was ... :lol:

 

Ummmm... okay, I've deleted that one and replaced it with this one...

 

Whoa, too much to deal with at once! But this seems to be at the heart of it:

... after TEH, it appears that he planned to "die" well before the episode even started; that none of his friends were actually in danger, and he knew it....

... and ...

 

I had to make him believe he’d beaten me, utterly defeated me, and then he’d show his hand. ***** There were thirteen likely scenarios once we were up on that roof. Each of them were rigorously worked out and given a code name. It wasn’t just my reputation that Moriarty needed to bury – I had to die.

I must admit this is the first time I've given careful thought to that precise bit of dialog. I see that I'll need to be very careful, because I don't want to leave myself in the same predicament that you currently find yourself in.

 

I have not deleted any dialog where I inserted a row of asterisks (see Ariane DeVere's transcript), but there's a sudden transition -- Sherlock is forcing Moriarty to show his hand, and then suddenly they're on the roof with thirteen scenarios.  I strongly suspect that he omitted a lot of "boring detail" in between -- maybe something like this:

 

Sherlock and Mycroft are forcing Moriarty's hand.  Meanwhile they're drawing up lists of possible scenarios, deleting some as they become unlikely, and adding more detail as they go along.  I don't think Sherlock realizes that it'll be the rooftop scenario -- or that he really must "die" -- until he and John are leaving Kitty Riley's apartment.  That's why he goes off without John, to work out some details with Molly and presumably to finish working out the thirteen scenarios with Mycroft.

 

So, although he and Mycroft had known for some time that something was coming, I don't think they knew exactly what until that night.

 

 

The only point I remember making is that Sherlock says the thirteen scenarios came into play "once we were up on that roof." So the roof, apparently, was essential to all the scenarios. (The easier to jump from, my dear.) And I could easily interpret "I had to die" as meaning the showdown was going to end in Sherlock's "death" (faked or otherwise) no matter which scenario played out. The implication being that the emphasis had shifted from stopping Moriarty (because they'd already figured out how to do that by the time TRF started) to taking down his network, a job which "required" Sherlock to go undercover.

 

Etc etc. It occurs to me I shouldn't blather on about it, or the next thing we'll know, I'll have convinced you. :blink: Run, Carol, run!

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 81 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of UseWe have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.Privacy PolicyGuidelines.